Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Asylum Recognition Rates in Western Europe

Their Determinants, Variation, and Lack of Convergence

Bibliographic Data

ID7878321
AuthorsE Neumayer (0000-0003-2719-7563, Peace Research Institute Oslo, corresponding author)
Year2005
Volume49
Issue1
Pages43-66
Publication date2005-02-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueJournal of Conflict Resolution (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0022-0027 • E-ISSN: 1552-8766
PublisherSAGE Publications (PUBLISHER • US)
DOI10.1177/0022002704271057
OpenAlexW573380382
LanguageEN
Citations received69
References cited13

Substantial variation in recognition rates for asylum claims from the same countries of origin subjects refugees to unfair and discriminatory treatment. This article demonstrates the extent of variation and lack of convergence over the period from 1980 to 1999 across Western European destination countries. Refugee interest groups also suspect that political and economic conditions in destination countries, as well as the number of past asylum claims, unduly affect recognition rates. This article estimates the determinants of asylum recognition rates. Origin-specific recognition rates vary, as they should, with the extent of political oppression, human rights violations, interstate armed conflict, and events of genocide and politicide in countries of origin. Recognition rates for the full-protection status are lower only in times of high unemployment in destination countries. Such rates are also lower if many asylum seekers from a country of origin have already applied for asylum in the past

Criminology · Demographic economics · Development economics · Economics · Human rights · Oppression · Political science · Politics · Refugee · Sociology · Suspect · Variation (astronomy · Law · Migration and Labor Dynamics · Migration, Health and Trauma · Migration, Refugees, and Integration

  • Unterschiedliche Pfade, ein Ziel? — Spezifikationen im Forschungsdesign und Vergleichbarkeit der Ergebnisse bei der Suche nach der Konvergenz nationalstaatlicher Politiken

    Stephan Heichel, Thomas Sommerer•Transfer, Diffusion und…•2007

  • Asylum seekers’ response to political risk in their countries of origin

    Open Access•Felicitas Nowak‐lehmann, Paúl Elguezabal et al.•Migration Studies•2026

  • Terug of niet? - Determinanten van terugkeerintenties en –attitudes onder (bijna) uitgeprocedeerde asielmigranten

    Arjen Leerkes, Moira Galloway et al.•Mens & Maatschappij•2011

  • Destination choice of asylum applicants in Europe from three conflict-affected countries

    Open Access•Tomoya Suzuki•Migration and Development•2022

  • Asylum recognition rates in Europe

    Open Access•T J Hatton•European Journal of Political…•2023

  • Do applications respond to changes in asylum policies in European countries

    Open Access•Simone Bertoli, Herbert Brücker et al.•Regional Science and Urban…•2022

  • The State and the Refugee. Governing Asylum at the Intersection Between Politics and Administration

    Open Access•Pierre Georges Van Wolleghem•Political Research Quarterly•2026

  • Asylpolitik im Bundesländervergleich

    Open Access•Felix Hörisch•Zeitschrift für Vergleichende…•2018

  • Au coeur des politiques d’asile

    Sule Tomkinson, Jonathan Miaz•Politique et Sociétés•2019

  • A progressive dilemma? Investigating cross-country variations in family-immigration policies through the lens of welfare-state regimes

    Open Access•Anton Ahlén•Political Research Exchange•2023

  • The implementation of Italian asylum policy and the recognition of protection in times of crisis

    Iole Fontana•Contemporary Italian Politics•2019

  • Law and Refugee Crises

    Open Access•Silvia Pasquetti, Noemi Casati et al.•Annual Review of Law and Social…•2019

  • The Cedaw Effect

    Neil A Englehart, Melissa K Miller•Journal of Human Rights•2014

  • A Rare Examination of Typically Unobservable Factors in US Asylum Decisions

    Linda Camp Keith, Jennifer S Holmes•Journal of Refugee Studies•2009

  • The Asylum Hump

    Open Access•Constantin Ruhe, Charles Martin-Shields et al.•Journal of Refugee Studies•2020

  • The decision to flee

    Open Access•Laura Renner, Lena Schmid•Journal of Population Economics•2025

  • Political Persecution or Economic Deprivation? A Time-Series Analysis of Haitian Exodus, 1990—2004

    Open Access•Stephen M Shellman, Brandon M Stewart et al.•Conflict Management and Peace…•2007

  • The Determinants of Refugees’ Destinations

    Open Access•Valentina Di Iasio, Jackline Wahba•World Development•2024

  • Rivalry, ethnicity, and asylum admissions worldwide

    Lamis Abdelaaty•International Interactions•2020

  • Asylum Migration in OECD Countries

    Open Access•Jordi Paniagua, Jesús Peiró-Palomino et al.•Social Indicators Research•2020

  • Collectivized Discretion

    Open Access•Johanna Vanto, Elsa Saarikkomäki et al.•International Migration Review•2022

  • The Path to Asylum in the US and the Determinants for who Gets in and Why

    Open Access•Andy J Rottman, Christopher J Fari et al.•International Migration Review•2009

  • Foreign or Domestic Affairs? Unpacking Mechanisms Behind Colombia and Peru's Policies on Venezuelan Displacement

    Open Access•Nieves Fernández-Rodríguez•International Migration Review•2025

  • Disentangling Forced Migration Governance

    Open Access•Lea Müller-Funk, Christian Fröhlich et al.•International Migration Review•2024

  • Refugee gravitation

    Open Access•Jon Echevarria-Coco, Jon Echevarria et al.•Public Choice•2016

  • Are stronger states more humane? A re-evaluation of ‘exemplary villains’

    Open Access•Seung Hoon Chae•Journal of Peace Research•2020

  • Goal ambiguity and informal discretion in the implementation of public policies

    Open Access•Joëlle Bastien•International Review of…•2009

  • Refugees

    Open Access•Peter V Schaeffer, Peter Schaeffer•International Migration•2009

  • The Push and Pull Factors Contributing Towards Asylum Migration from Developing Countries to Developed Countries Since 2000

    Open Access•Nozomi Matsui, James Raymer•International Migration•2020

  • Love thy neighbor

    Open Access•Eunhye Yoo, Jeong-Woo Koo et al.•International Journal of…•2014

  • The Rise and Fall of Asylum

    Open Access•T J Hatton•The Economic Journal•2009

  • Bordering from within

    Federica Festa•New Community•2026

  • Translating ‘legitimate’ violence in deportation

    Open Access•Nicole Marie Ostrand•New Community•2026

  • The Europeanization of asylum policy

    Dimiter Toshkov, Laura de Haan•Journal of European Public Policy•2013

  • Implementation leeway in the Dublin system

    Théoda Woeffray•Journal of European Public Policy•2024

  • Why courts are the life buoys of migrant rights

    Open Access•Natascha Zaun, Martin Leroch et al.•Journal of European Public Policy•2024

  • Symbolic Politics or Effective Burden-Sharing? Redistribution, Side-payments and the European Refugee Fund

    Open Access•Eiko R Thielemann•JCMS Journal of Common Market…•2005

  • Asylum Seekers in Europe

    Open Access•Silvia Angeloni, Francesco Maria Spano•Journal of International…•2018

  • Complementary protection and the recognition rate as tools of governance

    Olga Demetriou•New Community•2022

  • Bogus Refugees? The Determinants of Asylum Migration to Western Europe

    Open Access•E Neumayer•International Studies Quarterly•2005

  • Political Asylum and Sovereignty-Sharing in Europe

    Open Access•Hakan G Sicakkan•Government and Opposition•2008

  • The far-right and asylum outcomes

    Open Access•Meredith Winn•European Union Politics•2021

  • The dynamic relationship between asylum applications and recognition rates in Europe (1987–2010)

    Open Access•Dimiter Toshkov, Dimiter Doychinov Toshkov•European Union Politics•2014

  • Undesired properties of the European Commission’s refugee distribution key

    Open Access•Philip Grech•European Union Politics•2017

  • Do asylum recognition rates in Europe respond to transnational terrorism? The migration-security nexus revisited

    Open Access•Nazli Avdan•European Union Politics•2014

  • Women-Friendliness in European Asylum Policies

    Open Access•Patrick Emmenegger, Katarina Stigwall•Comparative Political Studies•2019

  • Beyond the deportation regime

    Open Access•Arjen Leerkes, Marieke Van Houte•Citizenship Studies•2020

  • The myth of free-riding

    Eiko R Thielemann, Torun Dewan•West European Politics•2006

  • Asylum seekers in the machinery of the state

    Open Access•Pierre Georges Van Wolleghem, Hakan G Sicakkan•European Union Politics•2022

  • Partisan Influence on Immigration

    Open Access•Frøy Gudbrandsen•Scandinavian Political Studies•2010

  • Migration policy trends in OECD countries

    Marc Helbling, Dorina Kalkum•Journal of European Public Policy•2018

  • The analysis of policy convergence, or

    Thomas Plümper, Christina J Schneider•Journal of European Public Policy•2009

  • Human rights violations and the gender gap in asylum recognition rates

    Open Access•Thomas Plümper, E Neumayer•Journal of European Public Policy•2021

  • A Spatial Model of Internal Displacement and Forced Migration

    Open Access•Jon Echevarria-Coco, Javier Gardeazabal•Journal of Conflict Resolution•2021

  • Forty-Eight Shades of Germany

    Gerald Schneider, Nadine Segadlo et al.•German Politics•2020

  • Measuring common standards and equal responsibility-sharing in EU asylum outcome data

    Open Access•Luc Bovens, Chlump Chatkupt et al.•European Union Politics•2012

  • Victim or Threat? Shipwrecks, Terrorist Attacks, and Asylum Decisions in France

    Open Access•Mathilde Emeriau•American Journal of Political…•2024

  • Learning to be Unbiased

    Open Access•Mathilde Emeriau•American Journal of Political…•2023

  • Preserving Law and Order

    Open Access•Angela Y Mcclean•International Political Sociology•2024

  • Higher acceptance rates of asylum seekers lead to slightly more asylum applications in the future

    Open Access•Hannes Weber•Demographic Research•2018

  • The role of conflict and organized violence in international forced migration

    Open Access•Alessandra Conte, Silvia Migali•Demographic Research•2019

  • Explaining the Divergence in Asylum Grant Rates among Immigration Judges

    Open Access•Linda Camp Keith, Jennifer S Holmes et al.•Law & Policy•2013

  • Just another benefit? Administrative judges' constructions of sameness and difference in asylum adjudications

    Open Access•Lena Johannesson•Citizenship Studies•2022

  • The Politics of Deservingness

    Open Access•Walter J Nicholls, Marcel Maussen et al.•American Behavioral Scientist•2016

  • State Capacity, State Failure, and Human Rights

    Open Access•Neil A Englehart•Journal of Peace Research•2009

  • Spatial Dependence in Asylum Migration

    Fabian Barthel, Eric Neumayer•New Community•2015

  • Trading numbers vs. rights? Accounting for liberal and restrictive dynamics in the evolution of asylum and refugee policies

    Eiko Thielemann, Eiko R Thielemann et al.•New Community•2016

  • Same, same but different? A Discourse Network Analysis of the EU's framings of refugee arrivals in 2015 and 2022

    Open Access•Lara Sosa Popovic, Natalie Welfens•New Community•2025

  • Recognizing international protection. How institutional arrangements affect asylum decisions

    Open Access•Pierre Georges Van Wolleghem, Hakan G Sicakkan•New Community•2025

  • An economic theory of democracy

    Anthony Downs•An economic theory of democracy•1985

  • A Comparative Analysis of the Asylum Policy of Seven European Governments

    Liza Schuster•Journal of Refugee Studies•2000

  • Asylum Applications and Recognition Rates in EU Member States 1982-2001

    Maarten Vink•Journal of Refugee Studies•2003

  • The ‘Realism’ of a European Asylum Policy

    Open Access•Daan Bronkhorst•Netherlands Quarterly of Human…•1991

  • The Impact of Legislative Deterrence Measures on the Number of Asylum Applications in Switzerland (1986-1995)

    Thomas Holzer, T E Holzer et al.•International Migration Review•2000

  • Discriminating Decentralization

    Open Access•Thomas Holzer, T E Holzer et al.•Journal of Conflict Resolution•2000

  • Asylum Destination Choice

    Open Access•E Neumayer•European Union Politics•2004

  • Toward Empirical Theory of Genocides and Politicides

    Barbara Harff, Ted Robert Gurr•International Studies Quarterly•1988

  • The State of the World's Refugees

    Martin Brockerhoff•Population and Development Review•1998

  • Armed Conflict 1946-2001

    Open Access•Nils Petter Gleditsch, Peter Wallensteen et al.•Journal of Peace Research•2002

  • Country of asylum by choice or by chance

    Tetty Havinga, Anita Böcker et al.•New Community•1999

Unique citing works69
Citations per year3,29
Citation span2005 - 2026 (22)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 69

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae