Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

The boundary setting of Chinese netizens’ citizenship identity

Social media responses to the Regulations of the PRC on the Administration of Permanent Residence of Foreigners

Bibliographic Data

ID7309970
AuthorsZhonghua Guo (0000-0003-0942-7513, Nanjing University, corresponding author), Zhuozhao Tao (Sun Yat-sen University)
Year2023
Volume9
Issue1
Pages104-129
Publication date2023-01-18
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessNo
TypeARTICLE
VenueJournal of Chinese Governance (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 2381-2354 • E-ISSN: 2381-2346
PublisherTaylor & Francis (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1080/23812346.2023.2166561
OpenAlexW4317387904
LanguageEN
Citations received16
References cited53

Since Reform and Opening Up, the Chinese government has been under pressure regarding policy on the residence of foreign migrants to the country. In response, the Chinese government released a document entitled the Regulations of the PRC on the Administration of Permanent Residence of Foreigners in February 2020, which has roused fierce social opposition, as reflected in Chinese netizens' attitudes towards foreign immigrants and citizenship identity. Based on online discussions in the Zhihu community, in this paper, we investigated the exclusive and inclusive boundaries of Chinese netizens' citizenship identity through quantitative and thematic textual analyses. The exclusive boundary includes racial and historical discourses that raise insurmountable walls between Chinese people and foreign immigrants, while the inclusive boundary is reflected in citizenship rights and access criteria. The issues of 'super-national treatment' (privileges enjoyed by foreign nationals with permanent Chinese residency) and 'low access criteria' (the relative ease with which foreign immigrants can obtain permanent residence in China) for foreign immigrants have weakened the openness of the inclusive boundary, causing netizens who were once willing to accept foreign immigrants to oppose the presence of non-native groups in the country. This study deepens our understanding of Chinese netizens' citizenship identity and contributes to citizenship identity theory

Administration (probate law · Aesthetics · Art · Boundary (topology · Citizenship · Identity (music · Political science · Residence · Social media · Sociology · Asian Culture and Media Studies · China's Socioeconomic Reforms and Governance · Gender Studies · Law · Philippine History and Culture

  • Machine learning in public administration research

    Min Yao, Lei Liu•International Public Management…•2026

  • Customers’ brand avoidance intention to exaggerated advertising in the digital age

    Open Access•Jizhi Chen, Yanan Wang et al.•Frontiers in Communication•2026

  • Corporate Social Responsibility and Brand Community Engagement

    Open Access•Moazzam Abbas, Zubair Nawaz et al.•Fudan Journal of the Humanities…•2024

  • Value co-creation in shared mobility

    Open Access•Chao Tian, Tian Chao et al.•Technological Forecasting and…•2024

  • Negotiating Gender, Race, and Nationhood in Parenting on Douyin

    Open Access•Xinxin Jiang•Social Media + Society•2025

  • Confronting the Citizenship’s Sacred Blood Aristocracy Principle

    Open Access•Dimitry Kochenov, Elena Basheska•Fudan Journal of the Humanities…•2026

  • Unveiling digital narratives of transnational migration to China

    Xintian Li, Guodong Du et al.•Chinese Journal of Communication•2026

  • Social media as a tool for cultural storytelling

    Meng Yang•International Journal of…•2025

  • Selective Migration Policies With Chinese Characteristics

    Open Access•Rey Koslowski, Sheng Ding•Journal on Migration and Human…•2024

  • Naturalised athletes as national icons

    Xiaoyu Zhang, Delia Dumitrica et al.•Culture Sport Society•2026

  • Examining the discursive construction of Chinese grassroots cybernationalism

    Open Access•Jiapei Gu, Salomi Boukala•Journal of Language Aggression…•2025

  • How Do Online Public Messages Affect Local Government Responsiveness in China? A Multilevel Analysis Based on the Message Board for Leaders

    Open Access•Difei Hu, Enmei Wang et al.•Journal of Chinese Political…•2023

  • Propaganda with Subculture

    Open Access•Yukun Li, Dongshu Liu et al.•Journal of Chinese Political…•2025

  • What does the ideal citizen look like in China's new era? A bottom-up view

    Open Access•Zhenzhou Zhao•Citizenship Studies•2023

  • Introduction

    Open Access•Zhenzhou Zhao, Canglong Wang et al.•Citizenship Studies•2023

  • From ethnic segregation to equal political status

    Zhonghua Guo•Citizenship Studies•2023

  • Contesting Citizenship in Urban China

    Dorothy J Solinger•Contesting Citizenship in Urban…•1999

  • Citizenship and Nationhood in France and Germany

    Rogers Brubaker•Citizenship and Nationhood in…•1992

  • Citizenship and Identity

    Engin Isin, Patricia A Wood et al.•Citizenship and Identity•1999

  • The Broken Ladder

    Open Access•Yihan Xiong•The China Quarterly•2015

  • Citizenship and Social Class

    T H Marshall, Tom Bottomore•Citizenship and Social Class•1987

  • Civic Virtues

    Richard Dagger•Civic virtues•1997

  • History, identity, and security

    William A Callahan•Bulletin of Concerned Asian…•2006

  • World Citizenship and Government

    Open Access•Derek Heater•World Citizenship and Government•1996

  • The Routledge Handbook of Chinese Citizenship

    Zhonghua Guo•Routledge Handbook of Chinese…•2021

  • Social Identity

    Richard Jenkins•SOCIAL IDENTITY•1996

  • Factors Affecting Attitudes Toward Migrants

    Open Access•Yanfeng Gu, Xingxi Zhang et al.•Chinese Political Science Review•2021

  • Post-reform gender politics

    Altman Yuzhu Peng, James Cummings et al.•Feminist Media Studies•2020

  • Who Can Enter? A Multilevel Analysis on Public Support for Immigration Criteria across 20 European Countries

    Open Access•Eva G T Green•Group Processes & Intergroup…•2008

  • Public Opinion Backlash against China’s International Expansion

    Dongshu Liu, Li Shao•Journal of Contemporary China•2021

  • Resistance through Accommodation

    Open Access•Małgorzata Jakimów•Journal of Contemporary China•2017

  • Identity and trust in government

    Open Access•Geng Niu, Guochang Zhao•Cities•2018

  • Situational differences, migratory duration, and social integration of internal migrants in urban China

    Open Access•Xin Mai, Jiejing Wang•Cities•2022

  • To settle but not convert hukou among rural migrants in urban China

    Open Access•Jing Zhou, Liyue Lin et al.•Habitat International•2022

  • Intra-national citizenship and dual-hukou strategies among migrant families in China

    Open Access•Jing Zhou, Rowan Arundel et al.•Habitat International•2021

  • Citizenship and Civil Society

    Open Access•T Janoski, Richard Madsen•Citizenship and Civil Society•1998

  • Theorizing Chinese Citizenship

    Catherine Owens•Europe Asia Studies•2017

  • Migration regimes and the governance of citizenship

    Paola Pasquali•Journal of Chinese Governance•2020

  • National Identity of Locality

    Open Access•Zhongbin Huang, Zesen Yang et al.•Journal of Chinese Political…•2023

  • Legitimating exclusion and inclusion

    Sophia Woodman•Citizenship Studies•2017

  • Using thematic analysis in psychology

    Open Access•Braun, Virginia Braun et al.•Qualitative Research in Psychology•2006

  • Citizenship & Personal Identity

    Edward B Portis•Polity•1986

  • Text as Data

    Open Access•Justin Grimmer, Brandon M Stewart et al.•Political Analysis•2013

  • A flawed perspective

    Open Access•Allen Carlson•Nations and Nationalism•2009

  • It's complicated, isn't it

    Open Access•L Baldassar, Roberta Raffaetà•Ethnicities•2018

  • Dilemmas of a Multicultural Theory of Citizenship

    Open Access•Bhikhu Parekh•Constellations•1997

  • Public Attitudes Toward Immigration

    Jens Hainmueller, D J Hopkins•Annual Review of Political Science•2014

  • Industrial ecology and local citizenship of migrant children in urban China

    Yihan Xiong, Miao Li•Journal of Chinese Governance•2021

  • Citizenship Institutions in Chinese Peasant-Workers’ Everyday Life

    Open Access•Fayin Xu•Journal of Chinese Political…•2016

  • Citizenship in China

    Open Access•T Janoski•Journal of Chinese Political…•2014

  • Right-wing populism with Chinese characteristics? Identity, otherness and global imaginaries in debating world politics online

    Open Access•Chenchen Zhang•European Journal of International…•2020

  • Boris Johnson in hospital

    Open Access•Altman Yuzhu Peng, Ivy Shixin Zhang et al.•Media International Australia•2020

  • Citizenship education as NGO intervention

    Yihan Xiong, Miao Li•Citizenship Studies•2017

  • Differentiating citizenship in urban China

    Zhonghua Guo, Tuo Liang•Citizenship Studies•2017

  • Learning to be safe citizens

    Miaoyan Yang•Citizenship Studies•2017

  • Between Facts and Norms

    Jürgen Habermas•Between Facts and Norms•1996

Unique citing works16
Citations per year5,33
Citation span2023 - 2026 (4)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 16

Tools

Open DOI
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae