Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Political parties and interest groups

Disentangling complex relationships

Bibliographic Data

ID6315751
AuthorsElin Haugsgjerd Allern (0000-0002-2583-5827, University of Oslo), Tim Bale (0000-0001-5917-1312, University of Sussex)
Year2012
Volume18
Issue1
Pages7-25
Publication date2012-01-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueParty Politics (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 1354-0688 • E-ISSN: 1460-3683
PublisherSAGE Publications Inc (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1177/1354068811422639
OpenAlexW2101895544
LanguageEN
Citations received99
References cited75

According to a widespread assumption, party–interest group links are significantly weaker than they used to be. Both sets of organizations, it is said, now prefer autonomy over the constraints implied by close relationships, especially in supposedly ‘cartelized’ established party systems but also in new democracies. In this article, we briefly review existing literature on party–group links and argue that the common wisdom – and this particular aspect of Katz and Mair’s cartel thesis – may need to be qualified. First, we have to define more precisely what we mean when we talk about the relationships in question, not least because they may assume myriad forms. Second, the little empirical research that has been done hints at a good deal of variety, both over time and between polities and parties. Third, we must further explore possible explanations for such differences in party–group relations, including the motives of the actors involved. The substantive articles in this special issue throw new light on all three issues

Autonomy · Cartel · Collusion · Economics · Epistemology · Law and economics · Political economy · Political science · Politics · Positive economics · Sociology · Variety (cybernetics · Electoral Systems and Political Participation · Labor Movements and Unions · Law · Political Influence and Corporate Strategies

  • Employer Organizations and Labour Immigration Policy in Australia and the United Kingdom

    Open Access•Chris F Wright•British Journal of Industrial…•2017

  • Towards Better Understanding of Party‐Union Relationship

    Open Access•Paweł Kamiński, Szczepan Czarnecki•Industrial Relations Journal•2025

  • Trade Union Legitimacy and Legitimation Politics in Australia and New Zealand

    Open Access•Chris F Wright, Colm McLaughlin•Industrial Relations A Journal of…•2021

  • The relative importance of industrial relations ideas in politics

    Open Access•J Ryan Lamare, John W Budd•Industrial Relations A Journal of…•2022

  • Going, going, . . . gone? The decline of party membership in contemporary Europe

    Open Access•Ingrid Van Biezen, Peter Mair et al.•European Journal of Political…•2012

  • New partners on the street? Cooperation between radical left parties and progressive social movements in Portugal

    Open Access•Tiago Conceição, Carlos Jalali et al.•Comparative European Politics•2026

  • Looking for Ariadne’s thread

    Open Access•Marco Lisi, Rui Oliveira et al.•Politics•2023

  • Political parties' framing of farm animal welfare

    Open Access•Renate Marie Butli Hårstad, Jostein Vik•European Policy Analysis•2022

  • Party-group disentanglement in the Italian case

    Renata Lizzi•Contemporary Italian Politics•2014

  • Interest Groups in Multi-Level Contexts

    Open Access•Joost Berkhout, Marcel Hanegraaff et al.•Politics and Governance•2020

  • When illiberalism looms-mortality anxiety and the perceived existential threat among Polish and Slovenian interest groups

    Open Access•Paweł Kamiński, Rafał Riedel•Interest Groups & Advocacy•2021

  • Balancing gains and hazards

    Open Access•A S Binderkrantz•Interest Groups & Advocacy•2015

  • Formal ties between interest groups and members of parliament

    Open Access•Steven Eichenberger, A Mach•Interest Groups & Advocacy•2017

  • Exploring the impact of partisan gatekeeping on interest group representation and bias

    Open Access•Andrea Pritoni•Interest Groups & Advocacy•2018

  • Interest groups and political parties in Central and Eastern Europe

    Open Access•Szczepan Czarnecki, Emilia Piotrowska•Interest Groups & Advocacy•2021

  • Associative linkages of political parties in Latin America

    Open Access•Patricia Otero-Felipe, Leticia María Ruiz Rodríguez et al.•Interest Groups & Advocacy•2025

  • Time is of the Essence

    Open Access•Ellis Aizenberg, Marcel Hanegraaff•The International Journal of…•2019

  • Business versus citizens

    Open Access•Andreas Dür, Robert A Huber et al.•European Political Science Review•2026

  • Maintaining registration and tax benefits

    Milka Ivanovska Hadjievska, Torill Stavenes•Journal of Civil Society•2020

  • Campaigns without civil society? The involvement of organized interests in electoral politics

    Marco Lisi, João Gaio E Silva•Journal of Civil Society•2023

  • Influence or support? Member perspectives on youth wings in political parties

    Open Access•Niklas Bolin•European Political Science•2025

  • Using Cognitive Mapping to Longitudinally Examine Political Brand Associations

    Alexander Ewan MacDonald, Roger Sherlock et al.•Journal of Political Marketing•2018

  • It Is All About Money! What Drives Interest Groups’ Relations with Political Parties in Central and Eastern Europe

    Open Access•Paweł Kamiński•Political Studies Review•2022

  • Left parties and trade unions in France

    Open Access•Nick Parsons•French Politics•2015

  • Each one is with their own electorate”

    Open Access•Vladimir Bortun•Comparative European Politics•2026

  • Breaking up is hard to do’

    Open Access•Wade Jacoby, Martin Behrens•Comparative European Politics•2014

  • Radical left cooperation in twenty-first century Western Europe

    Open Access•Giorgos Charalambous, DANIEL KEITH et al.•Comparative European Politics•2026

  • Partisan theory in forest nature conservation policy

    Open Access•Max Göhrs, Christiane Hubo et al.•Forest Policy and Economics•2021

  • In whose interests? Former rebel parties and ex-combatant interest group mobilisation in Aceh and East Timor

    Gyda Marås Sindre•Civil Wars•2016

  • Conceptualising party-driven movements

    Open Access•Janine Muldoon, Danny Rye•The British Journal of Politics…•2020

  • Party–interest group relations in Portugal

    Isabella Razzuoli, Filipa Raimundo•Mediterranean Politics•2018

  • Political party–interest group linkages in Greece before and after the onset of the economic crisis

    Dimitrios A Sotiropoulos, Dimitri A Sotiropoulos•Mediterranean Politics•2018

  • Party-group relations in new southern European democracies in the crisis era

    Marco Lisi•Mediterranean Politics•2018

  • Standing Alone? Towards a More Unified View of Party–Group Relations in Contemporary Democracies

    Open Access•Marco Lisi, Rui Oliveira•European Review•2020

  • State intervention in low-wage work

    Open Access•Joshua Cova•European Journal of Industrial…•2025

  • The impact of trade unions and government party orientation on income inequality

    Open Access•Constantinos Alexiou, Emmanouil Trachanas•Journal of Economic Studies•2022

  • When Social Partners Unite – Explaining Continuity and Change in A ustrian and D utch Labour Market Governance

    Open Access•Menno Soentken, J Timo Weishaupt•Social Policy and Administration•2015

  • Home is where the heart is? A comparative analysis of Flemish and Danish parties' organizational linkages with the EU

    Open Access•Gilles Pittoors•Scandinavian Political Studies•2024

  • Interactions between Interest Groups and Political Parties in the Czech Republic and Slovakia - Three Decades after the Velvet Divorce

    Open Access•Szczepan Czarnecki•Czech Sociological Review•2026

  • Do Politicians Listen to Youth Wings? Evidence from an Elite Experiment

    Henrik B Seeberg•The Journal of Politics•2025

  • Playing soldiers

    Wolfgang Werner•Journal of Southern African Studies•1990

  • Self-maintenance vs. goal attainment

    Open Access•Nicole Bolleyer, Patricia Corrêa•European Political Science Review•2020

  • Rediscovering Civil Society? Renewal and Continuity in the Portuguese Radical Left

    Marco Lisi•South European Society & Politics•2013

  • Zippin’ up My Boots, Goin’ Back to My Roots

    Iván Llamazares, Myrto Tsakatika et al.•South European Society & Politics•2013

  • Following the Money

    Open Access•Alexander Katsaitis•JCMS Journal of Common Market…•2020

  • Party–group interactions in Southern Europe

    Open Access•Marco Lisi•Italian Political Science…•2022

  • Change of government and interest groups' preference attainment on the formulation of the Italian National Recovery and Resilience Plan (NRRP)

    Open Access•Andrea Pritoni, Alberto Bitonti et al.•Italian Political Science…•2023

  • Legislators, organizations and ties

    Open Access•Raimondas Ibenskas, Adriana Bunea•European Journal of Political…•2021

  • A comparative and dynamic analysis of political party positions on energy technologies

    Open Access•Nicolas Schmid•Environmental Innovation and…•2021

  • National interest organisations in EU policy-making

    Rainer Eising, Daniel Rasch et al.•West European Politics•2017

  • Dissensus on the plate

    Adalgisa Martinelli•European Politics and Society•2025

  • Labour and left-wing parties’ programmatic orientations

    Marco Lisi•European Politics and Society•2021

  • Political participation of young people in political parties

    Open Access•Regina Weber•Zeitschrift für Politikwissenschaft•2017

  • Lobbying during government formations

    Open Access•Jeroen Romeijn•West European Politics•2021

  • State funding pressure in interest groups, political parties and service-oriented membership organisations

    Nicole Bolleyer•West European Politics•2021

  • Cleavage theory meets civil society

    Open Access•Alex Mierke-Zatwarnicki, Endre Borbáth et al.•West European Politics•2025

  • Special Interest Trade-Offs

    Melani Cammett, Lucas M Novaes et al.•The Journal of Politics•2025

  • Interest Group Support and Electoral Success in the Swiss Elections of 2015. A Candidate Survey Analysis

    Open Access•Georg Lutz, A Mach et al.•Swiss Political Science Review•2018

  • Federalism, Government Liberalism, and Union Weakness in America

    Open Access•David Darmofal, Nathan J Kelly et al.•State Politics & Policy Quarterly•2019

  • Trade Unions and Political Parties in Italy (1946–2014)

    Andrea Ceron, Fedra Negri•South European Society & Politics•2017

  • The Radical Left's Turn towards Civil Society in Greece

    Iván Llamazares, Myrto Tsakatika et al.•South European Society & Politics•2013

  • Impulse and Decadence of Linkage Processes

    Luis Ramiro, Tània Verge Mestre et al.•South European Society & Politics•2013

  • The Contemporary Relationship of ‘New Left’ and ‘New Right’ Parties with Interest Groups

    Open Access•Elin Haugsgjerd Allern•Scandinavian Political Studies•2013

  • Are Political Parties More Responsive to Advocacy Groups Mobilising Core Voters or Swing Voters? Political Responsiveness to Citizens' Protest Movements in Swedish Local Governments

    Open Access•Jonas Larsson Taghizadeh•Scandinavian Political Studies•2016

  • Part of the Elite”? Anti-Austerity Populism and Trade Unionism in Italy and Spain

    Open Access•Enrico Padoan•Revista de Estudios Políticos•2019

  • From agents of the people to agents of authority? How illiberal populism impacts interactions between regulatory agencies and external stakeholders

    Open Access•Michael Dobbins, Rafael Labanino•Regulation & Governance•2025

  • How parties and interest groups protect their ties

    Open Access•Michele Crepaz•Regulation & Governance•2021

  • Party think tanks as adaptation to the challenge of party linkage

    Open Access•Narelle Miragliotta•Politics•2021

  • Activist Parties and Hybrid Party Behaviours

    Open Access•Alejandro M Peña•Political Studies Review•2021

  • Political Parties and Interest Organizations at the Crossroads

    Open Access•Bert Fraussen, Darren Halpin et al.•Political Studies Review•2018

  • Selecting Ministers in Times of Crisis

    Open Access•Johan Bo Davidsson, Hanna Bäck•Political Studies•2019

  • The decline of membership-based politics

    Open Access•Ingrid Van Biezen, Thomas Poguntke•Party Politics•2014

  • Cartelization versus representation? On a misconception in contemporary party theory

    Open Access•Henrik Enroth•Party Politics•2017

  • Holding on to voters in volatile times

    Open Access•Nick Martins, Sarah L De Lange et al.•Party Politics•2022

  • Power and position

    Open Access•Iskander De Bruycker•Party Politics•2016

  • The collaboration between interest groups and political parties in multi-party democracies

    Open Access•Simon Otje, Anne Rasmussen•Party Politics•2017

  • Who still likes social democracy? The support base of social democratic parties reconsidered

    Open Access•Björn Bremer, Line Rennwald•Party Politics•2023

  • The contingent character of interest groups–political parties’ interaction

    Open Access•Laura Chaqués-Bonafont, Camilo Cristancho et al.•Journal of Public Policy•2021

  • Assessing the prominence of interest groups in parliament

    Open Access•Bert Fraussen, Tiffany Graham et al.•Journal of Legislative Studies•2018

  • The alignment of parties and interest groups in EU legislative politics. A tale of two different worlds

    Jan Beyers, Iskander De Bruycker et al.•Journal of European Public Policy•2015

  • Images of an Unbiased Interest System

    David Lowery, F R Baumgartner et al.•Journal of European Public Policy•2015

  • The partisan politics of institutional welfare state reform

    Michael Baggesen Klitgaard, G Schumacher et al.•Journal of European Public Policy•2015

  • Varieties of Inclusionary Populism? Syriza, Podemos and the Five Star Movement

    Open Access•Nuria Font, Paolo Graziano et al.•Government and Opposition•2021

  • Knowledge Is Power

    Open Access•Pieter Moens•Government and Opposition•2023

  • Balancing constituency and congruence

    Open Access•Evelien Willems, Iskander De Bruycker•Governance•2021

  • Cooperation in networks

    Open Access•Arndt Wonka, Sebastian Haun•European Union Politics•2020

  • Public opinion towards interest groups

    Open Access•Anne Rasmussen, Stefanie Reher•European Journal of Political…•2025

  • Origins of party formation and new party success in advanced democracies

    Open Access•Nicole Bolleyer, Evelyn Bytzek•European Journal of Political…•2013

  • Union members at the polls in diverse trade union landscapes

    Open Access•Christoph Arndt, Line Rennwald•European Journal of Political…•2016

  • Center-Right Parties and Post-War Secondary Education

    Anja Giudici, Jane Gingrich et al.•Comparative Politics•2023

  • Building Parties’ Grassroots

    Open Access•Luís Locatelli•Brazilian Political Science Review•2022

  • Does the Australian Labor Party care about climate change? A content analysis of ALP attitudes towards the environment from 2007 to 2013

    Babet De Groot•Australian Journal of Political…•2022

  • Setting the Party Agenda

    Open Access•Heinrich Kluver, Heike Klüver•British Journal of Political…•2020

  • Diversity in the News? A Study of Interest Groups in the Media in the UK, Spain and Denmark

    Open Access•Anne Skorkjær Binderkrantz, Laura Chaqués-Bonafont et al.•British Journal of Political…•2017

  • Party Institutionalization and Welfare State Development

    Open Access•Magnus Bergli Rasmussen, Carl Henrik Knutsen•British Journal of Political…•2021

  • How to study political parties

    Open Access•Nicole Bolleyer•Irish Political Studies•2024

  • Organização de novos partidos políticos

    Open Access•Décio Vieira Da Rocha•Revista Brasileira de Ciência…•2021

  • The politics of immigration locally

    Juan Carlos Triviño-Salazar•Ethnic and Racial Studies•2018

  • What's Work Got to Do with It? How Precarity Influences Radical Party Support in France and the Netherlands

    Open Access•Lorenza Antonucci, Carlo D’ippoliti et al.•Sociological Research Online•2023

  • Party systems and voter alignments

    Seymour Martin Lipset•Party systems and voter alignments•1967

  • The Contentious Alliance

    Lewis Minkin•The Contentious Alliance•1993

  • Linking Political Parties and Interest Groups

    M T Heaney•The Oxford handbook of American…•2010

  • Basic Interests

    F R Baumgartner, Beth L Leech•Basic Interests•1998

  • Confessions of an Interest Group

    Carolyn M Warner•Confessions of an Interest Group•2000

  • The Transformation of European Social Democracy

    Open Access•Herbert Kitschelt•Transformation of European Social…•1994

  • Political Parties and Interest Groups

    Bart Kerremans, Andrew Appleton et al.•Political Parties and Interest…•2001

  • Democracy Between Consolidation and Crisis

    Leonardo Morlino•Democracy between consolidation…•1998

  • Political Parties and Democracy

    L Diamond, Larry Jay Diamond et al.•Political Parties and Democracy•2001

  • Party Organizational Linkage

    Thomas Poguntke•Political parties in the new Europe•2002

  • The Logics of Party Formation

    Herbert Kitschelt•Logics of Party Formation•1989

  • Challenging the political order

    Russell J Dalton•Challenging the political order•1990

  • Politics, parties, & pressure groups.

    V O Key•Politics, parties, & pressure…•1964

  • Party System Change

    Peter Mair•Party System Change•1998

  • Political Parties in Western Democracies

    Leon D Epstein•Political Parties in Western…•2020

  • How Parties Organize

    Richard Katz, Richard S Katz et al.•How Parties Organize•1994

  • New Labour and the Trade Unions in Britain

    Thomas Quinn•Journal of Elections Public…•2010

  • Political Parties in New Democracies

    Open Access•Ingrid Van Biezen•Political Parties in New…•2003

  • The Transformation of the Western European Party Systems

    Otto Kirchheimer•Political Parties and Political…•1966

  • The Ascendancy of the Party in Public Office

    Richard S Katz, Peter Mair•Political parties•2002

  • Social Movements and Networks

    Mario Diani, Doug Mcadam•Social movements and networks•2003

  • When Parties Fail

    Kay Lawson, Peter H Merkl•When Parties Fail•1988

  • A History of Social Democracy in Postwar Europe

    Lutz R Reuter, Stephen Padgett et al.•German Studies Review•1994

  • Interest Groups in Norwegian Politics

    R E Gooderham•International Affairs•1977

  • Political Parties

    Brian Chapman•International Affairs•1955

  • Researching Interest Group Politics in Europe and Elsewhere

    Jan Beyers, Rainer Eising et al.•West European Politics•2008

  • Converging Perspectives on Interest Group Research in Europe and America

    Christine Mahoney, F R Baumgartner et al.•West European Politics•2008

  • National Labor Movements in the Postwar World

    Willis D Weatherford, Everett M Kassalow•Industrial and Labor Relations…•1964

  • Political parties, popular legitimacy and public privilege

    Peter Mair•West European Politics•1995

  • Policy Issues, Organisational Format and the Political Strategies of Interest Organisations

    Jan Beyers•West European Politics•2008

  • From Catch-all Politics to Cartelisation

    Mark Blyth, Richard Katz et al.•West European Politics•2005

  • Labour Market Organisations’ Participation in Swedish Public Policy–Making

    Open Access•Torsten Svensson, Perola Öberg•Scandinavian Political Studies•2002

  • Political Parties in Western Democracies

    Anthony King•Polity•1969

  • The Ecology of Party–Organized Interest Relationships

    Open Access•Christopher Witko•Polity•2009

  • Interest Group Strategies

    Open Access•Anne Skorkjær Binderkrantz, Anne Binderkrantz•Political Studies•2005

  • The Life-Span of Labour Parties

    Open Access•D W Rawson•Political Studies•1969

  • Block Voting in the Labour Party

    Open Access•Thomas Quinn•Party Politics•2002

  • Cadre, Catch-All or Cartel

    Open Access•Richard S Katz, Peter Mair•Party Politics•1996

  • After the Divorce

    Open Access•Nicholas Aylott•Party Politics•2003

  • Women's Movements and Political Parties

    Open Access•Lisa Young•Party Politics•1996

  • Political Parties as Public Utilities

    Open Access•Ingrid Van Biezen•Party Politics•2004

  • Bringing Society Back in

    Open Access•Yael Yishai•Party Politics•2001

  • De-Linking Labor

    Open Access•James A Piazza, James Piazza•Party Politics•2001

  • Cadre, Catch-all or Cartel

    Open Access•Ruud Koole•Party Politics•1996

  • Parties, promiscuity and politicisation

    Open Access•Iain Mcmenamin•European Journal of Political…•2004

  • Old and new politics

    Open Access•Hanspeter Kriesi, Philip Van Praag•European Journal of Political…•1987

  • Social Democrats and trade unions in Scandinavia

    Open Access•Elin Haugsgjerd Allern, Nicholas Aylott et al.•European Journal of Political…•2007

  • Organizational interlocks between new social movements and traditional elites

    Open Access•Rudiger Schmitt•European Journal of Political…•1989

  • Citizens, politicians, and party cartellization

    Open Access•Herbert Kitschelt•European Journal of Political…•2000

  • On the theory and practice of party formation and adaptation in new democracies

    Open Access•Ingrid Van Biezen•European Journal of Political…•2005

  • Trade Unionists, Party Activists, and Politicians

    Thomas A Koelble•Comparative Politics•1987

  • Cooperative Party Factions in American Politics

    Open Access•Gregory Koger, Seth Masket et al.•American Politics Research•2010

  • The Cartel Party Thesis

    Open Access•Richard S Katz, Peter Mair•Perspectives on Politics•2009

  • Changing Models of Party Organization and Party Democracy

    Open Access•Richard S Katz, Peter Mair•Party Politics•1995

  • Political Parties in Norway

    Erik Allardt, Henry Valen et al.•American Sociological Review•1965

  • More social movements or fewer? Beyond political opportunity structures to relational fields

    Open Access•Jack A Goldstone, Jack Α Goldstone•Theory and Society•2004

Unique citing works99
Citations per year2,75
Citation span1990 - 2026 (37)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 99

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae