Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Labour supplies in historical perspective

A study of the proletarianization of the African peasantry in Rhodesia

Bibliographic Data

ID19608366
AuthorsGiovanni Arrighi (corresponding author)
Year1970
Volume6
Issue3
Pages197-234
Publication date1970-04-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessNo
TypeARTICLE
VenueThe Journal of Development Studies (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0022-0388 • E-ISSN: 1743-9140
PublisherTaylor & Francis (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1080/00220387008421322
OpenAlexW2111171880
LanguageEN
Citations received234
References cited19

The article attempts to show that W. A. Lewis's model of economic development with ‘unlimited’ supplies of labour has a far more limited application to the Rhodesian experience of capitalist development than W. J. Barber has assumed. ‘Unlimited’ supplies of labour were to a large extent the result of a process of ‘primary accumulation’ in which political rather than market mechanisms predominated and through which the gap between labour productivities in the peasant and capitalist sectors was progressively widened. Thereafter, supplies of labour did become ‘unlimited’ and, for a period of about two decades, the Rhodesian economy displayed the main features of the Lewis model. However, owing to structural changes initiated by World War II (growing dominance of the economy by foreign oligopolies, development of a manufacturing industry, growing ‘superiority’ of capital intensive techniques, etc.), Lewis's assumption that investible surpluses are reinvested in loco so as to ‘widen’ capital ceased to be valid in the post‐war period. Barber's failure to understand the real nature of capitalist development in Rhodesia is attributed to the general antihistorical bias of modern economics

Agriculture · Capital (architecture) · Capitalism · Dominance (genetics) · Economic system · Economics · Economy · Market economy · Oligopoly · Peasant · Political science · Politics · Proletarianization · Wage labour · African studies and sociopolitical issues

  • Dualismo e o pensamento econômico latino-americano

    Open Access•Fábio Moreira Alves Esperança•2023

  • Hyenas of the Limpopo

    Xolani Tshabalala•2017

  • Economia e crime

    Open Access•Renato Rocha, Renato Gomes de Araujo Rocha•2022

  • A concealed economy’

    Open Access•Esther Makhetha, Sean Maliehe•The Extractive Industries and…•2020

  • Colonial Policy, Male Opposition, and the Integration of Swazi Women into Wage Employment, 1935–1955

    Hamilton Sipho Simelane•African Historical Review•2011

  • Intellectuals” Interpreting Zimbabwe's Primitive Accumulation

    David Moore•Safundi•2007

  • From Peasant Studies to Agrarian Change

    Open Access•H Bernstein, Terence J Byres•Journal of Agrarian Change•2001

  • Land, Livelihoods, and the Decline of Work

    Open Access•Ben Scully•Journal of World-Systems Research•2012

  • Colonial and Post-Colonial Reconstructions of Customary Land Tenure in Zimbabwe

    Open Access•Lawrence Tshuma•Social & Legal Studies•1998

  • State and Peasantry in Zimbabwe since Independence

    Open Access•Nick Amin•European Journal of Development…•1992

  • In memory of Giovanni Arrighi

    Open Access•Deniz Yükseker•New Perspectives on Turkey•2009

  • Pastoral Land Rights and Peacebuilding in North Kordofan

    Open Access•Mustafa Babiker•Nomadic Peoples•2009

  • Training for self-employment

    Open Access•Paul Bennell, David Nyakonda•International Journal of…•1992

  • The limits of colonial power

    Ian Henderson, Ian R Henderson•The Journal of Imperial &…•1974

  • Through a divided glass

    B O''Laughlin, Bridget O''Laughlin et al.•The Journal of Peasant Studies•1996

  • African peasantries

    Henry Bernstein•The Journal of Peasant Studies•1979

  • The evolution of a colonial space-economy

    Open Access•Stephen Britton, Stephen G Britton•Journal of Historical Geography•1980

  • Technology, marriage and women's work in the history of Maize-Growers in Mazabuka, Zambia

    M Wright•Journal of Southern African Studies•1983

  • Peasants, capitalists, and historians

    Frederick Cooper, Faith Cooper•Journal of Southern African Studies•1981

  • The settler mode of production

    Open Access•Werner Biermann, Reinhart Kößler•Review of African Political Economy•1980

  • Zimbabwe's land reform

    Open Access•I Scoones•Review of African Political Economy•2014

  • New realities’ and tenure reforms

    Thebe, Vusilizwe Thebe•Journal of Contemporary African…•2012

  • Identity, Culture and Consciousness

    Alan Jeeves, Alan H Jeeves•South African Historical Journal•1995

  • Rural exodus in the third world

    Eric R Weiss-Altaner•History of European Ideas•1983

  • New Social Formations, Livelihood Transition, and Food Insecurity in Worker–Peasant Communities

    Open Access•Thebe, Vusilizwe Thebe•Journal of Developing Societies•2014

  • Backward capitalism, primitive accumulation and modes of production

    Jairus Banaji•Journal of Contemporary Asia•1973

  • Rural Industries and the Communal Lands Economy in Zimbabwe

    Open Access•A H J Helmsing•Tijdschrift voor Economische en…•1987

  • The Decivilizing Rails

    Open Access•G H Pirie, Gordon Pirie•Tijdschrift voor Economische en…•1982

  • Reversal of migration in the labor reserves of Zimbabwe? Prospects for change

    Open Access•Robert Mazur, Robert E Mazur•Studies in Comparative…•1986

  • The labour market in a dual economy

    Susan I Ranney•The Journal of Development Studies•1985

  • Rethinking Rural Poverty

    Open Access•John Mccracken•The Journal of African History•1978

  • The Effect of Migration on Family Structures in Sub‐Saharan Africa

    Open Access•H W O Okoth‐ogendo•International Migration•1989

  • Agricultural transformation in Zimbabwe

    Open Access•D Weiner•Geoforum•1988

  • Urbanization and socialism in Zimbabwe

    Open Access•Paul Teedon, David Drakakis-Smith et al.•Geoforum•1986

  • A Labour Turnover Model of Wage Determination in Developing Economies

    Julie Fry•The Economic Journal•1979

  • Class Struggle and Migrant Labor in South African Gold Mines

    David Massey•Canadian Journal of African…•1983

  • The Food Crisis and Agrarian Change in Africa

    Sara S Berry, Sara Berry•African Studies Review•1984

  • The Cambridge History of Africa

    Open Access•John D Fage, Michael Crowder•The Cambridge History of Africa•1984

  • Aspects of economic history

    Open Access•C C Wrigley•Colonial Moment in Africa•1990

  • Portuguese-speaking Africa

    Open Access•Basil Davidson•The Cambridge History of Africa•1984

  • Angola and Mozambique, 1870–1905

    Open Access•Alan K Smith, Gervase Clarence Smith•The Cambridge History of Africa•1985

  • British West Africa and Liberia

    Open Access•David Dorward, D C Dorward•The Cambridge History of Africa•1986

  • Portuguese Africa

    Open Access•Andrew Roberts•The Cambridge History of Africa•1986

  • Historical Context

    Open Access•Klas Rönnbäck, Oskar Broberg•Capital and Colonialism•2019

  • East Africa 1870–1905

    Open Access•M Wright•The Cambridge History of Africa•1985

  • The Horn of Africa

    Open Access•Christopher Clapham•The Cambridge History of Africa•1984

  • Islam

    Open Access•C C Stewart•The Cambridge History of Africa•1986

  • Belgian Africa

    Open Access•Bogumił Jewsiewicki, Yvonne Brett et al.•The Cambridge History of Africa•1986

  • French Congo and Gabon 1886–1905

    Open Access•C Coquery-Vidrovitch, Yvonne Brett•The Cambridge History of Africa•1985

  • Africa on the Eve of Partition

    Open Access•Anthony Atmore, A E Atmore•The Cambridge History of Africa•1985

  • Aspects of economic history

    Open Access•C C Wrigley•The Cambridge History of Africa•1986

  • Western Africa, 1870–1886

    Open Access•Yves Person, Yvonne Brett•The Cambridge History of Africa•1985

  • The Maghrib

    Open Access•Michael Brett•The Cambridge History of Africa•1986

  • First Fruits of Immigration, 1907–19

    Richard Hodder-Williams, Richard Hodder‐Williams•White Farmers in Rhodesia,…•1983

  • East Africa

    Open Access•Andrew Roberts•The Cambridge History of Africa•1986

  • British Central Africa

    Open Access•John Mccracken•The Cambridge History of Africa•1986

  • African cross-currents

    Open Access•Andrew Roberts•The Cambridge History of Africa•1986

  • Migration and Labor in Sub-Saharan Africa during the Colonial Period

    Open Access•Opolot Okia•Cambridge History of Global…•2023

  • Western Africa, 1886–1905

    Open Access•John D Hargreaves•The Cambridge History of Africa•1985

  • The Maghrib

    Open Access•Clement Henry Moore•The Cambridge History of Africa•1984

  • North Africa

    Open Access•Jean Ganiage, Yvonne Brettt•The Cambridge History of Africa•1985

  • Madagascar

    Open Access•Bonar A Gow•The Cambridge History of Africa•1984

  • Madagascar and France, 1870–1905

    Open Access•Hubert Deschamps, Brett Yvonne et al.•The Cambridge History of Africa•1985

  • Zaire, Rwanda and Burundi

    Open Access•M Crawford Young•The Cambridge History of Africa•1984

  • French black Africa

    Open Access•C Coquery-Vidrovitch, Elizabeth Edwards et al.•The Cambridge History of Africa•1986

  • East and Central Africa

    Open Access•Cherry Gertzel•The Cambridge History of Africa•1984

  • Pan-Africanism Since 1940

    Open Access•Ian Duffield•The Cambridge History of Africa•1984

  • The Second World War

    Open Access•Michael Crowder•The Cambridge History of Africa•1984

  • The economic evolution of developing Africa

    Open Access•Adebayo Adedeji•The Cambridge History of Africa•1984

  • The European Partition of Africa

    Open Access•G N Sanderson•The Cambridge History of Africa•1985

  • The Lewis Model and Development Theory

    Open Access•P F Leeson•Manchester School•1979

  • The European Scramble and Conquest in African History

    Open Access•John Lonsdale•The Cambridge History of Africa•1985

  • King Leopold's Congo, 1886–1908

    Open Access•Jean Stengers, Jan Vansina•The Cambridge History of Africa•1985

  • Social and cultural change

    Open Access•J D Y Peel•The Cambridge History of Africa•1984

  • Labor and Labor History in Africa

    Bill Freund•African Studies Review•1984

  • Underdevelopment and Class Formation in Ovamboland, 1845–1915

    Open Access•W G Clarence-Smith, William Gervase Clarence‐smith et al.•The Journal of African History•1975

  • Settler Farmers and Coerced African Labour in Southern Rhodesia, 1936–46

    Open Access•D Gale Johnson, David Johnson•The Journal of African History•1992

  • Labour migration and peasant differentiation

    Lionel Cliffe•The Journal of Peasant Studies•1978

  • Meat and Monopolies

    Open Access•Ian Phimister, I R Phimister•The Journal of African History•1978

  • Worker consciousness in black miners

    Open Access•Charles Van Onselen•The Journal of African History•1973

  • Semiproletarização generalizada na África

    Open Access•Paris Yeros•Princípios Revista de Filosofia…•2022

  • The Life and Work of a South African Economist

    Open Access•Paul Maylam•Journal of the History of…•2022

  • Africa and the World Economy

    Frederick Cooper, Faith Cooper•African Studies Review•1981

  • Urban Planning and the Post-Colonial State in Africa

    Akin L Mabogunje•African Studies Review•1990

  • States and Social Processes in Africa

    John Lonsdale•African Studies Review•1981

  • Youth, agriculture and land reform in Zimbabwe

    Thebe, Vusilizwe Thebe•African Studies•2018

  • Defunct labour reserve

    Open Access•Johan Pottier•Africa•1983

  • Land, conflict and radical distributive claims in South Africa's rural mining frontier

    Open Access•Sonwabile Mnwana, Andrew Bowman•The Extractive Industries and…•2021

  • Bandits’ and machete gangs

    Open Access•Katz-Lavigne, Grasian Mkodzongi et al.•The Extractive Industries and…•2024

  • The social bases of a committed labor force

    Open Access•Zhu Yan•The Journal of Chinese Sociology•2018

  • The Complementarity Between Property Rights and Market Access for Crop Cultivation in Southern Rhodesia

    Tawanda Chingozha, Dieter Von Fintel•Economic History of Developing…•2019

  • Labour Control and the Establishment of Profitable Settler Agriculture in Colonial Kenya, c. 1920–45

    Open Access•Maria Mwaipopo Fibæk, E Green•Economic History of Developing…•2019

  • Two systems in one country

    Kam Wing Chan, Yanning Wei•Eurasian Geography and Economics•2019

  • Energy in South Asian history

    Open Access•Matthew Shutzer•History Compass•2020

  • When It's Dark in the East, It's Light in the West”

    Helina S Woldekiros, Yang Zhan•positions asia critique•2022

  • Small Towns and Land Reform in Zimbabwe

    Open Access•I Scoones, Felix Murimbarimba•European Journal of Development…•2020

  • Celso Furtado and the Myth of Economic Development

    Pedro Mendes Loureiro, Fernando Rugitsky et al.•Review of Political Economy•2020

  • Who Becomes a Farmer

    Thebe•Forum for Development Studies•2019

  • Beyond the description of spatial pattern

    Open Access•J Barry Riddell, John Riddell•Progress in Human Geography•1981

  • Trekking on

    Open Access•K S O Beavon, Keith Beavon et al.•Progress in Human Geography•1981

  • African Agrarian Systems

    Daniel Biebuyck•African Agrarian Systems•2018

  • Income, saving, and the theory of consumer behavior

    James Stemble Duesenberry•Income, saving, and the theory of…•1967

  • Essays on African Population

    K M Barbour, R M Prothero•Essays on African Population•2023

  • Capitalism and Underdevelopment in Latin America

    Andre Gunder Frank•Capitalism and Underdevelopment…•1969

  • Economic Development with Unlimited Supplies of Labour

    Open Access•W Arthur Lewis•Manchester School•1954

  • The Political Economy of Rhodesia

    Giovanni Arrighi•New left review•1966

  • The Economy of British Central Africa

    Tom Soper, W J Barber et al.•Economica•1962

  • The Birth of a Dilemma

    Open Access•Gwendolen M Carter•Political Science Quarterly•1959

  • Aspects of Central African History

    L H Gann, Terence O Ranger•African Historical Studies•1968

  • The Shona and Ndebele of Southern Rhodesia

    Hilda Kuper, A J B Hughes et al.•Shona and Ndebele of Southern…•2017

  • Modern Industry and the African

    W M Macmillan, J M Davis•The Economic Journal•1934

  • The Division of Land Resources in Southern Rhodesia

    Wolf Roder•Annals of the Association of…•1964

  • A History of Southern Rhodesia

    Gilbert Rannie•African Affairs•1966

  • Conservation in Eastern Africa

    Open Access•I B Pole-Evans, C Gillman•Geographical Review•1941

  • Economic Rationality and Behavior Patterns in an Underdeveloped Area

    William J Barber•Economic Development and Cultural…•1960

Unique citing works234
Citations per year4,25
Citation span1971 - 2026 (56)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedYes
Citation typesNeutral: 197

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae