Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Citizenship Rights for Immigrants

National Political Processes and Cross-National Convergence in Western Europe, 1980–2008

Bibliographic Data

ID7609720
AuthorsRuud Koopmans (WZB Berlin Social Science Center), Ines Michalowski (0000-0002-6626-4346, WZB Berlin Social Science Center), Stine Waibel (WZB Berlin Social Science Center)
Year2012
Volume117
Issue4
Pages1202-1245
Publication date2012-01-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessNo
TypeARTICLE
VenueAmerican Journal of Sociology (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0002-9602 • E-ISSN: 1537-5390
PublisherUniversity of Chicago Press (PUBLISHER • US)
DOI10.1086/662707
PMID22594120
OpenAlexW1603752002
LanguageEN
Citations received223
References cited44

Immigrant citizenship rights in the nation-state reference both theories of cross-national convergence and the resilience of national political processes. This article investigates European countries' attribution of rights to immigrants: Have these rights become more inclusive and more similar across countries? Are they affected by EU membership, the role of the judiciary, the party in power, the size of the immigrant electorate, or pressure exerted by anti-immigrant parties? Original data on 10 European countries, 1980-2008, reveal no evidence for cross-national convergence. Rights tended to become more inclusive until 2002, but stagnated afterward. Electoral changes drive these trends: growth of the immigrant electorate led to expansion, but countermobilization by right-wing parties slowed or reversed liberalizations. These electoral mechanisms are in turn shaped by long-standing policy traditions, leading to strong path dependence and the reproduction of preexisting cross-national differences

Citizenship · Convergence (economics) · Demographic economics · Development economics · Economic growth · Economics · Immigration · Political economy · Political science · Politics · Psychological resilience · Sociology · State (computer science) · European Union Policy and Governance · Law · Migration, Refugees, and Integration · Populism, Right-Wing Movements · Social Psychology

  • Does anyone care about migrant rights? An analysis of why countries enter the convention on the rights of migrant workers and their families

    Shaina D Western, Sarah P Lockhart et al.•The International Journal of…•2019

  • The enfranchisement of resident aliens

    David C Earnest•Democratization•2015

  • My Child Will Be a Citizen

    Open Access•Alex Street•World Politics•2014

  • Fortifying Citizenship

    Open Access•W Goodman•World Politics•2012

  • How Integration Policies have Discovered Religion

    Open Access•Christine Brunn•Interdisciplinary Journal for…•2016

  • Territory and Democratic Politics

    Open Access•Oscar Mazzoleni•Territory and Democratic Politics•2024

  • Migrants and Welfare States

    Open Access•Christian Albrekt Larsen•Migrants and Welfare States•2022

  • Liberal Nationalism and Its Critics

    David Leslie Miller, Gina Gustavsson et al.•Liberal Nationalism and Its Critics•2019

  • Neoliberal Multiculturalism?

    Will Kymlicka, Peter A Hall et al.•Social Resilience in the…•2013

  • Planning in the multicultural city

    Open Access•Ruth Fincher, Kurt Iveson et al.•Progress in Planning•2014

  • Familialism and migrant welfare policy

    Anna Boucher•Policy & Politics•2014

  • The Political Sources of Solidarity in Diverse Societies

    Open Access•Keith Banting, Keith G Banting et al.•SSRN Electronic Journal•2015

  • Now I am also Israeli”

    Open Access•Deby Babis, Anabel Lifszyc‐friedlander et al.•International Migration•2017

  • Restrictions on Access to Social Protection by New Southern European Migrants in Belgium

    Open Access•Jean‐michel Lafleur, Jean-Michel Lafleur et al.•South-North Migration of EU…•2017

  • Unequal Europe

    J Beckfield•Unequal Europe•2019

  • How Integration Policies have Discovered Religion

    Open Access•Christine Brunn•Interdisciplinary Journal for…•2016

  • Migration studies at a crossroads

    Anna Boucher, Justin Gest•Migration Studies•2014

  • Explaining migrant integration policies

    Open Access•Giacomo Solano, D De Coninck•Migration Studies•2022

  • Интеграционная политика общества и отношение к мигрантам принимающего населения

    Open Access•A Tatarko•Психология. Журнал Высшей школы…•2019

  • The importance of citizenship for deserving Covid-19 treatment

    Open Access•Marc Helbling, R Maxwell et al.•Humanities and Social Sciences…•2022

  • Stagnated Liberalization, Long‐term Convergence, and Index Methodology

    Open Access•Sonja D Schmid•Global Policy•2021

  • Refugees and Beneficiaries of Subsidiary Protection

    Open Access•Francesco Pasetti, Carmine Conte•Global Policy•2021

  • Arabic heritage language education in Sweden

    Open Access•Ute Bohnacker, Pascale Wehbe et al.•European Journal of Educational…•2025

  • Looking back and abroad while (not) moving forward. Migration, ideas and the stability of citizenship in Spain

    Open Access•Francesco Pasetti, Reinhard Schweitzer•Frontiers in Sociology•2025

  • Votes, Votes, Votes

    Open Access•Theresa Reidy•Frontiers in Political Science•2021

  • Integration Policies and Immigrants’ Labor Market Outcomes in Europe

    Open Access•I Kogan•Sociological Science•2016

  • Ius soli the Italian way. The long and winding road to reform the citizenship law

    Guido Tintori•Contemporary Italian Politics•2018

  • The integrative force of political institutions? Direct democracy and voter turnout across ethnic and nativity groups

    Open Access•Anita Manatschal•Comparative Migration Studies•2021

  • Exchange rates and immigration policy

    Open Access•Adrian J Shin•Comparative Migration Studies•2021

  • Bridging the citizenship law implementation gap

    Open Access•Luuk van der Baaren•Comparative Migration Studies•2024

  • From culture to class - legitimate boundary making in German immigration debates on Southern and Eastern Europeans

    Open Access•Christian Ulbricht•Comparative Migration Studies•2019

  • Is the post-multicultural era pro-diversity

    Open Access•Tamar De Waal•Comparative Migration Studies•2018

  • Surveillance and prayer – comparing Muslim prison chaplaincy in Germany’s federal states

    Open Access•Lisa Harms-Dalibon•Comparative Migration Studies•2017

  • Full membership or equal rights? The link between naturalisation and integration policies for immigrants in 29 European states

    Open Access•Thomas Huddleston, Maarten Vink•Comparative Migration Studies•2015

  • Beyond opportunity structures

    Open Access•Oliver Strijbis•Comparative Migration Studies•2015

  • The architecture of national boundary regimes

    Open Access•Sonja D Schmid•Comparative Migration Studies•2020

  • Israel’s Politics of Citizenship

    Assaf Shapira•Israeli Studies Review•2018

  • Welfare Chauvinism, Economic Insecurity and the Asylum Seeker “Crisis”

    Open Access•B Heizmann, Alexander Jedinger et al.•Societies•2018

  • Ethnic diversity and schooling in national education systems

    Open Access•Daniel Faas•Education Inquiry•2013

  • Explaining the birthright citizenship lottery

    Open Access•Omer Solodoch, Udi Sommer•Regulation & Governance•2020

  • The fit between regulatory instruments and targets

    Open Access•Markus Hinterleitner, Dorothy Kaufmann et al.•Regulation & Governance•2022

  • Measuring Immigration Policies

    Open Access•Marc Helbling, Liv Bjerre et al.•European Political Science•2016

  • Who can ride along? Discrimination in a German carpooling market

    Open Access•Carol, Daniel Eich et al.•Population Space and Place•2019

  • Ideological justifications for restrictive immigration policies

    Open Access•Paul May•French Politics•2016

  • Cantonal variations of integration policy and their impact on immigrant educational inequality

    Open Access•Anita Manatschal, I Stadelmann-Steffen•Comparative European Politics•2013

  • Validating integration and citizenship policy indices

    Open Access•Marc Helbling•Comparative European Politics•2013

  • Mysterious multiculturalism

    Open Access•Jan Willem Duyvendak, Rogier Van Reekum et al.•Comparative European Politics•2013

  • What to expect when you’re electing

    Open Access•Michael A Hansen, Jennifer L Clemens•Comparative European Politics•2018

  • Indices of immigrant rights

    Open Access•Ruud Koopmans•Comparative European Politics•2013

  • Citizenship configurations

    Open Access•Maarten Vink, Maarten Peter Vink et al.•Comparative European Politics•2013

  • Is there really a retreat from multiculturalism policies? New evidence from the multiculturalism policy index

    Open Access•Keith Banting, Will Kymlicka•Comparative European Politics•2013

  • An illiberal inclusion? The AKP’s politics of exceptional citizenship

    Open Access•Ayşe Serdar•Turkish Studies•2022

  • Teachers’ multicultural attitudes and perceptions of school policy and school climate in relation to burnout

    Open Access•Anneke Dubbeld, Natascha De Hoog et al.•European Journal of Intercultural…•2019

  • National identity and attitudes towards immigration in Australia

    I Mcallister•National Identities•2016

  • Migration Background and Voting Behavior in Switzerland

    Open Access•Oliver Strijbis•Swiss Political Science Review•2014

  • Switzerland – Really Europe's Heart of Darkness

    Open Access•Anita Manatschal•Swiss Political Science Review•2015

  • Voting with Their Feet by Staying? The Political Drivers of Noncitizens' (Im‐)mobility

    Open Access•Salomon Bennour, Anita Manatschal•Swiss Political Science Review•2022

  • Immigration and Integration Policy in Switzerland, 1848 to 2014

    Open Access•Didier Ruedin, Camilla Alberti et al.•Swiss Political Science Review•2015

  • An Indicator-Based Approach to Comparative Policy Analysis

    Open Access•Francesco Pasetti, Catherine Xhardez et al.•Journal of Comparative Policy…•2024

  • Immigrant Integration Policies of the Belgian Regions

    И Адам, Ilke Adam•Regional & Federal Studies•2013

  • Intergovernmental relations on immigrant integration in multi-level states. A comparative assessment

    И Адам, Ilke Adam et al.•Regional & Federal Studies•2018

  • Israel’s Citizenship Policy towards Family Immigrants

    Assaf Shapira•The Journal of Israeli History•2017

  • How Local Contexts Matter for Local Immigrant Policies

    Open Access•Heather Khan-Welsh, Laura A Reese et al.•Urban Affairs Review•2023

  • Explaining Access to Citizenship in Central and Eastern Europe

    Vainius Bartasevičius•Communist and Post-Communist…•2021

  • Shiite Patterns of Post-Migration in Europe

    Matthijs E W van den Bos•Islam and Christian–Muslim…•2019

  • Immigrants and poverty, and conditionality of immigrants’ social rights

    Open Access•Beatrice Eugster•Journal of European Social Policy•2018

  • Immigration policy and the modern welfare state, 1880–1920

    Open Access•Sara Kalm, Johannes Lindvall•Journal of European Social Policy•2019

  • Generous to all or ‘insiders only’? The relationship between welfare state generosity and immigrant welfare rights

    Open Access•Friederike Römer•Journal of European Social Policy•2017

  • Divergences et convergences des politiques d'intégration dans la Belgique multinationale. Le cas des parcours d'intégration pour les immigrés

    Open Access•Silke Adam, И Адам et al.•Revue européenne des migrations…•2013

  • Fuzzy Boundaries

    Open Access•Heba Alex•Sociological Theory•2025

  • Local immigrant support policies in the context of economic development

    Laura A Reese, Heather Khan-Welsh•Journal of Urban Affairs•2022

  • Affective Naturalization

    Open Access•Sara Kalm•Alternatives Global Local Political•2019

  • Equality and Diversity in the Classroom

    Open Access•Margret Fine-Davis, Margret Fine‐davi et al.•Social Indicators Research•2014

  • A Comparison of Migrant Integration Policies via Mixture of Matrix-Normals

    Open Access•Leonardo Salvatore Alaimo, Francesco Amato et al.•Social Indicators Research•2023

  • Statistical and Perceived Diversity and Their Impacts on Neighborhood Social Cohesion in Germany, France and the Netherlands

    Open Access•Ruud Koopmans, Merlin Schaeffer•Social Indicators Research•2016

  • Migrants and Expats

    Open Access•Ilka Steiner, Philippe Wanner•Migrants and Expats•2019

  • South-North Migration of EU Citizens in Times of Crisis

    Open Access•Jean‐michel Lafleur, Jean-Michel Lafleur et al.•South-North Migration of EU…•2017

  • Migrants with Irregular Status in Europe

    Open Access•Sarah Spencer, Anna Triandafyllidou•Migrants with Irregular Status in…•2020

  • Von Herkunft zu Überzeugung

    Open Access•Eylem Kanol•Zeitschrift für Religion…•2024

  • Five Traditions of Quantitative Research on Racism

    Open Access•P P Verhaeghe•Sociology Compass•2025

  • National disidentification and minority identity

    Open Access•Mieke Maliepaard, M Verkuyten•Self and Identity•2017

  • The Changing Cleavage Politics of Western Europe

    Open Access•Richard Ford, Will Jennings•Annual Review of Political Science•2020

  • The accommodation of Muslim body practices in German public swimming pools

    Open Access•Ines Michalowski, Max Behrendt•Ethnic and Racial Studies•2020

  • Racism versus culture

    Open Access•Anne-Marie Livingstone, Anne‐marie Livingstone•Ethnic and Racial Studies•2024

  • Immigrants and civil rights in cross-national perspective

    Open Access•I Bloemraad, Doris Marie Provine•Comparative Migration Studies•2013

  • When Extremes Converge

    Open Access•Holger Kolb•Comparative Migration Studies•2014

  • State Policies toward Islam in Twenty Countries in Western Europe

    Serdar Kaya•Muslim World Journal of Human…•2017

  • (Un)preferential treatment

    D Sredanovic•Journal of Contemporary European…•2018

  • Quo vadis, citizenship? A long-term assessment of policy continuity, convergence, and change in contemporary Europe

    John Graeber•Journal of Contemporary European…•2020

  • Solidarity in diverse societies

    Open Access•Will Kymlicka•Comparative Migration Studies•2015

  • Multiculturalism and welfare state integration

    Karin Borevi•Identities•2014

  • Theorizing and Analyzing Citizenship in Multicultural Societies

    Open Access•I Bloemraad•Sociological Quarterly•2015

  • Canada

    P May•Ethnic and Racial Studies•2022

  • The Punishment Consequences of Lacking National Membership in Germany, 1998–2010

    Michael T Light•Social Forces•2016

  • Civic Integration through Commissioned Communities

    Open Access•Ane Grubb, K Vitus•Nordic Journal of Migration…•2022

  • Between Christian and multicultural democracy

    Michael Minkenberg•West European Politics•2018

  • Migrants into Members

    Gregory Baldi, W Goodman et al.•West European Politics•2015

  • Political parties and Muslims in Europe

    Irina Ciornei, Eva-Maria Euchner et al.•West European Politics•2021

  • Consenting to Exclude? Empirical Patterns of Democracy and Immigrant Integration Policy

    Anita Manatschal, Julian Bernauer•West European Politics•2016

  • Variation in policy success

    Philipp Lutz•West European Politics•2018

  • The dynamics of ethnic competition and conflict.

    Susan Olzak•The dynamics of ethnic…•1994

  • Muslims and the State in the Post-9/11 West

    Erik Bleich•Muslims and the State in the…•2013

  • The Claims of Culture

    Seyla Benhabib•Claims of Culture•2002

  • The Ironies of Citizenship

    Open Access•T Janoski•Ironies of Citizenship•2010

  • Global transformations

    David Held•Global transformations•1999

  • Controlling immigration

    Wayne A Cornelius•Controlling immigration•2004

  • Polity and Group Difference

    Iris Marion Young•Ethics•1989

  • New Social Movements In Western Europe

    Hanspeter Kriesi, Kriesi Hanspeter et al.•New Social Movements in Western…•2015

  • The de facto Transnationalizing of Immigration Policy

    Sassen, Saskia Sassen•Challenge to the Nation-State•1998

  • The Policy Challenge of Ethnic Diversity

    Patrick R Ireland•Policy Challenge of Ethnic…•1994

  • Rights across Borders

    David L Jacobson, David Jacobson•Rights across borders•1997

  • The Integration of Immigrants in European Societies

    Friedrich Heckmann, Dominique Schnapper•Integration of Immigrants in…•2003

  • The Age of Migration

    Stephen Castles, Mark J Miller et al.•American Foreign Policy Interests•2005

  • The Politics of Citizenship in Europe

    Open Access•Marc M Howard•Politics of Citizenship in Europe•2009

  • Contested Citizenship

    Ruud Koopmans, Marco Giugni et al.•Contested citizenship•2005

  • Patterns of Democracy

    Arend Lijphart•Patterns of Democracy•2017

  • Family‐related migration

    E Kofman•New Community•2004

  • Changing parameters of citizenship and claims-making

    Open Access•Yasemin Soysal, Yasemin Nuhoğlu Soysal•Theory and Society•1997

  • Making sense of the new geography of citizenship

    Open Access•Antje Wiener•Theory and Society•1997

  • Bringing Parties Back In

    Open Access•Ted Perlmutter•International Migration Review•1996

  • Variation in Dual Citizenship Policies in the Countries of the EU

    Open Access•Marc M Howard•International Migration Review•2005

  • Modes of Immigration Politics in Liberal Democratic States

    Gary P Freeman•International Migration Review•1995

  • Repression and reaction

    Michael Minkenberg•Patterns of Prejudice•2006

  • Citizenship and the European Community

    Edward Moxon-Browne, Edward Moxon‐browne•International Affairs•1994

  • Citizenship and the European Community

    Open Access•E Meehan•The Political Quarterly•1993

  • Beyond national models

    C Joppke•West European Politics•2006

  • One Size Fits All? European Citizenship, National Citizenship Policies and Integration Requirements

    Pontus Odmalm•Representation•2007

  • Turning round the telescope. Centre-right parties and immigration and integration policy in Europe1

    Tim Bale•Journal of European Public Policy•2008

  • The Limited Europeanization of Domestic Citizenship Policy

    Open Access•Maarten Vink, Maarten P Vink•JCMS Journal of Common Market…•2001

  • An index to measure the legal obstacles to the integration of migrants

    Harald Waldrauch, Christoph Hofinger•New Community•1997

  • Homeland citizenship policies and the status of third country nationals in the European Union

    Gary P Freeman, Nedim Ögelman•New Community•1998

  • National models, policy types, and the politics of immigration in liberal democracies

    Gary P Freeman•West European Politics•2006

  • The volume and dynamics of international migration and transnational social spaces

    T Faist•The volume and dynamics of…•2000

  • The extreme-right and immigration policy-making

    Martin A Schain•West European Politics•2006

  • Comparative Citizenship

    Marc M Howard•Perspectives on Politics•2006

  • The analysis of policy convergence, or

    Thomas Plümper, Christina J Schneider•Journal of European Public Policy•2009

  • Institutional Effects on State Behavior

    Liliana Botcheva, Lisa L Martins et al.•International Studies Quarterly•2001

  • The Legal-domestic Sources of Immigrant Rights

    Open Access•C Joppke•Comparative Political Studies•2001

  • Does Immigration Erode Social Capital? The Conditional Effects of Immigration-Generated Diversity on Trust, Membership, and Participation across 19 Countries, 1981–2000

    Open Access•Christel Kesler, I Bloemraad•Canadian Journal of Political…•2010

Unique citing works223
Citations per year15,93
Citation span2012 - 2026 (15)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedYes
Citation typesNeutral: 219

Tools

Open DOISci-HubOpen Access
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae