Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

A Movement Society Evaluated

Collective Protest in The United States, 1960-1986

Bibliographic Data

ID6304752
AuthorsSarah A Soule (University of Arizona), Sarah Soule (University of Arizona, Tucson, AZ), Jennifer Earl (0000-0002-0904-1605, University of California, Santa Barbara, CA)
Year2005
Volume10
Issue3
Pages345-364
Publication date2005-10-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessNo
TypeARTICLE
VenueMobilization An International Quarterly (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 1086-671X • E-ISSN: 1938-1514
PublisherMobilization Journal (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.17813/maiq.10.3.730350353753l022
OpenAlexW2256353642
LanguageEN
Citations received70
References cited21

In an attempt to make sense of shifts in the social movement sector and its relationship to conventional politics over the past forty years, some have proposed that Western nations are increasingly becoming "movement societies." Accordingly, there are four key characteristics of the movement society: (1) over time expansion of protest; (2) over time diffusion of protest; (3) over time institutionalization of protest; and (4) over time institutionalization of state responses to protest. Using newly available data on over 19,000 protest events occurring in the U.S. between 1960 and 1986, we evaluate these four claims. Our findings suggest that movement society scholars are correct in some respects: the size of protest events has grown over time, the percentage of events at which at least one social movement organization is present has increased over time, the number of distinct protest claims has increased over time, and violent forms of protest policing have decreased over time. However, our findings call into question other movement society claims: the number of protests has declined over time, fewer organizations were present at each protest event over time, fewer new groups initiated events over time, fewer new claims emerged over time, and there was more significant activity by groups on the right in the 1960s and 1970s than expected. We suggest potential explanations for some of the negative findings in an attempt to refine the movement society arguments

Institutionalisation · Movement (music · Political economy · Political science · Politics · Social movement · Sociology · State (computer science · Electoral Systems and Political Participation · Law · Political Conflict and Governance · Social Capital and Networks

  • Cultural Analysis of Political Protest

    Hank Johnston•Handbooks of Sociology and Social…•2010

  • Movements and Parties

    Sidney Tarrow•Movements and Parties•2021

  • Climate Extremes and Protests in India, Pakistan, and Bangladesh, 1995–2013

    Open Access•Regina Werum, Michael J Hayes et al.•Weather, Climate, and Society•2025

  • La configuración de la flexibilización laboral. 50 años de transformaciones internacionales del mundo del trabajo

    Open Access•Claudio Llanos Reyes, J A Gonzalez•Revista CUHSO•2023

  • Embedded data activism

    Yu Sun, Vincent G Huang•Chinese Journal of Communication•2022

  • Situational Breakdowns

    Anne Nassauer•Situational Breakdowns•2019

  • The Cement of Civil Society

    Open Access•M Diani•Cement of Civil Society•2015

  • Negotiating White Power Activist Stigma

    P Simi, Robert Futrell•Social Problems•2009

  • Protest and Policymaking

    B G King, Keith Gunnar Bentele et al.•Social Forces•2007

  • The activist’s dilemma

    Matthew Feinberg, R Willer et al.•Journal of Personality and Social…•2020

  • Institutional Movement Logics and the Changing Shape of the US Social Movement Field, 1960–1995

    Open Access•Jeff Larson, Omar Lizardo•Social Forces•2019

  • The Nature of Popular Protest and the Employment of Repressive State Capacity in China

    Shinn‐Shyr Wang, Shinn-Shyr Wang et al.•Issues & Studies•2019

  • Environmental Movement Interventions in Tourism and Energy Development in the North Atlantic

    Mark C J Stoddart, Alice Mattoni et al.•Contention•2020

  • Accounting for the Decreasing Willingness of U.S. High School Seniors to Protest, 1976–2015

    Open Access•Hyun Woo Kim, John D Mccarthy•Social Currents•2018

  • Social Movements and Tactical Choice

    Open Access•Jeff A Larson•Sociology Compass•2013

  • Youth, activism, and social movements

    Open Access•Jennifer Earl, Thomas V Maher et al.•Sociology Compass•2017

  • Quantifying the power and consequences of social media protest

    Open Access•Deen Freelon, Charlton D Mcilwain et al.•New Media & Society•2016

  • The Mediation Model

    Erin M Evans, E Amenta et al.•Society and Animals•2021

  • Whatever can go wrong will

    C Warner, John D Mccarthy•Policing & Society•2013

  • Pursuing Social Change Online

    Open Access•Jennifer Earl•Social Science Computer Review•2006

  • Civil society and extreme-right collective action in Poland 1990–2013

    Daniel Platek, Piotr Płucienniczak•Revue d’études comparatives…•2016

  • The Impact of Protest on Elections in the United States

    Open Access•Daniel Q Gillion, Sarah A Soule•Social Science Quarterly•2018

  • Becoming a Movement Society? Patterns in the Public Acceptance of Protest, 1985–2006

    Soon Seok Park, R L Einwohner•Sociological Focus•2019

  • All the labor problems fit to print

    Quan D Mai•Labor History•2016

  • Repressing Protest

    Phillip M Ayoub, Phillip Ayoub•Mobilization An International…•2010

  • Different worlds of contention? Protest in Northwestern, Southern and Eastern Europe

    Open Access•Endre Borbáth, Theresa Gessler•European Journal of Political…•2020

  • Protesting in ‘hard times

    Open Access•Marta Quaranta, Mario Quaranta•Current Sociology•2016

  • Sector-Level Dynamics and Collective Action in the United States, 1965-1975

    Jeff Larson, Sarah A Soule et al.•Mobilization An International…•2009

  • Movement Institutions

    Open Access•L Bereni, Anne Revillard•Politics & Gender•2018

  • Three Prompts for Collective Action in the Context of Digital Media

    Bruce Bimber•Political Communication•2017

  • Contentious Activities, Disrespectful Protesters

    Open Access•Raynee Sarah Gutting•Political Behavior•2020

  • Explaining Differential Protest Participation

    Clare Saunders, Maria Grasso et al.•Mobilization An International…•2012

  • The Movement Society in Comparative Perspective

    Kyle Dodson•Mobilization An International…•2011

  • Velvet Glove, Iron Fist, or Even Hand? Protest Policing in the United States, 1960-1990

    Sarah A Soule, Sarah Soule et al.•Mobilization An International…•2009

  • Movement Analysis on the Fly

    D S Meyer•Mobilization An International…•2021

  • Seeing Blue

    Jennifer Earl, Sarah A Soule et al.•Mobilization An International…•2006

  • Describing and Accounting for the Trends in US Protest Policing, 1960−1995

    Open Access•Patrick Rafail, Sarah A Soule et al.•Journal of Conflict Resolution•2012

  • Contentious Institutionalization of Protests under Democracy

    Open Access•M S Ho, Yun-Chung Ting•Government and Opposition•2024

  • Isomorphism, Institutional Parochialism, and the Study of Social Movements

    Stephen C Poulson, Cory P Caswell et al.•Social movement studies•2014

  • Multi-Issue, Internet-Mediated Interest Organizations and their Implications for US Politics

    Victoria Carty•Social movement studies•2011

  • Scale shift in international tax justice

    Michael Vaughan•Social movement studies•2019

  • Profile

    D S Meyer•Social movement studies•2024

  • The future of the internet hangs in the balance

    Jared M Wright•Social movement studies•2024

  • Marching and voting

    Salvador Aldana Fernández, Andrés Santana et al.•The Social Science Journal•2025

  • Has protest increased since the 1970s? How a survey question can construct a spurious trend

    Open Access•Michael Biggs•British Journal of Sociology•2015

  • Protesting While Black

    Open Access•Christian Davenport, Sarah A Soule et al.•American Sociological Review•2011

  • A Social Movement Generation

    Open Access•Neal Caren, R Ghoshal et al.•American Sociological Review•2011

  • Why Targets Matter

    Open Access•Andrew W Martins, Andrew W Martin et al.•American Sociological Review•2009

  • All the Movements Fit to Print

    Open Access•E Amenta, Neal Caren et al.•American Sociological Review•2009

  • Prayers, Protest, and Police

    Open Access•Kraig Beyerlein, Sarah A Soule et al.•American Sociological Review•2015

  • The long cultural backlash movement

    Open Access•Amirhossein Teimouri•International Social Science…•2024

  • "Where do all the lovers go?" - The Cultural Politics of Public Kissing in Mumbai, India (1950-2005)

    Open Access•Sneha Annavarapu•Journal of Historical Sociology•2018

  • The Effect of Paramilitary Protest Policing on Protestors' Trust in the Police

    Open Access•Gali Perry, Tal Jonathan-Zamir et al.•Law & Society Review•2017

  • Action Organization Analysis

    Open Access•Maria Kousis, Maurizio Giugni et al.•American Behavioral Scientist•2018

  • Mexican Movers and Shakers

    Open Access•María Inclán•Latin American Politics and Society•2019

  • How the Islamic Republic Has Responded to Everyday Resistance Against the Mandatory Hijab

    Open Access•Amirhossein Teimouri•Critical Sociology•2024

  • Civic Recreation and a Theory of Civic Production

    Open Access•Peter Hart-Brinson•Sociological Theory•2012

  • Permeable Participation

    Open Access•Patrick Rafail, Isaac Freitas•Sociological Perspectives•2017

  • Size Matters

    Open Access•Michael Biggs•Sociological Methods & Research•2018

  • The Civic Engagement Gap(s)

    Open Access•Sarah Gaby•Youth & Society•2017

  • How Do Voluntary Organizations Foster Protest? The Role of Organizational Involvement on Individual Protest Participation

    Open Access•N M Somma•Sociological Quarterly•2010

  • Movement Societies and Digital Protest

    Open Access•Jennifer Earl, Katrina Kimport•Sociological Theory•2009

  • Globalization and Protest Expansion

    Kyle Dodson•Social Problems•2015

  • Softer Policing or the Institutionalization of Protest? Decomposing Changes in Observed Protest Policing over Time

    Thomas Elliott, Tom Elliott et al.•American Journal of Sociology•2022

  • Plausibility Structures, Status Threats, and the Establishment of Anti-Abortion Pregnancy Centers

    Rory Mcveigh, Bryant Crubaugh et al.•American Journal of Sociology•2017

  • Issue Bricolage

    Wooseok Jung, B G King et al.•American Journal of Sociology•2014

  • Confronting the State, the Corporation, and the Academy

    Edward T Walker, Andrew W Martins et al.•American Journal of Sociology•2008

  • Competition and Resource Partitioning in Three Social Movement Industries

    Sarah A Soule, B G King•American Journal of Sociology•2008

  • The Institutionalization of Anti-Business Protest, 1960-1995

    Andrew W Martins, Andrew W Martin et al.•Sociological Quarterly•2020

  • How to study political activists

    Open Access•Rachel M Durso, Rachel Durso et al.•Social Science Research•2018

  • Poor People's Movements

    Frances Fox Piven, Richard Cloward•Poor People's Movements•1978

  • Contentious Curricula

    Amy J Binder•Contentious Curricula•2009

  • Mobilizing Interest Groups in America

    Open Access•Jack L Walker, Jack Walker•Mobilizing interest groups in…•1991

  • The Targets of Social Movements

    Nella Van Dyke, Sarah A Soule et al.•Authority in contention•2004

  • The Demand and Supply of Participation

    Bert Klandermans•Blackwell Companion to Social…•2007

  • Dynamics of Contention

    Open Access•Doug Mcadam, Sidney Tarrow et al.•Dynamics of Contention•2001

  • Structural Incentives for Conservative Mobilization

    R Mcveighn•Social Forces•1999

  • The Anti-Abortion Movement and the Rise of the Religious Right

    Suzanne Staggenborg, Dallas A Blanchard•Contemporary Sociology A Journal…•1995

  • Under The Spotlight

    Dominique Wisler, Maurizio Giugni et al.•Mobilization An International…•1999

  • Linking Organization and Mobilization

    Dieter Rucht•Mobilization An International…•1999

  • Towards a 'Movement Society'? On the possibilities of institutionalizing social movements

    Dieter Rucht, Friedhelm Neidhardt•Social movement studies•2002

  • The Dynamics of Protest Waves

    Ruud Koopmans•American Sociological Review•1993

  • The Consequences of Professionalization and Formalization in the Pro-Choice Movement

    Suzanne Staggenborg•American Sociological Review•1988

  • Process and Protest

    Alan Schussman, A Soule et al.•Social Forces•2005

  • Political Process and the Development of Black Insurgency, 1930-1970

    Doug Mcadam•Political process and the…•1999

  • Structural Social Change and the Mobilizing Effect of Threat

    Nella Van Dyke, Sarah A Soule•Social Problems•2002

  • Associations and Interest Groups

    David Knoke•Annual Review of Sociology•1986

  • Tanks, Tear Gas, and Taxes

    Open Access•Jennifer Earl•Sociological Theory•2003

  • Social Movements in Organizations

    Mayer N Zald, Michael A Berger•American Journal of Sociology•1978

  • Bending with the Wind

    Debra Minkoff, Debra C Minkoff•American Journal of Sociology•1999

Unique citing works70
Citations per year3,5
Citation span2006 - 2025 (20)
Citation velocityrecent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 70

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae