Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Democratising sustainability transformations

Assessing the transformative potential of democratic practices in environmental governance

Bibliographic Data

ID13129155
AuthorsJeffrey Pickering (0000-0002-1862-3623, University of Canberra), Thomas Hickmann (0000-0001-5072-7855, Lund University, corresponding author), Karin Bäckstrand (0000-0002-8608-8888, Stockholm University), Agni Kalfagianni (0000-0003-3568-8012, Utrecht University), Michael Bloomfield (0000-0002-3381-2756, Centre For Development Studies), Ayşem Mert (0000-0002-5105-1540, University of Duisburg-Essen), Hedda Ransan-Cooper (0000-0002-9053-0229, Australian National University), Alex Y Lo (0000-0002-5953-4176, Victoria University of Wellington)
Year2022
Volume11
Pages100131-100131
Publication date2022-01-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueEarth System Governance (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 2589-8116 • E-ISSN: 2589-8116
PublisherElsevier BV (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1016/j.esg.2021.100131
OpenAlexW4205298166
LanguageEN
Citations received51
References cited147

Many democracies find it difficult to act swiftly on problems such as climate change and biodiversity loss. This is reflected in long-standing debates in research and policy about whether democratic practices are capable of fostering timely, large-scale transformations towards sustainability. Drawing on an integrative review of scholarly literature from 2011 to early 2021 on sustainability transformations and the democracy-environment nexus, this article synthesises existing research on prospects and pitfalls for democratising sustainability transformations. We advance a new typology for understanding various combinations of democratic/authoritarian practices and of transformations towards/away from sustainability. We then explore the role of democratic practices in accelerating or obstructing five key dimensions of sustainability transformations: institutional, social, economic, technological, and epistemic. Across all dimensions we find substantial evidence that democratic practices can foster transformations towards sustainability, and we conclude by outlining a set of associated policy recommendations

Authoritarianism · Bureaucracy · Corporate governance · Democracy · Economics · Environmental ethics · Management · Nexus (standard · Political science · Politics · Social sustainability · Sociology · Sustainability · Transformative learning · Typology · Engineering · Environmental Education and Sustainability · Environmental Sustainability in Business · Sustainability and Climate Change Governance · Ecology

  • Toward a post-carbon society

    Open Access•Gustav Osberg, Mine Islar et al.•Conservation Ecology•2024

  • The Green New Deal

    Open Access•Donal Brown, Marie Claire Brisbois et al.•Ecological Economics•2023

  • Energías renovables

    Open Access•ÁNGELA MARÍA JIMENA JIMÉNEZ-GARCÍA, Felipe Calderón-Valencia•Revista iberoamericana de…•2025

  • Policymakers' Perceptions of the Use of Deliberative Mini‐Publics to Support Sustainability Policies

    Open Access•Heli Saarikoski, Maria Ojanen et al.•Environmental Policy and Governance•2026

  • Eco‐Guilt and Eco‐Shame in Translating Green Messaging to Sustainable Action

    Open Access•Fengjuan Kou, Sushant Kumar Vishnoi et al.•Business Strategy and the…•2026

  • Sustainable futures

    Open Access•Inês Campos, João Paulo Limão et al.•Humanities and Social Sciences…•2025

  • Political-economic transformation and the reproduction of climate change vulnerability of a high-income city

    Open Access•Alex Y Lo, Shuwen Liu et al.•International Journal of Disaster…•2024

  • Carving space to learn for sustainable futures

    Open Access•Diana Holmqvist, Filippa Millenberg•European Journal for Research on…•2024

  • Towards a transformative governance of the Amazon

    Open Access•Joana Castro Pereira, João Terrenas•Global Policy•2022

  • Making the UNFCCC fit for purpose

    Open Access•Naghmeh Nasiritousi, Alexandra Buylova et al.•Global Policy•2024

  • Sustainability transformation calls for complexity-informed systemic policy design

    Open Access•Harri Jalonen, Petri Uusikylä•Public Management Review•2025

  • Why firms do not expect climate policies to have the intended effects – positioning in a polycentric governance landscape

    Open Access•Kajsa-Stina Benulic, Cecilia Enberg et al.•Journal of Environmental Planning…•2025

  • Beyond Statism and Deliberation

    Open Access•Jacob Smessaert, Giuseppe Feola•Environmental Values•2023

  • Tracing tacit knowledge of polity research

    Open Access•Krzysztof Kasianiuk•Quality & Quantity•2023

  • Design-driven citizen participation towards 1.5-degree planetary diets

    Open Access•Radhika Motani, Mikko Jalas et al.•British Food Journal•2025

  • What constitutes sustainable agriculture for different audiences in Germany? A comparative analysis of large‐scale text data

    Open Access•B Bartkowski, Marieke Cornelia Baaken et al.•People and Nature•2025

  • Can democratic innovations tackle social-ecological challenges? Gaining insights on transformative governance across European cases

    Open Access•José Duarte Ribeiro, Jill Moniz et al.•Socio-Ecological Practice Research•2025

  • What roles can democracy labs play in co-creating democratic innovations for sustainability

    Open Access•Inês Campos, Doris Fuchs et al.•Socio-Ecological Practice Research•2024

  • What Determines Country‐Level ESG Performance

    Open Access•Orkun Bayram, Mete Feridun•Journal of International…•2026

  • Impact of democracy on economic, human, and societal development

    Open Access•Staffan I I Lindberg, Martin Lundstedt et al.•Humanities and Social Sciences…•2026

  • Environmental democracy

    Open Access•Claudia Ituarte‐Lima, RADU MARES•Earth System Governance•2024

  • More than policy neutral

    Open Access•N Wagner, Simo Sarkki et al.•Earth System Governance•2024

  • Slippery pathways to socio-ecological utopias of community gardening

    Dorota Rancew-Sikora, Anna Horolets et al.•Environmental Sociology•2025

  • Inequality determined social outcomes of low-carbon transition policies

    Open Access•Chandni Dwarkasing•Energy Research & Social Science•2023

  • Enabling a just energy transition through solidarity in research

    Open Access•Sareen, Benjamin Girard et al.•Energy Research & Social Science•2023

  • Disrupting to decarbonise socio-energy systems

    Open Access•Marco Grasso, Daniel Delatin Rodrigues•Energy Research & Social Science•2022

  • Understanding the governance of sustainability pathways

    Open Access•Pablo F Méndez, Floriane Clement et al.•Sustainability Science•2022

  • Identifying mindsets for urban sustainability transformation

    Open Access•Flávia Guerra, Maryiam Syed•Sustainability Science•2023

  • What role for deliberative minipublics in sustainability transformations? An emerging topic for sustainability science

    Open Access•Tim M Daw, West et al.•Sustainability Science•2026

  • Making sense of power through transdisciplinary sustainability research

    Open Access•Tessa De Geus, Flor Avelino et al.•Sustainability Science•2023

  • Anticipating the Challenges of AI in Climate Governance

    Open Access•Ruth Machen, Warren Pearce•Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews…•2025

  • Can democracy accelerate sustainability transformations? Policy coherence for participatory co-existence

    Open Access•Jeffrey Pickering•International Environmental…•2023

  • Localising and democratising goal-based governance for sustainability

    Open Access•Elliot Honeybun-Arnolda, Rachel A Turner et al.•Environmental Science & Policy•2023

  • What do you mean 'Climate Change'? An analysis of climate change framings in three climate assemblies

    Open Access•Corinna Zeitfogel, Tim Daw et al.•Environmental Science & Policy•2024

  • Co-producing ‘The Future(s) We Want’

    Open Access•Tatiana Sokolova•Environmental Science & Policy•2023

  • Governance innovations in the coastal zone

    Open Access•Carmen E Elrick‐barr, Carmen E Elrick-Barr et al.•Environmental Science & Policy•2024

  • Navigating a changing Arctic

    Open Access•Anna G Sveinsdóttir, C Ren et al.•Tourism Geographies•2025

  • Examining the Impact of Environmental Knowingness and Orientation on Environmental Performance

    Open Access•Madiha Shafique Dar, Hadi Hassan Khan et al.•SAGE Open•2025

  • How green is my party? Programmatic stances towards environmental protection in Europe

    Open Access•Anna Grzymala-Busse, Piotr Jabkowski et al.•Party Politics•2025

  • A systematic literature review of the relationship between the rule of law and environmental sustainability

    Open Access•Nausheen Atta, A Sharifi•Sustainable Development•2024

  • Media Reform as Transformation Tool

    Open Access•Myanna Lahsen•International Journal of Politics…•2024

  • Democracy and the European Green Deal

    Open Access•Aron Buzogány, Laura Parks et al.•Journal of European Integration•2025

  • Democracy and the implementation of the European Green Deal

    Open Access•Karin Bäckstrand•Journal of European Integration•2025

  • Post-conventional anthropology

    Open Access•A Kearney•Hau Journal of Ethnographic Theory•2025

  • Reform or transform? A spectrum of stances towards the economic status quo within ‘new economics’ discourses

    Open Access•Sam J Buckton, Jasper O Kenter et al.•Global Social Challenges Journal•2024

  • Stalling, straining, severing, shallowing, simulating

    Open Access•Basil Bornemann, Holger Strassheim et al.•Frontiers in Political Science•2025

  • Environmental justice in conservation philanthropy

    Open Access•Jeffrey E Blackwatters, Michele M Betsill et al.•Earth System Governance•2024

  • Exporting environmental democracy to international forums

    Open Access•Nicola Sharman•AMBIO•2025

  • People’s voices for sustainability – Exploring expectations for participatory democratic practices in Europe

    Open Access•Inês Campos, Petteri Repo et al.•Futures•2026

  • Multi-Agent Ethnography

    M Artz•Anthropological Forum•2026

  • Influencing climate change adaptation in authoritarian states

    Open Access•Wendy Conway-Lamb•Environmental Politics•2025

  • Staying alive

    Vandana Shiva•Staying alive•2010

  • Policy

    Open Access•Måns Nilsson, David Grigg et al.•Nature•2016

  • The importance of social relations in shaping energy demand

    Open Access•Tom Hargreaves, Lucie Middlemi•Nature Energy•2020

  • Buen Vivir, Degrowth and Ecological Swaraj

    Open Access•Ashish Kothari, Federico Demaria et al.•Development•2014

  • The politics of sustainability transitions

    Open Access•Flor Avelino, J Grin et al.•Journal of Environmental Policy &…•2016

  • Defining Terms for Integrated (Multi-Inter-Trans-Disciplinary) Sustainability Research

    Open Access•Paul V Stock, Paul Stock et al.•Sustainability•2011

  • Sustainable development goals for people and planet

    Open Access•David Grigg, David Griggs et al.•Nature•2013

  • Transformative Environmental Governance

    Open Access•Brian C Chaffin, Ahjond S Garmestani et al.•Annual Review of Environment and…•2016

  • Between environmental and ecological democracy

    Open Access•Jeffrey Pickering, Karin Bäckstrand et al.•Journal of Environmental Policy &…•2020

  • A conceptual framework for understanding the social acceptance of energy infrastructure

    Open Access•Patrick Devine‐wright, Susana Batel et al.•Energy Policy•2017

  • Co-producing European climate science and policy

    Eva Lövbrand•Science and Public Policy•2011

  • Sustainability Transitions Research

    Open Access•Derk Loorbach, Derk A Loorbach et al.•Annual Review of Environment and…•2017

  • Trajectories of the Earth System in the Anthropocene

    Open Access•Will Steffen, Johan Rockström et al.•Proceedings of the National…•2018

  • Agricultural Cooperatives and Farm Sustainability – A Literature Review

    Open Access•Ahmet Candemir, Sabine Duvaleix‐Tréguer et al.•Journal of Economic Surveys•2021

  • Literature review as a research methodology

    Open Access•Hunter Snyder•Journal of Business Research•2019

  • Understanding carbon lock-in

    Open Access•Gregory C Unruh•Energy Policy•2000

  • A safe operating space for humanity

    Open Access•Johan Rockström, Will Steffen et al.•Nature•2009

  • Democratic Reason

    Open Access•Hélène Landemore•Democratic reason•2012

  • The Politics of Green Transformations

    Open Access•Macedward Leach, Melissa Leach et al.•Politics of Green Transformations•2015

  • Transforming Markets? Activists’ Strategic Orientations and Engagement With Private Governance

    Open Access•Graeme Auld•Organization & Environment•2018

  • The North–South Divide on Public Perceptions of Stratospheric Aerosol Geoengineering

    M Sugiyama, Shinichiro Asayama et al.•Environmental Communication•2020

  • The Life and Death of Democracy

    Paul Woodruff•First Democracy•2006

  • Down to Earth

    Bruno Latour, Caitlin Porter•Down to Earth•2018

  • Democracy and Climate Change

    Open Access•Frederic Hanusch•Democracy and Climate Change•2017

  • An Attempt at a “Compositionist Manifesto”

    Bruno Latour•New Literary History•2010

  • Public participation and climate change adaptation

    Roger Few, Katrina Brown et al.•Climate Policy•2007

  • Degrowth, Democracy and Autonomy

    Open Access•Viviana Asara, Emanuele Profumi et al.•Environmental Values•2013

  • Greening states and societies

    Open Access•Richard Eckersley, Robyn Eckersley•Environmental Politics•2021

  • Being Alive

    T Ingold•Being Alive•2021

  • NGOs, Ingos, and Environmental Policy Reform, 1970–2010

    Wesley Longhofer, Evan Schofer et al.•Social Forces•2016

  • The Climate Change Challenge and the Failure of Democracy

    David Shearman, Joseph Wayne Smith•The Climate Change Challenge and…•2007

  • Towards a Reflexive Turn in the Governance of Global Environmental Expertise. The Cases of the IPCC and the Ipbes

    Silke Beck, Maud Borie et al.•GAIA - Ecological Perspectives…•2014

  • Democracy and climate change policies

    Open Access•Per G Fredriksson, E Neumayer•Ecological Economics•2013

  • Beyond GDP

    Open Access•Ida Kubiszewski, R Costanza et al.•Ecological Economics•2013

  • Governance for achieving the Sustainable Development Goals

    Open Access•Lisa-Maria Glass, Jens Newig•Earth System Governance•2019

  • Leaving no one behind? The influence of civil society participation on the Sustainable Development Goals

    Open Access•Carole-Anne Sénit•Environment and Planning C…•2019

  • Participation and inclusiveness in the Intergovernmental Science–Policy Platform on Biodiversity and Ecosystem Services

    Open Access•Isabel Díaz‐reviriego, Esther Turnhout et al.•Nature Sustainability•2019

  • Democracy in a Global Emergency

    Open Access•Afsoun Afsahi, Emily Beausoleil et al.•Democratic Theory•2020

  • The influence of institutions, governance, and public opinion on the environment

    Open Access•Shouro Dasgupta, Enrica De Cian•Energy Research & Social Science•2018

  • Energy democracy

    Open Access•Mary Jean Burke, John C Stephens•Energy Research & Social Science•2017

  • Energy policy and research

    Open Access•Michael R Greenberg•Energy Research & Social Science•2014

  • Challenging obduracy

    Open Access•Tineke van der Schoor, Harro Van Lente et al.•Energy Research & Social Science•2016

  • The misallocation of climate research funding

    Open Access•Indra Overland, B K Sovacool•Energy Research & Social Science•2019

  • Just transitions

    Open Access•Sheila Jasanoff•Energy Research & Social Science•2017

  • Governing the dark side of renewable energy

    Open Access•Teresa Kramarz, Susan Park et al.•Energy Research & Social Science•2021

  • Deliberative Mini-Publics and the European Green Deal in Turbulent Times

    Open Access•Diarmuid Torney•Politics and Governance•2021

  • Does the Conceptualization and Measurement of Democracy Quality Matter in Comparative Climate Policy Research

    Open Access•Romy Escher, Melanie Walter-Rogg•Politics and Governance•2018

  • Knowledge politics and post-truth in climate denial

    Frank Fischer•Critical Policy Studies•2019

  • Transformations to sustainability

    Open Access•I Scoones, Andy Stirling et al.•Current Opinion in Environmental…•2020

  • Climate activism and its effects

    Open Access•Dana R Fisher, Sohana Nasrin•Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews…•2020

  • Promises and risks of nonstate action in climate and sustainability governance

    Open Access•Sander Chan, Idil Boran et al.•Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews…•2019

  • Designs on Nature

    Sambit Mallick•Asian journal of social science•2009

  • Rich man’s solution? Climate engineering discourses and the marginalization of the Global South

    Open Access•Felix Biermann, Ina Möller•International Environmental…•2019

  • New alliances in global environmental governance

    Open Access•Thomas Hickmann, Joshua Philipp Elsässer•International Environmental…•2020

  • Earth system governance

    Open Access•Felix Biermann, Michele M Betsill et al.•International Environmental…•2010

  • Hybrid governance mechanisms as political instruments

    Open Access•Ayşem Mert•International Environmental…•2013

  • Global labour unions and just transition to a green economy

    Open Access•D Stevis, Romain Felli•International Environmental…•2014

  • The impact of environmental interest groups in international negotiations

    Open Access•Tobias Böhmelt, Carola Betzold•International Environmental…•2012

  • Accountability in Global Environmental Governance

    Open Access•Teresa Kramarz, Susan Park•Global Environmental Politics•2016

  • Toward Environmental Democracy? Procedural Environmental Rights and Environmental Justice

    Joshua C Gellers, Christopher Jeffords•Global Environmental Politics•2018

  • Leaders and Laggards

    Paul Tobin•Global Environmental Politics•2017

  • All Hands on Deck”

    Thomas Hale•Global Environmental Politics•2016

  • Brokering Climate Action

    Barbara Saerbeck, Mareike Well et al.•Global Environmental Politics•2020

  • Populism and Environmental Performance

    Tobias Böhmelt•Global Environmental Politics•2021

  • Transparency in Global Environmental Governance

    Aarti Gupta•Global Environmental Politics•2010

  • Climate justice and sustained transnational mobilization

    Paul Almeida•Globalizations•2019

  • The labour–nature relationship

    D Stevis, D Uzzell et al.•Globalizations•2018

  • Reforming global climate governance in an age of bullshit

    Hayley Stevenson•Globalizations•2020

  • Opening up knowledge systems for better responses to global environmental change

    Open Access•Cornell, Frans Berkhout et al.•Environmental Science & Policy•2013

  • Reconfiguring environmental expertise

    Open Access•Sverker Sörlin•Environmental Science & Policy•2013

  • Global Production Networks and Activism

    Michael Bloomfield, Michael John Bloomfield•New Political Economy•2017

  • Emerging markets and private governance

    Philip Schleifer, Yixian Sun•Review of International Political…•2018

  • Do eco-labels prevent deforestation? Lessons from non-state market driven governance in the soy, palm oil, and cocoa sectors

    Open Access•Hamish Van Der Ven, Catherine Rothacker et al.•Global Environmental Change•2018

  • The effect of income on the energy mix

    Open Access•Esmeralda A Ramalho, Tiago Neves Sequeira et al.•Global Environmental Change•2018

  • Network analysis reveals open forums and echo chambers in social media discussions of climate change

    Open Access•H Williams, Hywel T P Williams et al.•Global Environmental Change•2015

  • Public values for energy system change

    Open Access•Christina Demski, Catherine Butler et al.•Global Environmental Change•2015

  • Processes of elite power and low-carbon pathways

    Open Access•B K Sovacool, L Baker et al.•Global Environmental Change•2019

  • Pluralising climate change solutions? Views held and voiced by participants at the international climate change negotiations

    Open Access•Naghmeh Nasiritousi, Mattias Hjerpe et al.•Ecological Economics•2014

  • Unpacking the unequal representation of Northern and Southern NGOs in international climate change politics

    Marika Gereke, Tanja Brühl•Third World Quarterly•2019

  • Release the Moths

    Helena Pedersen•Renaissance and Modern Studies•2011

  • National Institutions and Global Public Goods

    Open Access•Michèle B Bättig, Thomas Bernauer•International Organization•2009

  • Authoritarian environmentalism and China's response to climate change

    Bruce Gilley•Environmental Politics•2012

  • Cross-national variation in determinants of climate change concern

    Gregory B Lewis, Risa Palm et al.•Environmental Politics•2019

  • Trust gaps in energy transitions

    Open Access•Daphne Ngar‐yin Mah, Daphne Ngar-yin Mah et al.•Environmental Innovation and…•2021

  • Conceptualizing energy democracy

    Kacper Szulecki•Environmental Politics•2017

  • It Is All about Political Incentives

    Patrick Bayer, Johannes Urpelainen•The Journal of Politics•2016

  • Pathways to Implementation

    Open Access•Nicolas W Jager, Jens Newig et al.•Journal of Public Administration…•2020

  • V-Dem

    Open Access•Staffan I Lindberg, Michael Coppedge et al.•Journal of democracy•2014

  • The Wisdom of the Many in Global Governance

    Hayley Stevenson•International Studies Quarterly•2016

  • Democratic inclusiveness, climate policy outputs, and climate policy outcomes

    Tobias Böhmelt, Marit Böker et al.•Democratization•2016

  • Normative arguments for non-state actor participation in international policymaking processes

    Open Access•Naghmeh Nasiritousi, Mattias Hjerpe et al.•European Journal of International…•2016

  • Sustainability transitions and the state

    Open Access•Paul Johnstone, Phil Johnstone et al.•Environmental Innovation and…•2018

  • Comparing ecological sustainability in autocracies and democracies

    Stanley Wurster, Stefan Wurster•Contemporary Politics•2013

  • New directions in earth system governance research

    Open Access•Stuart Burch, Aarti Gupta et al.•Earth System Governance•2019

  • Global environmental change II

    Open Access•Karen O’brien•Progress in Human Geography•2011

  • Exploring the governance and politics of transformations towards sustainability

    Open Access•James Patterson, Karsten Schulz et al.•Environmental Innovation and…•2016

  • An agenda for sustainability transitions research

    Open Access•Jonathan Köhler, Frank W Geels et al.•Environmental Innovation and…•2019

  • Remaking Political Institutions

    Open Access•James Patterson, James J Patterson•Remaking Political Institutions•2020

  • Who speaks for the future of Earth? How critical social science can extend the conversation on the Anthropocene

    Open Access•Eva Lövbrand, Silke Beck et al.•Global Environmental Change•2015

  • The political economy of the 'just transition

    Open Access•Peter Newell, Dustin Mulvaney•Geographical Journal•2013

Unique citing works51
Citations per year12,75
Citation span2022 - 2026 (5)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 49

Tools

Open DOIOpen Access
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae