Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Resilient Royals

How Arab Monarchies Hang On

Bibliographic Data

ID6286705
AuthorsSean Yom (0000-0002-2369-2156), Sean L Yom, F Gregory Gause (0000-0001-5147-2778)
Year2012
Volume23
Issue4
Pages74-88
Publication date2012-10-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueJournal of democracy (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 1045-5736 • E-ISSN: 1086-3214
PublisherProject MUSE (PUBLISHER • US)
DOI10.1353/jod.2012.0062
OpenAlexW2044841334
LanguageEN
Citations received101
References cited11

No monarchy fell to revolution in the Arab Spring. What accounts for this monarchical exceptionalism? Analysts have argued that royal autocracies are inherently more resilient than authoritarian republics due to their cultural foundations and institutional structure. By contrast, this paper leverages comparative analysis to offer a different explanation emphasizing deliberate regime strategies made in circumstances of geographic fortuity. The mobilization of cross-cutting coalitions, hydrocarbon wealth, and foreign patronage account for the resilience of monarchical dictatorships in the Middle East. Without these factors, kingships are just as vulnerable to overthrow as any other autocracy—something that history indicates, given the long list of deposed monarchies in the region over the past half-century

American exceptionalism · Ancient history · Authoritarianism · Autocracy · Democracy · Dictatorship · Middle East · Monarchy · Political economy · Political science · Politics · Sociology · History · Islamic Studies and History · Law · Political Conflict and Governance · Politics and Conflicts in Afghanistan, Pakistan, and Middle East

  • The tradeoff between democratic governance and external security guarantees in a multipolar order

    Open Access•Chick Edmond•Discover Global Society•2026

  • Reforming Family Law

    Dörthe Engelcke•Reforming Family Law•2019

  • The Resilience of Parliamentary Politics in Kuwait

    Courtney Freer, Freer Freer•Resilience of Parliamentary…•2023

  • The Politics of Survival

    Open Access•Yusuf Bahadır Keskin•Contemporary Review of the Middle…•2026

  • Presenting the Governmental Incompatibilities Data Project (Gidp) 2.0

    Open Access•Peter B White, David E Cunningham et al.•International Studies Quarterly•2025

  • The intra-GCC crises

    Cinzia Bianco, Gareth Stansfield•International Affairs•2018

  • Securitisation and De-securitisation in the Middle East and North Africa

    Ruth Hanau Santini•The International Spectator•2026

  • The New Saudi Leadership and Its Impact on Regional Policy

    Fatiha Dazi-Heni•The International Spectator•2021

  • How is social resilience possible? a qualitative comparative analysis based on the “Arab Spring”

    Open Access•Rui Wang, Wang Rui et al.•Asian Review of Political Economy•2025

  • The Consequences of Some Angry Re-Tweets

    Open Access•Geoffrey Martins, Geoffrey Martin•Review of Middle East Studies•2019

  • Armies of Arabia

    Zoltan Barany•Armies of Arabia•2021

  • Hot Contention, Cool Abstention

    Stephanie Dornschneider, Stephanie Dornschneider-Elkink•Hot Contention, Cool Abstention•2021

  • A History of Modern Oman

    Open Access•Jeremy Jones, Nicholas Ridout•History of Modern Oman•2015

  • Expressive Constraint and Monarchical Legitimacy in Eswatini

    Open Access•Adeniyi Awoyemi•Representation•2026

  • Disassembling accountability and democracy

    Shumaila Fatima•Democratization•2026

  • On the Margins Of the arab spring

    Open Access•Alice Wilson•Social Analysis•2013

  • Eine Schwalbe macht noch keinen Frühling

    Open Access•Jannis Julien Grimm, Jannis Grimm•Zeitschrift für Vergleichende…•2015

  • Exit, Voice, Loyalty … or Deliberate Obstruction? Non-Collective Everyday Resistance under Oppression

    Open Access•Stephanie Dornschneider-Elkink•Perspectives on Politics•2021

  • Durable, Yet Different

    Open Access•André Bank, Thomas Richter et al.•Journal of Arabian Studies•2014

  • Temptations of Autocracy

    Tobias Zumbrägel, Thomas Demmelhuber•Journal of Arabian Studies•2020

  • Monarchies and Protests in the Arab Uprisings

    Russell Lucas, Russell E Lucas•Journal of Arabian Studies•2014

  • Dictators Never Die

    Adam Tyson, Nawawi Nawawi et al.•Contemporary Southeast Asia•2022

  • Economic, Social, and Political Elites in Mena Political Science

    Open Access•Ammar Shamaileh•Global Perspectives•2024

  • Separatism, the Arab uprisings and the legacies of lost territorial autonomy

    Ariel I Ahram•Territory Politics Governance•2018

  • The adoption of youth quotas after the Arab uprisings

    Open Access•Jana Belschner•Politics Groups and Identities•2018

  • The determinants of Jordan's stability case study

    Open Access•Nayera Mohamed Hamed Ibrahim•Asian Journal of Comparative…•2021

  • Long Live the Neo-traditional Kings? The Gulf Cooperation Council and Legitimation of Monarchical Rule in the Arabian Peninsula

    Leonie Holthaus•Middle East Critique•2019

  • Jordan and the ‘Arab Spring’

    Martin Beck, Simone Hüser•Middle East Critique•2015

  • The Persistence of Autocracy

    Hassan A Barari•Middle East Critique•2015

  • Saudi regime resilience after the 2011 Arab popular uprisings

    Madawi Al-Rasheed, Madawi Al‐rasheed•Contemporary Arab Affairs•2015

  • Beyond rentierism

    Osman Antwi-Boateng, Mohamed Bin Huwaidin et al.•Contemporary Arab Affairs•2017

  • Gulf Cooperation Council

    Wafaa Adnan Darweesh Alaradi, Wafaa A Alaradi et al.•Contemporary Arab Affairs•2021

  • A visual uprising

    Open Access•Kylie Moore-Gilbert•Media War & Conflict•2017

  • Governance, natural resources rent, and infrastructure development

    Open Access•Hamid E Ali, Shahjahan Bhuiyan•Politics & Policy•2022

  • Civic Space and Sectarianism in the Gulf States

    Open Access•Hasan Hafidh, Thomas Fibiger et al.•Studies in Ethnicity and…•2019

  • Anomalous authoritarianism

    Michael Seeberg, Michael Aagaard Seeberg•Commonwealth and Comparative…•2016

  • Can’t buy me legitimacy’

    Open Access•Uriel Abulof•Journal of International…•2015

  • Exploiting dissent

    Open Access•Shamiran Mako•International Politics•2021

  • The power of disrespect

    Open Access•Ali Balci, A TÜLAY BALCI et al.•The British Journal of Politics…•2025

  • Arab Spring

    Daniela Huber, Lorenzo Kamel•Mediterranean Politics•2015

  • Mobilizing Morocco

    Ceil Berman•Mediterranean Politics•2019

  • Continuity through Co-optation

    M Buehler•Mediterranean Politics•2015

  • Multilateral financial flows and state–business relations in Morocco

    Farid Boussaid•Mediterranean Politics•2024

  • Angst springs eternal

    Open Access•Andrew R Hom•Security Dialogue•2016

  • Civil society and survival

    Open Access•Peter Jacques•Global Environmental Change•2023

  • Domestic and international dynamics before and after the Arab uprisings

    Francesco Cavatorta•Cambridge Review of International…•2017

  • Blue blood or true blood

    Open Access•Fenja Søndergaard Møller•Conflict Management and Peace…•2017

  • Bread, Justice, or Opportunity? The Determinants of the Arab Awakening Protests

    Open Access•Matthew J Costello, Matthew Costello et al.•World Development•2014

  • Indigenous unrest and the contentious politics of social assistance in Mexico

    Open Access•Erdem Yörük, İbrahim Öker et al.•World Development•2019

  • The concept of mixed monarchy and the monarchical principle in the study of modern state systems

    Marcin Michał Wiszowaty•History of European Ideas•2023

  • Beautiful authoritarianism

    Open Access•Mustafa Menshawy•Third World Quarterly•2026

  • Traditionalising of Yogyakarta’s urban landscape

    Open Access•Bayu Dardias Kurniadi•Urban Studies•2025

  • Authoritarian resilience and regime cohesion in Morocco after the Arab Spring

    J N C Hill•Middle Eastern Studies•2019

  • Revolutionary struggle and its diffusion

    Open Access•Tyson Patros•International Journal of…•2021

  • Unconditional Loyalty

    Open Access•Salam Alsaadi•American Political Science Review•2025

  • Digital De-Citizenship

    Open Access•Marc Owen Jones•International Journal Middle East…•2020

  • How oil autocracies learn to stop worrying

    Anar K Ahmadov, Anar Ahmadov•Post-Soviet Affairs•2019

  • Variants of Authoritarian Robustness in the Arab Uprisings

    Open Access•Martin Beck, Simone Hüser•Digest of Middle East Studies•2026

  • The U nited S tates and B ahrain

    Open Access•Andrew F Cooper, Bessma Momani et al.•Digest of Middle East Studies•2014

  • The Finger on the Scale

    Robert A Portada, Lynsey Billet•Journal of global south studies•2019

  • Challenge of Localization under Restrictive Government Rule

    Open Access•Dima M Toukan•Global Studies Quarterly•2024

  • Monetary statecraft in the service of counter-revolution

    Open Access•H Baumann•Review of International Political…•2025

  • Political Reform as Regime Survival Strategy in the Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan After the Arab Uprisings

    Open Access•László Csicsmann•Alternatives Global Local Political•2024

  • Working on the Revolution in Bahrain

    Amy Austin Holmes•Social movement studies•2016

  • Protests and the Arab Spring

    Tansa George Massoud, John Doces et al.•Polity•2019

  • The myth of the reforming monarch

    Open Access•David Wearing•Politics•2024

  • Jordan and Morocco

    Open Access•Sean Yom•Journal of democracy•2017

  • Tracking the “Arab Spring

    Open Access•Jason Brownlee, Tarek Masoud et al.•Journal of democracy•2013

  • Democratic Parliamentary Monarchies

    Open Access•Alfred Stepan, Juan J Linz et al.•Journal of democracy•2014

  • Algeria versus the Arab Spring

    Open Access•Frédéric Volpi•Journal of democracy•2013

  • Jordan

    Open Access•Sean Yom, Sean L Yom•Journal of democracy•2013

  • Authoritarian resilience through top-down transformation

    Open Access•Stefano Ruzza, Giuseppe Gabusi et al.•Italian Political Science…•2019

  • Democratizing Potential of the ‘Arab Spring

    Open Access•Malik Mufti•Government and Opposition•2015

  • Sources of Authoritarian Resilience in Regional Protest Waves

    Open Access•Steve He, Steve Hess•Government and Opposition•2016

  • The Arab Spring

    Open Access•Sean Yom•Government and Opposition•2015

  • The limits of authoritarian solidarity

    Open Access•Daniel Odinius, Philipp Kuntz•European Journal of Political…•2015

  • Personalization and domestic policy outcomes

    Andrew Leber•Democratization•2024

  • Weathering the storm

    Gianni Del Panta•Democratization•2017

  • Long-term monarchical survival in the Middle East

    André Bank, Thomas Richter et al.•Democratization•2015

  • Challenging the rules of the game

    Douglas Jones•Democratization•2023

  • Influence of elite rotation on authoritarian resilience

    Ilia Nadporozhskii•Democratization•2023

  • Self-expression values, loyalty generation, and support for authoritarianism

    Sabri Ciftci•Democratization•2018

  • Refinancing the Rentier State

    Justin J Gengler, Bethany Shockley et al.•Comparative Politics•2021

  • Rethinking Democratic Diffusion

    Open Access•Edward Goldring, Sheena Chestnut Greiten•Comparative Political Studies•2020

  • How Erroneous Beliefs Trigger Authoritarian Collapse

    Open Access•Anne Wolf•Comparative Political Studies•2025

  • Repression as a Double‐edged Sword

    Open Access•Daniel Bischof, Simon Fink•Swiss Political Science Review•2015

  • Islam, Social Justice, and Democracy

    Open Access•Sabri Ciftci•Politics and Religion•2019

  • Democratic states and authoritarian firewalls

    Thomas Ambrosio•Contemporary Politics•2014

  • Identity, procedures and performance

    Christian Von Soest, Julia Grauvogel•Contemporary Politics•2017

  • Social services to claim legitimacy

    Andrea Cassani•Contemporary Politics•2017

  • Patron-client state relations and the geopolitics of authoritarian survival and breakdown

    Loretta Dell’aguzzo, Emidio Diodato•Contemporary Politics•2023

  • The Arab spring

    Safa Al-Saeedi•Contemporary Politics•2022

  • How do sources of traditional legitimacy constrain popular uprisings? The case of the Kingdom of Swaziland

    Fenja Søndergaard Møller•Small Wars and Insurgencies•2019

  • Royal power in the market-oriented society

    Open Access•M Holmqvist•British Journal of Sociology•2025

  • Demobilising the February 20 Movement in Morocco

    Sammy Badran, Sammy Zeyad Badran•The Journal of North African…•2020

  • Regionalism and Alliances in the Middle East, 2011-2021

    Open Access•Raffaella A Del Sarto, Eduard Soler I Lecha•Geopolitics•2024

  • Are Monarchies Exceptional to the Arab Uprisings? The Resilience of Moroccan Monarchy Revisited

    Open Access•Nur Koprulu, Hind Abdulmajeed•Digest of Middle East Studies•2019

  • Public diplomacy of authoritarianism

    Open Access•Mustafa Menshawy•Digest of Middle East Studies•2024

  • Queerer Than Queer

    Noor Al-Qasimi•GLQ A Journal of Lesbian and Gay…•2020

  • Social Policy and Regime Legitimacy

    Open Access•Xiaobo Lü•American Political Science Review•2014

  • Political Order in Changing Societies

    Samuel P Huntington•Political Order in Changing…•1969

  • Oil monarchies

    F Gregory Gause•Oil monarchies•1994

  • Ordering power

    Dan Slater, I Lasiecka•Control theory for partial…•2005

  • Hard Times in the Lands of Plenty

    Benjamin Smith•Hard Times in Lands of Plenty•2011

  • Oil, Coalitions, and Regime Durability

    Open Access•Sean Yom, Sean L Yom•Studies in Comparative…•2011

  • Arab Politics

    Open Access•Robert O Freedman•Political Science Quarterly•1978

  • Princes and Parliaments in the Arab World

    Michael Herb•The Middle East Journal•2004

  • Monarchical Authoritarianism

    Open Access•Russell Lucas, Russell E Lucas•International Journal Middle East…•2004

  • Political Parties and the State

    Open Access•Frank J Sorauf•Political Science Quarterly•1994

  • Jordan

    Open Access•Sean Yom, Sean L Yom•Journal of democracy•2009

  • Absolutism and the Resilience of Monarchy in the Middle East

    Open Access•Lisa Anderson•Political Science Quarterly•1991

Unique citing works101
Citations per year7,77
Citation span2013 - 2026 (14)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedYes
Citation typesNeutral: 100

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae