Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Emotions in scientific practice

Bibliographic Data

ID11936780
AuthorsAnatoly Kozlov (0000-0003-0504-809X, Institut Jean Nicod (CNRS-EHESS-ENS), Paris, France, corresponding author)
Year2023
Volume48
Issue2
Pages329-348
Publication date2023-04-03
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessNo
TypeARTICLE
VenueInterdisciplinary Science Reviews (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0308-0188 • E-ISSN: 1743-2790
PublisherTaylor & Francis (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1080/03080188.2023.2193073
OpenAlexW4366983062
LanguageEN
Citations received4
References cited121

For a long time, emotions were seen as incompatible with rationality and objectivity of science, and so were a marginal topic in the philosophy of science. This trend has changed progressively since it was determined that objectivity is much linked to social factors while rationality can’t do without emotions. As a result, emotions are now slowly finding their way into our understanding of what science is. Here, I make an overview of some aspects of science where emotions and scientific reasoning seem to come into tight contact. For my survey, I will consider such themes as scientific motivation, scientific evaluations, scientific explanations, scientific understanding, scientific imagination, and coherence in science. Using these examples, I discuss the epistemic role of emotions in scientific progress. In conclusion, I advocate for a nuanced view of emotions in science as values that contribute to both epistemic and humanistic dimensions of science

Cognitive science · Epistemology · Sociology · Empathy and Medical Education · Interdisciplinary Research and Collaboration · Philosophy · Philosophy and History of Science · Psychology

  • Surprise in Science

    Open Access•Milena Ivanova, Brandon Vaidyanathan•Erkenntnis•2026

  • From situated knowledges to situated modelling

    Open Access•Anja Klein, Krystin Unverzagt et al.•Ecosystems and People•2024

  • Scientific experimental articles are modernist stories

    Open Access•Anatoly Kozlov, Michael T Stuart•European Journal for Philosophy…•2024

  • Losing glaciers

    Open Access•Marzia Varutti, Mauro Gobbi et al.•The Anthropocene Review•2025

  • The Routledge Companion to Thought Experiments

    Joerg H Y Fehige, Michael T Stuart et al.•Routledge Companion to Thought…•2017

  • Explanation and Cognition

    R A Wilson, Robert Anton Wilson et al.•Explanation and Cognition•2000

  • How the Laws of Physics Lie

    Nancy Cartwright•How the laws of physics lie•1983

  • The Value of Knowledge and the Pursuit of Understanding

    Open Access•Jonathan L Kvanvig•Value of Knowledge and the…•2003

  • Models as Mediators

    Open Access•Mary S Morgan, Margaret Morrison•Models as Mediators•1999

  • Virtues of the Mind

    Open Access•Linda Trinkaus Zagzebski, Linda Zagzebski•Virtues of the Mind•1996

  • Understanding, Explanation, and Scientific Knowledge

    Kareem Khalifa•Understanding, Explanation, and…•2017

  • Understanding Scientific Understanding

    Henk W De Regt•Understanding Scientific…•2017

  • Idealization and the Aims of Science

    Angela Potochnik•Idealization and the Aims of…•2017

  • The Epistemic Benefit of Transient Diversity

    Open Access•Kevin J S Zollman•Erkenntnis•2010

  • Understanding and the facts

    Open Access•Catherine Z Elgin, Catherine Elgin•Philosophical Studies•2007

  • Recovering Understanding

    Linda Zagzebski•Knowledge, truth, and duty•2001

  • Experiments versus models

    Michael S Morgan, Mary S Morgan•Journal of Economic Methodology•2005

  • The Routledge Handbook of Philosophy of Imagination

    Guy Fletcher, Amy Kind•Routledge Handbook of Philosophy…•2016

  • Proper Functionalism and Virtue Epistemology

    Ernest Sosa, Alvin Plantinga•Noûs•1993

  • The heuristics theory of emotions and moderate rationalism

    Open Access•András Szigeti•Philosophical Psychology•2024

  • What is a Beautiful Experiment

    Open Access•Milena Ivanova•Erkenntnis•2023

  • Philosophy of Science after Feminism

    Janet A Kourany•Philosophy of science after…•2010

  • Passionate Minds

    Lewis Wolpert, Alison Richards•Passionate minds•1997

  • Narrative Science

    Open Access•Michael S Morgan, John E Huss et al.•Narrative Science•2022

  • Probing novelty at the LHC

    Open Access•Sophie Ritson•Studies in History and Philosophy…•2020

  • Are awe‐prone people more curious? The relationship between dispositional awe, curiosity, and academic outcomes

    Open Access•C Leroy Anderson, Dante D Dixson et al.•Journal of Personality•2020

  • The Essential Tension

    Thomas S Kuhn, Thomas Kühn•The Essential Tension•1977

  • What are narratives good for

    Open Access•John Beatty•Studies in History and Philosophy…•2016

  • Integrating data to acquire new knowledge

    Open Access•Sabina Leonelli•Studies in History and Philosophy…•2013

  • Uses of Value Judgments in Science

    Open Access•Elizabeth Anderson•Hypatia•2004

  • Emotions in knowledge production

    Laura Candiotto•Interdisciplinary Science Reviews•2023

  • Rescuing Objectivity

    Open Access•Jack Wright•Philosophy of the Social Sciences•2018

  • Understanding as representation manipulability

    Open Access•Daniel A Wilkenfeld•Synthese•2013

  • A Contextual Approach to Scientific Understanding

    Open Access•Henk W De Regt, Dennis Dieks•Synthese•2005

  • Imagination and insight

    Open Access•LETITIA MEYNELL•Synthese•2014

  • Structural representation and surrogative reasoning

    Open Access•Chris Swoyer•Synthese•1991

  • Towards a dual process epistemology of imagination

    Open Access•Michael T Stuart•Synthese•2021

  • Poincaré’s aesthetics of science

    Open Access•Milena Ivanova•Synthese•2017

  • Taming theory with thought experiments

    Open Access•Michael T Stuart•Studies in History and Philosophy…•2016

  • Theories that narrate the world

    Open Access•Alirio Rosales•Studies in History and Philosophy…•2017

  • Narrative science and narrative knowing. Introduction to special issue on narrative science

    Open Access•Mary S Morgan, M Norton Wise•Studies in History and Philosophy…•2017

  • Subjectivity and emotion in scientific research

    Jeff Kochan•Studies in History and Philosophy…•2013

  • Narrative ordering and explanation

    Open Access•Mary S Morgan•Studies in History and Philosophy…•2017

  • The material theory of induction and the epistemology of thought experiments

    Open Access•Michael T Stuart•Studies in History and Philosophy…•2020

  • In defence of story-telling

    Open Access•Adrian Currie, Kim Sterelny•Studies in History and Philosophy…•2017

  • Existential risk, creativity & well-adapted science

    Open Access•Adrian Currie•Studies in History and Philosophy…•2019

  • Imagination and Imaging in Model Building

    Open Access•Michael S Morgan, Mary S Morgan•Philosophy of Science•2004

  • Scientific Explanation and the Sense of Understanding

    Open Access•J D Trout•Philosophy of Science•2002

  • Toward a Pluralist Account of the Imagination in Science

    Open Access•A Murphy•Philosophy of Science•2020

  • Form and Content

    Open Access•A Murphy•Philosophy of Science•2023

  • What Counts as Scientific Data? A Relational Framework

    Open Access•Sabina Leonelli•Philosophy of Science•2015

  • Abstraction and the Organization of Mechanisms

    Open Access•Arnon Levy, William Bechtel•Philosophy of Science•2013

  • On Thought Experiments

    Open Access•John D Norton•Philosophy of Science•2004

  • The Roles of Possibility and Mechanism in Narrative Explanation

    Open Access•Daniel Swaim, Daniel G Swaim•Philosophy of Science•2019

  • The Productive Anarchy of Scientific Imagination

    Open Access•Michael T Stuart•Philosophy of Science•2020

  • Narrative Explanation

    J David Velleman•The Philosophical Review•2003

  • Beauty and Revolution in Science

    J D Trout, James W Mcallister•The Philosophical Review•1998

  • The epistemic imagination revisited

    Open Access•Olof Kinberg, Arnon Levy•Philosophy and Phenomenological…•2022

  • Two Kinds of Intellectual Virtue

    John Greco, Linda Zagzebski•Philosophy and Phenomenological…•2000

  • Epistemic Engagement, Aesthetic Value, and Scientific Practice

    Adrian Currie•The British Journal for the…•2023

  • Defending a Risk Account of Scientific Objectivity

    Open Access•Ilpo Koskinen, Inkeri Koskinen•The British Journal for the…•2020

  • The Fate of Knowledge

    Helen E Longino•Fate of Knowledge•2002

  • Explanation and Understanding

    Frank C Keil•Annual Review of Psychology•2005

  • The Value of Surprise in Science

    Open Access•Steven French, A Murphy•Erkenntnis•2021

  • Love and knowledge

    Alison M Jaggar•Inquiry•1989

  • The Psychology of Scientific Explanation

    Open Access•J D Trout•Philosophy Compass•2007

  • Aesthetic values in science

    Open Access•Milena Ivanova•Philosophy Compass•2017

  • One Imagination in Experiences of Beauty and Achievements of Understanding

    Open Access•Angela Breitenbach•The British Journal of Aesthetics•2020

  • Imagination in science

    Open Access•A Murphy•Philosophy Compass•2022

  • The Structure of Scientific Revolutions

    Thomas S Kuhn, Dennis Holland et al.•La Structure des révolutions…•2012

Unique citing works4
Citations per year2
Citation span2024 - 2026 (3)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 4

Tools

Open DOI
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae