Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

The Social Production of Indifference

Exploring the Symbolic Roots of Western Bureaucracy

Bibliographic Data

ID19919795
AuthorsM Herzfeld (0000-0002-8080-2542, corresponding author)
Year2021
Publication date2021-01-07
Open AccessNo
TypeBOOK
Reviewed byThe Social Production of Indifference: Exploring the Symbolic Roots of Western Bureaucracy, Sally Engle Merry, 1995
VenueSocial Production of Indifference (SOURCE_BOOK)
PublisherRoutledge (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.4324/9781003135029
OpenAlexW4206773804
Open LibraryOL36261481M
ISBN9781003135029
LanguageEN
Citations received273

In this fascinating book, Michael Herzfeld argues that 'modern' bureaucratically regulated societies are no more 'rational' or less 'symbolic' than the societies traditionally studied by anthropologists. Drawing primarily on the example of modern Greece and utilizing other European materials, he suggests that we cannot understand national bureaucracies divorced from local-level ideas about chance, personal character, social relationships and responsibility. He points out that both formal regulations and day-to-day bureaucratic practices rely heavily on the symbols and language of the moral boundaries between insiders and outsiders; a ready means of expressing prejudice and of justifying neglect. It therefore happens that societies with proud traditions of generous hospitality may paradoxically produce at the official level some of the most calculated indifference one can find anywhere

Economics · Microeconomics · Production (economics) · Social production · Social science · Sociology · Religion and Society Interactions · Social Policy and Reform Studies · Abuse of administrative power · Anthropology · Bureaucracy · Bureaucratie · Contrôle social · Developing countries · Élite (Sciences sociales) · Elite (Social sciences) · Excès de pouvoir (Droit administratif) · Social conflict · Social control

  • Anthropology and Public Service

    Open Access•Jeremy Macclancy•Anthropology and Public Service•2017

  • Burocracia como frontera

    Open Access•Ricardo Alfonso Zepeda Orozco•Encartes•2026

  • Performing In/formality beyond the Dichotomy

    Open Access•Martijn Koster, A Smart•Anthropologica•1969

  • A experiência de gravidez, parto e pós-parto das imigrantes bolivianas e seus desencontros na cidade de São Paulo - Brasil

    Open Access•Rosário Del Socorro Avellaneda Yajahuanca•2015

  • Tecer amizade, habitar o deserto

    Open Access•Daniela Carolina Perutti•2016

  • Cartórios judiciais e o acesso à justiça

    Open Access•Janaína Dantas Germano Gomes•2017

  • Família Forte, Nação Soberana

    Tatiane Moura Amaral•2023

  • Brincando na terra

    Gustavo Belisário D''Araújo Couto, Gustavo Belisário D'Araújo Couto•2016

  • Da ocupação aos conselhos

    Open Access•Lucas Ferreira Cruvinel•2018

  • Nome aos bois. Zebus e zebuzeiros em uma pecuária brasileira de elite

    Open Access•N S Leal•2014

  • The Institutional Betrayal and Bureaucratic Violence of Higher Education

    Open Access•A J Reinke•Teaching and Learning Anthropology•2022

  • Gubernamentalidades futuristas

    Open Access•Pablo Jaramillo•Contemporânea - revista de…•2016

  • Undoing mastery

    Open Access•Jess Linz, Anna Secor•Dialogues in Human Geography•2021

  • Significados Negociados

    Open Access•Aline Sapiezinskas Krás Borges Canani•Letrônica•2016

  • Materialismo histórico

    Open Access•Pedro Antunes, Paulo Fernando Rocha Antunes•Cadernos Cemarx•2016

  • Road Work

    Open Access•Ryan Cecil Jobson•The Journal of Latin American and…•2018

  • Opening a Path with Papers

    Open Access•Johanna Gonçalves Martins•The Journal of Latin American and…•2016

  • La política del valor y la política del significado

    Open Access•Julieta Gaztañaga•Antípoda Revista de Antropología…•2016

  • Entre lugares y documentos

    Open Access•Gonzalo Díaz Crovetto•Antípoda Revista de Antropología…•2015

  • Sociodicies of (im)mobility

    Anne-Christine Trémon•Mobilities•2018

  • Domesticating Sweet Sadness

    Open Access•R Tzanelli•Culture Studies ↔ Critical…•2012

  • Ser embruxado

    Open Access•A Borges•Civitas - Revista de Ciências…•2013

  • Entre o perigo da indiferença e o risco de ser afetado

    Open Access•L Lowenkron•Interseções Revista de Estudos…•2017

  • Entre razões técnicas e morais

    Open Access•Luciano Senna Peres Barbosa•Revista TOMO•2015

  • A disputa pelo sangue

    Open Access•Sara Alonso•Novos Cadernos NAEA•1999

  • Strife in Nazareth

    Open Access•D Rabinowitz•Ethnography•2001

  • The Deportation Gap as a Statistical Chimera

    Open Access•Stephan Scheel•Geopolitics•2025

  • Should (S)he Stay or Should (S)he Go? - Street-level Suspicion and the Construction of the '(Un)deserving Migrant

    L M Borrelli•Geopolitics•2022

  • Torture Survivors in Asylum - Ignoring the Obvious

    Open Access•N Wei•Geopolitics•2024

  • Street-level bureaucracy and depoliticized North Korean subjectivity in the service provision of Hana Center

    Seo Yeon Park•Asian Ethnicity•2016

  • Egalitarian Ambitions, Constructions of Difference

    Marita Eastmond•New Community•2011

  • Bureaucratic neglect

    Breanne Leigh Grace, Benjamin J Roth•New Community•2021

  • Citizenship as a gift

    Robin Vandevoordt, Gert Verschraegen•Citizenship Studies•2019

  • The promises of the bureaucratisation of intangible cultural heritage safeguarding in post-conflict regions

    Miloš Milenković•International Journal of Heritage…•2024

  • Colonialism as ‘shared history’? Negotiating European colonial heritage in Casablanca and beyond

    Alexandra Oancă•International Journal of Heritage…•2025

  • The politics of ‘forgetting’ as poetics of belonging

    Open Access•R Tzanelli•Nations and Nationalism•2007

  • Politics, Policies and Possibilities

    Gillian Bottomley•Communal/Plural Journal of…•2000

  • Commentary

    Open Access•Carol J Greenhouse•PoLAR Political and Legal…•1999

  • The emotional governance of immigration controls

    Open Access•M Griffiths•Identities•2024

  • Affective control

    Ioana Vrăbiescu, B Anderson•Identities•2024

  • Whose Sidewalk

    Open Access•Theodoros Kouros•The Anthropology of East Europe…•2021

  • Intentional structural violence? Weapons of the accountable and the administration of Wielangta

    Rob Laird•Griffith Law Review•2018

  • Governing by paper

    P Laungaramsri•South East Asia Research•2020

  • The saved and the drowned

    Open Access•Tugba Basaran•Security Dialogue•2015

  • Philanthropy or solidarity? Ethical dilemmas about humanitarianism in crisis-afflicted Greece

    Open Access•D Theodossopoulos•Social Anthropology•2016

  • ‘The feeling of pursuing an ideal’

    Open Access•J K Cowan•Social Anthropology•2020

  • Following the law, but losing the spirit of child protection in Kenya

    Elizabeth Cooper•Development in Practice•2012

  • Humanicrats

    Rebecca Napier-Moore, Rebecca Napier‐Moore•Development in Practice•2011

  • The politics of social assistance in South Africa

    Open Access•Erdem Yörük, Alper Şükrü Gençer•Governance•2021

  • Seeing The World From A Safe Distance

    Kevin Robins, Mark Terkessidis•Science as Culture•2001

  • På Gyngende Grund

    Turf Böcker Jakobsen•Tidsskriftet Antropologi•2005

  • Raspberries, Tablecloths, and Critical Thinking

    Open Access•Liene Ozolina•East European Politics and…•2010

  • Embodied Urbanisms

    Open Access•Namita Vijay Dharia•Cultural Anthropology•2021

  • Conflicting Conviviality

    Fabio Mattioli•Journal of Borderlands Studies•2012

  • Death, Taxes, Public Opinion, and the Midas Touch of Mary Tyler Moore

    Open Access•Melanie Rock•Medical Anthropology Quarterly•2003

  • Humanitarians in court

    Open Access•Kristin Bergtora Sandvik•The Journal of Legal Pluralism…•2018

  • Identification

    Gill Bottomley•Journal of Intercultural Studies•1997

  • Relaciones infraestructurales

    Open Access•Strang, Veronica Strang•Revista Colombiana de Antropología•2018

  • Italian Elite Groups at Work

    Open Access•Italo Pardo•Diogenes•2016

  • Voicing the silence

    Aide Esu•International Review of Sociology•2021

  • Bureaucratization, education and the meanings of responsibility

    Hannah Spector•Curriculum Inquiry•2018

  • Guarding the goods, producing the state

    Open Access•Dejana Kostic•Glasnik Etnografskog instituta•2017

  • Urban Waterlines

    Open Access•Karen Coelho•International Journal of Urban…•2022

  • Temporal Politics and Injustice in Mega Urbanization

    Open Access•Yunpeng Zhang•International Journal of Urban…•2022

  • Law, Tradition and the Making of the Catalan Family

    Open Access•Joan Bestard-Camps•Critique of Anthropology•1995

  • Safeguarding Data

    Open Access•J Cearns, H Knox•The Cambridge Journal of…•2024

  • Please Sign Here

    Open Access•Diego Valdivieso•The Cambridge Journal of…•2025

  • Bureaucracy and the politics of time in state-business relations

    Open Access•L Puygrenier•Theory and Society•2023

  • Patient agency and contested notions of disability in social assistance applications in South Africa

    Open Access•Gabrielle Kelly•Social Science & Medicine•2017

  • Alexander's Great Treasure

    Leonidas Vournelis•History and Anthropology•2016

  • Banishment

    Open Access•L M Borrelli, Anita Heindlmaier et al.•Critical Social Policy•2024

  • Internalization of Borders

    Open Access•Volker M Heins•Society•2025

  • Beautiful Registrations

    Laura Caballe-Climent•Medical Anthropology•2024

  • The Moral Economy of Lying

    R Beneduce•Medical Anthropology•2015

  • State‐Crafted Dominant Fictions

    Open Access•A Lindberg, L M Borrelli•Social Policy and Administration•2024

  • Cuidados, mobilidade e poder num contexto de epidemia

    Open Access•Parry Scott•Mana•2020

  • Um antropólogo no gabinete

    Open Access•Gustavo Belisário•Cadernos de Campo (São Paulo 1991•2021

  • From Access Challenges (as Data) to Methodological Insights

    Open Access•Bruno Luiz Américo, Stewart Clegg et al.•Administration & Society•2024

  • To Sell or Not to Sell? Theory Versus Practice, Public Versus Private, and the Failure of Liberalism

    Open Access•D Rabinowitz•American Ethnologist•1994

  • Documents of indiscipline and indifference

    Open Access•Kristen Drybread•American Ethnologist•2016

  • Good clean tobacco

    Open Access•Peter Benson•American Ethnologist•2008

  • The Bureaucratic Capture of Child Migrants

    Open Access•R Humphris, N Sigona•Antipode•2019

  • Life is Individual

    Open Access•N Rapport•Anthropological Forum•2024

  • Judgement and Ambivalence in Migration Work

    Open Access•Robin Vandevoordt•Sociology•2018

  • Secure States

    Open Access•Mabel Berezin•The Sociological Review•2002

  • Multicultural Geography versus Multicultural Genealogy

    Open Access•Davydd J Greenwood•Disparidades. Revista de…•1996

  • Whisper down, up and between the lanes

    Open Access•L M Borrelli•Public Administration•2018

  • Texts, Authority, and Community in the South African 'Ibandla lamaNazaretha' (Church of the Nazaretha), 1910-1976

    Joel Cabrita•Journal of Religion in Africa•2010

  • Migration, gentrification and housing crisis. The case of Peruvians living in Abasto (Buenos Aires)

    Open Access•Francisco J Cuberos‐gallardo•International Migration•2024

  • Measuring Nothing

    Open Access•Apostolos Ballas, Apostolos A Ballas et al.•Human Relations•2004

  • The Homonational Archive

    D A B Murray•Ethnos•2017

  • When Culture Is Not A System

    Ilana Gershon•Ethnos•2006

  • Purity and Corruption

    Anders Sybrandt Hansen•Ethnos•2013

  • Boundaries crossing and blurring

    Open Access•L Sion•Current Sociology•2014

  • Trusting the Poor

    Tom Neumark•Anthropological Quarterly•2020

  • Introduction

    Open Access•Karine Geoffrion, Geoffrion Karine et al.•Anthropologica•2021

  • National Character

    Open Access•Federico Neiburg•International Encyclopedia of the…•2001

  • ID Wars in Côte d'Ivoire

    Richard Banégas, Armando Cutolo•ID Wars in Côte d'Ivoire•2024

  • Modern Folk Devils

    Open Access•Martin Demant Frederiksen, Ida Harboe Knudsen•Modern Folk Devils•2021

  • The Bureaucratic Production of Difference

    Open Access•Chowra Makaremi, Julia M Eckert et al.•Bureaucratic Production of…•2020

Unique citing works271
Citations per year4,79
Citation span1969 - 2026 (58)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedYes
Citation typesNeutral: 177

Tools

Open DOI
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae