Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

The Apathy Syndrome

How We Are Trained Not to Care about Politics

Bibliographic Data

ID2245259
AuthorsAnna Zhelnina (0000-0001-6558-2281, City University of New York, Graduate Center, and the National Research University Higher School of Economics, Saint Petersburg, Russia, corresponding author)
Year2020
Volume67
Issue2
Pages358-378
Publication date2020-05-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueSocial Problems (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0037-7791 • E-ISSN: 1533-8533
PublisherOxford University Press (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1093/socpro/spz019
OpenAlexW2955091974
LanguageEN
Citations received32
References cited54

The role of emotions in social movements and mobilization has been an important focus of recent research, but the emotional mechanisms producing apathy and non-participation remain under studied. This article explores the thinking and feeling processes involved in the production of apolitical attitudes, paying particular attention to their social and cultural context. Cultural norms of appropriateness and emotional expression can hinder or boost the emotions involved in the mobilizing processes. Based on 60 interviews with young people in two Russian cities, collected during and in the aftermath of the anti-regime protests of 2011-12, I explore the apathy syndrome-a combination of emotional mechanisms and cultural norms that produce political apathy. Personal frustrating experiences develop into long-term cynicism and disbelief in the efficacy of collective action, a process exacerbated by the transmission of apathy in families and educational institutions, as well as by cultural norms of appropriate emotions. Cultural clichés and dissociation from others help people cope with the trap and justify inaction

Apathy · Cognition · Collective action · Context (archaeology) · Cynicism · Feeling · Political science · Politics · Psychiatry · Sociology · Law · Populism, Right-Wing Movements · Psychology · Social and Cultural Dynamics · Social Psychology · Sociopolitical Dynamics in Russia

  • Killing Politics Softly

    Paul Shields•Communist and Post-Communist…•2021

  • The geography of discontent

    Open Access•Sebastian Jungkunz•Social Forces•2025

  • Political Participation and Critical Thinking of Youth

    Huabing Yang•Basic and Applied Social Psychology•2026

  • Reinventing Urban Identities in Kazan

    Open Access•Aleksandra Turowska•Prace Etnograficzne•2021

  • The Role of Cynicism in Social Responses to the Climate Emergency

    Open Access•D J Davidson•Socius Sociological Research for…•2024

  • Modern and Historical Parallels of Perception of Anomie in Armenian Society

    Open Access•Srbuhi Gevorgyan, Naira Hakobyan et al.•Cultural-Historical Psychology•2023

  • Centering Resistance Amid the Vitriol

    Open Access•Leonardo Kattari•Journal of Mixed Methods Research•2025

  • Fervent Christians

    J Kormina•Religion State & Society•2023

  • Religious activism in Eastern Europe and beyond

    Open Access•Tsypylma Darieva, J Kormina•Religion State & Society•2023

  • Internalized political repression

    Open Access•Nadia Almasalkhi•Sociological Forum•2024

  • Digital literacy and strategic (dis)engagement

    Open Access•G Polizzi•Information Communication & Society•2025

  • Gender-based dynamics in Russian online political discourse

    Elizaveta Savchenko, Е Я Савченко et al.•Information Communication & Society•2026

  • Flexible authoritarianism

    Open Access•Anna Zhelnina•European Journal of Cultural and…•2025

  • Young people (de)politicizing youth cultures

    Nadezhda Vasileva•Journal of Youth Studies•2024

  • Apathy, resistance, and disengagement

    Open Access•Katelyn Davenport‐klunder, Katelyn Davenport-Klunder et al.•Policing & Society•2025

  • Performing Nationalism

    Open Access•Lingxiao Chen•American Sociological Review•2026

  • ‘The church should know its place

    J Kormina•History and Anthropology•2021

  • Fractured Pasts? Views on Soviet History Among Russians and Ukrainians Prior to the 2022 Invasion

    Open Access•Félix Krawatzek, George Soroka•Nationalities Papers•2025

  • Bring Your Own Politics

    Open Access•Anna Zhelnina•Sociology•2022

  • Propaganda to a cynical audience

    Open Access•Alexei Zakharov•Political Science Research and…•2026

  • To Speak or Stay Silent? Russian Migrants in Norway and the Dilemma of Political Protest during the War in Ukraine

    Open Access•Bygne, Susanne Bygne et al.•Sociology•2026

  • Rethinking Propaganda

    Anton Shirikov•The Journal of Politics•2024

  • On the relationship between age and conspiracy beliefs

    Open Access•Jean-Nicolas Bordeleau, Daniel Stockemer•Political Psychology•2025

  • Fake News for All

    Anton Shirikov•Political Communication•2024

  • I’m sick of doing nothing

    Benjamin R Wei•Social movement studies•2022

  • Beyond the binary

    Open Access•Martin Bekker, Carin Runciman et al.•Politikon•2022

  • Echoes of silence

    Open Access•W Guo•Social Forces•2025

  • The Looming, Crazy Stalker Coronavirus

    Open Access•Alexandrea J Ravenelle, Andy Newell et al.•Socius Sociological Research for…•2021

  • Cooperation without Consensus

    Open Access•Liora O’donnell Goldensher•Social Problems•2022

  • Hope, Emotional Charges, and Online Action

    Open Access•Luke Elliott-Negri, Siqi Tu et al.•Social Problems•2022

  • Strategic non-engagement

    Open Access•Liudmila Listrovaya•Social Forces•2025

  • A crypto way out

    Open Access•Kobe De Keere, Maksim Novokreshchenov•Journal of Cultural Economy•2025

  • Rock-A-by Baby

    Verta A Taylor•Rock-A-by Baby•2016

  • Extreme Right Parties in Western Europe

    Piero Ignazi•Extreme right parties in Western…•2003

  • The Emotions of Protest

    James M Jasper•Emotions of Protest•2018

  • Right-Wing Populism in Europe

    Open Access•R Wodak, Majid Khosravinik et al.•Right-Wing Populism in Europe•2013

  • Parties Without Partisans

    Martin P Wattenberg, Martin Wattenberg et al.•Parties without partisans•2002

  • Moving Politics

    Deborah B Gould•Moving Politics•2009

  • Emotions and Social Movements

    Jeff Goodwin, James M Jasper•Handbook of the Sociology of…•2007

  • The relation between gender and emotion in different cultures

    Open Access•Agneta H Fischer, Agneta Fischer et al.•Gender and Emotion•2000

  • Habits of the heart

    Ann Swidler, Richard Madsen et al.•Habits of the heart•2007

  • Democratic Phoenix

    Open Access•P Norris•Democratic Phoenix•2002

  • The social roles and functions of emotions

    Nico H Frijda, Batja Mesquita•Emotion and culture•2004

  • Emotions and Social Movements

    Helena Flam, Debra King•Emotions and Social Movements•2007

  • Urban Grassroots Movements in Central and Eastern Europe

    Kerstin Jacobsson•Urban Grassroots Movements in…•2016

  • Avoiding Politics

    Open Access•Nina Eliasoph•Avoiding Politics•1998

  • The Art of Moral Protest

    James M Jasper•Art of Moral Protest•1997

  • Handbook of the Sociology of Emotions

    Open Access•Jan Stets, Jan E Stets et al.•Handbook of the Sociology of…•2006

  • Individualization

    Ulrich Beck, Elisabeth Beck‐gernsheim et al.•Individualization•2002

  • Living in Denial

    Kari Marie Norgaard•Living in Denial•2011

  • Unlikely mobilisations

    Open Access•Karine Clément•European Journal of Cultural and…•2015

  • Protesting Putinism

    Graeme B Robertson•Problems of Post-Communism•2013

  • Political Opposition in Russia

    Владимир Гельман, Vladimir Gel'Man•Europe Asia Studies•2015

  • The Sociological Imagination

    C W Mills•The Mississippi Valley Historical…•1959

  • Politics are Bollocks’

    Open Access•H Pilkington, Gary Pollock•The Sociological Review•2015

  • The Cynical Society

    Open Access•Richard M Merelman•Political Science Quarterly•1991

  • Party Membership in Twenty European Democracies, 1980-2000

    Open Access•Peter Mair, Ingrid Van Biezen•Party Politics•2001

  • Voter turnout dynamics in post‐Communist Europe

    Open Access•Tatiana Kostadinova•European Journal of Political…•2003

  • Speaking from the Heart

    Stephanie A Shield, Stephanie A Shields•Speaking from the Heart•2002

  • Towards a Psychological Analysis of Anomie

    Open Access•A Teymoori, Brock Bastian et al.•Political Psychology•2017

  • Com/passionate Protests

    Sieglinde Rosenberger, Jakob Winkler•Mobilization An International…•2014

  • Putinism Under Siege

    Open Access•Denis Volkov•Journal of democracy•2012

  • Demonstrations against demonstrations

    Jardar Østbø•Social movement studies•2017

  • Norms for experiencing emotions in different cultures

    Michael Eid, Ed Diener•Journal of Personality and Social…•2001

  • The Return of The Repressed

    Jeff Goodwin, James M Jasper et al.•Mobilization An International…•2000

  • Culture in Action

    Ann Swidler•American Sociological Review•1986

  • The Structural Contexts of Civic Engagement

    Evan Schofer, Marion Fourcade-Gourinchas et al.•American Sociological Review•2001

  • Of ordinariness and citizenship processes

    Catherine Neveu•Citizenship Studies•2015

  • Secure States

    Open Access•Mabel Berezin•The Sociological Review•2002

  • Memory Transmission and Political Socialization in Post-Socialist Hungary

    Open Access•D Sik•The Sociological Review•2015

  • Process and Protest

    Alan Schussman, A Soule et al.•Social Forces•2005

  • Passionate Politics

    Jeff Goodwin, James M Jasper et al.•Passionate Politics•2001

  • Freedom's children in protest movements

    Open Access•Erpyleva, Svetlana Erpyleva•Current Sociology•2018

  • Gender's crooked path

    Open Access•A Temkina, Elena Zdravomyslova et al.•Current Sociology•2014

  • The Study of Boundaries in the Social Sciences

    M Lamont, Molnar et al.•Annual Review of Sociology•2002

  • Emotions and Social Movements

    James M Jasper•Annual Review of Sociology•2011

  • The Sociology of Feeling and Emotion

    Open Access•Arlie Russell Hochschild•Sociological Inquiry•1975

  • Disavowing Politics

    Emily A Bennett, Elizabeth A Bennett et al.•American Journal of Sociology•2013

  • On the Sociological Imagination

    Allen, Danielle Allen et al.•Critical Inquiry•2004

  • Recruitment to High-Risk Activism

    Doug Mcadam•American Journal of Sociology•1986

Unique citing works32
Citations per year6,4
Citation span2021 - 2026 (6)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 31

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae