Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Regime Cycles

Democracy, Autocracy, and Revolution in Post-Soviet Eurasia

Bibliographic Data

ID8042864
AuthorsHenry E Hale (0000-0002-2956-8033, George Washington University, corresponding author)
Year2005
Volume58
Issue1
Pages133-165
Publication date2005-10-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueWorld Politics (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0043-8871 • E-ISSN: 1086-3338
PublisherProject MUSE (PUBLISHER • US)
DOI10.1353/wp.2006.0019
OpenAlexW2051395383
LanguageEN
Citations received159
References cited55

Research on regime change has often wound up chasing events in the post-Soviet world because it has frequently assumed that regime change, if not simple instability, implies a trajectory toward a regime-type endpoint like democracy or autocracy. A supplemental approach recognizes that regime change can be cyclic, not just progressive, regressive, or random. In fact, regime cycles are much of what we see in the postcommunist world, where some states have oscillated from autocracy toward greater democracy, then back toward more autocracy, and, with recent “colored revolutions,” toward greater democracy again. An institutional logic of elite collective action, focusing on the effects of patronalpresidentialism, is shown to be useful in understanding such cyclic dynamics, explaining why “revolutions” occurred between 2003 and 2005 in Ukraine, Georgia, and Kyrgyzstan but not in countries like Russia, Azerbaijan, and Uzbekistan

Autocracy · Democracy · Development economics · Economic system · Economics · Elite · Political economy · Political science · Politics · Regime change · Law · Political Conflict and Governance · Russia and Soviet political economy · Soviet and Russian History

  • From the Frying Pan into the Fire

    Владимир Гельман, V Ia Gel'man•Sociological Research•2008

  • Populism in the Post-Soviet States

    Luke March•The Oxford Handbook of Populism•2017

  • The State as Investment Market

    Johan Engvall•State As Investment Market•2016

  • Russian and Post-Soviet Studies

    Open Access•Jeffrey K Ha, Jeffrey Hass•International Encyclopedia of the…•2015

  • Religious Politics in Turkey

    Open Access•Ceren Lord•Religious Politics in Turkey•2018

  • Behind the storefront of democracy

    Open Access•Ainius Lašas•Journalism•2017

  • Główne podejścia teoretyczne do analizy „kolorowych rewolucji” na obszarze postradzieckim

    Open Access•Liana Hurska-Kowalczyk•Przegląd Wschodnioeuropejski•2021

  • The Protest Movements’ Opportunities and Outcomes

    Mikhaïl Minakov, Mykhailo Minakov•Protest•2022

  • Exploring subjective well-being using machine learning

    Open Access•Vinod Sharma, Yogesh Mahajan et al.•Cogent Social Sciences•2025

  • Health policy implications for cardiovascular disease, type 2 diabetes mellitus, and stroke in Central Asia

    Open Access•Sharapat Moiynbayeva, Valikhan Akhmetov et al.•Frontiers in Public Health•2024

  • Bedrohte Artenvielfalt

    Jan Matti Dollbaum•Forschungsjournal Soziale…•2022

  • Bottom‐up or top‐down

    Inna Melnykovska, Rainer Schweickert•Journal of Southeast European and…•2008

  • The Oligarch Vanishes

    John S Earle, Solomiya Shpak et al.•Quarterly Journal of Political…•2022

  • Georgiens parlamentsval

    Open Access•Christofer Berglund•Nordisk øst-forum/Nordisk østforum•2013

  • Democratizing kompromat

    K E Pearce•Information Communication & Society•2015

  • Networked Authoritarianism and Social Media in Azerbaijan

    Open Access•K E Pearce, Sarah Kendzior•Journal of Communication•2012

  • On Revolutions

    Colin J Beck, Mlada Bukovansky et al.•On Revolutions•2022

  • Russia, the Former Soviet Republics, and Europe Since 1989

    Katherine Graney•Russia, the Former Soviet…•2019

  • The Foundations of Ethnic Politics

    Open Access•Henry E Hale•Foundations of Ethnic Politics•2008

  • Political Survival and Sovereignty in International Relations

    Open Access•Jesse Dillon Savage•Political Survival and…•2020

  • The Politics of Protest in Hybrid Regimes

    Open Access•Graeme B Robertson•Politics of Protest in Hybrid…•2010

  • Back to the USSR? Quantifying Behavioral Strategies of Environmental NGOs in Post-2022 Russia

    Arina Loginova•Problems of Post-Communism•2026

  • Striving towards democracy? Political participation in post-Soviet countries

    Viktor Tuzov, Muhammad Masood•European Politics and Society•2022

  • Eurasian Polities as Hybrid Regimes

    Open Access•Henry E Hale•Journal of Eurasian Studies•2010

  • When Revolutionary Coalitions Break Down

    Ceil Berman•Middle East Law and Governance•2019

  • Usaid Democracy Promotion as a Possible Predictor of Revolutionary Destabilization

    Maksim Kostin, Andrey Korotayev•Comparative Sociology•2024

  • Authoritarian Party Systems

    Grigorii V Golosov•Comparative Sociology•2013

  • When can external actors influence democratization? Leverage, linkages, and gatekeeper elites

    Jakob Tolstrup•Democratization•2013

  • Questioning democracy promotion

    Elena Korosteleva•Democratization•2012

  • Oil in the family

    Scott Radnitz•Democratization•2012

  • Democratization at the grassroots

    Anastassia Obydenkova, Anastassia V Obydenkova•Democratization•2012

  • Rethinking the ‘presidentialism debate

    Paul Chaisty, Nic Cheeseman et al.•Democratization•2014

  • Personal rule, neopatrimonialism, and regime typologies

    Farid Guliyev•Democratization•2011

  • Responding to the Street

    Alejandro M Peña, Thomas Davies et al.•Mobilization An International…•2017

  • Ukraine

    Open Access•Henry E Hale•Journal of democracy•2010

  • Kyrgyzstan's Latest Revolution

    Open Access•Kathleen Collins•Journal of democracy•2011

  • Formal Constitutions in Informal Politics

    Open Access•Henry E Hale•World Politics•2011

  • Defeating Dictators

    Open Access•Valerie J Bunce, Sharon L Wolchik•World Politics•2010

  • Government and biodiversity governance in Post-Soviet Azerbaijan

    Open Access•Sebastian Schmidt, Sebastian M Schmidt et al.•Environment Development and…•2017

  • Elite Management in Electoral Authoritarian Regimes

    Gulnaz Sharafutdinova•Central Asian Affairs•2015

  • The Declining Role of Political Elites in Revolutions in Post-communist Eurasia

    Arzuu Sheranova, Marat Uraimov•Central Asian Affairs•2023

  • Uzbekistan’s ‘Real’ Second Chance

    Open Access•Steven Levin•Central Asian Affairs•2024

  • The Diversity of Actors in Reform Backsliding and Its Containment in the Ukrainian Hybrid Regime

    Open Access•Michael Martin Richter•Politics and Governance•2022

  • Halk, Watan, Berdymukhammedov! Political Transition and Regime Continuity in Turkmenistan

    Charles J Sullivan•Region Regional Studies of Russia…•2016

  • Revolutionary mass uprisings in authoritarian regimes

    Open Access•Holger Albrecht, Kevin Koehler•International Area Studies Review•2020

  • Resilience of the Communist Party of Vietnam's Authoritarian Regime since Đổi Mới

    Open Access•Hai Hong Nguyen•Journal of Current Southeast…•2016

  • Manufacturing resilience

    Open Access•Skye C Cooley, Ethan C Stokes•Global Media and Communication•2018

  • The problem of political calculation in autocracies

    Open Access•Sherzod Abdukadirov•Constitutional Political Economy•2010

  • Towards a Model Explaining the Political (In)stability and Variety of Regimes in the Post-Soviet Region

    Matej Makarovič, Janja Mikulan Kildi•Comparative Sociology•2017

  • What's Left Behind When the Party's Over

    Open Access•Ted Brader, Joshua A Tucker•Politics & Policy•2009

  • Londongrad, a post-socialist city

    Nadir Kinossian•Eurasian Geography and Economics•2025

  • Goodbye to 1989 and All That

    Open Access•Markus Bernhard, Daniel I O’neill•Perspectives on Politics•2022

  • The EU’s stability-democracy dilemma in the context of the problematic accession of the Western Balkan states

    Nicholas Ross Smith, Nina Markovic Khaze et al.•Journal of Contemporary European…•2020

  • Democratic Revolutions from a Different Angle

    Taras Kuzio•Journal of Contemporary European…•2012

  • The AKP'S proposal for a “Turkish type of presidentialism” in comparative context

    Open Access•Şule Özsoy Boyunsuz•Turkish Studies•2016

  • Global Kondratiev waves and political transformations in Russia since 1800

    Open Access•Salvatore Babone, Philipp Babcicky et al.•International Politics•2023

  • Régimes politiques, pratiques systémiques et dynamiques de l'émergence dans les États africains et post-soviétiques

    Daniel C Bach•Revue internationale de politique…•2014

  • Structural factors vs. regime change

    Theodor Tudoroiu•Democratization•2011

  • The Authoritarian Origins of the President‐Ruling Party Relationship in South Korea

    Open Access•Sun‐Woo Lee, Sun-Woo Lee•Pacific Focus•2026

  • The Limits of the Matrix

    Gulnaz Sharafutdinova•Problems of Post-Communism•2012

  • The Politics of Electoral Reform in Ukraine

    Dima Kortukov•Problems of Post-Communism•2019

  • Power, Knowledge, and the “Self” in Everyday Normalization of the Political Truth

    Diana T Kudaibergenova•Problems of Post-Communism•2019

  • The Dynamics of Regional and National Contentious Politics in Russia

    Tomila V Lankina, Tomila Lankina•Problems of Post-Communism•2015

  • After the Revolution

    Grigore Pop-Eleches, Graeme B Robertson•Problems of Post-Communism•2014

  • Environmental Regionalism and International Organizations

    Open Access•Anastassia Obydenkova•Problems of Post-Communism•2022

  • Risks and Constraints of Sub-Federal Politics in Russia under Vladimir Putin

    Marat Grebennikov•The Soviet and Post-Soviet Review•2015

  • Regionally Distinct Post-Socialist Leaders

    Azamat Sakiev•The Soviet and Post-Soviet Review•2017

  • Is a Consolidation of Liberal Democracy in the Russia Federation a Reality

    Open Access•Chaim Shinar•European Review•2014

  • Change for the sake of continuity? Élite politics in post-Nazarbayev Kazakhstan (2019–2023)

    Open Access•Luciano Anceschi, Kristiina Silvan•Post-Soviet Affairs•2025

  • Neo-patrimonial practices and sustainability of authoritarian regimes in Eurasia

    Open Access•Stanislav Shkel, Stanislav N Shkel•Communist and Post-Communist…•2019

  • Immersion and Distancing

    Sofya Du Boulay•Communist and Post-Communist…•2024

  • Losers” in the Age of Democratization

    Peng Liu, Liu Peng•Communist and Post-Communist…•2024

  • Comparing democratic performance of semi-presidential regimes in the post-communist region

    Open Access•Huang-Ting Yan•Communist and Post-Communist…•2017

  • Party Politics in Russia

    Владимир Гельман, Vladimir Gel'Man•Europe Asia Studies•2008

  • Foreign Policy Diversification and Intercontinental Transport Corridors

    Nicola Contessi, Nicola P Contessi•Europe Asia Studies•2018

  • The End of Adaptive Authoritarianism in Belarus

    Open Access•Stephen Hall•Europe Asia Studies•2022

  • Cherry Picking EU Conditionality

    Ketevan Bolkvadze•Europe Asia Studies•2016

  • Institutionalising Authoritarian Presidencies

    Open Access•Fabian Burkhardt•Europe Asia Studies•2020

  • Globalisation, Authoritarianism and the Post-Soviet State in Kazakhstan and Uzbekistan

    Ernesto Gallo•Europe Asia Studies•2020

  • Reading the Tea Leaves

    Annette Baturo, Slava Mikhaylov et al.•Europe Asia Studies•2014

  • From Balcony to Barricade

    Ellen Carnaghan•Europe Asia Studies•2016

  • Patronage and the Party of Power

    Thomas F Remington, Thomas Remington•Europe Asia Studies•2008

  • The End of Russian Hegemony in the Post-Soviet Space? War in Ukraine and Disintegration Processes in Eurasia

    Ruslan Zaporozhchenko•Europe Asia Studies•2024

  • Rivalité des modèles et décalage des normes

    Guillaume Sauvé•Revue d’études comparatives…•2019

  • Les Violences ethniques de juin 2010 au Kirghizstan

    Olivier Ferrando•Revue d’études comparatives…•2010

  • The More Fragmented the Better?—The Impact of Armed Forces Structure on Defection during Nonviolent Popular Uprisings

    Philipp M Lutscher•International Interactions•2015

  • Situating the ‘Tulip Revolution’

    Sally N Cummings, Maxim Ryabkov•Central Asian Survey•2008

  • Governance and order-making in Central Asia

    Philipp Lottholz, John Heathershaw et al.•Central Asian Survey•2020

  • Author–critic forum

    Nick Megoran, John Heathershaw et al.•Central Asian Survey•2013

  • Rational or reckless? Georgia's zugzwang in the Caucasus

    Open Access•David S Siroky, Valeriy Dzutsev•Nationalities Papers•2012

  • Misruling the Masses

    Open Access•Charles J Sullivan, Charles Sullivan•Nationalities Papers•2019

  • Carrots and Sticks of Authoritarian Federalism

    Open Access•Andrey Yushkov, Kathleen Gergely et al.•Publius The Journal of Federalism•2025

  • An economic theory of a hybrid (competitive authoritarian or illiberal) regime

    Open Access•Ronald Wintrobe•Public Choice•2018

  • Sovereign Commitment and Property Rights

    Open Access•Stanislav Marku, Stanislav Markus•Studies in Comparative…•2016

  • Beyond Authoritarianism

    Open Access•Leah Gilbert, Payam Mohseni•Studies in Comparative…•2011

  • Eyes Wide Shut

    Open Access•J P Goode•Social Science Quarterly•2016

  • The Reformer's Spirit

    Open Access•Eva M Witesman, Eva Witesman et al.•Public Administration Review•2012

  • The Centralization/Decentralization Paradox in Civil Service Reform

    Open Access•Eva M Witesman, Eva Witesman et al.•Public Administration Review•2008

  • The Color of Money

    Scott Radnitz•Comparative Politics•2010

  • Representation and Democracy in Eurasia's Unrecognized States

    Oleh Protsyk•Post-Soviet Affairs•2009

  • Why Not Parties in Russia?

    Henry E Hale•Why Not Parties in Russia?•2005

  • The ruling class

    Gaetano Mosca•The ruling class•1960

  • Political Cycles and the Macroeconomy

    Alberto Alesina, Nouriel Roubini et al.•Political Cycles and the…•1997

  • The Failure of Presidential Democracy

    Juan J Linz, Arturo Valenzuela et al.•The Failure of Presidential…•1994

  • Democracy and the Market

    Open Access•Adam Przeworski•Democracy and the Market•1991

  • Sultanistic Regimes

    H E Chehabi, Houchang Chehabi et al.•Sultanistic regimes•1998

  • The Regime Question

    Open Access•Gerardo L Munck•World Politics•2001

  • Postcommunism and the Theory of Democracy

    Richard D Anderson, Philip G VE Roeder et al.•Postcommunism and the Theory of…•2002

  • Democracy Derailed in Russia

    Open Access•M Steven Fish•Democracy Derailed in Russia•2005

  • Problems of Democratic Transition and Consolidation

    Juan J Linz, Juan Linz et al.•Problems of democratic transition…•1996

  • Post-Communist Party Systems

    Open Access•Herbert Kitschelt, Zdenka Mansfeldová et al.•Post-Communist Party Systems•1999

  • The 2002 parliamentary elections in Ukraine

    Taras Kuzio•Journal of Communist Studies•2003

  • The sources and dynamics of competitive authoritarianism in Ukraine

    Lucan A Way•Journal of Communist Studies•2004

  • What Has Changed in Ukrainian Politics

    Paul D’anieri•Problems of Post-Communism•2005

  • On the state, democratization and some conceptual problems

    Open Access•Guillermo O’donnell, Guillermo O'Donnell•World Development•1993

  • Azerbaijan after Heydar Aliev

    Open Access•Alec Rasizade•Nationalities Papers•2004

  • Red sunset

    Richard Sakwa•International Affairs•1994

  • Gorbachev and Yeltsin as Leaders

    Robert Legvold, George W Breslauer•Foreign Affairs•2002

  • Democratic Experiments in Africa

    Open Access•Michael Bratton, Gail M Gerhart et al.•Democratic Experiments in Africa•1997

  • The Logic of Economic Reform in Russia

    Robert Legvold, Jerry F Hough•Foreign Affairs•2001

  • The Global Resurgence of Democracy

    Francis Fukuyama, L Diamond et al.•Foreign Affairs•1993

  • Now out of Never

    Open Access•Timur Kuran•World Politics•1991

  • The Elite Variable in Democratic Transitions and Breakdowns

    John Higley, Michael Burton et al.•American Sociological Review•1989

  • Varieties of Post-Soviet Authoritarian Regimes

    Philip G Roeder•Post-Soviet Affairs•1994

  • Preference for Presidentialism

    Open Access•Gerald M Easter•World Politics•1997

  • The Fourth Wave of DemocracyandDictatorship

    Open Access•Michael Mcfaul•World Politics•2002

  • Rethinking Recent Democratization

    Open Access•Valerie Bunce•World Politics•2003

  • Explaining Machine Politics in Russia's Regions

    Henry E Hale•Post-Soviet Affairs•2003

  • Putin and the "Delegative Democracy" Trap

    Henry E Hale, Michael Mcfaul et al.•Post-Soviet Affairs•2004

  • The End of the Transition Paradigm

    Open Access•Thomas Carothers•Journal of democracy•2002

  • Elections Without Democracy

    Open Access•L Diamond•Journal of democracy•2002

  • Democratization Falters in Azerbaijan

    Open Access•Svante E Cornell, Svante Cornell•Journal of democracy•2001

  • Elections Without Democracy

    Open Access•Steven Levitsky, Lucan A Way•Journal of democracy•2002

  • Georgia's Rose Revolution

    Open Access•Charles H Fairbanks•Journal of democracy•2004

  • Delegative Democracy

    Open Access•Guillermo A O''Donell, Guillermo A O'Donell•Journal of democracy•1994

  • Transitions from Postcommunism

    Open Access•Michael Mcfaul•Journal of democracy•2005

  • Juan Linz, Presidentialism, and Democracy

    Scott Mainwaring, Matthew Soberg Shugart•Comparative Politics•1997

  • Political Liberalization in Africa after Ten Years

    Jeffrey Herbst, E Ike Udogu et al.•Comparative Politics•2001

  • A Politics of Institutional Choice

    Open Access•Timothy Frye•Comparative Political Studies•1997

  • What Do We Know About Democratization After Twenty Years

    Barbara Geddes•Annual Review of Political Science•1999

  • The Ukrainian Orange Revolution brought more than a new president

    Open Access•Robert K Christensen, Edward R Rakhimkulov et al.•Communist and Post-Communist…•2005

  • Transitions to Democracy

    Dankwart A Rustow•Comparative Politics•1970

  • All Kuchma's Men; The Reshuffling of Ukrainian Governors and the Presidential Election of 1999

    Кимитака Мацузато•Post-Soviet Geography and Economics•2001

  • The Hybrid Regimes of Central America

    Open Access•Terry Lynn Karl•Journal of democracy•1995

  • Authoritarian State Building and the Sources of Regime Competitiveness in the Fourth Wave

    Open Access•Lucan A Way•World Politics•2005

  • Should Transitologists Be Grounded

    Open Access•Valerie Bunce•Slavic Review•1995

  • Ukraine's Orange Revolution

    Adrian Karatnycky•Foreign Affairs•2005

Unique citing works159
Citations per year7,95
Citation span2006 - 2026 (21)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedYes
Citation typesNeutral: 158

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae