Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

The Shape of Actions

What Humans and Machines Can Do

Bibliographic Data

ID19992425
AuthorsH M Collins, Harry Collins (0000-0003-2909-9035), Michael Kusch (0000-0003-4570-7272), Martin Kusch
Year1999
Pages224
Publication date1999-01-05
Open AccessNo
TypeBOOK
Reviewed byThe Shape of Actions: What Humans and Machines Can Do, P Aspers, 2000
VenueThe Shape of Actions (SOURCE_BOOK)
PublisherThe MIT Press (PUBLISHER • US)
DOI10.7551/mitpress/6200.001.0001
OpenAlexW4249539045
Open LibraryOL10236848M
ISBN9780262270687
LanguageEN
Citations received96

What can humans do? What can machines do? How do humans delegate actions to machines? In this book, Harry Collins and Martin Kusch combine insights from sociology and philosophy to provide a novel answer to these increasingly important questions.The authors begin by distinguishing between two basic types of intentional behavior, which they call polimorphic actions and mimeomorphic actions. Polimorphic actions (such as writing a love letter) are ones that community members expect to vary with social context. Mimeomorphic actions (such a swinging a golf club) do not vary. Although machines cannot act, they can mimic mimeomorphic actions. Mimeomorphic actions are thus the crucial link between what humans can do and what machines can do. Following a presentation of their detailed categorization of actions, the authors apply their approach to a broad range of human-machine interactions and to learning. Key examples include bicycle riding and the many varieties of writing machines. They also show how their theory can be used to explain the operation of organizations such as restaurants and armies. Finally, they look at a historical case—the technological development of the air pump—applying their categorization of actions to the processes of mechanization and automation. Automation, they argue, can occur only where what we want to bring about can be brought about through mimeomorphic action

Action (physics) · Categorization · Cognitive science · Computer security · Context (archaeology) · Delegate · Key (lock) · Presentation (obstetrics) · Artificial Intelligence · Computer Science · Ethics and Social Impacts of AI · History of Computing Technologies · Information Systems Theories and Implementation · Psychology · Artificial Intelligence - General · Automation · Automatisation · Automatisering · Engineering & Applied Sciences · Environmental - General · General · Human beings · Human-machine systems · Impact of computing & IT on society · Industrial & Management Engineering · Industrial design · Machinery · Man-machine systems · Mechanical engineering · Mens-machinesystemen · modern · Philosophy · Philosophy & Social Aspects · Science · Science/Mathematics · Social aspects · Sociology, Social Studies · Systèmes homme-machine · Technology & Engineering

  • Technology as a Strategy of the Human? A Comparison Between the Extension Concept and the Fetish Concept of Technology

    Open Access•Maximilian Pieper•Philosophy & Technology•2024

  • La máquina de hacer pan

    Open Access•Sofia Mondaca•Griot Revista de Filosofia•2023

  • Social Ontologies Online

    Open Access•Benjamin Krämer, Julia Conrad•Social Media + Society•2017

  • Ações de informação, colaboração e concertação institucional no contexto da extensão rural │ Information, collaboration and institutional concertation in the context of rural extension

    Open Access•Ana Cristina Gomes Santos, Maria Nelida González De Gómez•Liinc em Revista•2014

  • Contextual social valences for artificial intelligence

    Open Access•Tuukka Lehtiniemi•Information Communication & Society•2024

  • Data witnessing

    Open Access•Jonathan Gray•Information Communication & Society•2019

  • Les conditions de corporéité et d’intersubjectivité chez la personne morale

    Open Access•Shaun Gallagher, Sonia Mansour-Robaey•Théologiques•2004

  • Why artificial intelligence needs sociology of knowledge

    Open Access•Harry Collins•AI & Society•2025

  • Socialness and the Undersocialized Conception of Society

    Open Access•H M Collins, Harry Collins•Science Technology & Human Values•1998

  • Introduction

    Open Access•Michael Patrick Lynch, Michael Lynch et al.•Science Technology & Human Values•1998

  • Changing Infrastructural Practices

    Open Access•Robert Meckin•Science Technology & Human Values•2020

  • Science as a counter to the erosion of truth in society

    Open Access•Harry Collins•Synthese•2023

  • Materializing values

    Open Access•Alexandra Karakas, Adam Tamas Tuboly•Synthese•2024

  • Internet Artworks, Artists and Computer Programmers

    Jean-Paul Fourmentraux•Leonardo•2006

  • Interactional expertise as a third kind of knowledge

    Open Access•Harry Collins•Phenomenology and the Cognitive…•2004

  • Towards a Philosophy of Real Mathematics

    David Corfield•Towards a Philosophy of Real…•2009

  • Die Frage nach der „Agency“ von Technik und die Normenvergessenheit der Techniksoziologie

    Hironori Matsuzaki•Akteur - Individuum - Subjekt•2011

  • Automated Artefacts as Co-performers of Social Practices

    Open Access•Lenneke Kuijer•Social Practices and Dynamic…•2019

  • La forza delle comunità locali

    Open Access•Nicolò Bellanca•La forza delle comunità locali•2023

  • Peripheral Vision

    Open Access•Theodore R Schatzki•Organization Studies•2005

  • The Oxford Handbook of Expertise

    J Suss, L Boulton et al.•Oxford Handbook of Expertise•2019

  • Programmer l’interface

    Open Access•Jean-Paul Fourmentraux•Questions de communication•2005

  • The Role of the Sociologist after half-a-century of studying science

    Harry Collins•Society in Transition•2013

  • Credibility by automation

    Open Access•Juho Pääkkönen, Salla-Maaria Laaksonen et al.•Convergence The International…•2020

  • Randomised controlled trials and the interventionisation of education

    Cathy Burnett, Nick Moore•Oxford Review of Education•2021

  • AI-Testimony, Conversational AIs and Our Anthropocentric Theory of Testimony

    Ori Freiman•Social Epistemology•2024

  • A Sociological Analysis of Ethical Expertise

    Open Access•Nathan Emmerich•SAGE Open•2015

  • A New Approach for STS? A Synthesis of Marxism and Actor-Network Theory

    C Thorpe•Science as Culture•2015

  • Crossing Boundaries

    Open Access•Henrik Bruun, Janne I Hukkinen et al.•Social Studies of Science•2003

  • King Canute Meets the Beach Boys

    Open Access•H M Collins, Harry Collins et al.•Social Studies of Science•2003

  • A New Societist Social Ontology

    Open Access•Theodore R Schatzki•Philosophy of the Social Sciences•2003

  • Weder rationale Reflexion noch präreflexive Praktik – erfahrungsgeleitet-subjektivierendes Handeln

    Fritz Böhle•Handeln Unter Unsicherheit•2009

  • Die Logik des Sozialen. Entwurf einer intentional-relationalen Sozialtheorie

    Rainer Schützeichel•Dimensionen und Konzeptionen Von…•2010

  • Die Instabilität der Praxis

    Open Access•Hilmar Schäfer•Die Instabilität der Praxis•2020

  • Out of My Viewfinder, Yet in the Picture

    Open Access•Ericka Sue Johnson•Science Technology & Human Values•2008

  • Managing Ambiguities at the Edge of Knowledge

    Open Access•Steve G Hoffman, Steve Hoffman•Science Technology & Human Values•2017

  • The Ghost of Wittgenstein

    Open Access•William T Lynch•Philosophy of the Social Sciences•2005

  • Judging machines

    Open Access•Arno Schubbach•Synthese•2021

  • Quantifying the Tacit

    Open Access•Harry Collins, Robert Evans•Sociology•2014

  • Visual Cognition

    Open Access•David Gooding, David C Gooding•Philosophy of Science•2006

  • Towards a Pragmatist-Inspired Philosophy of Social Science

    Open Access•Patrick Baert•Acta Sociologica•2005

  • On the Embodied Nature of Action

    Open Access•Henrik Bruun, Richard Langlais•Acta Sociologica•2003

  • Trained Judgements Artificial Intelligence, Epistemic Tensions and the Production of Scientific Objectivity

    Open Access•G Anichini, Baptiste Kotras•Science Technology & Human Values•2024

  • A story of nimble knowledge production in an era of academic capitalism

    Open Access•Steve G Hoffman, Steve Hoffman•Theory and Society•2021

  • The Donders Machine

    Henning Schmidgen•Configurations•2005

  • Whom to call as an expert on the social dimension of transformative change in global environmental assessments

    Open Access•Karin M Gustafsson•Environmental Sociology•2025

  • Stop studying “fake news” (we can still fight against disinformation in the media)

    Open Access•Benjamin Krämer•Studies in Communication and Media•2021

  • Polityka, organizacja i praktyki tworzenia wiedzy w kolektywach otwartego kodu. Socjolog techniki czyta Inną Rzeczpospolitą Jana Sowy

    Open Access•Marcin Zaród•Praktyka Teoretyczna•2015

  • Object and shadow

    Harry Collins, Martin Weinel et al.•Critical Policy Studies•2011

  • The politics and policy of the Third Wave

    Harry Collins, Martin Weinel et al.•Critical Policy Studies•2010

  • The Sociology of Expertise

    Open Access•R Evans•Sociology Compass•2008

  • Probes, Surveys, and the Ontology of the Social

    Open Access•Harry Collins, R Evans•Journal of Mixed Methods Research•2015

  • The Imitation Game and the Nature of Mixed Methods

    Open Access•Harry Collins, R Evans et al.•Journal of Mixed Methods Research•2015

  • The sociological critique of evolutionary psychology

    Open Access•Matthew David•New Genetics and Society•2002

  • The imitation Game and the nature of science

    Open Access•Harry Collins, Robert Evans•Studies in History and Philosophy…•2019

  • Expertise revisited, Part I—Interactional expertise

    Open Access•Harry Collins, Robert Evans•Studies in History and Philosophy…•2015

  • Bringing tacit knowledge back to contributory and interactional expertise

    Open Access•Luis Reyes-Galindo, Tiago Ribeiro Duarte•Studies in History and Philosophy…•2014

  • Interactional expertise and embodiment

    Open Access•Evan Selinger, Hubert Dreyfus et al.•Studies in History and Philosophy…•2007

  • Testimony

    Open Access•Martin Kusch, Peter Lipton•Studies in History and Philosophy…•2002

  • Experiments with interactional expertise

    Open Access•Harry Collins, Rob Evans et al.•Studies in History and Philosophy…•2006

  • Interactional expertise through the looking glass

    Open Access•Theresa Schilhab•Studies in History and Philosophy…•2007

  • Surviving Closure

    H M Collins, Harry Collins•American Sociological Review•2000

  • Simulating What

    Open Access•Harry Collins•Journal of Artificial Societies…•2011

  • Machine learning for policing

    Elwin van ’t Wout, Christian Pieringer et al.•Policing & Society•2020

  • Discipline, subjectivity and personality

    Open Access•Maarten Derksen•History of the Human Sciences•2001

  • Decomposition as Practice and Process

    Wolfgang Kaltenbrunner•Interdisciplinary Science Reviews•2014

  • The most important thing about science is values

    Harry Collins•Interdisciplinary Science Reviews•2022

  • Unsavory medicine for technological civilization

    Colin Garvey•Interdisciplinary Science Reviews•2021

  • The two kinds of artificial intelligence, or how not to confuse objects and subjects

    Open Access•Alan F Blackwell•Interdisciplinary Science Reviews•2023

  • When Systemizers Meet Empathizers

    Alan F Blackwell•Interdisciplinary Science Reviews•2010

  • Magnum Opus

    Open Access•Malcolm Ashmore•Social Studies of Science•2007

  • Surgical Simulators and Simulated Surgeons

    Open Access•Ericka Johnson•Social Studies of Science•2007

  • Communication Regimes in Competition

    Open Access•Ingemar Bohlin•Social Studies of Science•2004

  • Language and practice

    Open Access•Harry Collins•Social Studies of Science•2011

  • Scientific conferences, socialization, and the Covid-19 pandemic

    Open Access•Harry Collins, Willow Leonard‐clarke et al.•Social Studies of Science•2023

  • Virtual diversity revisited

    Open Access•Harry Collins, R Evans et al.•Social Studies of Science•2025

  • Appealing Images

    Open Access•Kelly Joyce•Social Studies of Science•2005

  • Morality and Technology

    Open Access•Bruno Latour, Couze Venn•Theory Culture & Society•2002

  • Developing the Information and Knowledge Agenda in Information Systems

    Leslie P Willcocks, Leslie Willcocks et al.•The Information Society•2009

  • Ethos and Eidos as Field Level Concepts for the Sociology of Morality and the Anthropology of Ethics

    Open Access•Nathan Emmerich•Human Studies•2021

  • La création au risque d'Internet

    Jean-Paul Fourmentraux•Ethnologie française•2008

  • Images of Work

    Open Access•Julian E Orr•Science Technology & Human Values•1998

  • L'oeuvre négociée

    Jean-Paul Fourmentraux•Sociologie et sociétés•2008

  • The Craft and Code Binary

    J A Evans, James Evans et al.•Osiris•2023

  • Objective functions

    Open Access•Alan F Blackwell•Hau Journal of Ethnographic Theory•2019

Unique citing works85
Citations per year3,43
Citation span1998 - 2025 (28)
Citation velocityrecent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 82

Tools

Open DOILibgen
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae