Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Immigration policy and electoral competition in Western Europe

A fine-grained analysis of party positions over the past two decades

Bibliographic Data

ID7950352
AuthorsTjitske Akkerman (University of Amsterdam, The Netherlands, corresponding author)
Year2015
Volume21
Issue1
Pages54-67
Publication date2015-01-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueParty Politics (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 1354-0688 • E-ISSN: 1460-3683
PublisherSAGE Publications (PUBLISHER • US)
DOI10.1177/1354068812462928
OpenAlexW2020334443
LanguageEN
Citations received117
References cited37

This article estimates policy positions of mainstream parties and radical right parties in seven countries in Western Europe over the past two decades. The assumption that mainstream parties have moved rightwards under pressure from the electoral success of radical right parties is assessed in close-up. A fine-grained analysis has been used to measure party distances in this specific policy field. Moreover, the new dataset is sufficiently differentiated to enable the identification of specific programmatic strategies followed by mainstream parties. The article concludes that the impact of radical right parties on mainstream policy agendas tends to be overestimated

Competition (biology · Economics · Field (mathematics · Immigration · Mainstream · Political economy · Political science · Politics · Radical right · Electoral Systems and Political Participation · Law · Populism, Right-Wing Movements · Social Policy and Reform Studies

  • In the wake of radical right electoral success

    Andrea Bohman, Mikael Hjerm•New Community•2016

  • Global Migration and Illiberalism in Russia, Eurasia, and Eastern Europe

    Open Access•Anna-Liisa Heusala, Kaarina Aitamurto et al.•Global Migration and Illiberalism…•2024

  • Cultural Backlash

    Open Access•P Norris, Ronald Inglehart•Cultural Backlash•2019

  • Hungary – A Hungarian Crisis or Just a Crisis in Hungary?

    Open Access•Theresa Gessler, Anna Kyriazi•European Party Politics in Times…•2019

  • Conclusion

    Open Access•Hanspeter Kriesi•European Party Politics in Times…•2019

  • Ireland – Limited Restructuration in the Poster Child of Austerity

    Open Access•Swen Hutter, Giorgio Malet•European Party Politics in Times…•2019

  • European Party Politics in Times of Crisis

    Open Access•Swen Hutter, Hanspeter Kriesi•European Party Politics in Times…•2019

  • Spain – Out with the Old

    Open Access•Guillem Vidal, Irene Sánchez Vitores et al.•European Party Politics in Times…•2019

  • Portugal – A Tale of Apparent Stability and Surreptitious Transformation

    Open Access•Frederico Ferreira Da Silva, Mariana S Mendes•European Party Politics in Times…•2019

  • Crises and the Transformation of the National Political Space in Europe

    Open Access•Hanspeter Kriesi, Swen Hutter•European Party Politics in Times…•2019

  • Divided government, polarization, and policy

    Open Access•Luca Repetto, Maximiliano Sosa Andrés•European Journal of Political…•2023

  • Looking back and abroad while (not) moving forward. Migration, ideas and the stability of citizenship in Spain

    Open Access•Francesco Pasetti, Reinhard Schweitzer•Frontiers in Sociology•2025

  • Europe’s immigration divide

    Open Access•Philipp Lutz, Maud Bachelet•Journal of European Public Policy•2026

  • Discurso político ante el multiculturalismo de la derecha española

    Open Access•José Manuel León Ranero, Zakariae Cheddadi El Haddad•Migraciones Publicación del…•2024

  • When everyone talks about migration

    Open Access•Jakob Schwörer, Engler et al.•Political Research Exchange•2026

  • Making the government accountable

    Open Access•Andrea Fumarola•European Politics and Society•2020

  • Wettstreit um Deutung

    Open Access•Bartek Pytlas•Zeitschrift für Vergleichende…•2019

  • The rise and fall of GMOs in politics

    Jakob Schwörer, Xavier Romero-Vidal et al.•Environmental Sociology•2022

  • Political elites and immigration in Italy

    Damon Di Mauro, Luca Verzichelli•Contemporary Italian Politics•2019

  • Muslims’ Vote Choice

    Open Access•Odelia Oshri, Reut Itzkovitch-Malka•Politics and Governance•2025

  • Populism versus Technocracy? Populist Responses to the Technocratic Nature of the EU

    Open Access•Marion Reiser, Jörg Hebenstreit•Politics and Governance•2020

  • Public perceptions of populist radical parties in government

    Open Access•Sofia Marini•European Political Science Review•2026

  • Radical right politics in East and West

    Open Access•Bartek Pytlas•Sociology Compass•2018

  • Immigration and integration policy change in France during Sarkozy’s era

    Open Access•Anna McKeever•French Politics•2024

  • Towards the median economic crisis voter? The new leftist economic agenda of the Front National in France

    Open Access•Gilles Ivaldi•French Politics•2015

  • Immigration attitudes among Western and Eastern European MPs

    Open Access•Bojana Kocijan, Marko Kukec•Comparative European Politics•2021

  • How to please voters without alienating friends? Parties, organised interests and advocacy coalitions in Swiss immigration policy

    Open Access•António Afonso, Alexandre Afonso•Comparative European Politics•2014

  • Party competition and immigration and integration policies

    Open Access•Matthias Kortmann, Christian Stecker•Comparative European Politics•2017

  • What to expect when you’re electing

    Open Access•Michael A Hansen, Jennifer L Clemens•Comparative European Politics•2018

  • Moderation of Radical Right‐wing Populist Parties in Western European Governments – A Comparative Analysis

    Open Access•Raphael Capaul, Christian Ewert•Swiss Political Science Review•2021

  • Politicisation of Immigration in Central and Eastern Europe

    Jan Kovář•Problems of Post-Communism•2022

  • Migration as amplifier. How the influence of welfare chauvinism on the vote for far-right populist parties is conditioned by migration

    Open Access•Lars Rumpf, Georg Wenzelburger•Journal of European Social Policy•2025

  • Thirty years of welfare chauvinism research

    Open Access•Romana Careja, Eloisa Harris•Journal of European Social Policy•2022

  • Categorizing discourses of welfare chauvinism

    Open Access•Benjamin Leruth, Peter Taylor-Gooby et al.•Journal of European Social Policy•2024

  • Agency, institutions, and welfare chauvinism

    Open Access•Dominic Afscharian, Cecilia Bruzelius et al.•Journal of European Social Policy•2024

  • The political economy of minimum income benefits

    Open Access•Mario T Taschwer•Journal of European Social Policy•2020

  • Contesting the EU’s external democratization agenda

    Open Access•Aron Buzogány, Oriol Costa et al.•Cambridge Review of International…•2021

  • Far-right agenda setting

    Open Access•Daniel Saldivia Gonzatti, Teresa Völker•European Journal of Political…•2025

  • Mainstreaming vs. normalisation

    Open Access•Anna-Sophie Heinze, Gefjon Off•European Journal of Political…•2026

  • The Political Consequences of Nativism

    Open Access•Nicholas T Davis, Kirby Goidel et al.•Social Science Quarterly•2019

  • Better Against Than in Favor

    Open Access•Silvia Bolgherini, Luca Carrieri•Political Studies•2025

  • Party Positions on Economic Criteria for Naturalization in Austria

    Open Access•Jeremias Stadlmair•International Migration•2017

  • Radical right success and mainstream parties’ position ambiguity on immigration

    Open Access•Kyung Joon Han•Acta Politica•2022

  • A micro perspective on political competition

    Open Access•Aiko Wagner•Acta Politica•2017

  • Radicalisation and discursive accommodation

    Open Access•Natasha Wunsch, Marie‐eve Bélanger•West European Politics•2023

  • Political parties and Muslims in Europe

    Irina Ciornei, Eva-Maria Euchner et al.•West European Politics•2021

  • Variation in policy success

    Philipp Lutz•West European Politics•2018

  • The implications of the European financial crisis and parties’ positions on European integration on the outcomes of government formation processes in Southern Europe

    Nicola Palma, Marc Debus•South European Society & Politics•2023

  • Populism, Partisan Convergence, and Mobilization in Western Europe

    Julia Lynch•Polity•2019

  • Policy Effects of Anti-Immigrant Party Representation on Aid to Vulnerable European Union/European Economic Area Citizens

    Open Access•Maria Tyrberg, Carl Dahlström•Political Studies•2018

  • The effect of radical right fringe parties on main parties in Central and Eastern Europe

    Open Access•Reinhard Heinisch, Steven Saxonberg et al.•Party Politics•2021

  • Contagious Euroscepticism

    Open Access•Maurits J Meijers•Party Politics•2017

  • Anti-Immigrant Sentiment and Opposition to Democracy in Europe

    Karen Vaughan, Kenneth R Vaughan•Journal of Immigrant & Refugee…•2021

  • Green Versus Radical Right as the New Political Divide? The European Parliament Election 2019 in Germany

    Open Access•Carl C Berning, C Ziller•JCMS Journal of Common Market…•2020

  • Welfare Pluralism and a Policy Window in Refugee Policies

    Open Access•Renata Stefańska, Aleksandra Grzymała-Kazłowska et al.•Journal of International…•2025

  • Coping with the asylum challenge

    Ludwig Bernhard, Dorothy Kaufmann•New Community•2018

  • Ethnic minority MPs as reputational shields? How Western European political parties respond to public opinion shifts on immigration policy

    Open Access•Marc Van De Wardt, Maria Sobolewska et al.•European Political Science Review•2024

  • Who liberalizes high-skilled immigration policy and when? Partisanship and the timing of policy liberalization in 19 European states

    Melanie Kolbe•Ethnic and Racial Studies•2021

  • Causes and consequences of the rise of populist radical right parties and movements in Europe

    Open Access•Jasper Muis, Tim Immerzeel•Current Sociology•2017

  • Paradox of choices

    Min Tang, Seung‐mi Han et al.•Contemporary Politics•2025

  • Parties on the Left, Parties on the Right

    Open Access•John Graeber•British Journal of Political…•2022

  • Realignment within the right field

    Open Access•Silja Häusermann, Simón Bornschier et al.•West European Politics•2025

  • Do EU policies constrain government autonomy? Insights from the implementation of EU migration policies

    Open Access•Asya Zhelyazkova•West European Politics•2024

  • The social policy agendas of populist radical right parties in comparative perspective

    Open Access•Menno Fenger•Journal of International and…•2018

  • Dealing with the populist radical right in parliament

    Open Access•Anna-Sophie Heinze•European Political Science Review•2022

  • Migration and Healthcare Reforms in Spain

    Open Access•María Bruquetas-Callejo, María Bruquetas‐callejo et al.•South European Society & Politics•2020

  • Italy’s right turn. A spatial analysis of party competition in the 2022 Italian national election

    Paolo Gambacciani, Daniela Giannetti et al.•South European Society & Politics•2025

  • Do Anti‐immigration Parties Matter? The Case of theSwedenDemocrats and Local Refugee Policy

    Open Access•Niklas Bolin, Gustav Lidén et al.•Scandinavian Political Studies•2014

  • Do Parties Matter for Environmental Policy Stringency? Exploring the Program-to-Policy Link for Environmental Issues in 28 Countries 1990–2015

    Open Access•Staffan Lundquist•Political Studies•2024

  • Pariahs or Partners? Inclusion and Exclusion of Radical Right Parties and the Effects on Their Policy Positions

    Open Access•Tjitske Akkerman, Matthijs Rooduijn•Political Studies•2015

  • Can political speech foster tolerance of immigrants

    Open Access•Petra Schleiter, M Tavits et al.•Political Science Research and…•2022

  • Reassessing the gap-hypothesis

    Open Access•Philipp Lutz•Party Politics•2021

  • A policy like no other? The populist radical right challenge in the field of democracy reform

    Open Access•Camille Bedock, Volker Best et al.•Party Politics•2023

  • Old versus new politics

    Open Access•Swen Hutter, Hanspeter Kriesi et al.•Party Politics•2018

  • Changing positions without losing face

    Open Access•Alexandra Feddersen•Party Politics•2023

  • Representative Democracy in Danger? The Impact of Populist Parties in Government on the Powers and Practices of National Parliaments

    Open Access•Aleksandra Maatsch, Eric Miklin•Parliamentary Affairs•2021

  • How Does the Strength of the Far Right Affect Ethnic Minority Political Behaviour

    Open Access•Nicole S Martins•Parliamentary Affairs•2023

  • What are the effects of entry of new extremist parties on the policy platforms of mainstream parties

    Open Access•Samuel Merrill, B Grofman•Journal of Theoretical Politics•2019

  • The use of the abuse policy narrative in asylum debates and its effects on citizens’ opinion formation

    Open Access•Dorothy Kaufmann, Ludwig Bernhard•Journal of Public Policy•2023

  • Why parties take up digitization in their manifestos

    Pascal D König, Georg Wenzelburger•Journal of European Public Policy•2019

  • Policy issue salience and legislative output of populist governments

    Open Access•Tobias Böhmelt, Lawrence Ezrow•Journal of European Public Policy•2024

  • Parties, governments and the integration of immigrants

    Lasse Aaskoven•Journal of European Public Policy•2020

  • The impact of issue politicization around redistribution on support for equality and its ideological divides

    Open Access•Arno Van Hootegem•Journal of European Public Policy•2025

  • From Cohesion to Contagion? Populist Radical Right Contestation of EU Enlargement

    Open Access•Marie‐eve Bélanger, Natasha Wunsch•JCMS Journal of Common Market…•2022

  • The Role of Public Opinion in EU Integration

    Open Access•Damon Di Mauro, Vincenzo Memoli•JCMS Journal of Common Market…•2021

  • The impact of mass-level ideological orientations on immigration policy preferences over time

    Open Access•Jens Peter Frølund Thomsen, Arzoo Rafiqi•Italian Political Science…•2019

  • Populism and emotions

    Open Access•Manuela Caiani, Jessica Di Cocco•Italian Political Science…•2023

  • Politicization of the refugee crisis

    Open Access•Stella Gianfreda•Italian Political Science…•2018

  • The Three Faces of Populism in Power

    Open Access•Manuela Caiani, Paolo Graziano•Government and Opposition•2022

  • Parties Matter

    Open Access•Michelle Falkenbach•Government and Opposition•2022

  • Mainstream Sell-Outs? How Collaboration with the Radical Right Changes Perceptions of Party Positions on Immigration

    Open Access•Ida B Hjermitslev•Government and Opposition•2022

  • Elections and Immigration Policy in Autocracy

    Open Access•Song Ha Joo•Government and Opposition•2024

  • The Social Democratic Party of Germany (SPD) and Immigration Policies

    Suat Alper Orhan•German Politics•2025

  • Party Competition in Migration Debates

    Dana Siobhan Atzpodien•German Politics•2022

  • Once they are seated

    Open Access•Morten Hedegaard Larsen•European Political Science Review•2023

  • Two worlds, one nation? Comparing the political spaces of Flanders and Francophone Belgium

    Open Access•Daan Delespaul, Cecil Meeusen et al.•European Political Science Review•2025

  • The punitive impact of radical right populism on foreign aid

    Open Access•Motoshi Suzuki•European Political Science Review•2023

  • Positions and saliency of immigration in party manifestos

    Open Access•Pola Lehmann, Malisa Zobel•European Journal of Political…•2018

  • Mainstream parties and global warming

    Open Access•Jakob Schwörer•European Journal of Political…•2024

  • Explaining the immigration policy mix

    Open Access•Caroline Schultz, Philipp Lutz et al.•European Journal of Political…•2021

  • Immigration and Politics in the New Europe

    Open Access•Gallya Lahav•Immigration and Politics in the…•2004

  • Radical Right

    Open Access•P Norris•Radical Right•2005

  • Populist Radical Right Parties in Europe

    Open Access•Cas Mudde•Populist Radical Right Parties in…•2007

  • Radical Right-Wing Populism in Western Europe

    Open Access•Hans-Georg Betz, Hans‐georg Betz•Radical Right-Wing Populism in…•1994

  • The Impact of Radical Right-Wing Parties in West European Democracies

    Open Access•M Williams, Michelle Hale Williams•Impact of Radical Right-Wing…•2006

  • Acquisition and Loss of Nationality. Volumes 1 + 2

    Rainer Bauböck, Eva Ersbøll et al.•Acquisition and loss of nationality•2006

  • One size fits all?

    Open Access•Franz Todtling, Michaela Trippl•Research Policy•2005

  • An economic theory of democracy

    Anthony Downs•An economic theory of democracy•1985

  • Toward Assimilation and Citizenship

    Open Access•Christian Joppke, Ewa Morawska•Toward Assimilation and Citizenship•2014

  • European Immigration Policies in Comparative Perspective

    Open Access•Terri E Givens, Terri Givens et al.•Comparative European Politics•2005

  • Explaining and Predicting Elections

    Open Access•John R Petrocik•Political Science Quarterly•1984

  • Revisiting Lepanto

    Hans-Georg Betz, Hans‐georg Betz et al.•Patterns of Prejudice•2009

  • The European extreme-right and Islam

    José Pedro Zúquete•Journal of Political Ideologies•2008

  • One Size Fits All? European Citizenship, National Citizenship Policies and Integration Requirements

    Pontus Odmalm•Representation•2007

  • If you can't Beat them, Join them? Explaining Social Democratic Responses to the Challenge from the Populist Radical Right in Western Europe

    Open Access•Tim Bale, Christoffer Green-Pedersen et al.•Political Studies•2010

  • The Growing Importance of Issue Competition

    Open Access•Christoffer Green-Pedersen•Political Studies•2007

  • Immigration and the transnational European centre-right

    Fraser Duncan, Steven Van Hecke•Journal of European Public Policy•2008

  • Turning round the telescope. Centre-right parties and immigration and integration policy in Europe1

    Tim Bale•Journal of European Public Policy•2008

  • The Impact of the Far Right on Citizenship Policy in Europe

    Marc M Howard•New Community•2010

  • Citizenship Attribution in Western Europe

    Maarten Vink, Maarten P Vink et al.•New Community•2010

  • The extreme-right and immigration policy-making

    Martin A Schain•West European Politics•2006

  • Comparing Radical Right Parties in Government

    Tjitske Akkerman•West European Politics•2012

  • Pariahs in their midst

    William M Downs•West European Politics•2001

  • Immigration, left and right

    Open Access•Sonia Alonso, Sonia Alonso Sáenz De Oger et al.•Party Politics•2012

  • Politicization of ethnicity in party manifestos

    Open Access•Oleh Protsyk, Stela Garaz•Party Politics•2013

  • Contagious Parties

    Open Access•Joost Van Spanje•Party Politics•2010

  • A double-edged sword! The Dutch centre-right and the ‘foreigners issue

    Kees Van Kersbergen, André Krouwel•Journal of European Public Policy•2008

  • Nicolas Sarkozy and the politics of French immigration policy

    Sally Marthaler•Journal of European Public Policy•2008

  • Christian Democracy

    Stathis N Kalyva, Stathis N Kalyvas et al.•Annual Review of Political Science•2010

  • Estimating Policy Positions from Political Texts

    Michael Laver, John Garry•American Journal of Political…•2000

  • Testing the Mandate Model in Britain and the United States

    Open Access•Terry J Royed, Terry Royed•British Journal of Political…•1996

  • Expert Interpretations of Party Space and Party Locations in 42 Societies

    Open Access•John D Huber, John Huber et al.•Party Politics•1995

  • Integration Requirements for Integration's Sake? Identifying, Categorising and Comparing Civic Integration Policies

    W Goodman, Sara Wallace Goodman•New Community•2010

  • Competition Between Unequals

    Open Access•Bonnie M Meguid•American Political Science Review•2005

Unique citing works117
Citations per year9,75
Citation span2014 - 2026 (13)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedYes
Citation typesNeutral: 116

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae