Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Democracy in crisis? The declining support for national democracy in E uropean countries, 2007–2011

Bibliographic Data

ID7436612
AuthorsKlaus Armingeon (0000-0003-4186-3155, University of Bern, corresponding author), Kai Guthmann (0000-0002-5854-4233, University of Bern)
Year2013
Volume53
Issue3
Pages423-442
Publication date2013-12-20
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueEuropean Journal of Political Research (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0304-4130 • E-ISSN: 1475-6765
PublisherWiley (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1111/1475-6765.12046
OpenAlexW1677355571
LanguageEN
Citations received254
References cited28

The Great Recession that started in 2007/2008 has been the worst economic downturn since the crisis of the 1930s in E urope. It led to a major sovereign debt crisis, which is arguably the biggest challenge for the E uropean Union ( EU ) and its common currency. Not since the 1950s have advanced democracies experienced such a dramatic external imposition of austerity and structural reform policies through inter‐ or supranational organisations such as the EU and the International Monetary Fund ( IMF ) or as implicitly requested by international financial markets. Did this massive interference with the room for maneuver of parliaments and governments in many countries erode support for national democracy in the crisis since 2007? Did citizens realise that their national democratic institutions were no longer able to effectively decide on major economic and social policies, on economic and welfare state institutions? And did they react by concluding that this constrained democracy no longer merited further support? These are the questions guiding this article, which compares 26 EU countries in 2007–2011 and re‐analyses 78 national surveys. Aggregate data from these surveys is analysed in a time‐series cross‐section design to examine changes in democratic support at the country level. The hypotheses also are tested at the individual level by estimating a series of cross‐classified multilevel logistic regression models. Support for national democracy – operationalised as satisfaction with the way democracy works and as trust in parliament – declined dramatically during the crisis. This was caused both by international organisations and markets interfering with national democratic procedures and by the deteriorating situation of the national economy as perceived by individual citizens

Austerity · Democracy · Economic policy · Economics · European debt crisis · European integration · European union · Financial crisis · International economics · Macroeconomics · Parliament · Political economy · Political science · Politics · Recession · Electoral Systems and Political Participation · European Union Policy and Governance · Social Policy and Reform Studies

  • Contention in Times of Crisis

    Hanspeter Kriesi, Jasmine Lorenzini et al.•Contention in Times of Crisis•2020

  • Crises of Democracy

    Open Access•Adam Przeworski•Crises of Democracy•2019

  • Comparing institutional trust

    Open Access•Rasmus Sandy Harboesgaard Nielsen•International Journal of Social…•2026

  • Beyond the ideal type

    Open Access•Sebastien Rojon, Jean-Benoit Pilet et al.•European Journal of Political…•2026

  • Democratic Satisfaction and the Public Sphere

    Open Access•Agustín Goenaga•British Journal of Political…•2026

  • Cultural Backlash

    Open Access•P Norris, Ronald Inglehart•Cultural Backlash•2019

  • Electoral Punishment and Protest Politics in Times of Crisis

    Open Access•Björn Bremer, Swen Hutter et al.•Contention in Times of Crisis•2020

  • Bailouts, Austerity, and Protest

    Open Access•Argyrios Altiparmakis, Jasmine Lorenzini•Contention in Times of Crisis•2020

  • Political Economy of EMU

    Open Access•Felix Roth•Public Support for the Euro•2022

  • The welfare state and political trust

    Staffan Kumlin, Atle Haugsgjerd•Handbook on Political Trust•2017

  • Populism and the quest for political power

    Open Access•Sirvan Karimi•Humanities and Social Sciences…•2024

  • Mass receptiveness to unconstrained emergency legislation during crisis

    Open Access•Harunobu Saijo, Charles Crabtree•Humanities and Social Sciences…•2025

  • Interplay between civic engagement, political trust, and support for democracy

    Open Access•Zenaw Alem Abebe, Kassahun Asres Admassu et al.•Social Sciences & Humanities Open•2024

  • Humour as a political communication strategy

    Open Access•Adam North•European Journal of Humour Research•2026

  • Political voice on monetary policy

    Open Access•Federico M Ferrara, Donato Masciandaro et al.•European Journal of Political…•2022

  • If you really love nothing. Evaluating second-order factors in the case of Italian constitutional referendum of 2020

    Open Access•Marzia Ippolito, Adriano Cozzolino et al.•Evaluation and Program Planning•2024

  • Don’t they understand climate science? Reflections in times of crisis in science and politics

    Open Access•Cristina García Casañas•Public Understanding of Science•2021

  • Backsliding

    Open Access•Stephan Haggard, Robert R Kaufman et al.•Backsliding•2021

  • Whither slacktivism? Political engagement and social media use in the 2013 Czech Parliamentary elections

    Open Access•Václav Štětka, Jaromír Mazák•Cyberpsychology Journal of…•2014

  • Politisches Institutionenvertrauen im Wandel. Eine Längsschnittanalyse mit Daten des ALLBUS

    Open Access•Florian Buchmayr•Zeitschrift für Soziologie•2026

  • Who benefits from the retrospective vote? Bringing in new parties

    Daniel Bochsler, Miriam Hänni•West European Politics•2024

  • The party choice set and satisfaction with democracy

    Ruth Dassonneville, I Mcallister•West European Politics•2020

  • How political malpractice affects trust in EU institutions

    Open Access•Erika J Van Elsas, Anna Brosius et al.•West European Politics•2020

  • The market, the state and satisfaction with democracy

    Richard Nadeau, Jean-François Daoust et al.•West European Politics•2020

  • Examining macroeconomic determinants of trust in parliament

    Open Access•Anna Ruelens, Bart Meuleman et al.•Social Science Research•2018

  • Political support through representation by the government. Evidence from Dutch panel data

    Open Access•Julian Erhardt•Swiss Political Science Review•2023

  • Not every dissatisfaction is the same

    Mehmet Necip Tunç, Mark J Brandt et al.•Emotion•2022

  • European anti-austerity and pro-democracy protests in the wake of the global financial crisis

    Cristina Flesher Fominaya•Social movement studies•2017

  • When and where did the great recession erode the support of democracy

    Open Access•Paul Pennings•Zeitschrift für Vergleichende…•2017

  • What drives citizens’ evaluation of democratic performance? The interaction of citizens’ democratic knowledge and institutional level of democracy

    Open Access•Carsten Wegscheider, Toralf Stark•Zeitschrift für Vergleichende…•2020

  • Euroskeptizismus und Wahlenthaltung

    Open Access•Constantin Schäfer•Zeitschrift für Vergleichende…•2017

  • La política desde abajo

    Open Access•Kerman Calvo, Andres Martin et al.•Empiria Revista de metodología de…•2022

  • How Does Internet Use Affect the Farmers’ Trust in Local Government

    Open Access•Suhao Wei, Yangxiao Lu•International Journal of…•2023

  • The change in the perception of the state by students in Poland and Lithuania in the context of research on social Capital

    Open Access•Rafał Nagaj, Piotr Szkudlarek•Economic Research-Ekonomska…•2019

  • Economic crisis and social trust

    Open Access•Diego Torrente, Jordi Caïs et al.•Social Science Information•2019

  • Satisfaction with Democracy

    Open Access•Swaran P Singh, Quinton Mayne•Public Opinion Quarterly•2023

  • Political Science and the Eurozone Crisis. A Review of Scientific Journal Articles 2004–15

    Open Access•Oliver Höing, Tobias Kunstein•JCMS Journal of Common Market…•2019

  • Is It Interests, Ideas or Institutions? Explaining Elected Representatives' Positions Toward Democratic Innovations in 15 European Countries

    Open Access•Nino Junius, Joke Matthieu et al.•Frontiers in Political Science•2020

  • Fragility of democratic minimalism

    Open Access•Sam Mace•Frontiers in Political Science•2025

  • The recession generation? Age-period-cohort dynamics of political trust in six countries severely affected by the 2008 crisis

    Open Access•Viktor Valgarðsson•Frontiers in Political Science•2024

  • Quality of Democracy Makes a Difference, but Not for Everyone

    Open Access•Marlene Mauk•Frontiers in Political Science•2021

  • Do Citizens Perceive Elected Politicians, Experts and Citizens as Alternative or Complementary Policy-Makers? A Study of Belgian Citizens

    Open Access•Jean-Benoit Pilet, David Talukder et al.•Frontiers in Political Science•2020

  • Digitalization in Candidate Selection. Support and Resistance Within Established Political Parties in Germany

    Open Access•C Bloquet, Isabelle Borucki et al.•Frontiers in Political Science•2022

  • Patterns of (de)politicization in times of crisis

    Open Access•Lionel Marquis, Ursina Kuhn et al.•Frontiers in Political Science•2022

  • Economic Crisis and Attitudes Towards Democracy

    Open Access•Ignacio Jurado, Rosa M Navarrete•Frontiers in Political Science•2021

  • Three Is a Crowd? Podemos, Ciudadanos, and Vox

    Open Access•Jander Rama, Gonzalo C Garcia et al.•Frontiers in Political Science•2021

  • How critical are Germans of democracy? The pattern and origins of constitutional support in Germany

    Ross Campbell•Journal of Contemporary Central…•2020

  • From rally to reality

    Open Access•G Zoch, Steffen Wamsler•Political Research Exchange•2024

  • Moderating Effects of Urbanization on Citizens’ Perception of Government Performance and Democratic Support in Sub-Saharan Africa

    Open Access•Nathan Teklemariam, Patricia Ng’ethe•Urban Science•2025

  • Identity Politics and Democratic Crisis in Western Europe

    Open Access•Dingping Guo, Shujia Hu•Chinese Political Science Review•2019

  • Protest Wave or Protest Spike

    Matthew Schoene•Contention•2018

  • National Identities in Troubled Times

    Open Access•Antonia M A Ruiz Jiménez, Nieves Aquino Llinares et al.•Genealogy•2021

  • Inequality and voting in Italy’s regions

    Francesco Bloise, Daniela Chironi et al.•Territory Politics Governance•2020

  • Youth Democratic Political Identity and Disaffection

    Open Access•Miquel Àngel Essomba, Maria Nadeu et al.•Societies•2023

  • Young People’s Critical Politicization in Spain in the Great Recession

    Open Access•Jorge Benedicto Millán, María Ramos•Societies•2018

  • Trust in Government and Media Slant

    Open Access•Andrea Ceron, Vincenzo Memoli•The International Journal of…•2015

  • Stable Support for Democracy in East and Southeast Asia? Examining Citizens’ Trust in Democratic Institutions

    Open Access•Marlene Mauk•East Asia•2021

  • The impact of the economic crisis on media corruption

    Open Access•Theodora A Maniou, Elena Ketteni•International Communication Gazette•2020

  • Poor linkage and lacking representation

    Nathan Brack•Politique européenne•2014

  • Stability or Stagnation

    Open Access•Andrew Hunter•Political Studies Review•2024

  • Institutional quality in the Euro area countries

    Salvador Pérez‐moreno, E Bárcena-Martín et al.•Journal of Contemporary European…•2020

  • Political support and democratic backsliding trends. The strange case of Central and Eastern European countries

    Antonino Castaldo, Vincenzo Memoli•Journal of Contemporary European…•2023

  • Conceptions of democracy, political representation and socio-economic well-being

    Open Access•Camille Bedock, Sophie Panel•French Politics•2017

  • How the Euro divides the union

    Klaus Armingeon, Kai Guthmann et al.•Socio-Economic Review•2015

  • The democratic paradox

    Open Access•Suthan Krishnarajan•Socio-Economic Review•2022

  • Anti-austerity between militant materialism and real democracy

    Olatz Ribera-Almandoz, Nikolai Huke et al.•Globalizations•2020

  • Challenging the age of austerity

    Open Access•David J Bailey, David Bailey et al.•Comparative European Politics•2016

  • After the crisis

    Open Access•Francesca Vassallo•Comparative European Politics•2019

  • Political distrust amidst The Great Recession

    Open Access•Atle Haugsgjerd•Comparative European Politics•2017

  • The long-term effects of the economic crisis on political trust in Europe

    Open Access•Marc Hooghe, Martin Okolikj•Comparative European Politics•2020

  • Shifting spectrums

    Open Access•Josep Martí, K Peren Arın et al.•Comparative European Politics•2025

  • Institutions, crises, and political confidence in seven contemporary democracies. An elite–mass analysis

    Open Access•Hennie Kotzé, Carlos García-Rivero et al.•Journal of Public Affairs•2017

  • Three Outcomes of Contentious Elections

    Open Access•Richard W Frank•International Studies Review•2020

  • Crisis and Revolt in Spain

    Oscar Berglund•Historical Materialism•2017

  • Crisis management and attitudes towards democracy

    Open Access•Lea Heyne, Rubén Ruiz-Rufino•European Union Politics•2025

  • Economic crisis and social capital in European societies

    Open Access•Hajdeja Iglič, Jesper Rozer et al.•European Societies•2020

  • Strukturwandel, regionale politische Kultur und Demokratiezufriedenheit im Saarland

    Open Access•PEDRO LUCAS BEILNER HOLZ, Paulina Holz et al.•Zeitschrift für Politikwissenschaft•2025

  • Coordination of legislative speech in times of crisis

    Open Access•Hanna Bäck, Markus Baumanns et al.•International Journal of Social…•2019

  • Making sense of federalism – insights from an open-ended survey question

    Open Access•Eva-Maria Trüdinger, Eva‐maria Trüdinger et al.•Regional & Federal Studies•2025

  • Disrupting the European Crisis

    Nikolai Huke, Monica Clua-Losada et al.•New Political Economy•2015

  • The “Big Bang” of the populist parties in the European Union

    Joaquín Martín-Cubas, Anselm Bodoque et al.•Innovation The European Journal…•2018

  • Populist radical right party representation and satisfaction with democracy in Europe

    Open Access•Atle Haugsgjerd, Jonas Linde et al.•Journal of European Public Policy•2025

  • The Gap Between Youth and Politics

    Open Access•C Malafaia, Tiago Neves et al.•Young•2021

  • Internet, News, and Political Trust

    Open Access•Andrea Ceron•Journal of Computer-Mediated…•2015

  • The State of Democracy in Poland after 2007

    Claudia-Yvette Matthes, Claudia-Y Matthes•Problems of Post-Communism•2016

  • Czech Billionaires as Politicians

    Andrew Roberts•Problems of Post-Communism•2018

  • Democracies Adrift

    Martin Brusis•Problems of Post-Communism•2016

  • Comparative Assessments of the State of Democracy in East-Central Europe and Its Anchoring in Society

    Claudia-Yvette Matthes, Claudia-Y Matthes•Problems of Post-Communism•2016

  • Satisfaction with democracy and perceived performance of the welfare state in Europe

    Open Access•Tomáš Sirovátka, Martin Guzi et al.•Journal of European Social Policy•2018

  • The Paradox of Elites in Civil Society

    Open Access•Megan Kathleen Baxter, Jayeon Lee et al.•Voluntas Revista Internacional de…•2024

  • Bad News, Declining Trust? Effects of Exposure to Economic News on Trust in the European Union

    Open Access•Anna Brosius, Erika J Van Elsas et al.•International Journal of Public…•2019

  • A Three-Level Approach to Examining the Relationship Between Categorical Beacons of Influence and Democracy in Western Europe

    Open Access•Erik M Cruz, Christopher E Torres et al.•International Journal of Politics…•2024

  • Public attitudes to referendums on Irish unification in Northern Ireland

    Open Access•Alan Renwick, Nadia Dobrianska et al.•Irish Political Studies•2022

  • Responsive E-government in China

    Open Access•Tao Chen, Zhehao Liang et al.•Government Information Quarterly•2023

  • The double bailout

    Anna Wenz-Temming, Jared Sonnicksen•Journal of European Integration•2020

  • The state and its schooled elite across 84 countries

    Open Access•Leandros Kavadias, J Van Noord et al.•European Journal of Political…•2026

  • Democracy and disadvantage

    Open Access•Maximilian Filsinger, Steffen Wamsler•European Journal of Political…•2025

  • At Which Level Does Unemployment Affect Political Trust? A Multilevel Analysis Across Europe

    Open Access•Leo Azzollini, Ebru Sanliturk et al.•Social Indicators Research•2025

  • Retrospective voting under supranational constraints

    Open Access•Ignacio Jurado, Pablo Fernández-Vázquez•Electoral Studies•2022

  • La insatisfacción con la democracia en México (2014-2017)

    Open Access•Alejandro Monsiváis Carrillo, Alejandro Monsivais-Carrillo•Perfiles Latinoamericanos•2018

  • Party Policy in Modern Democracies

    Kenneth Benoit, Michael Laver•Party Policy in Modern Democracies•2006

  • Understanding Euroscepticism

    Open Access•Cécile Leconte•Understanding Euroscepticism•2010

  • Data Analysis Using Regression and Multilevel/Hierarchical Models

    Open Access•Andrew Gelman, Jennifer Hill•Data Analysis Using Regression…•2006

  • The Economic Vote

    Open Access•Raymond M Duch, Raymond Duch et al.•Economic Vote•2008

  • Multilevel Analysis

    Joop Hox, Joop J Hox et al.•Multilevel analysis•2010

  • Economic Crisis, Quality of Work, and Social Integration

    Duncan Gallie•Economic Crisis Quality Of Work…•2013

  • Hierarchical linear models

    Anthony S Bryk, Stephen W Raudenbush•Hierarchical linear models•2002

  • Small States in World Markets

    Peter J Katzenstein•Small States in World Markets•2017

  • Economic Crisis, Political Legitimacy, and Social Cohesion

    Polavieja Javier•Economic Crisis Quality Of Work…•2013

  • Non-Hierarchical Multilevel Models

    Jon Rasbash, William J Browne•Handbook of multilevel analysis•2007

  • Multilevel Analysis

    Tom Ab Snijders, Tom A B Snijders•International encyclopedia of…•2011

  • Democratic Deficit

    Open Access•P Norris•Democratic Deficit•2011

  • Coping with Crisis

    Open Access•Thomas B Pepinsky•Political Science Quarterly•2013

  • Satisfaction with democracy

    Open Access•Jonas Linde, Joakim Ekman•European Journal of Political…•2003

  • Trust in Democratic Institutions in Germany

    Robert Rohrschneider, Rüdiger Schmitt-Beck et al.•German Politics•2002

  • Meaning and Measurement in Cross-National Research on Satisfaction with Democracy

    Damarys Canache, Jeffery J Mondak et al.•Public Opinion Quarterly•2001

  • Do Surveys Provide Representative or Whimsical Assessments of the Economy

    Open Access•Harvey D Palmer, Raymond M Duch et al.•Political Analysis•2001

  • Calculation, Community and Cues

    Open Access•Liesbet Hooghe, Gary Marks•European Union Politics•2005

  • To Know it is to Love it

    Open Access•Jeffrey A Karp, Susan Banducci et al.•Comparative Political Studies•2003

  • When in Doubt, Use Proxies

    Open Access•Christopher J Anderson•Comparative Political Studies•1998

  • What Are the Origins of Political Trust

    Open Access•William Mishler, Richard Rose•Comparative Political Studies•2001

  • The Democracy Deficit and Mass Support for an EU-Wide Government

    Robert Rohrschneider•American Journal of Political…•2002

  • A Re-assessment of the Concept of Political Support

    Open Access•David Easton•British Journal of Political…•1975

  • Benchmarking across Borders

    Open Access•Mark Andreas Kayser, Mark Andreas Lindst Auml Dt Kayser et al.•American Political Science Review•2012

Unique citing works254
Citations per year21,17
Citation span2014 - 2026 (13)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedYes
Citation typesNeutral: 254

Tools

Open DOISci-HubOpen Access
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae