Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Vergil's "Aeneid" and the "Argonautica" of Apollonius Rhodius

Bibliographic Data

ID9290560
AuthorsCharles Rowan Beye
Year2004
Volume97
Issue4
Pages450-450
Publication date2004-01-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessNo
TypeREVIEW
Review ofVergil's Aeneid and the Argonautica of Apollonius Rhodius (Arca, 39), Damien Nelis, 2001
VenueThe Classical World (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0009-8418 • E-ISSN: 1558-9234
PublisherJSTOR (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.2307/4352884
OpenAlexW594569318
LanguageEN

This major study of the Aeneid's indebtedness to the Argonautica of Apollonius Rhodius follows on from G.N. Knauer's monumental study of Homeric influence on Vergil, Die Aeneis und Homer (1964). But extra levels of complexity are involved. Apollonius himself was engaged in thoroughgoing imitation of Homer, as Nelis demonstrates in considerable detail. A deep understanding of Apollonius' interaction with IIomer is essential for the exploration of how Vergil, in full awareness of Apollonius' use of Homer, reworked the characters and episodes of the Argonautica. Structurally also the Aeneid adapts not only the broad outlines of the Iliad and of the Odyssey, but also and simultaneously that of the Argonautica. A study of the Aeneid in relation to the Argonautica must therefore also be a study of the Argonautica in relation to the Homeric poems; and our understanding of Vergil's imitation of Homer is profoundly affected by the Apollonian dimension

Art · Literature · Classical Antiquity Studies · History · Philosophy

  • Preposterous Poetics

    Simon Goldhill•Preposterous Poetics•2020

  • Now my charms are all o’erthrown”

    James J Clauss•The Classical World•2018

  • Epic Inclusivity

    S J Harrison, Shane Harrison•Generic Enrichment in Vergil and…•2007

  • Intra‐Epic Debate

    S J Harrison, Shane Harrison•Generic Enrichment in Vergil and…•2007

  • On Not Being Archilochus

    S J Harrison, Shane Harrison•Generic Enrichment in Vergil and…•2007

  • Lyric Flexibility

    S J Harrison, Shane Harrison•Generic Enrichment in Vergil and…•2007

  • Ambition to Rise

    S J Harrison, Shane Harrison•Generic Enrichment in Vergil and…•2007

  • Beyond Pastoral? Generic Pressures in Vergil's Eclogues

    S J Harrison, Shane Harrison•Generic Enrichment in Vergil and…•2007

  • Introduction

    S J Harrison, Shane Harrison•Generic Enrichment in Vergil and…•2007

  • On Virgil's Lightning, Comets, and Libyan She-Bears

    Open Access•Davide Antonio Secci•The Classical Quarterly•2014

  • Ennius' Annals

    Cynthia Damon, Joseph Farrell•Ennius' Annals•2020

  • Statius' Thebaid and the Poetics of Civil War

    Charles Mcnelis•Statius' Thebaid and the Poetics…•2009

  • Virgil's Ascanius

    Anne Rogerson•Virgil's Ascanius•2017

  • Virgil, Aeneid, 4.1–299

    Open Access•Ingo Gildenhard•Virgil, Aeneid, 4.1-299•2012

  • Speaking Aposiopeseis

    Open Access•Stefano Briguglio•Unspoken Rome•2021

  • Et sine auctore notissimi uersus

    Open Access•Barbara Del Giovane•Unspoken Rome•2021

  • Catullus’ Sapphic Lacuna

    Open Access•Ábel Tamás•Unspoken Rome•2021

  • Reading Ennius’ Annals and Cato’s Origins at Rome

    Open Access•Jackie Elliott•Ennius' Annals•2020

  • Intertextuality

    Open Access•Donncha O’Rourke, Aaron Pelttari•The Cambridge Critical Guide to…•2024

  • Speaking Silence in Cicero’s Brutus and Tacitus’ Dialogus de Oratoribus

    Open Access•Kathrin Winter•Unspoken Rome•2021

  • Ennius’ Annals and Tacitus’ Annals

    Open Access•A J Woodman•Ennius' Annals•2020

  • Conspicuous Absence

    Open Access•Ellen O’gorman•Unspoken Rome•2021

  • Lost in Germania

    Open Access•James McNamara, James David McNamara•Unspoken Rome•2021

  • Ennius and Lucilius

    Open Access•Brian W Breed•Ennius' Annals•2020

  • Livy’s Ennius

    Open Access•Ayelet Haimson Lushkov•Ennius' Annals•2020

  • Afterword

    Open Access•Mary Jaeger•Ennius' Annals•2020

  • Allegory and Authority in Latin Verse-Historiography

    Open Access•Thomas Biggs•Ennius' Annals•2020

  • Tamen apsentes prosunt pro praesentibus

    Open Access•Giuseppe Pezzini•Unspoken Rome•2021

  • Ennius’ Annals as Source and Model for Historical Speech

    Open Access•Lydia Spielberg•Ennius' Annals•2020

  • Allegorical Absences

    Open Access•Philip Hardie•Unspoken Rome•2021

  • Apollonius Rhodius, Herodotus and Historiography

    Open Access•Andrew Morrison, A D Morrison•Apollonius Rhodius, Herodotus and…•2020

  • Looking for auctoritas in Ennius’ Annals

    Open Access•Cynthia Damon•Ennius' Annals•2020

  • Absence, Metaphysically Speaking

    Open Access•Duncan F Kennedy•Unspoken Rome•2021

  • The Gaze on the Void

    Open Access•Viola Starnone•Unspoken Rome•2021

  • Unspoken Rome

    Open Access•Tom Geue, Elena Giusti•Unspoken Rome•2021

  • Initiation into the Mysteries of the Ancient World

    Jan N Bremmer•Initiation into the mysteries of…•2014

  • Vergil’s Political Commentary in the Eclogues, Georgics and Aeneid

    Open Access•Leendert Weeda•Vergil ́s Political Commentary•2015

  • Georgics 2.458–542

    Open Access•Damien Nelis•Dictynna•2004

  • The Homeric Formula ἐπ’ εὐρέα νῶτα θαλάσσης and Its Reception

    Open Access•Maria N Kazanskaya•Centre of Linguocultural Research…•2022

  • Virgilian Criticism and the Intertextual Aeneid

    Open Access•Elena Giusti•Mnemosyne•2023

  • Tragedy and Transformation

    Richard Trousdell•Jung Journal•2008

  • The Cambridge Guide to Homer

    Open Access•Jan Paul Crielaard, Corinne Ondine Pache et al.•Cambridge Guide to Homer•2020

  • Ovid and Hesiod

    Open Access•Ioannis Ziogas•Ovid and Hesiod•2013

  • Critical Moments in Classical Literature

    Open Access•Richard Hunter•Critical Moments in Classical…•2009

  • Cassandra and the Poetics of Prophecy in Greek and Latin Literature

    Open Access•Emily Pillinger•Cassandra and the Poetics of…•2019

  • Claudian and the Roman Epic Tradition

    Open Access•Catherine Ware•Claudian and the Roman Epic…•2012

  • Cosmography and the Idea of Hyperborea in Ancient Greece

    Open Access•Renaud Gagné•Cosmography and the Idea of…•2021

  • Constructing Literature in the Roman Republic

    Open Access•Sander M Goldberg•Constructing Literature in the…•2005

  • The meaning of Mr. Tumnus

    Open Access•Randall Pogorzelski, Randall J Pogorzelski•Classical Receptions Journal•2024

  • Passing Over Cephisos' Grandson

    Open Access•Robert Cowan•Ramus•2011

  • La cosmogonía de las Metamorfosis de Ovidio y las Rapsodias órficas

    Open Access•Alberto Bernabé•Emerita•2018

  • Measuring and Mapping Intergeneric Allusion in Latin Poetry using Tesserae

    Open Access•Patrick J Burns, Patrick Burns•Journal of Data Mining & Digital…•2017

  • Reading Roman Pride

    Yelena Baraz•Reading Roman Pride•2020

  • Dido’s Deductio

    Lauren Caldwell•Classical Philology•2008

  • Silvia’s Stag on the Tiber

    Krešimir Vuković•Mnemosyne•2019

  • Der ‚dekadente‘ Feldherr

    Lisa Sannicandro•Mnemosyne•2014

  • Sown Men and Rome’s Civil Wars

    Open Access•Thomas Biggs•Mnemosyne•2022

  • Typhonic Voices

    Stephen A Sansom•Mnemosyne•2019

  • Medea Aiδhλoς

    Peter Hulse•Mnemosyne•2020

  • Compounding Compound Creatures

    Peter Kelly, Peter J Kelly•Mnemosyne•2017

  • Varivm Et Mvtabile Semper Femina

    Open Access•Kevin Muse•The Classical Quarterly•2023

  • Women Scorned

    Open Access•Dunstan Lowe•The Classical Quarterly•2013

  • Pompey, Venus and the Politics of Hesiod in Lucan's Bellvm Civile 8.456–9

    Open Access•Stephen A Sansom•The Classical Quarterly•2020

  • Eastern’ Elegy and ‘Western’ Epic

    Open Access•Donncha O’Rourke•Dictynna•2011

  • A Heraclitean Allusion to the Odyssey

    Open Access•Tom Mackenzie•The Classical Quarterly•2021

  • Inventing Origins? Aetiological Thinking in Greek and Roman Antiquity

    Open Access•Antje Wessels, Jacqueline Klooster•Inventing Origins? Aetiological…•2021

  • The Georgics , the Mysteries and the Muses at Rome

    Open Access•Alex Hardie•Proceedings of the Cambridge…•2002

  • Changing the Sail

    Open Access•Guy Westwood•The Classical Quarterly•2022

  • Elegiac Love and Death in Vergil's Aeneid

    Sarah L McCallum•Elegiac Love and Death in…•2023

  • Hospitality Narratives in Virgil and Callimachus

    Open Access•Donncha O’Rourke•The Cambridge Classical Journal•2017

  • Pluperfects and the Artist in Ekphrases

    Irene J F De Jong•Mnemosyne•2015

  • Virgil's Carthaginians at Aen . 1.430–6

    Open Access•Elena Giusti•The Cambridge Classical Journal•2014

  • Allusive Translation and Chronological Paradox in Varro of Atax’s Argonautae

    Christopher B Polt•The American Journal of Philology•2013

  • And Cytherea Smiled

    Alexander E W Hall•The American Journal of Philology•2011

  • Sulle orme dell'Iliade

    Open Access•F Cannizzaro•Sulle orme dell'Iliade•2023

  • Apollonius and the End of the Aeneid

    Open Access•Adrian Kelly•The Classical Quarterly•2014

  • Mystery Cult in Vergil

    Fiachra Mac Góráin, Damien Nelis•Mnemosyne•2022

  • Ovid, Virgil and the Echoing Rocks of the Two Scyllas

    Open Access•Robert Cowan•The Cambridge Classical Journal•2017

  • Looking Edgeways. Pursuing Acrostics in Ovid and Virgil

    Open Access•M E Robinson, Matthew Robinson•The Classical Quarterly•2019

  • Politics and Divinization in Augustan Poetry

    Bobby Xinyue•Politics and Divinization in…•2022

  • Memory in Vergil's Aeneid

    Aaron M Seider•Memory in Vergil's Aeneid•2013

  • Furrowing Prows

    Open Access•Christopher B Polt•The Classical Quarterly•2017

  • Child's Play

    Open Access•Llewelyn Morgan•The Journal of Roman Studies•2003

  • The Representation and Misrepresentation of Virgilian Poetry in Propertius 2.34

    Donncha O’Rourke, Donncha O'Rourke•The American Journal of Philology•2011

  • Lovers in Arms

    Open Access•Donncha O’Rourke•Dictynna•2014

  • Juno, Hercules, and the Muses at Rome

    Alex Hardie•The American Journal of Philology•2007

  • Aeneas the Flamen

    Open Access•Llewelyn Morgan•The Classical Quarterly•2020

  • Virgil's Cinematic Art

    Kirk Freudenburg•Virgil's Cinematic Art•2022

  • Like Father, Like Son

    Christopher Trinacty•Phoenix•2009

  • Latin Poetry in the Ancient Greek Novels

    Daniel Jolowicz•Latin Poetry in the Ancient Greek…•2021

  • The Measure of Homer

    Richard Hunter, Richard L Hunter•Measure of Homer•2018

  • Inconsistency in Roman Epic

    Open Access•James J O'Hara, James J O’Hara•Inconsistency in Roman Epic•2007

  • Generic Enrichment in Vergil and Horace

    S J Harrison, Shane Harrison•Generic Enrichment in Vergil and…•2007

Citation velocityhistorical
Highly citedNo

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae