Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Does Local Government Fragmentation Reduce Local Spending

Bibliographic Data

ID6404089
AuthorsRebecca M Hendrick (University of Illinois at Chicago, Chicago, IL, USA,), Rebecca Hendrick (0000-0002-7016-8947, University of Illinois Chicago, corresponding author), Benedict S Jimenez (0000-0002-4184-7713, Rutgers University-Newark, Newark, NJ, USA), Kamna Lal (University of Illinois at Chicago, Chicago, IL, USA)
Year2011
Volume47
Issue4
Pages467-510
Publication date2011-07-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueUrban Affairs Review (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 1078-0874 • E-ISSN: 1552-8332
PublisherSAGE Publications Inc (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1177/1078087411400379
OpenAlexW3125754733
LanguageEN
Citations received43
References cited42

This study uses multiple measures of fragmentation and decentralization to assess the effects of these conditions on total local spending in 126 metropolitan regions and 538 counties in the same regions in 2002. The measures are derived from a recognized scheme that distinguishes among total, horizontal, and vertical dimensions of these conditions, and the models control for other causes of total local spending, including sprawl and interlocal spending. The study finds support for the claim that total spending by local governments is higher in regions and counties with more single purpose governments (vertical fragmentation), but also jurisdictions where a greater percentage of spending is done by counties (centralization). Findings also vary by unit of analysis and type of special purpose government, which suggests that the effects of governing structure are not as straightforward as theory suggests

Decentralization · Economics · Fragmentation (computing · Geography · Government spending · Local government · Metropolitan area · Political science · Public economics · Urban planning · Urban sprawl · Welfare · Fiscal Policies and Political Economy · Fiscal Policy and Economic Growth · Local Government Finance and Decentralization · Public Administration

  • Municipal Fragmentation and Metropolitan Open Space Patterns

    Open Access•Stephan Schmidt, Wenzheng Li•Urban Affairs Review•2026

  • Mapping non-profits participation in disaster mitigation

    Open Access•Xinjie Zhao, Hao Wang et al.•International Journal of Disaster…•2025

  • Are Metropolitan Areas Primed for Success? A Prosperity Risk Index for Evaluating Economic Development Patterns

    Open Access•Richard C Sadler, Dayne Walling et al.•Urban Planning•2020

  • Local autonomy and service delivery

    Xin Chen•Public Management Review•2024

  • Decentralisation or patronage

    Open Access•Amin Masud Ali, Antonio Savoia•European Journal of Political…•2023

  • The fiscal consequences of special district consolidation

    Open Access•Travis St Clair•Regional Science and Urban…•2026

  • The problem of the fiscal common-pool

    Open Access•Yu Shi, Rebecca Hendrick•Journal of Public Budgeting…•2020

  • When Demand Mixes and Matches with Supply

    Open Access•Jiahuan Lu, Bin Chen et al.•Nonprofit Policy Forum•2026

  • What determines the government’s policy instrument choice for steering nonprofit organizations? The role of government capacity and contextual complexity

    Zejin Liu, Steven Van De Walle•Journal of Asian Public Policy•2021

  • Does local government fragmentation reduce poverty? Evidence from Bangladesh

    Open Access•Amin Masud Ali, Antonio Savoia•The Journal of Economic Inequality•2025

  • Opting Out of Transit

    Open Access•David Weinreich, Ahmad Bonakdar•Public Works Management & Policy•2020

  • What Influences the Growth of the Chinese Nonprofit Sector

    Open Access•Jiahuan Lu, Qiang Dong•Voluntas Revista Internacional de…•2018

  • Self-Organizing Special Districts

    Open Access•Brian Y An•Journal of Planning Education and…•2022

  • Exploring the Determinants of Variations in Land Use Policy Outcomes

    Open Access•Jae Hong Kim•Journal of Planning Education and…•2019

  • How Can We Better Study the Links between Regional Governance and Public Service Outcomes? Governance Topologies in Metropolitan Public Transportation Systems

    Open Access•Thomas Skuzinski, David Weinreich et al.•Journal of Planning Education and…•2022

  • Designing Proper Fiscal Arrangements for Sub-Local Decentralization in Montreal

    Jean-Philippe Meloche, Jean‐Philippe Meloche et al.•Journal of Urban Affairs•2014

  • Is there anybody out there?” Political implications of a territorial integration

    Miguel Ângelo Rodrigues, Oliver Meza•Journal of Urban Affairs•2017

  • Governing through austerity

    Nik Theodore•Journal of Urban Affairs•2019

  • Bottom-Up or Top-Down Local Service Delivery? Assessing the Impacts of Special Districts as Community Governance Model

    Open Access•Brian Y An•The American Review of Public…•2020

  • Sorting Through the Determinants of Local Government Competition

    Open Access•Michael Overton•The American Review of Public…•2016

  • Externalities in the Fragmented Metropolis

    Open Access•Benedict S Jimenez•The American Review of Public…•2014

  • Functional Responsibilities of Municipal Governments

    Open Access•Agustin Leon-Moreta•The American Review of Public…•2016

  • Political fragmentation and land use changes in the Interior Plains

    Open Access•Jae Hong Kim, Jaewoo Cho et al.•Population and Environment•2015

  • The Effect of Fragmentation and Second-Order Devolution on Efficacy of Local Public Welfare Policy

    Michael Craw•Publius The Journal of Federalism•2015

  • These rules are made for spending

    Open Access•Germà Bel, Ringa Raudla et al.•Public Choice•2018

  • Impacts of political fragmentation on inclusive economic resilience

    Open Access•Soomi Lee, Shu Wang•Urban Studies•2023

  • Intra‐provincial fiscal decentralization, relative wealth, and healthcare efficiency

    Open Access•Shuo Sun, Rhys Andrews•Public Administration•2022

  • Collaborating with the competition? A study of interlocal partnership choices

    Open Access•Meghan E Rubado•Public Administration•2021

  • Special-purpose authorities

    Open Access•Khaldoun Abouassi, Ann O’m Bowman et al.•International Review of…•2015

  • Macro-Level Determinants of Local Government Interaction

    Open Access•Rebecca Hendrick, Yu Shi•Urban Affairs Review•2015

  • Power to the People? The Initiative Process and Fiscal Discipline in City Governments

    Open Access•Benedict S Jimenez•Urban Affairs Review•2019

  • Boundaries and Speed Bumps

    Open Access•Aaron Deslatte•Urban Affairs Review•2017

  • Institutional Analysis of Neighborhood Collective Action

    Open Access•Michael Craw•Public Administration Review•2016

  • Separate, Unequal, and Ignored? Interjurisdictional Competition and the Budgetary Choices of Poor and Affluent Municipalities

    Open Access•Benedict S Jimenez•Public Administration Review•2014

  • Policy of Delay

    Open Access•Aaron Deslatte, Antonio F Tavares et al.•Policy Studies Journal•2018

  • The Economic and Political Impacts of Top-Down Territorial Reforms

    Antonio F Tavares, Miguel Rodrigues et al.•Local Government Studies•2015

  • The expansion of the public sector in federalism

    Yu Shi•Local Government Studies•2020

  • Municipal Government Form and Budget Outcomes

    Open Access•Benedict S Jimenez•Journal of Public Administration…•2020

  • Interjurisdictional Competition and Intracity Fiscal Disparity across Chinese Prefectural Cities

    Open Access•Huiping Li, Qingfang Wang et al.•Governance•2017

  • Tax base fragmentation as a dimension of metropolitan inequality

    Open Access•Robert Manduca, Brian Highsmith et al.•Socio-Economic Review•2025

  • Urban Pressures and Innovations

    Open Access•Aaron Deslatte, Richard C Feiock et al.•Review of Policy Research•2017

  • Fiscal Centralization and Inequality in Children's Economic Mobility

    Open Access•Rourke O’brien, M Schechtl et al.•American Sociological Review•2025

  • Metropolitan governance structure and growth-inequality dynamics in the United States

    Open Access•Jaewoo Cho, Jae Hong Kim et al.•Environment and Planning A…•2019

  • The power to tax

    Geoffrey Brennan, James M Buchanan•The power to tax•1980

  • Cities without Suburbs

    David Rusk•Cities without suburbs•1993

  • The Competitive City

    Mark Schneider•The Competitive City•1989

  • Tax and Expenditure Limitations

    Open Access•Daniel R Mullins, Bruce A Wallin•Public Budgeting & Finance•2004

  • Does Economic Sclerosis Set in with Age? An Empirical Study of the Olson Hypothesis

    Open Access•John Joseph Wallis, John Wallis et al.•Kyklos•1988

  • Tiebout's Sorting Hypothesis

    Open Access•Robert M Stein•Urban Affairs Quarterly•1987

  • Local Government Fragmentation

    Open Access•Drew A Dolan•Urban Affairs Quarterly•1990

  • Is there a Relationship between Fragmentation and Local Government Costs

    Open Access•George A Boyne•Urban Affairs Quarterly•1992

  • What We Argue about When We Argue about Regionalism

    Todd Swanstrom•Journal of Urban Affairs•2001

  • Local Government Constitutions

    Open Access•Ronald J Oakerson, Roger B Parks•The American Review of Public…•1989

  • Economic competition and political competition

    Open Access•Thomas J Dilorenzo•Public Choice•1983

  • The median voter hypothesis

    Open Access•Geoffrey K Turnbull, Salpie S Djoundourian et al.•Public Choice•1994

  • Overlapping jurisdictions

    Open Access•Geoffrey K Turnbull, Salpie S Djoundourian et al.•Public Choice•1993

  • Revenue structure, fiscal illusion, and budgetary choice

    Open Access•Richard E Wagner•Public Choice•1976

  • Leviathan and Fiscal Illusion in Local Government Overlapping Jurisdictions

    Open Access•Rebecca Campbell, Rebecca J Campbell•Public Choice•2004

  • An empirical analysis of state and local tax structure in the context of the Leviathan model of government

    Open Access•Michael A Nelson•Public Choice•1986

  • Fragmentation and the growth of local government

    Open Access•Mark Schneider•Public Choice•1986

  • Economic competition and political competition

    Open Access•George J Stigler•Public Choice•1972

  • Local Government Structure and Performance

    Open Access•George A Boyne•Public Administration•1992

  • Metropolitan Government and Governance

    Open Access•Richard M Flanagan, Richard Flanagan•Political Science Quarterly•2000

  • A Pure Theory of Local Expenditures

    Charles M Tiebout•Journal of Political Economy•1956

  • Exploring the Horizontal and Vertical Dimensions of the Governing of Metropolitan Regions

    Open Access•D Kirk Hamilton, David Y Miller et al.•Urban Affairs Review•2004

  • Taming the Local Leviathan

    Open Access•Michael Craw•Urban Affairs Review•2008

  • Political Participation and Metropolitan Institutional Contexts

    Open Access•Christine A Kelleher, Christine Kelleher et al.•Urban Affairs Review•2004

  • Interlocal Cooperation and the Distribution of Federal Grant Awards

    Kenneth N Bickers, Robert M Stein•The Journal of Politics•2004

  • Fragmentation, Fiscal Mobility, and Efficiency

    Keith Dowding, Thanos Mergoupis•The Journal of Politics•2003

  • The Tiebout Hypothesis 50 Years Later

    Open Access•Michael Howell‐moroney•Public Administration Review•2008

  • A Transactions Costs Model of Metropolitan Governance

    David Lowery•Journal of Public Administration…•2000

  • Intermunicipal Competition, Budget-Maximizing Bureaucrats, and the Level of Suburban Competition

    Mark Schneider•American Journal of Political…•1989

  • Piling On

    Open Access•Christopher R Berry, Christopher Berry•American Journal of Political…•2008

Unique citing works43
Citations per year3,58
Citation span2014 - 2026 (13)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 42

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae