Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Sequencing Disadvantage

Barriers to Employment Facing Young Black and White Men with Criminal Records

Bibliographic Data

ID9770246
AuthorsDevah Pager (Office of Population Research at Princeton University, corresponding author), B Western (0000-0001-8615-6767, Harvard University), Naomi F Sugie (0000-0002-2346-4786, Princeton University), Naomi Sugie (Princeton University)
Year2009
Volume623
Issue1
Pages195-213
Publication date2009-05-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueThe Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0002-7162 • E-ISSN: 1552-3349
PublisherSAGE Publications (PUBLISHER • US)
DOI10.1177/0002716208330793
PMID23459367
PMCIDPMC3583356
OpenAlexW2107577675
LanguageEN
Citations received190
References cited15

In this article, the authors report the results of a large-scale field experiment conducted in New York City investigating the effects of race and a prison record on employment. Teams of black and white men were matched and sent to apply for low-wage jobs throughout the city, presenting equivalent resumés and differing only in their race and criminal background. The authors find a significant negative effect of a criminal record on employment outcomes that appears substantially larger for African Americans. The sequence of interactions preceding hiring decisions suggests that black applicants are less often invited to interview, thereby providing fewer opportunities to establish rapport with the employer. Furthermore, employers' general reluctance to discuss the criminal record of an applicant appears especially harmful for black ex-offenders. Overall, these results point to the importance of rapport-building for finding work, something that the stigmatizing characteristics of minority and criminal status make more difficult to achieve

Criminal history · Criminal justice · Criminal record · Criminology · Disadvantage · Political science · Prison · Race (biology · Sociology · White (mutation · Crime Patterns and Interventions · Criminal Justice and Corrections Analysis · Gender Studies · Law · Policing Practices and Perceptions · Psychology

  • The process of offender reintegration

    Open Access•Md Tanvir Mahtab, Jannatul Bakia Jeni•Contemporary South Asia•2026

  • Trabajo y mujeres privadas de la libertad

    Open Access•Astrid Sánchez-Mejía, Juliana Morad•Revista CS•2018

  • Children's antisocial behavior, mental health, drug use, and educational performance after parental incarceration

    Open Access•Joseph Murray, David P Farrington et al.•Psychological Bulletin•2012

  • Employment After Prison

    Christy A Visher, Sara Debus-Sherrill et al.•Justice Quarterly•2011

  • A Vicious Cycle

    Open Access•Jason A Okonofua, Gary M Walton et al.•Perspectives on Psychological…•2016

  • An Introduction to Audit Studies in the Social Sciences

    Open Access•M Gaddi, S Michael Gaddis•Audit Studies: Behind the Scenes…•2018

  • Social vulnerabilities for substance use

    Open Access•Hortensia Amaro, Mariana Sanchez et al.•Neuropharmacology•2021

  • Racial disparities in school-based disciplinary actions are associated with county-level rates of racial bias

    Open Access•Travis Riddle, Stacey Sinclair•Proceedings of the National…•2019

  • A conceptual model for understanding post-release opioid-related overdose risk

    Open Access•Paul J Joudrey, Maria R Khan et al.•Addiction Science & Clinical…•2019

  • Discrimination based on criminal record and healthcare utilization among men recently released from prison

    Open Access•Joseph W Frank, Emily A Wang et al.•Health & Justice•2014

  • Zwart werk na vrijlating

    Anke Ramakers, Pedro Nobbe et al.•Mens & Maatschappij•2017

  • Weer vrij om aan de slag te gaan

    Chantal van den Berg, Nicole Versteege et al.•Mens & Maatschappij•2020

  • School Reentry

    Open Access•Charles H Lea, Tanaya Sardesai et al.•Education Sciences•2026

  • Onset and trajectory of alcohol and other drug use among Aboriginal men entering a prison treatment program

    Open Access•Michael Doyle, Jill Guthrie et al.•Drug and Alcohol Review•2020

  • Assessing legal socialisation in a youth sample

    Open Access•Oluwagbenga Michael Akinlabi, Moses Agaawena Amagnya et al.•Crime Law and Social Change•2025

  • The Network of Neighborhoods and Geographic Space

    Open Access•A Boessen, J R Hipp•Journal of Quantitative Criminology•2022

  • Estimating effects of short-term imprisonment on crime using random judge assignments

    Open Access•Hilde T Wermink, Arjan Blokland et al.•Justice Quarterly•2024

  • Multiple Disadvantage and Social Networks

    Open Access•Andria Timmer, Oshea Johnson et al.•International Journal of Offender…•2025

  • Experiencing Burnout

    Open Access•Jardin Dogan, Danelle Stevens-Watkins et al.•International Journal of Offender…•2024

  • Employment Perceptions of Parolees

    Open Access•Femina P Varghese, Sydney Skaggs et al.•International Journal of Offender…•2021

  • Citizenship on probation

    Open Access•Beth Weaver, Cara Jardine•Probation Journal•2022

  • Do firms redline workers

    Open Access•Ana Maria Diaz, Luz Magdalena Salas•Regional Science and Urban…•2020

  • Age and Chronic and Temporary Criminality

    Open Access•Bonita M Veysey, Luis M Rivera•Criminal Justice and Behavior•2024

  • Negotiating Survival and Dignity

    Open Access•Dong Li•Criminal Justice and Behavior•2026

  • Employer Perceptions of Hiring Juveniles With Criminal Records

    Open Access•Heather Griller Clark, Sarup R Mathur et al.•Criminal Justice and Behavior•2020

  • Informational Properties of Liability Regimes

    Open Access•Claude Fluet, Murat C Mungan•The Journal of Legal Studies•2025

  • Designing the Divide Authentic Perspectives From the Justice-Impacted Population on STEM Exclusion as a Driver of the School-to-Prison Pipeline

    Open Access•Christopher Etienne•Urban Education•2026

  • ‘Would You Prefer Jail or Probation?’ Differences in Sanctioning Preferences among White, Black, and Latinx Adults

    Open Access•Eric J Wodahl, Leanne Fiftal Alarid et al.•The Prison Journal•2022

  • Undergraduate students’ perspectives on the impact of a prison health course

    Open Access•Rose B Cameron, Katherine E McLeod et al.•Health Education Journal•2021

  • The Impact of a Multiple Conviction Record on Hiring Outcomes

    Open Access•Peter Leasure, ROBERT J KAMINSKI•Crime & Delinquency•2021

  • The Benefits of Hindsight and Modern Risk Assessment Tools

    Open Access•Valerie A Clark•Crime & Delinquency•2024

  • Pathways to second chances

    Open Access•C Allen Gorman, Sarah Tucker et al.•Journal of Vocational Behavior•2025

  • “Nothing but a rope to hang yourself

    Open Access•Katherine LeMasters, Hannah Camp et al.•SSM - Mental Health•2023

  • The role of substance use treatment in reducing stigma after release from incarceration

    Open Access•Kelly E Moore, Janan Wyatt et al.•Health & Justice•2023

  • A multi-level intervention to reduce the stigma of substance use and criminal involvement

    Open Access•Kelly E Moore, Jennifer E Johnson et al.•Health & Justice•2023

  • “You can’t incarcerate yourself out of the drug problem in America

    Open Access•Katherine LeMasters, Samantha K Nall et al.•Health & Justice•2025

  • New York State’s Bail Elimination Act of 2019

    Leah G Pope, Daniel Pohl et al.•Impact Assessment and Project…•2023

  • Still Paying for the Past

    Gina Curcio, April Pattavina•Women & Criminal Justice•2018

  • Race Brokers

    E Korver-Glenn•Race Brokers•2021

  • Maternal and paternal imprisonment in the stress process

    Open Access•Holly Foster, J Hagan•Social Science Research•2013

  • The interaction of serious mental disorder and race on time to reincarceration

    Christopher A Veeh, Stephen J Tripodi et al.•American Journal of Orthopsychiatry•2018

  • The Growth of Incarceration in the United States

    Jeremy Travis, National Research Council•The Growth Of Incarceration In…•2014

  • Salience and context of incarceration history disclosure in sexual and reproductive health service delivery

    Open Access•Erin J Mccauley, Erin R Johnson•SSM - Qualitative Research in…•2026

  • Past year and prior incarceration and HIV transmission risk among HIV-positive men who have sex with men in the US

    Maria R Khan, Kathleen A McGinnis et al.•AIDS Care•2019

  • Job Market Signaling through Occupational Licensing

    Peter Q Blair, Bobby Chung et al.•The Review of Economics and…•2025

  • The Role of Religious Belief and Sentencing Decisions in a UK Sample

    Open Access•Isaac Halstead, Alex Lloyd•Journal of Personality•2026

  • Paternal Incarceration and Child Support

    D R Meyer, Pajarita Charles et al.•Social Service Review•2026

  • The Racialized Consequences of Jail Incarceration on Local Labor Markets

    Open Access•Christopher Thomas•Race and Justice•2022

  • Stigma or Separation? Understanding the Incarceration-Divorce Relationship

    Michael Massoglia, Brianna Remster et al.•Social Forces•2011

  • Racialized Re-entry

    Open Access•B Western, Catherine Sirois•Social Forces•2019

  • Sticky Stigma

    Open Access•Bridget Brew, Frances Alani et al.•Social Forces•2022

  • Criminal Labels, Racial Inequities, and the Lifelong Impact of Early Arrests on Employment

    Open Access•Samantha Kopf, Autumn Rydarowicz•Race and Justice•2025

  • How Race and Unemployment Shape Labor Market Opportunities

    Open Access•D S Pedulla•Social Forces•2018

  • Neighborhood isolation in Chicago

    Open Access•C Graif, Alina Lungeanu et al.•Social Networks•2017

  • Examining the Role of Meaningful Work for Desistance Among Justice-Involved Emerging Adults

    Open Access•Madeline Steward, Maia L Ferry et al.•Emerging Adulthood•2026

  • Juvenile Records Negatively Impact Mock‐Hiring Decisions

    Open Access•Krystia Reed, Morgan Wagner•Analyses of Social Issues and…•2026

  • “It’s two separate systems that … keep you under a thumb”

    Open Access•Hannah Schwendeman, Veronica L Horowitz et al.•Law & Society Review•2024

  • Exploring the Influence of Coping Strategies on Depression Scores Among Black Men in Maryland

    Darius Gwynn•Urban Social Work•2025

  • Predicting support for fine penalty replacing imprisonment

    Open Access•Yuxi Shang, Xue Dong et al.•International journal of law,…•2024

  • Sexual misconduct and evaluation of candidate appropriateness for employment within a nonpublic-facing role

    Open Access•Cody Normitta Porter, Laura Haggar et al.•International journal of law,…•2025

  • The Downstream Well-Being Effect of Encounters with the U.S. Criminal Justice System

    Open Access•Christopher A Sanders, Laura A King•Social Justice Research•2025

  • How Racial Tasking Leads to Inequitable Financial Remuneration Among Power-5 College Football Coaches

    Chris Corr, Charles Dt Macaulay et al.•Sociology of Sport Journal•2024

  • Is it a self-fulfilling prophecy

    Open Access•Tova A Cohen, Ian A Silver•Journal of Criminal Justice•2025

  • Does time heal all? Evaluating the effect of time since conviction on employability

    Open Access•Chae M Jaynes, Mateus Rennó Santos et al.•Journal of Criminal Justice•2025

  • Premature Death Risk from Young Adulthood Incarceration

    Open Access•D Witteveen•Sociological Quarterly•2022

  • The causes and consequences of stigma among individuals involved in the criminal legal system

    Open Access•Kelly E Moore, Sarah Phillips et al.•Stigma and Health•2023

  • State Violence, Black Lives, and Environmental Justice

    Open Access•L Downey, Brigid Mark•Environmental Justice•2021

  • When She Says Daddy”

    Open Access•Alvin Thomas, Jennifer Wirth et al.•International Journal of…•2022

  • Competing priorities that rival health in adults on probation in Rhode Island

    Open Access•Kimberly R Dong, Aviva Must et al.•BMC Public Health•2018

  • Incarceration, Maternal Hardship, and Perinatal Health Behaviors

    Open Access•Dora M Dumont, C Wildeman et al.•Maternal and Child Health Journal•2014

  • Message framing to reduce stigma and increase support for policies to improve the wellbeing of people with prior drug convictions

    Open Access•Sachini Bandara, Sachini N Bandara et al.•International Journal of Drug…•2020

  • Structural and healthcare predictors of substance use-related death following release from incarceration

    Open Access•Lauren Brinkley‐rubinstein, Lauren Brinkley-Rubinstein et al.•International Journal of Drug…•2025

  • Level of Criminal Justice Contact and Early Adult Wage Inequality

    Open Access•R Apel, Kathleen Powell•RSF The Russell Sage Foundation…•2019

  • Exclusion and Extraction

    Open Access•Sandra Susan Smith, Jonathan Simon•RSF The Russell Sage Foundation…•2020

  • Providing After Prison

    Open Access•A Dwyer Emory, Lenna Nepomnyaschy et al.•RSF The Russell Sage Foundation…•2020

  • Faculty attitudes toward college students with criminal records

    Molly Ott, Terrence S Mctier•Journal of Diversity in Higher…•2019

  • Employer attitudes towards hiring people with a criminal record

    Open Access•Cody Normitta Porter, Paul Gavin et al.•International journal of law,…•2026

  • Finding employment in the stigma machine

    Open Access•Samantha Mcaleese•International journal of law,…•2026

  • Workforce diversity in Cambodia

    Open Access•Sangmi Cho, Soonok An et al.•Asian Social Work and Policy Review•2024

  • Assisting ex-offenders in employment

    Sam Chi-fung Lo•China Journal of Social Work•2014

  • Parental incarceration and child outcomes

    Open Access•Anna R Haskins, M Amorim et al.•Sociology Compass•2018

  • Paternal incarceration and the family

    Open Access•Britni L Adams•Sociology Compass•2018

  • Fighting labor market discrimination with ban the box (BTB)

    Open Access•Monica Solinas‐saunder, Melissa J Stacer•Sociology Compass•2017

  • Romantic (In)Justice

    Open Access•Allison E Monterrosa•Feminist Criminology•2021

  • Race, Law, and Inequality, 50 Years After the Civil Rights Era

    Open Access•Frank W Munger, Carroll Seron•Annual Review of Law and Social…•2017

  • Who Benefits from Mass Incarceration? A Stratification Economics Approach to the “Collateral Consequences” of Punishment

    Open Access•Tasseli Mckay, William Darity•Annual Review of Law and Social…•2024

  • Criminal Record Questions, Statistical Discrimination, and Equity in a “Ban the Box” Era

    Open Access•Naomi F Sugie•Criminology & Public Policy•2017

  • Electronic Monitoring

    Open Access•Matthew Demichele•Criminology & Public Policy•2014

  • Policy Implications About Properties of Arrest Risk Across Populations of Provisional Employees With and Without a Criminal Record

    Open Access•Michael R Gottfredson•Criminology & Public Policy•2017

  • Fair Chance Act failures? Employers’ hiring of people with criminal records

    Open Access•Sharon S Oselin, Justine Gail Margarethe Ross et al.•Criminology & Public Policy•2023

  • Devolving the carceral state

    Open Access•Reuben Jonathan Miller•Punishment & Society•2014

  • The effects of language on the stigmatization and exclusion of returning citizens

    Open Access•Hilary M Jackl•Punishment & Society•2021

  • James B Jacobs, The Eternal Criminal Record

    Open Access•Jordan M Hyatt•Punishment & Society•2015

  • Association between Recent Criminal Justice Involvement and Transactional Sex among African American Men Who Have Sex with Men in Baltimore

    Open Access•Peng Yang, Nick Zaller et al.•Journal of Urban Health•2019

  • Barriers to Reintegration

    Open Access•Sarah W Galgano•Social Thought and Research•2009

  • Applying the Theory of Social Good to Mass Incarceration and Civil Rights

    Open Access•Robynn Cox•Research on Social Work Practice•2019

  • Implicit and Explicit Measurement Approaches to Research on Policy Implementation

    Open Access•Eugene Borgida, Andrea Miller et al.•PS Political Science & Politics•2013

  • Working around the Law

    Open Access•Dallas Augustine•Law & Social Inquiry•2019

  • Work Your Story”

    Open Access•Philip Goodman•Law & Social Inquiry•2020

  • Before and After Ban the Box

    Open Access•Lesley E Schneider, M Vuolo et al.•Law & Social Inquiry•2021

  • What employers want

    Harry J Holzer•What employers want•1996

  • Crime in the making

    John H Laub, Robert J Sampson•Crime in the making•1993

  • Stories Employers Tell

    Chris Tilly, Philip I Moss•Stories Employers Tell•2001

  • A Continuum of Impression Formation, from Category-Based to Individuating Processes

    Susan T Fiske, Steven L Neuberg•Advances in Experimental Social…•1990

  • Race and the Invisible Hand

    Deirdre A Royster, Deirdre Royster•Race and the Invisible Hand•2019

  • When prisoners come home

    Joan Petersilia•Choice Reviews Online•2003

  • Recidivism of Prisoners Released in 1994

    Patrick A Langan, David J Levin•Federal Sentencing Reporter•2002

  • "Getting Paid"

    Mercer L Sullivan•Getting Paid•1990

  • Looking for truth in all the wrong places? Asymmetric search of individuating information about stereotyped group members

    Yaacov Trope, Erik P Thompson•Journal of Personality and Social…•1997

  • The nonverbal mediation of self-fulfilling prophecies in interracial interaction

    Open Access•Carl O Word, Mark P Zanna et al.•Journal of Experimental Social…•1974

  • Work as a Turning Point in the Life Course of Criminals

    Christopher Uggen•American Sociological Review•2000

  • Incarceration and the Formation and Stability of Marital Unions

    Open Access•Leonard M Lopoo, B Western•Journal of Marriage and the Family•2005

  • The Mark of a Criminal Record

    Devah Pager•American Journal of Sociology•2003

Unique citing works190
Citations per year11,18
Citation span2009 - 2026 (18)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedYes
Citation typesNeutral: 187

Tools

Open DOISci-HubOpen Access
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae