Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Out of the Cabinet

What Drives Defections From the Government in Presidential Systems

Bibliographic Data

ID6244397
AuthorsCecilia Martinez-Gallardo (University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Chapel Hill, NC, USA), Cecilia Martínez‐gallardo (0000-0002-3700-1037, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, corresponding author)
Year2012
Volume45
Issue1
Pages62-90
Publication date2012-01-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueComparative Political Studies (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0010-4140 • E-ISSN: 1552-3829
PublisherSAGE Publications Inc (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1177/0010414011421306
OpenAlexW2108903247
LanguageEN
Citations received65
References cited34

This article challenges a key part of the conventional view of coalitions in presidential systems that sees them as short-lived and ad hoc. The author shows instead that there is wide variation in the durability of governing coalitions across these regimes. She develops a theory of the incentives of parties to participate in the government and the circumstances under which scholars might expect to see the existing governing coalition break down. The author draws on data from 121 cabinets in 12 Latin American countries between the late 1980s and the mid-2000s to show that the dissolution of the cabinet is more likely when the president places less value on coalition building as a policy-making strategy and when parties find it costly to participate in the government. In particular, the author shows that strong unilateral institutional powers tend to diminish the incentives of presidents to compromise with other parties; in contrast, effective legislatures and high rates of approval for the executive contribute significantly to more stable governments

Cabinet (room · Compromise · Divided government · Economics · Executive branch · Government (linguistics · Incentive · Law and economics · Legislature · Market economy · Political economy · Political science · Politics · Presidential system · Public economics · Value (mathematics · Electoral Systems and Political Participation · Law · Politics and Society in Latin America · Public Administration · Social Policy and Reform Studies

  • Government Formation and Cabinets

    Open Access•Sona N Golder•Emerging Trends in the Social and…•2015

  • El carácter múltiple de la racionalidad estatal

    Open Access•Manel Gené, Mariana Gené et al.•Sociohistórica•2021

  • Presidentes y gabinetes en Argentina (1862-1930)

    Open Access•Juan Manuel Abal Medina, María Laura Eberhardt et al.•Ciencia Política•2021

  • When Democracies Deliver

    Open Access•Katherine Bersch•When Democracies Deliver•2019

  • Fighting Past Economic Wars

    Open Access•Stephen B Kaplan•Latin American Research Review•2022

  • Public support for Latin American presidents

    Open Access•Ryan E Carlin, Jonathan Hartlyn et al.•Research & Politics•2018

  • Portfolio Allocation as the President's Calculations

    Open Access•Don S Lee•Journal of East Asian Studies•2018

  • Pre-electoral coalitions and cabinet stability in presidential systems

    Open Access•Adrián Albala, André Borges et al.•The British Journal of Politics…•2021

  • Bicameralism and Coalition Cabinets in Presidential Polities

    Open Access•Adrián Albala•The British Journal of Politics…•2017

  • Ministerial stability during presidential approval crises

    Open Access•Bastián González‐bustamante•The British Journal of Politics…•2022

  • Partisan distribution of ministerial portfolios in Asian-Pacific democracies

    Open Access•Jinhyuk Jang•Party Politics•2023

  • La efectividad de las políticas de justicia de la última década en América Latina

    Open Access•María Luisa Ramos Rollón, Marisa Ramos Rollón•Reforma y democracia•2017

  • Parties and Coalition Governance in Presidential Democracies

    Open Access•Joris Alberdingk Thijm, Jorge M Fernandes•Political Research Quarterly•2024

  • A Multilevel Model for Coalition Governments

    Open Access•Benjamin Rosche•Political Analysis•2026

  • Line‐item vetoes as a coordination mechanism

    Open Access•Valeria Palanza, Gisela Sin et al.•Legislative Studies Quarterly•2024

  • The Institutional Presidency in Latin America

    Open Access•Magna Inácio, Mariana Llanos•Presidential Studies Quarterly•2016

  • Cambios de gabinete y supervivencia de los ministros en Chile durante los gobiernos de la Concertación (1990-2010)

    Open Access•Bastián González‐bustamante, Bastián González-Bustamante et al.•Colombia Internacional•2016

  • Gaining new insights by going local

    Open Access•Martin Gro, Marc Debus•Public Choice•2018

  • Blame Shifting in Presidential Systems

    Open Access•Bastián González‐bustamante, Bastián González-Bustamante•Public Opinion Quarterly•2026

  • The drivers of resemblance in presidential regimes

    Open Access•Lucas Couto•European Political Science Review•2025

  • Party Systems and Government Stability in Central and Eastern Europe

    Open Access•Florian Grotz, Till Weber•World Politics•2012

  • Party System Polarisation and Government Duration in Central and Eastern Europe

    Lydia Savage, Lee Savage•West European Politics•2013

  • Party System Institutionalization and Government Formation in new Democracies

    Open Access•Lydia Savage, Lee Savage•World Politics•2016

  • Designing Cabinets

    Open Access•Cecilia Martínez‐gallardo•Journal of Politics in Latin…•2014

  • Oversized Government Coalitions in Latin America

    Open Access•Fernando Meireles•Brazilian Political Science Review•2016

  • Legislative Effectiveness in Multiparty Presidential Systems

    Sergio A Bárcena Juárez, Yann P Kerevel•The Journal of Politics•2022

  • Minister Turnover, Critical Events, and the Electoral Calendar in Presidential Democracies

    Marcelo Camerlo, Aníbal Pérez-Liñán•The Journal of Politics•2015

  • Why do parties cooperate in presidentialism? Electoral and government coalition formation in Latin America

    Open Access•Kenneth Bunker•Revista de Estudios Políticos•2019

  • Executive control of bureaucracy and presidential cabinet appointments in East Asian democracies

    Open Access•Don S Lee•Regulation & Governance•2020

  • When do coalitions form under presidentialism, and why does it matter? A configurational analysis from Latin America

    Open Access•Adrián Albala•Politics•2021

  • How Do Minority Presidents Manage Multiparty Coalitions? Identifying and Analyzing the Payoffs to Coalition Parties in Presidential Systems

    Open Access•Paul Chaisty, Svitlana Chernykh•Political Research Quarterly•2017

  • Parties for hire

    Open Access•Marisa Kellam•Party Politics•2015

  • Electoral incentives to coalition formation in multiparty presidential systems

    Open Access•André Borges, Mathieu Turgeon et al.•Party Politics•2021

  • Policy Monitoring and Ministerial Survival

    Open Access•Talita Neves Silva, Alejandro Medina•Legislative Studies Quarterly•2023

  • Congruent We Govern

    Open Access•C Pereira, Frederico Bertholini et al.•Government and Opposition•2023

  • Presidents, Prime Ministers and Legislative Behaviour

    Open Access•André Borges, Pedro Floriano Ribeiro•Government and Opposition•2023

  • Executive capacity to control legislatures and presidential choice of cabinet ministers in East Asian democracies

    Open Access•Don S Lee•Governance•2018

  • Gamson going global? Cabinet proportionality in comparative perspective

    Open Access•Paul Chaisty, Timothy J Power•European Political Science Review•2024

  • Flying solo

    Open Access•Paul Chaisty, Timothy J Power•European Journal of Political…•2019

  • A new political system model

    Open Access•Steffen Ganghof•European Journal of Political…•2018

  • Presidential hegemony and democratic backsliding in Latin America, 1925–2016

    Aníbal Pérez-Liñán, Nicolás Schmidt et al.•Democratization•2019

  • The Pigmentocracy of Executive Approval

    Open Access•Swaran P Singh, Ryan E Carlin•Comparative Political Studies•2025

  • Policy Regimes and Economic Accountability in Latin America

    Open Access•Ryan E Carlin, Timothy Hellwig•Comparative Political Studies•2019

  • Security, Clarity of Responsibility, and Presidential Approval

    Open Access•Ryan E Carlin, Gregory J Love et al.•Comparative Political Studies•2015

  • Partisan Portfolio Allocation in African Democracies

    Open Access•Margaret Ariotti, Margaret H Ariotti et al.•Comparative Political Studies•2018

  • Inside Revolutionary Parties

    Open Access•Santiago Anria, Jennifer Cyr•Comparative Political Studies•2017

  • Question of Timing

    Open Access•Adrián Albala, Lucas Couto•Brazilian Political Science Review•2023

  • Coalition Presidentialism in Bicameral Congresses

    Open Access•Adrián Albala•Brazilian Political Science Review•2017

  • The Institutional Presidency from a Comparative Perspective

    Open Access•Magna Inácio, Mariana Llanos•Brazilian Political Science Review•2015

  • Maximizing the Reliability of Cross-National Measures of Presidential Power

    Open Access•David Doyle, Robert Elgie•British Journal of Political…•2016

  • Presidents’ Sex and Popularity

    Open Access•Ryan E Carlin, Miguel Carreras et al.•British Journal of Political…•2020

  • The Politics of Minister Retention in Presidential Systems

    Marcelo Camerlo, Aníbal Pérez-Liñán•Comparative Politics•2015

  • Sociología política de las elites. Apuntes sobre su abordaje a través de entrevistas

    Open Access•Manel Gené, Mariana Gené•Revista de Sociologia e Política•2014

  • Política Distributiva em Coalizão

    Open Access•Fernando Meireles•Dados•2024

  • Os ciclos do presidencialismo de coalizão e seus determinantes político-econômicos

    Open Access•Aline Melquíades Silva•Revista Brasileira de Ciência…•2017

  • Razões da Fragmentação

    Open Access•André Borges•Dados•2019

  • Mensurando e explicando a instabilidade dos gabinetes presidenciais no Brasil entre 1946 e 1964

    Open Access•Adriano Codato, Paulo Franz et al.•Estudos Históricos (Rio de Janeiro•2024

  • Todos Os Estados São Iguais, Mas Alguns São Mais Iguais Que Os Outros

    Open Access•Pedro Neiva, Taeko Hiroi•Revista Brasileira de Ciências…•2020

  • Watchdogs in Our Midst

    Open Access•Carlos Pereira, Marta Batista et al.•Latin American Politics and Society•2017

  • Too Legit to Quit? Analyzing the Effect of No-Confidence Motions on Cabinet Members' Instability in Presidential Systems

    Open Access•Jhon Kelly Bonilla-Aranzales•Latin American Politics and Society•2023

  • Foreign Policy Specificity

    Open Access•Pedro Feliú Ribeiro, Camilo López Burian•Latin American Politics and Society•2023

  • The Formation of Cabinet Coalitions in Presidential Systems

    Open Access•Johannes Freudenreich•Latin American Politics and Society•2016

  • How Valuable Is a Presidential Cabinet? Measuring Ministries' Political Attractiveness in Brazil

    Open Access•Arnaldo Mauerberg, C Pereira•Latin American Politics and Society•2020

  • Informal Coalitions and Legislative Agenda Setting in Mexico's Multiparty Presidential System

    Open Access•Yann P Kerevel, Sergio A Bárcena Juárez•Latin American Politics and Society•2022

  • Presidentas Rise

    Open Access•Catherine Reyes-Housholder•Latin American Politics and Society•2016

  • How Democracy Works

    Ernesto Stein, Mark P Jones et al.•How democracy works•2010

  • Parliaments and Coalitions

    Leonard W Martins, Lanny W Martin et al.•Parliaments and coalitions•2011

  • The Failure of Presidential Democracy

    Juan J Linz, Arturo Valenzuela et al.•The Failure of Presidential…•1994

  • Government Turnover in Parliamentary Democracies

    Open Access•Daniel Diermeier, Antonio Merlo•Journal of Economic Theory•2000

  • Public Opinion in America

    James A Stimson•Public Opinion in America•2018

  • Government Survival in Parliamentary Democracies

    Open Access•Paul Warwick•Government Survival in…•1995

  • Parties and Democracy

    Open Access•Reuven Y Kazan•Political Science Quarterly•1991

  • Ideological Diversity and Government Survival in Western European Parliamentary Democracies

    Open Access•Paul Warwick•Comparative Political Studies•1992

  • Constitutional Frameworks and Democratic Consolidation

    Open Access•Alfred Stepan, Cindy Skach•World Politics•1993

  • How Political Stability Shapes Administrative Performance

    Simona Milio•West European Politics•2008

  • The Politics of Coalition Formation and Survival in Multiparty Presidential Democracies

    Open Access•David Altman•Party Politics•2000

  • Institutions, Expectations, and Currency Crises

    David Leblang, Shanker Satyanath•International Organization•2006

  • Government survival in Western multi–party democracies

    Open Access•Peter Van Roozendaal•European Journal of Political…•1997

  • Unified Government, Bill Approval, and the Legislative Weight of the President

    Open Access•Eduardo Alemán, E Calvo•Comparative Political Studies•2010

  • Presidentialism, Multipartism, and Democracy

    Open Access•Scott Mainwaring•Comparative Political Studies•1993

  • Government Capacities and Policy Making by Decree in Latin America

    Open Access•Gabriel L Negretto•Comparative Political Studies•2004

  • The Presidential Calculus

    Open Access•Octavio Amorim Neto•Comparative Political Studies•2006

  • Democraticinstitutions Andregimesurvival

    José Antônio Cheibub, Fernando Limongi•Annual Review of Political Science•2002

  • Government Termination

    Michael Laver•Annual Review of Political Science•2003

  • Time is of the Essence

    J M Box-Steffensmeier, Bradford Jones et al.•American Journal of Political…•1997

  • The Process of Cabinet Dissolution

    Eric C Browne, John P Frendreis et al.•American Journal of Political…•1986

  • A Unified Model of Cabinet Dissolution in Parliamentary Democracies

    Gary King, James E Alt et al.•American Journal of Political…•1990

  • Cabinet Survival and Competing Risks

    Daniel Diermeier, Randy Stevenson et al.•American Journal of Political…•1999

  • Government Coalitions and Legislative Success Under Presidentialism and Parliamentarism

    Open Access•José Antônio Cheibub, Adam Przeworski et al.•British Journal of Political…•2004

  • Cabinet Instability and the Accumulation of Experience

    Open Access•John D Huber, Cecilia Martinez-Gallardo et al.•British Journal of Political…•2004

  • Modelling Cabinet Durability and Termination

    Open Access•B Grofman, Peter Van Roozendaal•British Journal of Political…•1997

  • Wasting Time? The Impact of Ideology and Size on Delay in Coalition Formation

    Open Access•Leonard W Martins, Lanny W Martins et al.•British Journal of Political…•2003

  • The Comparative Analysis of Coalition Formation and Duration

    Open Access•B Grofman•British Journal of Political…•1989

  • Political Parties and Government Coalitions in the Americas

    Open Access•Eduardo Alemán, George Tsebelis•Journal of Politics in Latin…•2011

  • Incentives to cultivate a personal vote

    Open Access•John Michael Carey, Matthew Soberg Shugart•Electoral Studies•1995

  • Tipos de presidencialismo y coaliciones políticas en América Latina

    Open Access•Elena Martínez Barahona, Jorge Lanzaro•Revista Española de Investigaciones…•2002

  • How Does Cabinet Instability Affect Political Performance? Portfolio Volatility and Health Care Cost Containment in Parliamentary Democracies

    Open Access•John D Huber•American Political Science Review•1998

  • Minority Presidents and Democratic Performance in Latin America

    Open Access•Gabriel L Negretto•Latin American Politics and Society•2006

Unique citing works65
Citations per year4,64
Citation span2012 - 2026 (15)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 65

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae