Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

The Stories We Tell

Challenging Exclusionary Histories of Geography in U.S. Graduate Curriculum

Bibliographic Data

ID7635005
AuthorsEden Kinkaid (0000-0003-0793-2049, University of Arizona), Lauren Fritzsche (0000-0001-5081-721X, University of Arizona)
Year2022
Volume112
Issue8
Pages2469-2485
Publication date2022-11-17
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueAnnals of the American Association of Geographers (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 2469-4452 • E-ISSN: 2469-4460
PublisherInforma UK Limited (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1080/24694452.2022.2072805
OpenAlexW4285012756
LanguageEN
Citations received21
References cited60

In this article, we examine how the exclusionary and problematic aspects of geography’s history are narrated, reproduced, and challenged in graduate education in the United States. Approaching introductory graduate courses as sites in the reproduction of geography as a discipline, we consider how these courses can either bolster or challenge problematic legacies of geography’s disciplinary history. To do so, we analyze thirty-two syllabi from graduate-level “introduction to geography” courses in the United States with a focus on how issues of colonialism, race and racism, and gender figure into narratives about the history of geography. In drawing attention to seemingly minor decisions about framing, content, and organization within syllabi, and connecting these decisions to broader concerns about the history of geography and its exclusions, we demonstrate that syllabi indeed play a role in disciplinary reproduction. We argue that, with some conscious effort and design, we can rework the stories that we tell in our syllabi toward more inclusive and diverse imaginaries of the geographic tradition

Colonialism · Critical geography · Cultural geography · Curriculum · Discipline · Geography · Human geography · Pedagogy · Political science · Social science · Sociology · Syllabus · Gender Studies · Geography Education and Pedagogy · Historical Geography and Geographical Thought · Law · Qualitative Research Methods and Ethics

  • Whose geography, whose future? Queering geography’s disciplinary reproduction

    Open Access•Eden Kinkaid•Dialogues in Human Geography•2023

  • Commentary on Craig et al.’s “Bowling for Better

    Jamison Conley, Jamison F Conley et al.•The Professional Geographer•2025

  • Enhancing the Climate in Geography Through Diversity and Inclusion

    Ann M Oberhauser, Barnali Dixon et al.•The Professional Geographer•2026

  • Bowling for Better

    Bethany Craig, Jack Swab et al.•The Professional Geographer•2024

  • Whose Geography, Whose History? Reimagining How We Teach the History of Geography

    Eden Kinkaid, Bethany Craig et al.•The Professional Geographer•2025

  • Contrasting Ideologies

    Talula Pontuti, Serena Madsen et al.•Journal of Geography•2024

  • Re-imagining the futures of geographical thought and praxis

    Open Access•Reuben Rose-Redwood, CindyAnn Rose-Redwood et al.•Dialogues in Human Geography•2024

  • The challenges and potentials of critical Muslim geographies

    Open Access•Karen Culcasi•Dialogues in Human Geography•2024

  • Relationality and anti-oppressive geographic praxis

    Kelsey Emard•Gender Place & Culture•2022

  • Navigating STEMification for critical geography educators

    David K Seitz, Daniel Cockayne et al.•Journal of Geography in Higher…•2023

  • Social geography I

    Open Access•A Nayak•Progress in Human Geography•2024

  • Reimagining landscape

    Open Access•Olivia Mason, James Riding•Progress in Human Geography•2023

  • Geographical education II

    Open Access•Steve Puttick•Progress in Human Geography•2023

  • Bridging Critical Geographic Scholarship and Educational Infrastructure

    Christabel Devado, Christabel Devadoss et al.•Annals of the American…•2026

  • Placing critical geographic thought. A commentary on David Chandler and Jonathan Pugh's ‘Abyssal geography’

    Open Access•Kevin Grove•Singapore Journal of Tropical…•2023

  • Political Geographies of the Pluriverse in Practice

    Open Access•Lindsay Naylor•Political Geography in Practice•2024

  • Resilience, Critique and the Limits of Geographic Thought in the Anthropocene

    Open Access•Kevin Grove•Geoforum•2025

  • A Pedagogy of Unbecoming for Geoscience Otherwise

    Christopher Reimer, Sarah-Louise Ruder et al.•Annals of the American…•2023

  • Queering feminist geography IV

    Queering Feminist Geography Collective, Eden Kinkaid et al.•Gender Place & Culture•2025

  • Mobilising spaces of fugitive complaint within the neoliberal university

    Open Access•Kavita Ramakrishnan, Farhana Ghaffar et al.•Gender Place & Culture•2026

  • A classroom of our own

    Open Access•Myriam Houssay-Holzschuch•Geographica Helvetica•2024

  • On Not Excluding Half of the Human in Human Geography

    Janice Monk, Susan Hanson•The Professional Geographer•1982

  • Reflections on a White Discipline

    Lucila Pulido, Laura Pulido•The Professional Geographer•2002

  • A Long Way to Go

    Caroline V Faria, Caroline Faria et al.•The Professional Geographer•2019

  • Title unavailable

    Open Access•null null•Philosophy study•2016

  • The Space That Race Makes

    David Delaney•The Professional Geographer•2002

  • Who Makes Geographical Knowledge? The Gender of Geography’s Gatekeepers

    Open Access•C Schurr, Marguerite Müller et al.•The Professional Geographer•2020

  • Geographies of Sexualities

    Jason Lim, Gavin Brown et al.•Geographies of Sexualities•2017

  • Mapping Desire

    David Bell, G Valentine•Mapping Desire•2003

  • Geographies of sexuality - a review of progress

    Open Access•J Binnie, G Valentine•Progress in Human Geography•1999

  • A Critical Commentary on the AAG Geography and Military Study Committee Report

    Open Access•J Wainwright, Bryan R Weaver•Annals of the American…•2020

  • More than “Silly Stories”

    Ann E Bartos, Sarah Ive et al.•GeoHumanities•2019

  • Questions on the canon

    Open Access•Richard C Powell•Dialogues in Human Geography•2012

  • An other geography

    Open Access•N Oswin•Dialogues in Human Geography•2019

  • We have never been canonical

    Open Access•Innes M Keighren, Christian Abrahamsson et al.•Dialogues in Human Geography•2012

  • The white unseen

    Open Access•Aretina R Hamilton•Dialogues in Human Geography•2020

  • The shadow of her wings’

    Open Access•A Roy•Dialogues in Human Geography•2020

  • Fear of an other geography

    Open Access•Latoya E Eaves•Dialogues in Human Geography•2020

  • Treasuring classic texts, engagement and the gender gap in the geographical canon

    Open Access•Avril Maddrell•Dialogues in Human Geography•2012

  • It's time to recognize how men's careers benefit from sexually harassing women in academia

    Open Access•Becky Mansfield, Rebecca Lave et al.•Human Geography•2019

  • Citation matters

    Carey Mott, Daniel Cockayne•Gender Place & Culture•2017

  • Organizing for collective feminist killjoy geographies in a US university

    Danya Al-Saleh, Elsa Noterman•Gender Place & Culture•2020

  • Coming of age in a straight white man’s geography

    Eden Kinkaid, Aparna Parikh et al.•Gender Place & Culture•2021

  • Against the Odds

    Sheila R Akinleye•Gender Place & Culture•2006

  • At the limits of critical geography

    Eden Kinkaid•Gender Place & Culture•2019

  • Glass ceilings and stone floors

    Avril Maddrell, Nicola J Thomas et al.•Geografiska Annaler Series B…•2018

  • Mapping race and gender in the academy

    Minelle Mahtani•Journal of Geography in Higher…•2004

  • Challenging racism through geography teaching

    P Jackson•Journal of Geography in Higher…•1989

  • Physical Geography and the Geographic Thought Course

    Kevin R Cox•Journal of Geography in Higher…•2006

  • Integrating contemplative pedagogy and anti-oppressive pedagogy in geography higher education classrooms

    Lauren Fritzsche•Journal of Geography in Higher…•2021

  • Decolonising pedagogies in undergraduate geography

    Anna F Laing•Journal of Geography in Higher…•2020

  • Female Representation in the Discipline of Geography

    Sarah J Brinegar•Journal of Geography in Higher…•2001

  • Reflections on operationalizing an anti-racism pedagogy

    Derek H Alderman, Rodrigo A Narro Pérez et al.•Journal of Geography in Higher…•2019

  • Teaching the history of geography

    Open Access•Innes M Keighren, Jeremy W Crampton et al.•Progress in Human Geography•2015

  • To read or not to read? The politics of overlooking gender in the geographical canon

    Open Access•Avril Maddrell•Journal of Historical Geography•2015

  • Enlightening choices

    Open Access•Robert J Mayhew•Journal of Historical Geography•2015

  • From where we stand

    Open Access•Michelle Daigle, Juanita Sundberg•Transactions of the Institute of…•2017

  • Beyond the Frontiers of Geographical Knowledge

    Mona Domosh•Transactions of the Institute of…•1991

  • Decolonising The Geographical Tradition

    Open Access•Ruth Craggs•Transactions of the Institute of…•2019

  • Tradition and Paternity

    G Rose•Transactions of the Institute of…•1995

  • Racism out of Place

    Audrey Kobayashi, Linda Peake•Annals of the Association of…•2000

  • Mind the gap

    Open Access•Avril Maddrell, Kendra Strau et al.•Area•2016

  • Taking on the tweed suits

    Open Access•Cheryl Mcewan•Area•2020

  • A day in the life of a Geographer

    Open Access•Divya P Tolia-Kelly, Divya P Tolia‐kelly•Area•2017

  • Teaching a history of “race” and anti‐racist action in an academic classroom

    Open Access•Mark Hinton, Meleisa Ono‐George•Area•2020

  • The why and the white”

    Open Access•James Esson•Area•2020

  • Geography and the Military

    Joe Bryan, Joseph Bryan•Annals of the American…•2016

  • Mainstreaming geography's decolonial imperative

    Open Access•Tariq Jazeel•Transactions of the Institute of…•2017

  • Geography, 'race' and Whiteness

    Open Access•Alastair Bonnett•Area•1997

  • What we're teaching teachers

    Open Access•Paul C Gorski•Teaching and Teacher Education•2008

  • Coming out of Geography

    Open Access•J Binnie•Environment and Planning D…•1997

  • Malestream Geography

    Open Access•Mike Crang•Environment and Planning A…•2003

  • Toxic geographies

    Minelle Mahtani•Social & Cultural Geography•2014

  • The Passing of "Geography's Empire" and Question of Geography in Decolonization, 1945-1980

    D Clayton, Daniel W Clayton•Annals of the American…•2020

  • What Happens If We Start from Nigeria? Diversifying Histories of Geography

    Open Access•Ruth Craggs, Hannah Neate•Annals of the American…•2020

  • Unsettling the Coloniality of Being/Power/Truth/Freedom

    Sylvia Wynter•CR The New Centennial Review•2003

Unique citing works21
Citations per year5,25
Citation span2022 - 2026 (5)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 20

Tools

Open DOI
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae