Saltar al contenido principal

ETHNOS_APP

Inicio • Búsqueda • Revistas • Lista 0

When the Problem Is Not the Question and the Solution Is Not the Answer

Mathematical Knowing and Teaching

Datos Bibliográficos

ID8222777
AutoresMagdalene Lampert (Michigan State University, autor de correspondencia)
Año1990
Volumen27
Número1
Páginas29-63
Fecha de publicación1990-03-01
Peer ReviewedSí
Open AccessSí
TipoARTICLE
RevistaAmerican Educational Research Journal (JOURNAL)
Identificadores de la revistaISSN: 0002-8312 • E-ISSN: 1935-1011
EditorialAmerican Educational Research Association (AERA) (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.3102/00028312027001029
OpenAlexW1963516460
IdiomaEN
Citas recibidas141
Referencias citadas26

This paper describes a research and development project in teaching designed to examine whether and how it might be possible to bring the practice of knowing mathematics in school closer too what it means to know mathematics within the discipline by deliberately altering the roles and responsibilities of teacher and students in classroom discourse. The project was carried out as a regular feature of lessons in fifth-grade mathematics in a public school. A case of teaching and learning about exponents derived from lessons taught in the project is described and interpreted from mathematical, pedagogical, and sociolinguistic perspectives. To change the meaning of knowing and learning in school, the teacher initiated and supported social interactions appropriate to making mathematical arguments in response to students’ conjectures. The activities students engaged in as they asserted and examined hypotheses about the mathematical structures that underlie their solutions to problems are contrasted with the conventional activities that characterize school mathematics

Mathematical practice · Mathematics education · Meaning (existential · Pedagogy · Teaching method · Cognitive and developmental aspects of mathematical skills · Education and Technology Integration · Mathematics Education and Teaching Techniques · Psychology · Teacher Education and Leadership Studies

  • Situated cognition and learning

    Open Access•Linda Allal•Swiss Journal of Educational…•2018

  • Zur Rolle der Lehrperson beim kooperativen Lernen

    Open Access•Christine Pauli, Kurt Reusser•Swiss Journal of Educational…•2000

  • Les structures de participation de la micro-culture de classe dans une leçon de mathématiques

    Open Access•Lucie Mottier Lopez•Swiss Journal of Educational…•2003

  • Knowledge Building in Discourse Communities

    Open Access•Ellice Ann Forman•Human Development•2000

  • Dialogue in the Classroom

    Gordon Wells, Alex Wells et al.•Journal of the Learning Sciences•2006

  • The classroom environment and students' reports of avoidance strategies in mathematics

    Julianne C Turner, Carol Midgley et al.•Journal of Educational Psychology•2002

  • Reconstructing Mathematics Pedagogy from a Constructivist Perspective

    Martin A Simon•Journal for Research in…•1995

  • Sociomathematical Norms, Argumentation, and Autonomy in Mathematics

    Erna Yackel, Paul Cobb•Journal for Research in…•1996

  • Personal Epistemology Research

    Open Access•Barbara K Hofer•Educational Psychology Review•2001

  • Constructing competence

    Open Access•Melissa Gresalfi, Taylor Martin et al.•Educational Studies in Mathematics•2009

  • The Development of Epistemological Theories

    Open Access•Barbara K Hofer, Paul R Pintrich•Review of Educational Research•1997

  • Learning to Think Mathematically

    Open Access•Alan H Schoenfeld•Journal of Education•2016

  • Cognition and Policy Implementation

    James P Spillane•Cognition and Instruction•2000

  • Learning to argue

    Open Access•Jonathan Osborne, Shirley Simon et al.•Journal of Research in Science…•2013

  • Social Constructivist Perspectives on Teaching and Learning

    A Sullivan Palincsar, Javier Mozas Lérida et al.•Annual Review of Psychology•1998

  • Identity, Goals, and Learning

    Na’ilah Suad Nasir, Na'Ilah Suad Nasir•Mathematical Thinking and Learning•2002

  • Guiding Principles for Fostering Productive Disciplinary Engagement

    Randi A Engle, Faith R Conant•Cognition and Instruction•2002

  • A Situated and Sociocultural Perspective on Bilingual Mathematics Learners

    Judit Moschkovich•Mathematical Thinking and Learning•2002

  • Policy Implementation and Cognition

    Open Access•James P Spillane, Brian J Reiser et al.•Review of Educational Research•2002

  • Dimensionality and Disciplinary Differences in Personal Epistemology

    Open Access•Barbara K Hofer•Contemporary Educational Psychology•2000

  • Toward a Theory of Teacher Community

    Open Access•Pamela Grossman, Sam Wineburg et al.•Teachers College Record The Voice…•2001

  • Orchestrating Productive Mathematical Discussions

    Mary Kay Stein, Randi A Engle et al.•Mathematical Thinking and Learning•2008

  • A conceptualization of the teaching practice of building

    Open Access•Shari L Stockero, Blake E Peterson et al.•Journal of Mathematics Teacher…•2026

  • Proposing an alternative direction for the development of research

    Open Access•Yusuke Uegatani, Ippo Ishibashi•Mathematical Thinking and Learning•2026

  • Understanding teaching behavior through a theoretical perspective of teacher conception

    Open Access•Fangchun Zhu, Binyan Xu•Frontiers in Education•2023

  • “I learned more, but it was very hard

    Open Access•Emily J Yanisko, Rachel McClam et al.•Frontiers in Education•2026

  • Responsiveness and intellectual work

    Jessica Pierson Bishop•Journal of the Learning Sciences•2021

  • The “tricky business” of genre blending

    Panchompoo Wisittanawat, Melissa Gresalfi•Journal of the Learning Sciences•2021

  • Enhancing students' metacognition, achievement and transfer between domains

    Open Access•Orna Heaysman, Bracha Kramarski•International Journal of…•2022

  • Examining discourse structures in Chinese and U.S. elementary mathematics classes

    Open Access•Shuai Wang, Michelle Perry et al.•International Journal of…•2020

  • Successful Black Mathematics Teachers Building Collectivity, Autonomy, and Mathematics Expertise of Their Black Girls

    Open Access•Brittany L Marshall, Aziel O Rosado et al.•Teachers College Record The Voice…•2022

  • Initial Steps in Developing Classroom Observation Rubrics Designed Around Instructional Practices that Support Equity and Access in Classrooms with Potential for “Success”

    Open Access•Jonee Wilson•Teachers College Record The Voice…•2022

  • Contrastive Approaches to the Dynamic Nature of the Teacher’s Definition From the Diachronic Perspective

    Open Access•Adam Świątek•Roczniki Humanistyczne•2025

  • Stimulus Control for Making Math Verbal

    Open Access•Yifei Sun, R Douglas Greer•The Psychological Record•2023

  • What is Ambitious (Mathematics) Teaching? Clarifying a Key Concept in Education Research and Practice

    Open Access•William Zahner, Kristin Tenney et al.•Journal of Education•2025

  • Principles for the design of a fully-resourced, coherent, research-informed school mathematics curriculum

    Open Access•Colin Foster, Tom Francome et al.•Journal of Curriculum Studies•2021

  • Principals’ conceptions of mathematics instruction

    Open Access•Christina Kimmerling, Patricia Fuentes Acevedo et al.•Journal of Curriculum Studies•2025

  • Hybrid teaching intelligence

    Open Access•Giulia Cosentino, Jacqueline Anton et al.•British Journal of Educational…•2025

  • Teacher support and learning engagement

    Open Access•Meiping Chen, Zhongyan Xu et al.•Acta Psychologica•2026

  • (Re)Framing Educational Possibility

    Open Access•Victoria Hand, W R Penuel et al.•Human Development•2012

  • When the student is the ‘problem’ and the teacher is not the solution

    Open Access•Aliza Segal•Learning Culture and Social…•2022

  • Analyzing the effects of mathematical discourse-based instruction on eleventh-grade students’ procedural and conceptual understanding of probability and statistics

    Open Access•Mekonnen Legesse, Mekonnen Yimam Legesse et al.•Studies In Educational Evaluation•2020

  • Lernwege und Aneignungsformen im Sachunterricht

    Open Access•null :null, Anny Friedrich et al.•Lernwege und Aneignungsformen im…•2003

  • Mathematics and the Body

    Open Access•E De Freitas, Nathalie Sinclair•Mathematics and the Body•2014

  • Teacher pedagogical constructions

    Maher Z Hashweh•Teachers and Teaching•2005

  • Toward a Theory of Teacher Community

    Open Access•Pamela Grossman, Sam Wineburg et al.•Teachers College Record The Voice…•2001

  • Social Influences on the Development of Children's Adaptive Help Seeking

    Open Access•Richard Newman, Richard S Newman•Developmental Review•2000

  • But What Does it Look Like in Maths

    Open Access•A Marshall, Samantha Marshall•International Journal of…•2023

  • Positioning Students as Actors and Authors

    Raymond Brown, Raymond Albert Joseph Brown et al.•Mind Culture and Activity•2006

  • “It’s Understandable Enough, Right?” The Natural Accountability of a Mathematics Lesson

    Timothy Koschmann, Joyce Mori et al.•Mind Culture and Activity•2016

  • Cognition as Communication

    A Sfard, Carolyn Kieran•Mind Culture and Activity•2001

  • Learning as a Prosaic Act

    Deborah Hicks•Mind Culture and Activity•1996

  • Authentic activity and learning

    Elizabeth Clayden, Charles Desforges et al.•British Journal of Educational…•1994

  • Crenças epistêmicas em mudança? Um estudo investigativo do conhecimento entre futuros professores de história

    Open Access•Bruce A Vansledright, Kimberly Reddy•Revista Tempo e Argumento•2014

  • Changing epistemic beliefs? An exploratory study of cognition among prospective history teacher

    Open Access•Bruce A Vansledright, Kimberly Reddy•Revista Tempo e Argumento•2014

  • Millennial teachers and multiculturalism

    Open Access•Heidi L Hallman•Journal for Multicultural Education•2017

  • Dialogue in the elementary school mathematics classroom

    Open Access•Qiong Li, Yujing Ni•Frontiers of Education in China•2009

  • Exploring Relationship between Teaching Practice and Student Learning

    Jian Wang•Frontiers of Education in China•2014

  • Students? knowledge about the value of discussions for teaching and learning

    Open Access•Helen Askell‐Williams, Michael J Lawson•Social Psychology of Education•2005

  • Understanding conditions leading to student gestures during fractions lessons

    Open Access•Tiffany Reyes-Denis, Michelle Perry•Gesture•2024

  • Development of Mathematical Communication in Problem Solving Groups By Language Minority Students

    Mary E Brenner•Bilingual Research Journal•1998

  • Bilingual Students' Articulation and Gesticulation of Mathematical Knowledge During Problem Solving

    Higinio Domínguez•Bilingual Research Journal•2005

  • Retombées collatérales d’un Teaching Experiment

    Open Access•Jérôme Proulx, Charlotte Mégrourèche•Canadian Journal of Science…•2021

  • Point de vue sur une perspective canadienne en didactique des mathématiques

    Open Access•Jérôme Proulx•Canadian Journal of Science…•2020

  • Emergence of Uncertainties and Mathematical Problems Through Collective Investigation on Routine Tasks

    Open Access•Geneviève Barabé•Canadian Journal of Science…•2023

  • Understanding Students’ Experiences as Listeners During Mathematical Discussion

    Allison Hintz•Canadian Journal of Science…•2011

  • Faire vivre une formation à l’enseignement des mathématiques par résolution de problèmes

    Open Access•Jérôme Proulx•Canadian Journal of Science…•2019

  • Can We Engage Students in Authentic Mathematical Activity While Embracing Critical Pedagogy? A Commentary on the Tensions Between Disciplinary Activity and Critical Education

    Open Access•Keith Weber, Kathleen Melhuish•Canadian Journal of Science…•2022

  • Uses of video in social research

    Frederick Erickson•International Journal of Social…•2011

  • Developing mathematical thinking skills of preservice mathematics teachers in the problem-solving process

    Hülya Yıldızlı, Pınar Guner•Innovation The European Journal…•2025

  • Educational Sciences

    Open Access•E De Corte•European Review•2018

  • Addressing Horizontal and Vertical Gaps in Educational Systems

    Open Access•Alan H Schoenfeld•European Review•2020

  • Ventriloquating the Meanings of Mathematics

    Elizabeth Graue, Stephanie Z Smith•Curriculum Studies•1996

  • Adapting scientific modeling practice for promoting elementary students’ productive disciplinary engagement

    Tingting Li, Emily Adah Miller et al.•International Journal of Science…•2024

  • Régulations interactives situées dans des dynamiques de microculture de classe

    Open Access•Lucie Mottier Lopez•Mesure et évaluation en éducation•2007

  • Interroger la pratique du portfolio en situation scolaire dans une perspective « située » de l’apprentissage

    Open Access•Lucie Mottier Lopez•Mesure et évaluation en éducation•2006

  • Teaching and Learning Chinese

    Xiao Lan Curdt-Christiansen•Language Culture and Curriculum•2006

  • Ambitious instruction and student achievement

    Open Access•Jihyun Kim, Serena J Salloum et al.•Teaching and Teacher Education•2022

  • Why are you talking when you could be listening? The role of discourse and reflection in the professional development of a secondary mathematics teacher

    Open Access•Dominic Peressini, Dominic D Peressini et al.•Teaching and Teacher Education•1998

  • Elementary teachers' conceptualizations of classroom discussions across content areas

    Open Access•Sarah Schneider Kavanagh, Sam Prough et al.•Teaching and Teacher Education•2025

  • Varieties of wisdom in the practice of teachers

    Open Access•Allan Feldman•Teaching and Teacher Education•1997

  • Learning a new curricular approach

    Open Access•Inez Rovegno•Teaching and Teacher Education•1992

  • Working with learners’ mathematical thinking

    Open Access•Karin Brodie•Teaching and Teacher Education•2010

  • Assessment of teaching and learning in “literature-based” classrooms

    Open Access•Peter H Johnston, Peter Johnston et al.•Teaching and Teacher Education•1995

  • How do teachers reason about their practice? Representing the epistemic nature of teachers’ practical knowledge

    Open Access•Khalil Gholami, Jukka Husu•Teaching and Teacher Education•2010

  • Pre-service teachers learning mathematics using calculators

    Open Access•Sharon B Walen, Steven R Williams et al.•Teaching and Teacher Education•2003

  • Change in beliefs after first-year of teaching

    Open Access•Çiğdem Haser, Jon R Star•International Journal of…•2008

  • Pointing the Way

    Vicki Ross•Curriculum Inquiry•2005

  • Historical Understanding among Adolescents in a Multicultural Setting

    Peter Seixas•Curriculum Inquiry•1993

  • Curriculum Materials in Mathematics Education Reform

    Janine T Remillard•Curriculum Inquiry•1999

  • Theories and Practices of Thinking and Learning to Think

    James G Greeno•American Journal of Education•1997

  • Music Teacher Knowledge

    Open Access•Sommer H Forrester•Journal of Research in Music…•2017

  • The Teacher Research Movement

    Marilyn Cochran‐smith, Marilyn Cochran-Smith et al.•Educational Researcher•1999

  • Not Tension but Intention

    Open Access•Suzanne M Wilson•Educational Researcher•1995

  • The situativity of knowing, learning, and research

    James G Greeno•American Psychologist•1998

  • Supporting Sustainability

    Cynthia E Coburn, Jennifer Russell et al.•American Journal of Education•2012

  • Talk About Evidence During Argumentation

    Yuchen Shi•Discourse Processes•2020

  • Beyond the Looking Glass

    Marcy Singer Gabella•Theory & Research in Social…•1994

  • What Counts and How

    Open Access•Melisa Cahnmann‐taylor, Melisa S Cahnmann et al.•The Urban Review•2002

  • Does Biliteracy + Mathematical Discourse = Binumerate Development? Language Use in a Middle School Dual-Language Mathematics Classroom

    Open Access•Eliane Rubinstein‐avila, Eliane Rubinstein-Avila et al.•Urban Education•2015

  • Proofs and Refutations

    Open Access•Imre Lakatos, John Worrall et al.•Proofs and Refutations•1976

  • How Do Teachers Manage to Teach? Perspectives on Problems in Practice

    Magdalene Lampert•Harvard Educational Review•1985

  • Reciprocal Teaching of Comprehension-Fostering and Comprehension-Monitoring Activities

    Aannemarie Sullivan Palinscar, Ann L Brown•Cognition and Instruction•1984

  • The Interpretation of Cultures

    Clifford Geertz•The Interpretation of Cultures•1973

  • The Philosophy of Symbolic Forms

    Ernst Cassirer, Charles W Hendel et al.•The Philosophy of Symbolic Forms•2021

  • The Philosophy Of Symbolic Forms

    Deniz Coskun•Law As Symbolic Form•2007

  • Learning Lessons

    Hugh Mehan•Learning Lessons•1979

  • Ethnography and Language in Educational Settings

    Wilfred B W Martin, Judith L Green et al.•Contemporary Sociology A Journal…•1983

  • Social Organizational Factors in Learning to Read

    Kathryn Hu‐pei Au, Kathryn Hu-Pei Au et al.•Reading Research Quarterly•1981

  • Philosophy and the Mirror of Nature

    Robert Greene, Richard Rorty•Modern Language Notes•1980

  • Educational theory, practical philosophy and action research

    John Elliott•British Journal of Educational…•1987

  • The Skill of Learning from Classroom Lessons

    Open Access•Gaea Leinhardt, Ralph T Putnam•American Educational Research…•1987

  • Knowledge and Teaching

    Lee S Shulman, LEE SHULMAN•Harvard Educational Review•1987

  • How Adequate are the Knowledge Base Frameworks in Teacher Education

    Open Access•Linda Valli, Alan R Tom•Journal of Teacher Education•1988

  • Philosophy and the Mirror of Nature

    Richard Rorty, David Bromwich et al.•Philosophy and the Mirror of Nature•2009

  • School Teacher

    Ronald G Corwin, Dan C Lortie•Social Forces•1976

  • Taught Cognitive learning in its Immediate Environments

    Open Access•Frederick Erickson•Anthropology & Education Quarterly•1982

Obras citantes distintas133
Citas por año4,03
Intervalo de citas1991 - 2026 (36)
Velocidad de citacióncurrent
Altamente citadoSí
Tipos de citaNeutras: 134
Ethnos_APP • Proyecto Open Source • Licencia MIT • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacidad y Cookies • Documentación de la API: api.ethnos.app/docs • Código de la API: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Código del Frontend: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae