Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Reflective supervision and reflective practice in infant mental health

A scoping review of a diverse body of literature

Bibliographic Data

ID14636100
AuthorsMary Tobin (0009-0000-7367-4776, Department of Psychology University of Limerick & Health Service Executive Dublin Ireland, corresponding author), Samantha Carney (0000-0001-6151-7570, University of Limerick), Sile Carney (Department of Psychology University of Limerick & Health Service Executive Dublin Ireland), Elaine Rogers (Department of Psychology University of Limerick Limerick Ireland)
Year2024
Volume45
Issue1
Pages79-117
Publication date2024-01-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueInfant Mental Health Journal (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0163-9641 • E-ISSN: 1097-0355
PublisherWiley (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1002/imhj.22091
PMID38038186
OpenAlexW4389220637
LanguageEN
Citations received10
References cited65

Reflective practice is a core component of Infant Mental Health (IMH) training and work in the form of reflective supervision/consultation (RS/C). RS/C supports and facilitates relationship‐based practice, and is considered to help prevent burnout and promote work satisfaction. In response to an identified gap in empirical research on RS/C, this scoping review aimed to give an overview of the broad range of study designs and outcomes by systematically charting empirical studies on RS/C in IMH‐based work with children and families. Searches of Academic Search Complete, CINAHL, MEDLINE, APA PsychArticles, APA PsycInfo, and Web of Science were supplemented with a Google Scholar search and citation searching. Following title/abstract screening ( n = 233) and full‐text review ( n = 168), 35 reports met criteria for inclusion. Key findings were organized into four categories: Essential components and processes of RS/C ; Experiences and outcomes of RS/C ; Emerging issues in RS/C literature ; and Measuring, researching, and reporting on RS/C . Results describe the components and experience of engaging in quality RS/C, and show that practitioners generally experience RS/C as supportive and beneficial. The existing literature has some methodological limitations and further empirical research is needed on outcomes of RS/C. Practice implications and potential future research directions are discussed

Burnout · CINAHL · Citation · Empirical research · Library science · Medical education · MEDLINE · Mental health · Pedagogy · Political science · Psychological intervention · Psychotherapist · PsycINFO · Reflective Practice · Applied Psychology · Clinical Psychology · Computer Science · Counseling, Therapy, and Family Dynamics · Educational and Psychological Assessments · Family and Disability Support Research · Medicine · Nursing · Psychology · Social Psychology

  • The Trauma-Informed Attitudes and Practices of Early Childhood Special Education Teachers

    Open Access•Mia Chudzik, Catherine Corr et al.•Journal of Child & Adolescent…•2026

  • Early Childhood Teachers’ Experiences Partnering with Early Childhood Mental Health Consultants

    Open Access•Elizabeth A Steed, Rachel Stein et al.•Early Childhood Education Journal•2026

  • Evaluating the Implementation and Outcomes of a Community‐Based Doula Program in Washington State

    Open Access•Taylor Riley, Zeruiah V Buchanan et al.•Perspectives on Sexual and…•2025

  • You go in heavy and you come out light”

    Open Access•Mary Tobin, Nicola O’sullivan et al.•Infant Mental Health Journal•2024

  • Providers’ Perceptions of Trauma-Focused EBT/EBP Implementation Fidelity

    Open Access•Stephanie Gusler, Ginny Sprang et al.•Community Mental Health Journal•2025

  • Trauma‐informed care in early intervention

    Open Access•Crystal S Williams, Mia Chudzik et al.•Infant Mental Health Journal•2026

  • Holding up the mirror

    Open Access•Ruby Batz, Melissa C Walter et al.•Infant Mental Health Journal•2025

  • One state's journey with a reflective supervision professional development series

    Open Access•Rebecca B Silver, Christine M Low et al.•Infant Mental Health Journal•2025

  • What supervisors are saying and not saying about culture, privilege and equity in mental health settings

    Open Access•Barbara Stroud, Torrian Brent et al.•Infant Mental Health Journal•2026

  • Feasibility, Acceptability, and Preliminary Effectiveness of a Reflective Supervision Professional Development Series Within Early Care and Education

    Lindsay Huffhines, Rebecca B Silver et al.•Early Education and Development•2025

  • 'Scoping the scope' of a cochrane review

    Rebecca Armstrong, Belinda J Hall et al.•Journal of Public Health•2011

  • The PRISMA 2020 statement

    Open Access•Matthew J Page, Joanne E McKenzie et al.•International Journal of Surgery•2021

  • Scoping studies

    Open Access•Danielle Levac, Heather Colquhoun et al.•Implementation Science•2010

  • Methods for the thematic synthesis of qualitative research in systematic reviews

    Open Access•James Thomas, Angela Harden•BMC Medical Research Methodology•2008

  • Reflective Supervision/Consultation and Early Childhood Professionals’ Well-Being

    Amy Susman-Stillman, Stefanie Lim et al.•Early Education and Development•2020

  • The role of infant and early childhood mental health consultation in reducing racial and gender relational and discipline disparities between Black and white preschoolers

    Open Access•Eva Marie Shivers, Flora Farago et al.•Psychology in the Schools•2022

  • Shorter can Also be Better

    Open Access•Steven S Russell, Christiane Spitzmüller et al.•Educational and Psychological…•2004

  • The Mixed Methods Appraisal Tool (MMAT) version 2018 for information professionals and researchers

    Quan Nha Hong, Sergi Fàbregue et al.•Education for Information•2018

  • Evaluating the Facilitating Attuned Interactions (FAN) approach

    Open Access•Katherine P Hazen, Matthew W Carlson et al.•Children and Youth Services Review•2020

  • Is Reflective Supervision Enough? An Exploration of Workforce Perspectives

    Open Access•Tanika Eaves, Tanika Eaves Simpson et al.•Infant Mental Health Journal•2018

  • Release, Reframe, Refocus, and Respond

    Open Access•Mary Harrison•Infant Mental Health Journal•2016

  • Professional quality of life in home visitors

    Open Access•Tanika Eaves, JoAnn Robinson et al.•Infant Mental Health Journal•2022

  • The role of consultative alliance in infant and early childhood mental health consultation

    Open Access•Annie Davis Schoch, Sandra Barrueco et al.•Infant Mental Health Journal•2021

  • Taking care of the caregivers

    Open Access•Diana Morelen, Julia A Najm et al.•Infant Mental Health Journal•2022

  • A Community Mental Health Professional Development Model for the Expansion of Reflective Practice and Supervision

    Open Access•Sarah E Shea, Sheryl Goldberg et al.•Infant Mental Health Journal•2016

  • Transitions to virtual early childhood home visitation during Covid‐19

    Open Access•Dorian E Traube, Sharlene Gozalians et al.•Infant Mental Health Journal•2022

  • Perspectives on helping traumatized infants, young children, and their families

    Open Access•Joy D Osofsky•Infant Mental Health Journal•2009

  • Stress and coping among early childhood intervention professionals receiving reflective supervision

    Open Access•Cynthia A Frosch, Yolanda T Mitchell et al.•Infant Mental Health Journal•2019

  • The implementation of a multi‐level reflective consultation model in a statewide infant & early childcare education professional development system

    Open Access•Sarah E Shea, Kelly Sipotz et al.•Infant Mental Health Journal•2022

  • Creating a “Nest” of Emotional Safety

    Open Access•Michele Many, Michele M Many et al.•Infant Mental Health Journal•2016

  • Exploring a model for infant and early childhood mental health consultation in early childhood home visiting

    Open Access•Callie H Lambarth, Beth L Green•Infant Mental Health Journal•2019

  • Infant mental health home visiting therapists’ reflective supervision self‐efficacy in community practice settings

    Open Access•Sarah E Shea, Jennifer M Jester et al.•Infant Mental Health Journal•2020

  • Intersubjective Experience of the Infant and Early Childhood Mental Health Consultant–Program Administrator Consultee Relationship

    Open Access•Laura Mick DeNatale•Infant Mental Health Journal•2013

  • Reflecting Together

    Open Access•Mary Claire Heffron, Diane Reynolds et al.•Infant Mental Health Journal•2016

  • From the voices of supervisees

    Open Access•Carla C Barron, Carolyn J Dayton et al.•Infant Mental Health Journal•2022

  • Building Capacity in Reflective Practice

    Open Access•Christopher L Watson, Ann E Bailey et al.•Infant Mental Health Journal•2016

  • The Michigan infant mental health home visiting model

    Open Access•Deborah J Weatherston, Julie Ribaudo et al.•Infant Mental Health Journal•2020

  • Facilitating reflective supervision in an early child development center

    Open Access•Robert Newcomb Emde•Infant Mental Health Journal•2009

  • Early Childhood Mental Health Consultation

    Open Access•M Alexandra Vuyk, Jessica Sprague‐Jones et al.•Infant Mental Health Journal•2016

  • Measuring Reflective Supervision Within Home Visiting

    Open Access•Christine M Low, Rebecca Newland et al.•Infant Mental Health Journal•2018

  • Measuring the depth of reflection in reflective supervision/consultation sessions

    Open Access•Alyssa S Meuwissen, Christopher Watson et al.•Infant Mental Health Journal•2022

  • Observe, listen, wonder, and respond

    Open Access•Angela Tomlin, Angela M Tomlin et al.•Infant Mental Health Journal•2009

  • Impact of Reflective Supervision on Early Childhood Interventionists’ Perceptions of Self‐efficacy, Job Satisfaction, and Job Stress

    Open Access•Cynthia A Frosch, Zubeda Varwani et al.•Infant Mental Health Journal•2018

  • The significance of reflective supervision for infant mental health work

    Open Access•Patricia O'Rourke•Infant Mental Health Journal•2011

  • Reflection in Home Visiting

    Open Access•Angela Tomlin, Angela M Tomlin et al.•Infant Mental Health Journal•2016

  • The explication of a mentor model, videotaping, and reflective consultation in support of infant mental health

    Open Access•Susan Janko Summers, Kristin Funk et al.•Infant Mental Health Journal•2007

  • Building reflective capacity and improving well‐being of early childhood professionals through an embedded cross‐system model of infant early childhood mental health consultation

    Open Access•Julie Spielberger, Tiffany Burkhardt et al.•Infant Mental Health Journal•2022

  • From the voices of supervisees

    Open Access•Carla C Barron, Carolyn J Dayton et al.•Infant Mental Health Journal•2022

  • Critical Components of Reflective Supervision

    Open Access•Angela Tomlin, Angela M Tomlin et al.•Infant Mental Health Journal•2014

  • Irving B. Harris Distinguished Lecture

    Open Access•Linda Gilkerson•Infant Mental Health Journal•2004

  • Best Practice in Individual Supervision of Psychologists Working in the French Capedp Preventive Perinatal Home-Visiting Program

    Open Access•Tim Greacen, Bertrand Welniarz et al.•Infant Mental Health Journal•2017

  • The Professional Is the Personal

    Tanika Eaves, Laura Mauldin et al.•Journal of Social Service Research•2021

  • Reflective Practice in Contemporary Child-care Social Work

    Gillian Ruch•The British Journal of Social Work•2005

  • Scoping studies

    Hilary Arksey, Lisa O’malley•International Journal of Social…•2005

Unique citing works10
Citations per year5
Citation span2024 - 2026 (3)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 10

Tools

Open DOI
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae