Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

East versus West? Over-qualification and Earnings among the UK's European Migrants

Bibliographic Data

ID7843489
AuthorsRon Johnston (0000-0003-3031-8573, Digital Catapult, corresponding author), Nabil Khattab (0000-0002-7972-9229), David Manley (0000-0003-1864-5141)
Year2015
Volume41
Issue2
Pages196-218
Publication date2015-01-28
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessNo
TypeARTICLE
VenueNew Community (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0047-9586 • E-ISSN: 1469-9451
PublisherInforma UK Limited (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1080/1369183x.2014.935308
OpenAlexW2107732484
LanguageEN
Citations received53
References cited47

West and East Europeans have been important components of the migration flows into the UK in the last decade, but they remain largely under-studied. This paper utilises 12 quarters of the Labour Force Survey for the years 2002–2013 to examine patterns of over-qualification and their impact on those migrants' earnings. The findings show a clear and greater penalty for East Europeans. They were more likely than the majority White-British and West European migrants to be substantially over-qualified and have earned the lowest pay premium on their excess education. The East European migrants' double penalty is explained by their over-concentration in the secondary labour market where discrimination by employers, exploitation and lower rewards are common practices. Contrary to this, West European migrants enjoy a much better labour market position as they are able to successfully negotiate access to its primary sector

Demographic economics · Earnings · Economics · Geography · Immigration · Political science · Sociology · Demography · Labor market dynamics and wage inequality · Law · Migration and Labor Dynamics · Migration, Ethnicity, and Economy · Accounting

  • An Examination of Ethnic Hierarchies and Returns to Human Capital in the UK

    Open Access•Wouter Zwysen, Neli Demireva•Social Inclusion•2018

  • Dreaming of Sweden as a Space of Wellbeing

    Open Access•Henrik Emilsson, Caroline Adolfsson•Nordic Journal of Migration…•2019

  • Labour Market Disadvantages Faced by Migrant Workers from Czech Republic, Hungary, and Slovakia in Britain

    Open Access•Andrej Přívara, Eva Rievajová et al.•MIGRATION LETTERS•2019

  • The Transitions of Transitional Justice

    Lauren Marie Balasco•Journal of Human Rights•2013

  • El mercado laboral y la religión

    Open Access•Rita Sobczyk, Rosa M Soriano Miras et al.•Migraciones Publicación del…•2018

  • Ethno-religious identities and persisting penalties in the UK labor market

    Open Access•Nabil Khattab, Ron Johnston•The Social Science Journal•2014

  • Onward Migration and Multi-Sited Transnationalism

    Open Access•Jill Ahrens, Russell King•Onward Migration and Multi-Sited…•2023

  • İnsan Kaynakları Yönetimlerinin İşe Alım Kararlarında Vasıfsal İkilem

    Open Access•Nezahat KOCYİGİT, A Aslan ŞENDOĞDU•MANAS Sosyal Araştırmalar Dergisi•2022

  • Determinants and wage penalty of qualification mismatches

    Rabeh Morrar, Hélène Syed Zwick•British Journal of Education & Work•2021

  • Coloniali, europei e qualificati

    Open Access•D Sredanovic•Quaderni di Sociologia•2025

  • Impacts of negative labor market experiences on the life satisfaction of European East–West mobile workers

    Open Access•Raimund Haindorfer•Journal of Industrial Relations•2020

  • The gendered consequences of skill-discounting for migrants

    Open Access•Gerrit J M Treuren, Ashokkumar Manoharan et al.•Journal of Industrial Relations•2021

  • Intra-migrant workplace conflict

    Open Access•Puja Chatrath, Dieu Hack-Polay•Discover Global Society•2024

  • Brexit, Covid and Bulgarian migrants in the UK

    Open Access•Eugenia Markova, Russell King•Journal of Southeast European and…•2023

  • Confronting Racialised Power Asymmetries in the Interview Setting

    Open Access•E Scheibelhofer, Clara Holzinger et al.•Social Inclusion•2023

  • Theorising new European youth mobilities

    Open Access•Russell King•Population Space and Place•2017

  • From Mobile Workers to Fellow Citizens and Back Again? The Future Status of EU Citizens in the UK

    Open Access•A D''Angelo, E Kofman•Social Policy and Society•2018

  • New member state workers in Western European labour markets. Are they civically stratified

    Open Access•Jesús García-Gómez, Mikolaj Stanek et al.•European Societies•2020

  • The interacting effects of religion and birthplace on the labour market outcomes of Asian immigrants in Australia

    Open Access•Sheruni De Alwis, Nick Parr et al.•Journal of Population Research•2022

  • Barriers for Highly Qualified A8 Immigrants in the UK Labour Market

    Open Access•Ibrahim Sirkeci, Necla Acik et al.•Work Employment and Society•2018

  • With a Little Help from My Friends

    Open Access•Janine Leschke, Silvana Wei•Work Employment and Society•2020

  • Wage Differences between Polish and Romanian Intra-EU Migrants in a Flexi-Secure Labour Market

    Open Access•Jonas Felbo-Kolding, Janine Leschke•Work Employment and Society•2023

  • Two-tier EU citizenship

    Open Access•Magdalena Ulceluşe, Felix Bender•Organization•2022

  • Mismatched expectations

    Open Access•Sara Jones, Natalya Kogut•Memory Studies•2025

  • Same rights different outcomes? Decomposition of differences in over-qualification among mobile EU workers

    Mikolaj Stanek, Alberto Del Rey et al.•Journal of Contemporary European…•2021

  • The vulnerability of in-between statuses

    D Sredanovic•Identities•2023

  • Ethnic Penalties and Hiring Discrimination

    Open Access•Wouter Zwysen, Di Stasio et al.•Sociology•2021

  • The Citizenship Gap in European Societies

    Open Access•Ettore Recchi•International Migration•2016

  • Five Characteristics of Youth Unemployment in Europe

    Open Access•Jacqueline O’reilly, Werner Eichhorst et al.•SAGE Open•2015

  • The challenge of retaining highly educated migrants in tourism destinations

    Open Access•Yun-Tzu Chang, Eric Fong•Cities•2023

  • Does It Pay Off? Understanding Subjective Employment Mobility of European Physicians in Germany

    Open Access•Regina Becker•International Migration Review•2023

  • International Migration and the (Un)happiness Push

    Open Access•Jan Brzozowski, Nicola Daniele Coniglio•International Migration Review•2021

  • Compositions of the labour force

    Open Access•Qiujie Shi•Habitat International•2019

  • The effect of perceived overqualification on job satisfaction and career satisfaction among immigrants

    Open Access•Maria Wassermann, Kaori Fujishiro et al.•International Journal of…•2017

  • Patterns of overeducation among highly educated mobile intra-EU workers, 2005–2016

    Open Access•Alberto Del Rey, Mikolaj Stanek et al.•International Journal of…•2024

  • Conditioning Family-life at the Intersection of Migration and Welfare

    Open Access•Majella Kilkey•Journal of Social Policy•2017

  • Transferring Skills but Not Progressing

    Justyna Salamonska•Journal of Immigrant & Refugee…•2025

  • Both Ethnic and Religious

    Open Access•Nabil Khattab, T Modood•Journal for the Scientific Study…•2015

  • Revisiting the EU's new mobility regime

    Jens Arnholtz, Janine Leschke•New Community•2023

  • Does Ethnicity Matter in Intentions to Study Abroad? Analysis of High School Students in Estonia

    Enel Pungas, Kadri Täht et al.•New Community•2015

  • Gender and free movement

    Isabel Shutes, Sarah Walker et al.•New Community•2018

  • One improves here every day

    Laura Moroşanu, Russell King et al.•New Community•2021

  • Muslims in their European societies of settlement

    P Statham, Jean Tillie•New Community•2016

  • Foreign-Born Adults’ Participation in Educational Activities

    Ellen Boeren•European Education•2019

  • All in it Together'? Ethnoreligious Labour-Market Penalties and the Post-2008 Recession in the UK

    Open Access•Nabil Khattab, Ron Johnston et al.•Environment and Planning A…•2015

  • Unequal Europe, unequal Brexit

    Open Access•Lorenza Antonucci, Varriale•Current Sociology•2020

  • The diversification of inequality

    Open Access•M Brynin, Simonetta Longhi et al.•British Journal of Sociology•2019

  • Returned migrants acquisition of competences

    Hania Janta, Calvin Jephcote et al.•New Community•2021

  • Labour market hierarchies between intra-EU migrants

    Janine Leschke, Silvana Wei•New Community•2023

  • Unpacking the immigration hierarchy

    Open Access•Erica Consterdine•New Community•2023

  • A division of labour? Labour market segmentation by region of origin

    Jonas Felbo-Kolding, Janine Leschke et al.•New Community•2019

  • Growing up abroad

    Laura Moroşanu, Alexandra Bulat et al.•Ethnic and Racial Studies•2019

  • Whiteness, Migration and Integration into the British Labour Market

    Open Access•David Manley, Nabil Khattab et al.•Journal of International…•2020

  • Eurostars and Eurocities

    Open Access•A Favell•Eurostars and Eurocities•2008

  • Employment, wages, and the economic cycle

    Open Access•Christian Dustmann, Albrecht Glitz et al.•European Economic Review•2010

  • Overeducation in the labor market

    Open Access•Wim Groot, Henriëtte Maassen Van Den Brink•Economics of Education Review•2000

  • Over-education and earnings

    Open Access•Joop Hartog•Economics of Education Review•2000

  • "Overeducation" in the Labor Market

    Nachum Sicherman•Journal of Labor Economics•1991

  • The Economics of Discrimination

    Gary S Becker•Economics of Discrimination•1971

  • Multicultural Politics

    T Modood•Multicultural Politics•2005

  • Are Immigrants Favorably Self-Selected

    Barry R Chiswick•American Economic Review•1999

  • Human Capital, Effort, and the Sexual Division of Labor

    Gary S Becker•Journal of Labor Economics•1985

  • Immigrant over-education

    Open Access•Chantal Pohl Nielsen•Journal of Population Economics•2009

  • Overeducation and Underemployment

    Herbert L Smith•Sociology of Education•1986

  • Dualism in the Labor Market

    Michael J Piore•Revue économique•1978

  • Brain Abuse”, or the Devaluation of Immigrant Labour in Canada

    Open Access•Harald Bauder•Antipode•2003

  • A Double Disadvantage? Minority Group, Immigrant Status, and Underemployment in the United States

    Open Access•Gordon F De Jong, Anna B Madamba•Social Science Quarterly•2001

  • Economic Migrants” or “Middling Transnationals”? East European Migrants’ Experiences of Work in the UK

    Open Access•Violetta Parutis•International Migration•2011

  • Finding an Adequate Job

    Open Access•Haya Stier, Varda Levanon•International Migration•2003

  • Poles Apart? EU Enlargement and the Labour Market Outcomes of Immigrants in the United Kingdom

    Open Access•Stephen Drinkwater, John Eade et al.•International Migration•2009

  • Measuring Over‐education

    Open Access•Arnaud Chevalier•Economica•2003

  • The Economic Situation of First and Second‐Generation Immigrants in France, Germany and the United Kingdom

    Open Access•Yann Algan, Christian Dustmann et al.•The Economic Journal•2010

  • Language Proficiency and Labour Market Performance of Immigrants in the UK

    Open Access•Christian Dustmann, Francesca Fabbri•The Economic Journal•2003

  • The Over-Educated American

    Harry F Silberman, Robert Freeman et al.•American Educational Research…•1977

  • The New Face of East–West Migration in Europe

    A Favell•New Community•2008

  • The Second Generation in Western Europe

    A F Heath, Catherine Rothon et al.•Annual Review of Sociology•2008

  • Birds of Passage

    Michael J Piore•Birds of Passage•2009

  • Over- and undereducation in the UK graduate labour market

    Carmen Alpin, J R Shackleton et al.•Studies in Higher Education•1998

  • New Migrants in the UK

    Neli Demireva•New Community•2011

  • Negotiating Skills in the Global City

    Krisztina Csedő•New Community•2008

  • Decredentialization and Recredentialization

    Open Access•Miri Lerner, Gila Menahem•Work and Occupations•2003

  • Ethno-religious Background as a Determinant of Educational and Occupational Attainment in Britain

    Open Access•Nabil Khattab•Sociology•2009

  • Bring Race to the Center

    Open Access•Korie L Edwards•Journal for the Scientific Study…•2008

  • Super-diversity and its implications

    Vertovec, Steven Vertovec•Ethnic and Racial Studies•2007

  • Underemployment across immigrant generations

    Open Access•Tim Slack, Leif Jensen•Social Science Research•2007

Unique citing works53
Citations per year4,08
Citation span2013 - 2025 (13)
Citation velocityrecent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 47

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae