Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

National models, policy types, and the politics of immigration in liberal democracies

Bibliographic Data

ID7422334
AuthorsGary P Freeman (corresponding author)
Year2006
Volume29
Issue2
Pages227-247
Publication date2006-03-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessNo
TypeARTICLE
VenueWest European Politics (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0140-2382 • E-ISSN: 1743-9655
PublisherTaylor & Francis (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1080/01402380500512585
OpenAlexW1979204034
LanguageEN
Citations received85
References cited55

Immigration policy can be disaggregated into theoretically and empirically meaningful components which are associated with different issues and patterns of benefits and costs that elicit distinctive modes of politics. A four-part typology identifies concentrated distributive, diffuse distributive, redistributive, and regulatory policies, which predict client, majoritarian, interest group, and entrepreneurial modes of politics, respectively. The utility of the typology is illustrated with respect to policies concerning visas for permanent residence, non-immigrant visas for purposes other than work, temporary labour visas, and political asylum. The case studies generally indicate that immigration policy can be broken down into distinctive types that are associated with predicted modes of politics, but that these patterns are not always consistent across countries with different immigration experiences. Furthermore, the framing of policies is subject to change due to external events and political manipulation. The interaction between national models and policy types should be a central focus of comparative immigration research

Demographic economics · Economics · Framing (construction · Immigration · Immigration policy · Political economy · Political science · Politics · Residence · Sociology · Temporary work · Typology · Work (physics · Law · Migration and Labor Dynamics · Migration, Refugees, and Integration · Social Policy and Reform Studies

  • El discurso politico de integración de los inmigrantes en el nivel regional en España

    Open Access•Belén Fernández-Suárez, Belén Fernández Suárez•Revista TOMO•2015

  • The Economics of Temporary Migrations

    Christian Dustmann, Joseph-Simon Gorlach et al.•Journal of Economic Literature•2016

  • Immigration policy and market institutions in liberal market economies

    Open Access•Chris F Wright•Industrial Relations Journal•2012

  • Employers, the state and highly skilled migration

    Niina Kotavaara, Eeva-Kaisa Prokkola•European Planning Studies•2023

  • “The mother of all political problems”? On asylum seekers and elections

    Open Access•Lukas Tomberg, Karen Smith Stegen et al.•European Journal of Political…•2021

  • On Resilience

    Open Access•Philippe Bourbeau•On Resilience•2018

  • Comparative Immigration Policy

    John Money, Jeannette Money•Comparative Immigration Policy•2018

  • Towards a Systemic Theory of Irregular Migration

    Open Access•Gabriel Echeverría•Towards a Systemic Theory of…•2020

  • The International Law of Economic Migration

    Open Access•Joel P Trachtman•The International Law of Economic…•2009

  • Reconfiguring European Union Migration Governance

    Open Access•Midori Okabe•JCMS Journal of Common Market…•2026

  • Swedish Employers and Trade Unions, Varieties of Capitalism and Labour Migration Policies

    Open Access•Jesper Johansson•Nordic Journal of Migration…•2012

  • The impact of EU citizenship on migrant integration

    Open Access•Snježana Gregurović•Etnološka tribina•2019

  • Redaktören har ordet

    Open Access•Sverre Wide•Sociologisk Forskning•2016

  • Performing for multiple audiences

    Open Access•Antje Ellermann, Mireille Paquet•Migration Studies•2026

  • Theorizing Migration Policy

    Open Access•Christina Boswell•International Migration Review•2007

  • Preferenser och intressen hos Svenskt Näringsliv och Landsorganisationen om arbetskraftsinvandring under 2000-talets inledning

    Open Access•Jesper Johansson•Sociologisk Forskning•2016

  • The contextual cogs of “migrant jobs”

    Open Access•Seán King•Frontiers in Political Science•2022

  • Venue-Shopping and the Role of Non-governmental Organisations in the Development of the European Union Asylum Policy

    Open Access•Christian Kaunert, Sarah Léonard et al.•Comparative Migration Studies•2013

  • Migration studies at a crossroads

    Anna Boucher, Justin Gest•Migration Studies•2014

  • The EU Blue Card

    Lucie Cerna•Migration Studies•2013

  • Political economy of immigration policy

    Open Access•Louis Jaeck•Economia Politica•2024

  • The entanglement of employers and political elites in migration policymaking

    Sam Scott•Evidence & Policy•2022

  • Economic Migration and the Politics of Hospitality in Spain

    Open Access•Alex Balch•Politics & Policy•2010

  • From Progressive Pioneer to Nativist Crackdown

    Open Access•Robert C Turner, William Sharry•Politics & Policy•2012

  • Integration for whom? The migration bias in social norms

    Open Access•Stefan Manser-Egli, Philipp Lutz•European Societies•2025

  • Employer Preferences for Labour Migration

    Open Access•Georg Menz•The British Journal of Politics…•2011

  • Bringing the state back in’

    João Carvalho, João Miguel Duarte De Carvalho•Mediterranean Politics•2017

  • Skill Formation, Immigration and European Integration

    Steve Coulter•New Political Economy•2017

  • The effect of integration and social democratic welfare states on immigrants’ educational attainment

    Open Access•F Fossati•Journal of European Social Policy•2011

  • Temporary and circular migration in the construction of European migration governance

    Andrew Geddes•Cambridge Review of International…•2015

  • Resettlement vs. spontaneous applications

    Open Access•Pierre Georges Van Wolleghem•Journal of Refugee Studies•2025

  • Structure and Agency in Swedish Municipalities’ Reception of Unaccompanied Minors

    Gustav Lidén, Jon Nyhlén•Journal of Refugee Studies•2015

  • The short-term effects of visa restrictions on migrants’ legal status and well-being

    Open Access•Omar Hammoud-Gallego•World Development•2024

  • Rivalry, ethnicity, and asylum admissions worldwide

    Lamis Abdelaaty•International Interactions•2020

  • When Politics Trumps Economics

    Open Access•Melanie Kolbe•International Migration Review•2021

  • Swimming against the tide

    Linda Berg, Andrea Spehar•Policy Studies•2013

  • Managing labour migration in Malaysia

    Open Access•J T Anderson•Third World Quarterly•2021

  • Attracting High‐Skilled Immigrants

    Open Access•Lucie Cerna•International Migration•2014

  • Migrant workers or future citizens? Taiwan’s foreign mid-skilled workers program

    Open Access•Yi-Chun Chien, Sohoon Yi•New Community•2026

  • Redefining Human Security for Vulnerable Migrants in East Asia

    Open Access•Jay Song•Journal of Human Security•2015

  • Buying in? The political economy of investor migration in Western Europe

    Open Access•Erica Consterdine, James Hampshire•West European Politics•2023

  • A Conceptual Framework for Analysing Admission Policy

    Open Access•Claudia Schneider•Two Homelands•2017

  • The regional dimension in the global competition for talent

    Lucie Cerna, Meng-Hsuan Chou•Journal of European Public Policy•2014

  • Asylum Seekers in Europe

    Open Access•Silvia Angeloni, Francesco Maria Spano•Journal of International…•2018

  • Migration, Resilience and Security

    Philippe Bourbeau•New Community•2015

  • Coping with the asylum challenge

    Ludwig Bernhard, Dorothy Kaufmann•New Community•2018

  • The crisis as an opportunity for change? High-skilled immigration policies across Europe

    Lucie Cerna•New Community•2016

  • Immigrant integration

    Hermann Kurthen, Barbara Schmitter Heisler•Ethnic and Racial Studies•2008

  • The enfranchisement of resident aliens

    David C Earnest•Democratization•2015

  • Adjusting democracy indices to the age of mass migration

    David Altman•Contemporary Politics•2022

  • Paths to citizenship? Public views on the extension of rights to legal and second-generation immigrants in Europe

    Open Access•Alin M Ceobanu, Xavier Escandell•British Journal of Sociology•2011

  • Citizenship Rights for Immigrants

    Ruud Koopmans, Ines Michalowski et al.•American Journal of Sociology•2012

  • Politische Steuerung im Migrations-Integrations-Dilemma

    Open Access•Andreas Blätte•Zeitschrift für Politikwissenschaft•2016

  • Policy Legacies, Visa Reform and the Resilience of Immigration Politics

    Chris F Wright•West European Politics•2012

  • Allowing mobility and preventing migration? The combination of entry and stay in immigration policies

    Open Access•Philipp Lutz•West European Politics•2024

  • Does Social Mobility Matter? The Kafala System and Anti-Immigrant Sentiment

    Open Access•Amir Abdul Reda, Nicholas A R Fraser et al.•Political Studies Review•2023

  • The Role of Networks in the Development of UK Migration Policy

    Open Access•Will Somerville, W Goodman et al.•Political Studies•2010

  • The Role of Humanitarianism in Shaping Public Attitudes Toward Refugees

    Open Access•Nicholas A R Fraser, Go Murakami•Political Psychology•2022

  • The use of the abuse policy narrative in asylum debates and its effects on citizens’ opinion formation

    Open Access•Dorothy Kaufmann, Ludwig Bernhard•Journal of Public Policy•2023

  • The development of the EU asylum policy

    Open Access•Christian Kaunert, Sarah Léonard•Journal of European Public Policy•2012

  • When Will Left-Wing Governments Introduce Liberal Migration Policies? An Implication of Power Resources Theory

    Open Access•Kyung Joon Han•International Studies Quarterly•2015

  • Do immigrants at bay keep the xenophobes away? Post-entry rights and public opposition to immigrant admission

    Open Access•Philipp Lutz•European Political Science Review•2025

  • Explaining the immigration policy mix

    Open Access•Caroline Schultz, Philipp Lutz et al.•European Journal of Political…•2021

  • Mobilisation pénale et cycle politique au Canada

    Open Access•Marc Tremblay-Faulkner, Marc Tremblay‐faulkner•Canadian Journal of Political…•2015

  • Venue Shopping and Legitimacy

    Open Access•Mireille Paquet, Lindsay Larios•Canadian Journal of Political…•2018

  • Residential concentration and political engagement among racialized Canadians

    Open Access•Stephen E White, Antoine Bilodeau et al.•Political Geography•2023

  • Policy framing and denizen enfranchisement in Portugal

    Luicy Pedroza•Citizenship Studies•2013

  • The difference that empire makes

    T Janoski•Citizenship Studies•2009

  • Immigrants' acquisition of national citizenship in Portugal and Spain

    João Miguel Duarte De Carvalho•Citizenship Studies•2020

  • Making sense of immigration policy

    Open Access•Blanca Sánchez‐alonso•The Economic History Review•2013

  • When do states give voting rights to non-citizens? The role of population, policy, and politics on the timing of enfranchisement reforms in liberal democracies

    Elif Naz Kayran, Merve Erdilmen•New Community•2021

  • Two paths towards the exceptional extension of national voting rights to non-citizen residents

    David Altman, Sergio Huertas-Hernández et al.•New Community•2023

  • Perspectives of flow and place

    Open Access•Paula Hoffmeyer-Zlotnik•New Community•2024

  • The Politics and Discourse of Migrant Return

    Anne Koch•New Community•2014

  • Who drives migration discourse and in what direction? claims-making and political mobilisation analyses of labor migration in Israel

    A Kemp, R Raijman et al.•New Community•2022

  • Managed Migration under Labour

    Erica Consterdine•New Community•2015

  • Bureaucrats as Immigration Policy-makers

    Mireille Paquet•New Community•2015

  • Why Do States Adopt Liberal Immigration Policies? The Policymaking Dynamics of Skilled Visa Reform in Australia

    Chris F Wright•New Community•2015

  • The centre no longer holds

    Open Access•J Dennison, Andrew Geddes•New Community•2022

  • To see ourselves as others see us

    Arno Van Der Zwet•New Community•2016

  • Explaining Local Swedish Refugee Policy

    Open Access•Gustav Lidén, Jon Nyhlén•Journal of International…•2014

  • Dilemmas in Representation

    Open Access•J Cha, Justin Gest et al.•The Journal of Race Ethnicity and…•2025

  • Race and ethnicity in context

    Anna Zamora-Kapoor, Francisco Javier Moreno Fuentes et al.•Ethnic and Racial Studies•2017

  • British and French policies towards high-skilled immigration during the 2000s

    João Carvalho, João Miguel Duarte De Carvalho•Ethnic and Racial Studies•2014

  • Expanding the Electorate

    Open Access•David C Earnest•Journal of International…•2015

  • Political organizations

    James Q Wilson•Political organizations•1973

  • The French melting pot

    Gérard Noiriel•The French melting pot•1996

  • Here for good

    Stephen Castles•Here for good•1984

  • Limits of citizenship

    Yasemin Nuhoğlu Soysal•Limits of citizenship•1994

  • The new Americans

    Barry Edmonston•The new Americans•1997

  • Challenging Immigration and Ethnic Relations Politics

    Ruud Koopmans, Paul Statham•Challenging immigration and…•2000

  • Citizenship and Nationhood in France and Germany

    Rogers Brubaker•Citizenship and Nationhood in…•1992

  • Dividing Lines

    Daniel J Tichenor•Dividing Lines•2002

  • European Immigration Policy

    Open Access•Tomas Hammar•European Immigration Policy•1985

  • Europe's Postwar Growth

    Charles P Kindleberger•Europe's Postwar Growth•1967

  • Selecting by Origin

    Open Access•C Joppke•Selecting by Origin•2005

  • Controlling immigration

    Wayne A Cornelius•Controlling immigration•2004

  • Controlling a New Migration World

    D Bigo, Virginie Guiraudon et al.•Controlling a New Migration World•2003

  • Weapons of the Weak

    James C Scott•Weapons of the Weak•2017

  • U.S. Immigration Policy in an Age of Rights

    Debra L Delaet•U.S. Immigration Policy in an Age…•2000

  • International Immigration Policy

    Open Access•Eytan Meyers•International Immigration Policy•2004

  • Immigration Policy and the Challenge of Globalization

    Julie R Watts•Immigration Policy and the…•2018

  • The Human Face of Global Mobility

    Michael Peter Smith, Michael Smith et al.•Human Face of Global Mobility•2017

  • The Age of Migration

    Stephen Castles, Mark J Miller et al.•American Foreign Policy Interests•2005

  • The Age of Migration

    Open Access•Stephen Castles, Hein De Haas et al.•The Age of Migration•1998

  • Immigration and the Nation-State

    C Joppke•Immigration and the nation-state•1999

  • The Ethics and Politics of Asylum

    Open Access•Matthew J Gibney•Ethics and Politics of Asylum•2004

  • The Politics of Migration and Immigration in Europe

    Andrew Geddes, Peter Scholten•The politics of migration and…•2003

  • Asylum Levels and Trends in Industrialized Countries

    Bela Hovy•International Journal of Refugee…•2003

  • State‐Society Relations in the Making of Canadian Immigration Policy during the Mulroney Era

    Open Access•John W P Veugelers•Canadian Review of Sociology/Revue…•2000

  • The Politics of Rapid Legal Change

    Open Access•Peter H Schuck•Studies in American Political…•1992

  • U.S. immigration policy in an age of rights

    Open Access•Nancy N Haanstad•The Social Science Journal•2001

  • The Ramparts of Nations

    Martin A Schain•Journal of American Ethnic History•2003

  • Immigrant Incorporation in Western Democracies

    Open Access•Gary P Freeman•International Migration Review•2004

  • Allocational and Distributional Aspects of Future Immigration to Western Europe

    Thomas Straubhaar•International Migration Review•1992

  • The Congressional Politics of Immigration Reform

    Susan F Martins, Susan Forbes Martin et al.•International Migration Review•2000

  • Labor Unions and Immigration Policy in France

    Open Access•Leah Haus•International Migration Review•1999

  • Allocational and Distributional Aspects of Future Immigration to Western Europe

    Open Access•Thomas Straubhaar•International Migration Review•1992

  • Labor Unions and Immigration Policy in France

    Leah Haus•International Migration Review•1999

  • Modes of Immigration Politics in Liberal Democratic States

    Gary P Freeman•International Migration Review•1995

  • Decision Making vs. Policy Making

    Theodore J Lowi, Theodore Lowi et al.•Public Administration Review•1970

  • Political impediments to the resumption of labour migration to Western Europe

    Antony M Messina•West European Politics•1990

  • National Styles and Policy Sectors

    Open Access•Gary P Freeman•Journal of Public Policy•1985

  • Institutional crises and reforms in policy sectors

    Fleur Alink, Arjen Boin et al.•Journal of European Public Policy•2001

  • The Europeanization of Refugee Policies

    Open Access•Sandra Lavenex•JCMS Journal of Common Market…•2001

  • Openings in the wall

    Open Access•Leah Haus•International Organization•1995

  • Immigration and the new politics of inclusion and exclusion in the European Union

    Open Access•Lauren Mclaren, Lauren M Mclaren•European Journal of Political…•2001

  • American Business, Public Policy, Case-Studies, and Political Theory

    Open Access•Theodore J Lowi•World Politics•1964

  • Why Liberal States Accept Unwanted Immigration

    Open Access•C Joppke•World Politics•1998

  • European Integration and Migration Policy

    Open Access•Virginie Guiraudon•JCMS Journal of Common Market…•2000

  • Asylum and State Sovereignty

    Open Access•C Joppke•Comparative Political Studies•1997

  • Globalization, Embedded Realism, and Path Dependence

    Open Access•Russell Hansen, Randall Hansen•Comparative Political Studies•2002

  • Divergent Paths of Immigration Politics in the United States and Australia

    Open Access•Gary P Freeman, Bob Birrell•Population and Development Review•2001

  • The Great Divide

    Open Access•Damien Cahill, Katherine Betts et al.•Labour History•2000

Unique citing works85
Citations per year4,47
Citation span2007 - 2026 (20)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 84

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae