Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Theorizing EU enlargement

Research Focus, Hypotheses, and the State of Research

Bibliographic Data

ID6288975
AuthorsFrank Schimmelfennig (0000-0002-1638-1819), Ulrich Sedelmeier (0000-0001-6963-4296)
Year2002
Volume9
Issue4
Pages500-528
Publication date2002-01-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessNo
TypeARTICLE
VenueJournal of European Public Policy (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 1350-1763 • E-ISSN: 1466-4429
PublisherInforma UK Limited (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1080/13501760210152411
OpenAlexW2139328842
LanguageEN
Citations received100
References cited46

Despite its indisputable political relevance, the enlargement of the EU has suffered from a theoretical neglect in studies of European integration. While theoretically informed studies have emerged recently, this literature suffers from a predominant focus on single cases and from not being linked to the more general study of international organizations in the social sciences. This article aims to structure the emerging debate in order to generate more generalizable and cumulative insights. First, we define enlargement as a process of gradual and formal horizontal institutionalization. We identify key dependent variables of a so-defined enlargement, for which we propose comparative research strategies. Second, we draw on two basic approaches to the analysis of international organizations - rationalist and sociological or constructivist institutionalism - to derive core hypotheses on the conditions of enlargement. Finally, we demonstrate the usefulness of these theoretical approaches in structuring the debate by giving an overview of the state of research on EU enlargement. Keywords: ConstructivismEnlargementEuropean UnionIntegration TheoryRationalist InstitutionalismRegional Organizations

Economics · Epistemology · European union · Focus (optics · International trade · Political science · Positive economics · Resizing · Sociology · State (computer science · Computer Science · European Union Policy and Governance · Philosophy

  • Ex Interim Voting

    Sven Fischer, Andreas Nicklisch•Journal of Institutional and…•2007

  • Interested, able and prepared

    Open Access•Gherghina, Clara Volintiru•Journal of Contemporary European…•2026

  • The Invisible Constitution of Politics

    Open Access•Antje Wiener•Invisible Constitution of Politics•2008

  • The EU, Nato and the Integration of Europe

    Open Access•Frank Schimmelfennig•EU, NATO and the Integration of…•2003

  • The European Employment Strategy

    Diamond Ashiagbor•The European employment strategy•2005

  • Democracy, security and European Union enlargement

    Open Access•Emanuele Sessa, Virginie Mamadouh•Journal of European Public Policy•2026

  • Het verbod op hulp aan mensen zonder wettig verblijf

    Anja Van den Durpel•Mens & Maatschappij•2017

  • The Trouble with “Gender” in Latvia

    Open Access•Elizabete Vizgunova, Elīna Graudiņa•Baltic Journal of Law and Politics•2020

  • Are international organisations in decline? An absolute and relative perspective on institutional change

    Open Access•Maria Josepha Debre, Hylke Dijkstra•Global Policy•2023

  • Evolutionary institutionalism in Europe’s neighborhood post-enlargement

    Open Access•Boyka Stefanova•Asia Europe Journal•2021

  • In Croatia’s slipstream or on an alternative road? Assessing the objective case for the remaining Western Balkan states acceding into the EU

    Milenko Petrović, Nicholas Ross Smith•Journal of Southeast European and…•2013

  • Continuity and change in the European Union’s approach to enlargement

    Erhan İçener, David Phinnemore et al.•Journal of Southeast European and…•2010

  • European Neighbourhood Policy as a tool for stabilizing Europe’s Neighbourhood

    Özgür Ünal Eriş, Özgür Ünal Erιş•Journal of Southeast European and…•2012

  • Dancing along with the party? party-cues and attitudes towards the EU unification in Montenegro

    Boris Lipovina•Journal of Southeast European and…•2025

  • The outsiders

    Open Access•Kristin E Smith, Karen E Smith•International Affairs•2005

  • Advancing the European audiovisual sector through external action

    Open Access•Evangelia Psychogiopoulou, Apostolos Samaras et al.•International Journal of Cultural…•2026

  • Euro-optimism Intertwined with Pragmatism

    Lia Tsuladze•Caucasus Survey•2023

  • Asean Enlargement and Norm Change -A Window of Opportunity for Democracy and Human Rights Entrepreneurs

    Open Access•Kerstin Radtke•Journal of Current Southeast…•2014

  • Measuring Russia’s Snag on the Fabric of the EU’s International Society

    Open Access•Caterina Carta, Stefano Braghiroli•Journal of Contemporary European…•2011

  • The Eastern Enlargement of the European Union

    Open Access•Tereza Novotna•Journal of Contemporary European…•2007

  • The State of the Art in the EU Democracy Promotion Literature

    Open Access•P Simmons•Journal of Contemporary European…•2011

  • A reaction to the French “non”? Or a case of institutional bricolage

    Michel Vincent Anderlini•Politique européenne•2022

  • Usages et mesusages du concept de gouvernance appliqué à l'élargissement de l'Union Européenne

    Dorota Dakowska•Politique européenne•2003

  • A reaction to the French “non”? Or a case of institutional bricolage

    Michel Vincent Anderlini•Politique européenne•2022

  • Le champ politique européen saisi par les élargissements

    Cédric Pellen•Politique européenne•2013

  • L'élargissement comme fondement de l'ordre communautaire

    Marie‐eve Bélanger•Politique européenne•2014

  • Energy Security, Normative Dilemmas, and Institutional Camouflage

    Open Access•Steve Wood•Politics & Policy•2009

  • Turkey’s Accession to the European Union

    Open Access•Meltem Müftüler-Bac•International Studies Perspectives•2008

  • Conflict conditionality in the Western Balkans

    Tereza Marošková•Journal of Contemporary European…•2024

  • Th anniversary of the EU Eastern enlargement

    Matúš Mišík, Monika Brusenbauch Meislová•Journal of Contemporary European…•2025

  • Religion, civilisation, geography

    Richard Mcmahon•Journal of Contemporary European…•2017

  • On temporal determinants of European Union enlargement

    Open Access•Isa Camyar•Comparative European Politics•2009

  • From Nation-States to Member States

    Open Access•John K Glenn•Comparative European Politics•2004

  • Interest groups and EU-Turkey relations

    Open Access•Orhan Günay•Turkish Studies•2024

  • A Certain Sense of Europe

    Open Access•Helene Sjursen•European Societies•2012

  • Do norms matter? The principle of solidarity and the EU's eastern enlargement

    Open Access•Elena Jileva•Journal of International…•2004

  • Power beyond conditionality

    Open Access•Jakob Skovgaard•Journal of International…•2011

  • L'européanisation comme processus de transfert de politique publique

    Sabine Saurugger, Yves Surel•Revue internationale de politique…•2006

  • Status Quo Bias or Institutionalisation for Reversibility

    Geoffrey Pridham•Europe Asia Studies•2008

  • Securing the Only Game in Town

    Geoffrey Pridham•Europe Asia Studies•2009

  • Assessing Accession

    Eamonn Butler•Europe Asia Studies•2014

  • Health care across borders

    Open Access•August Österle•Journal of European Social Policy•2007

  • Does EU Enlargement Start a Race to the Bottom? Strategic Interaction among EU Member States in Social Policy

    Open Access•Jon Kvist•Journal of European Social Policy•2004

  • The Weakest Link? EU Accession and Enlargement

    Open Access•Noémi Lendvai•Journal of European Social Policy•2004

  • European Social Model

    Juraj Draxler, Olaf Van Vliet•Journal of European Integration•2010

  • Ukraine and the European Union

    Mikhail A Molchanov•Journal of European Integration•2004

  • Doorkeepers and Gatecrashers

    Herbert Brücker, Philipp J H Schröder et al.•Journal of European Integration•2004

  • Barriers to Socialization

    John A Scherpereel, Matthew C Zierler•Journal of European Integration•2011

  • From Policy to Politics? Informal Practices within the Social Protection Committee after the Enlargement

    Anna Horváth•Journal of European Integration•2008

  • Two steps forward one step back

    Oliver Schwarz•Journal of European Integration•2016

  • Can constitution–building advance European integration? A three–pillared institutionalist analysis

    Hungdah Su•Journal of European Integration•2004

  • Repenser les relations entre transferts et apprentissages en Europe centrale Les théories de l’européanisation à l’épreuve du changement des politiques de développement local en Bulgarie (1990-2013)

    Thierry Delpeuch, Margarita Vassileva•Revue d’études comparatives…•2013

  • R epenser les relations entre transferts et apprentissages en E urope centrale

    Thierry Delpeuch, Margarita Vassileva•Revue d’études comparatives…•2013

  • The Dynamics of Enlargement in International Organizations

    Julia Gray, René Lindstädt et al.•International Interactions•2016

  • Gaining a Stake in Global Internet Governance

    Open Access•George Christou, Seamus Simpson•European Journal of Communication•2007

  • Transnational cooperation

    Margit Bussmann, Sebastian Nickel•Journal of Baltic Studies•2018

  • Uncharted growth

    Open Access•Eyal Rubinson, Chen Kertcher•Third World Quarterly•2026

  • Judicial Globalization, Europeanization and (G)localization

    Ramona Coman, Jacques Commaille•Southeastern Europe•2016

  • The Role of the EU in Facilitating a Hard Implementation Dialogue

    Bardhok Bashota, Afrim Hoti•Southeastern Europe•2021

  • Transfers and Learning in the Framework of Bulgarian Legal Reforms (1990–2013)

    Thierry Delpeuch, Margarita Vassileva•Southeastern Europe•2016

  • The Role of European Union Integration in Post-Communist Democratization in Bulgaria and Macedonia

    Open Access•Simeon Mitropolitski•Canadian Slavonic Papers•2013

  • Social dialogue during enlargement

    Open Access•Tomasz Grzegorz Grosse•Acta Politica•2010

  • For and against European Union expansion

    Open Access•Jeffrey C Dixon, Andrew S Fullerton•International Journal of…•2014

  • Civil society in Central and Eastern Europe

    Open Access•Amelie Kutter, Vera Trappmann•Acta Politica•2010

  • Enabling harmonization – Business actors and the eastern enlargement of the EU

    Open Access•Charalampos Koutalakis•Acta Politica•2010

  • European security and the accession of Turkey

    Open Access•Senem Aydın-Düzgit•Cooperation and Conflict•2013

  • Narrative-Based Production of State Spaces for International Region Building

    Alun Jones•Annals of the Association of…•2006

  • Lógica da (In)apropriação? Os problemas do construtivismo na análise do alargamento da União Européia

    Open Access•Fabiano Mielniczuk, Fabiano Pellin Mielniczuk•Estudos Internacionais Revista de…•2019

  • "Development Challenges of the "New Europe

    Open Access•Richard J Estes•Social Indicators Research•2004

  • The Europeanisation of Employment Policy in the Czech Republic

    Open Access•Anne Schüttpelz•Revija za socijalnu politiku•2006

  • EU external governance in 'wider Europe

    Sandra Lavenex•Journal of European Public Policy•2004

  • Research Design in European Studies

    Open Access•Theofanis Exadaktylos, Claudio M Radaelli•JCMS Journal of Common Market…•2009

  • Qualitative research in six European countries and cities on the relation between the Facilitators’ Package and racism

    Anja Van den Durpel•European Politics and Society•2016

  • Democracy in Central and Eastern Europe

    N Bandelj, Katelyn Finley et al.•East European Politics•2015

  • A governance perspective on the European neighbourhood policy

    Sandra Lavenex•Journal of European Public Policy•2008

  • International Institutions and Socialization in Europe

    Jeffrey T Checkel•International Organization•2005

  • Help your neighbor, help yourself

    Open Access•Karina Shyrokykh•Governance•2022

  • Turkey and the European Union

    Open Access•Claire Visier•European journal of Turkish studies•2009

  • Market imperative meets normative power

    Open Access•Jennifer L Erickson•European Journal of International…•2013

  • A Strategic–Relational Approach to European Union Enlargement

    Open Access•Nikolaos Tzifakis, Eleni Vasdoka•Comparative Southeast European…•2025

  • Opposition to Enlargement among “New” and “Old” Europeans

    Jeffrey C Dixon, Andrew S Fullerton•Comparative Sociology•2014

  • Praca socjalna - analiza instytucjonalna z perspektywy konwersacyjnej

    Open Access•Mariusz Granosik•Praca socjalna - analiza…•2013

  • Oligarchization, formalization, adaptation? Linking Sociological Theory and EU Enlargement Research

    Stefanie Bailer, Robin Hertz et al.•Journal of European Public Policy•2009

  • Why Expand

    Open Access•Helene Sjursen•JCMS Journal of Common Market…•2002

  • EU-Erweiterungspolitik in der Zeitenwende

    Open Access•Barbara Lippert•Zeitschrift für Politikwissenschaft•2023

  • External differentiation as a strategy of system maintenance

    Maria Giulia Amadio Viceré, Matteo Bonomi•West European Politics•2025

  • Rhetorical action in a liberal international order in crisis

    Open Access•Dirk Leuffen, Антоанета Димитрова et al.•Journal of European Public Policy•2025

  • Restituting victims

    Ainius Lašas•Journal of European Public Policy•2008

  • From transformation to demarcation

    Open Access•Marius Ghincea, Laurențiu Pleșca•Journal of European Public Policy•2025

  • Why widening makes deepening

    Eva G Heidbreder•Journal of European Public Policy•2014

  • EU political accession conditionality after the 2004 enlargement

    Frank Schimmelfennig•Journal of European Public Policy•2008

  • A Bridge Too Phare? EU Pre‐Accession Aid and Capacity‐Building in the Candidate Countries

    Open Access•David Bailey, Lisa De Propris•JCMS Journal of Common Market…•2004

  • The EU's Political Conditionality and Post‐Accession Tendencies

    Open Access•Geoffrey Pridham•JCMS Journal of Common Market…•2008

  • The Internal Value of External Options

    Open Access•Walter Mattli, Thomas Plümper•European Union Politics•2004

  • Constituent power and its institutions

    Open Access•Joel I Colón-Ríos, Joel I Colón‐río et al.•Contemporary Political Theory•2021

  • Promotion de la démocratie dans les Balkans

    Open Access•Diane Éthier•Canadian Journal of Political…•2006

  • The Political Economy of Regional Integration

    Christina J Schneider•Annual Review of Political Science•2017

  • Contested Compliance

    Open Access•Antje Wiener•European Journal of International…•2004

  • Opposition to enlargement as a symbolic defence of group position

    Open Access•Jeffrey C Dixon•British Journal of Sociology•2010

  • Missing conceptual links in the international environmental policy debate

    David P Dolowitz•Environmental Politics•2020

  • Constructing the nation-state

    Connie L Mcneely•Constructing the nation-state•1995

  • National Interests in International Society

    Martha Finnemore•National Interests in International…•1996

  • The Logic of Regional Integration

    Open Access•Walter Mattli•Logic of Regional Integration•1999

  • The Social Construction of Europe

    Thomas Christiansen, Knud Jørgensen et al.•The Social Construction of Europe•2001

  • Political community at the international level

    Karl W Deutsch•Political community at the…

  • Uniting Of Europe

    Ernst B Haas, Ernst Haas•Uniting of Europe•2020

  • Eastern Enlargement

    Ulrich Sedelmeier•The State of the European Union•2000

  • The Political and Institutional Consequences of Widening

    Bart Kerremans•The State of the European Union,…•1998

  • Theories of International Regimes

    Open Access•Andreas Hasenclever, Peter Mayer et al.•Theories of International Regimes•1997

  • Eastern enlargement

    Ulrich Sedelmeier•The Politics of European Union…•2005

  • The Origins of Alliances

    Stephen M Walt•Origins of Alliances•2019

  • Accommodation beyond self-interest

    Ulrich Sedelmeier•Politique européenne•2001

  • Sovereignty Bargains in Regional Integration

    Open Access•Walter Mattli•International Studies Review•2000

  • Understanding the Domestic Impact of International Norms

    Open Access•Andrew P Cortell, James W Davis et al.•International Studies Review•2000

  • Russia as Central Europe's Constituting Other

    Open Access•Iver B Neumann•East European Politics and…•1993

  • The anatomy of autonomy

    Open Access•Orfeo Fioretos, KARL-ORFEO FIORETOS•Review of International Studies•1997

  • A public choice approach to international organization

    Open Access•Roland Vaubel•Public Choice•1986

  • The Enlargement of Europe

    Stanley Hoffmann, Stuart Croft et al.•Foreign Affairs•1999

  • An Economic Theory of Clubs

    James M Buchanan•Economica•1965

  • And Then They Were 15

    Open Access•Lykke Friis•Cooperation and Conflict•1998

  • The power of legislative hot air

    Stefanie Bailer, Gerald Schneider•Journal of Legislative Studies•2000

  • Turbo-charged negotiations

    Lykke Friis, Anna Murphy•Journal of European Public Policy•2000

  • Towards Convergence in Europe? Institutional Adaptation to Europeanization in Germany and Spain

    Open Access•Tanja A Bürzel•JCMS Journal of Common Market…•1999

  • The European Union and Central and Eastern Europe

    Open Access•Lykke Friis, Anna Murphy•JCMS Journal of Common Market…•1999

  • How Pervasive are Euro‐Politics? Effects of EU Membership on a New Member State

    Open Access•Gerda Falkner•JCMS Journal of Common Market…•2000

  • Norms, Institutions, and National Identity in Contemporary Europe

    Jeffrey T Checkel•International Studies Quarterly•1999

  • The Community Trap

    Open Access•Frank Schimmelfennig•International Organization•2001

  • Origins of the European Bank for Reconstruction and Development

    Open Access•Steven Weber•International Organization•1994

  • Between deepening and widening

    Henning Tewes•West European Politics•1998

  • Constructing institutional interests

    K M Fierke, Antje Wiener•Journal of European Public Policy•1999

  • Approaching the 'third half' of EU grand bargaining - the post-negotiation phase of the 'Europe Agreement game

    Lykke Friis•Journal of European Public Policy•1998

  • Why States Act through Formal International Organizations

    Open Access•Kenneth W Abbott, Duncan Snidal•Journal of Conflict Resolution•1998

  • An institutional critique of intergovernmentalism

    Open Access•Geoffrey Garrett, George Tsebelis•International Organization•1996

  • Three Neo-Functional Hypotheses About International Integration

    Open Access•Philippe C Schmitter•International Organization•1969

  • Let's Argue

    Open Access•Thomas Risse•International Organization•2000

  • Catching the EC Train

    Open Access•Cédric Dupont, Pascal Sciarini et al.•European Journal of International…•1999

  • The New Raison d'État as a Problem for Democracy in World Society

    Open Access•Klaus Dieter Wolf•European Journal of International…•1999

  • The Politics, Power, and Pathologies of International Organizations

    Open Access•Michael N Barnett, Michael Barnett et al.•International Organization•1999

Unique citing works100
Citations per year4,17
Citation span2002 - 2026 (25)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 98

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae