Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Trading carbon for food

Global comparison of carbon stocks vs. crop yields on agricultural land

Bibliographic Data

ID23344882
AuthorsPaul West (0000-0001-9024-1657, University of Wisconsin–Madison, corresponding author), Paul C West (Center for Sustainability and the Global Environment (SAGE), University of Wisconsin, Madison, WI 53726), Holly K Gibbs (0000-0001-8420-3259, Stanford University), Holly Gibbs (Stanford University), Chad Monfreda (Consortium for Science, Policy and Outcomes (CSPO), Arizona State University, Tempe, AZ 85287), John E Wagner (0000-0002-9394-3125, The Nature Conservancy), John Wagner (0000-0003-2266-0184, Wisconsin Program, The Nature Conservancy, Madison, WI 53703; and), Carol Barford (0000-0002-4941-8710, University of Wisconsin–Madison), Carol C Barford (Center for Sustainability and the Global Environment (SAGE), University of Wisconsin, Madison, WI 53726), R Carpenter (0000-0001-8097-8700, University of Wisconsin–Madison), Stephen R Carpenter (Center for Limnology, University of Wisconsin, Madison, WI 53706), Jonathan A Foley (Institute on the Environment (IonE), University of Minnesota, St. Paul, MN 55108)
Year2010
Volume107
Issue46
Pages19645-19648
Publication date2010-11-16
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0027-8424 • E-ISSN: 1091-6490
PublisherNational Academy of Sciences (PUBLISHER • US)
DOI10.1073/pnas.1011078107
PMID21041633
PMCIDPMC2993385
OpenAlexW2169497991
LanguageEN
Citations received66
References cited32

Expanding croplands to meet the needs of a growing population, changing diets, and biofuel production comes at the cost of reduced carbon stocks in natural vegetation and soils. Here, we present a spatially explicit global analysis of tradeoffs between carbon stocks and current crop yields. The difference among regions is striking. For example, for each unit of land cleared, the tropics lose nearly two times as much carbon (∼120 tons·ha −1 vs. ∼63 tons·ha −1 ) and produce less than one-half the annual crop yield compared with temperate regions (1.71 tons·ha −1 ·y −1 vs. 3.84 tons·ha −1 ·y −1 ). Therefore, newly cleared land in the tropics releases nearly 3 tons of carbon for every 1 ton of annual crop yield compared with a similar area cleared in the temperate zone. By factoring crop yield into the analysis, we specify the tradeoff between carbon stocks and crops for all areas where crops are currently grown and thereby, substantially enhance the spatial resolution relative to previous regional estimates. Particularly in the tropics, emphasis should be placed on increasing yields on existing croplands rather than clearing new lands. Our high-resolution approach can be used to determine the net effect of local land use decisions.

Agricultural land · Agriculture · Agroforestry · Agronomy · Biology · Carbon dioxide · Carbon fibers · Carbon sequestration · Clearance · Crop · Crop yield · Greenhouse gas · Temperate climate · Tropics · Yield (engineering) · Agriculture Sustainability and Environmental Impact · Ecology · Environmental Impact and Sustainability · Environmental Science · Land Use and Ecosystem Services · Mathematics

  • An integrated framework for sustainable development goals

    Open Access•David Grigg, Mark Stafford Smith et al.•Conservation Ecology•2014

  • Food-Carbon Trade-offs between Agriculture and Reforestation Land Uses under Alternate Market-based Policies

    Open Access•Stacey Paterson, Brett A Bryan•Conservation Ecology•2012

  • Cuál es la situación de la Ley de Bosques en la Región Chaqueña a diez años de su sanción? Revisar su pasado para discutir su futuro

    Open Access•Sebastián Aguiar, Matías E Mastrangelo et al.•Ecología Austral•2018

  • Beyond Inputs and Outputs

    Open Access•Karlheinz Erb, Karl-Heinz Erb et al.•Social Ecology•2016

  • Leverage points for improving global food security and the environment

    Open Access•Paul West, Paul C West et al.•Science•2014

  • Climate change mitigation through livestock system transitions

    Open Access•Peter Havlík, Petr Havlík et al.•Proceedings of the National…•2014

  • Yield Trends Are Insufficient to Double Global Crop Production by 2050

    Open Access•D K Ray, Nathaniel D Mueller et al.•PLoS ONE•2013

  • Lost food, wasted resources

    Open Access•Matti Kummu, Hans de Moel et al.•The Science of The Total…•2012

  • Trends in Global Agricultural Land Use

    Open Access•Navin Ramankutty, Zia Mehrabi et al.•Annual Review of Plant Biology•2018

  • Future threats to biodiversity and pathways to their prevention

    Open Access•D Tilman, Michael Clark et al.•Nature•2017

  • Unexpectedly large impact of forest management and grazing on global vegetation biomass

    Open Access•Karlheinz Erb, Thomas Kastner et al.•Nature•2018

  • Assessing the efficiency of changes in land use for mitigating climate change

    Open Access•Timothy D Searchinger, Stefan Wirsenius et al.•Nature•2018

  • Solutions for a cultivated planet

    Open Access•Jonathan A Foley, Josep Antoni Fluixà et al.•Nature•2011

  • Global land use change, economic globalization, and the looming land scarcity

    Open Access•Eric F Lambin, Patrick Meyfroidt•Proceedings of the National…•2011

  • Drivers of increasing global crop production

    Open Access•Linus Blomqvist, Luke A Yates et al.•Environmental Research Letters•2020

  • Achieving sustainable irrigation water withdrawals

    Open Access•Jing Liu, Thomas W Hertel et al.•Environmental Research Letters•2017

  • High-yield oil palm expansion spares land at the expense of forests in the Peruvian Amazon

    Open Access•Víctor Hugo Gutiérrez-Vélez, Ruth Defries et al.•Environmental Research Letters•2011

  • Increasing global crop harvest frequency

    Open Access•D K Ray, Jonathan A Foley•Environmental Research Letters•2013

  • Carbon emissions from cropland expansion in the United States

    Open Access•S Spawn, Tyler J Lark et al.•Environmental Research Letters•2019

  • Making environmental assessments of biomass production systems comparable worldwide

    Open Access•Markus A Meyer, Ralf Seppelt et al.•Environmental Research Letters•2016

  • Implementing land-based mitigation to achieve the Paris Agreement in Europe requires food system transformation

    Open Access•Heera Lee, Calum Brown et al.•Environmental Research Letters•2019

  • Increasing carbon footprint of grain crop production in the US Western Corn Belt

    Open Access•Chaoqun Lu, Zhen Yu et al.•Environmental Research Letters•2018

  • Climate adaptation as mitigation

    Open Access•David B Lobell, Uris Lantz C Baldos et al.•Environmental Research Letters•2013

  • The surprisingly small but increasing role of international agricultural trade on the European Union’s dependence on mineral phosphorus fertiliser

    Open Access•Thomas Nesme, Solène Roques et al.•Environmental Research Letters•2016

  • Impacts of tillage practices on soil carbon stocks in the US corn-soybean cropping system during 1998 to 2016

    Open Access•Zhen Yu, Chaoqun Lu et al.•Environmental Research Letters•2019

  • Pathways for recent Cerrado soybean expansion

    Open Access•Lucy S Nepstad, James Gerber et al.•Environmental Research Letters•2019

  • Trade-Off and Synergy among Ecosystem Services in the Guanzhong-Tianshui Economic Region of China

    Open Access•Keyu Qin, Jing Li et al.•International Journal of…•2015

  • Rewilding should be central to global restoration efforts

    Open Access•Jens-Christian Svenning•One Earth•2020

  • Three decades of landscape change across the largest peri-urban horticultural region of Argentina

    Carolina Baldini, Mariana Edith Marasas et al.•Journal of Environmental Planning…•2022

  • How can ecosystem services trade-offs/synergies help select the optimal cultivated land restoration pattern? A study based on multi-scenario simulations

    Open Access•Xian Zhao, Wei Sun et al.•Applied Geography•2025

  • Data and analysis toolbox for modeling the nexus of food, energy, and water

    Open Access•Mojtaba Sadegh, Amir AghaKouchak et al.•Sustainable Cities and Society•2020

  • Carbon Neutrality Prospects in Russian Agriculture under Shared Socioeconomic Pathways’ Scenarios

    Open Access•I Yu Ryabov, Elena Ponkina et al.•Regional Research of Russia•2025

  • Soil information in support of policy making and awareness raising

    Open Access•Jetske Bouma, Gabriele Broll et al.•Current Opinion in Environmental…•2012

  • Rapid adaptive modelling for policy support towards achieving Sustainable Development Goals

    Open Access•Amy Thomas, B J Cosby et al.•Environmental Science & Policy•2021

  • Functional land management

    Open Access•Rogier P O Schulte, Rachel Creamer et al.•Environmental Science & Policy•2013

  • A monitoring, reporting and verification system for low carbon agriculture

    Open Access•Bruno Benzaquen Perosa, Peter Newton et al.•Environmental Science & Policy•2023

  • Options for support to agriculture and food security under climate change

    Open Access•S Vermeulen, S J Vermeulen et al.•Environmental Science & Policy•2011

  • Redd + research

    Open Access•Richard S Mbatu•Forest Policy and Economics•2016

  • Agricultural production and greenhouse gas emissions from world regions—The major trends over 40 years

    Open Access•Eskild H Bennetzen, Pete Smith et al.•Global Environmental Change•2016

  • Transforming agricultural land use through marginal gains in the food system

    Open Access•Peter Alexander, A Raja Gopala Reddy et al.•Global Environmental Change•2019

  • Supply of carbon sequestration and biodiversity services from Australia's agricultural land under global change

    Open Access•Brett A Bryan, Martin Nolan et al.•Global Environmental Change•2014

  • Governing agriculture-forest landscapes to achieve climate change mitigation

    Open Access•Arun Agrawal, Eva Wollenberg et al.•Global Environmental Change•2014

  • Attaining food and environmental security in an era of globalization

    Open Access•Thomas W Hertel, Uris Lantz C Baldos•Global Environmental Change•2016

  • Biodiversity mediates relationships between anthropogenic drivers and ecosystem services across global mountain, island and delta systems

    Open Access•Martin O Reader, Maarten B Eppinga et al.•Global Environmental Change•2022

  • Globalized supply chains

    Open Access•Yankuic Galván-Miyoshi, Cynthia S Simmons et al.•Global Environmental Change•2022

  • Light-duty vehicle fleet electrification in the United States and its effects on global agricultural markets

    Open Access•Jerome Dumortier, Amani Elobeid et al.•Ecological Economics•2022

  • Does agricultural trade reduce pressure on land ecosystems? Decomposing drivers of the embodied human appropriation of net primary production

    Open Access•Nicolas Le Roux, Nicolas Roux et al.•Ecological Economics•2020

  • The natural capital framework for sustainably efficient and equitable decision making

    Open Access•Ian J Bateman, Georgina M Mace•Nature Sustainability•2020

  • Effects of profit-driven cropland expansion and conservation policies

    Open Access•Julia M Schneider, Ruth Delzeit et al.•Nature Sustainability•2024

  • The global cropland-sparing potential of high-yield farming

    Open Access•Christian Folberth, Nikolay Khabarov et al.•Nature Sustainability•2020

  • Reduced benefits of climate-smart agricultural policies from land-use spillovers

    Open Access•David B Lobell, Nelson B Villoria•Nature Sustainability•2023

  • The carbon opportunity cost of animal-sourced food production on land

    Open Access•Matthew Hayek, Helen Harwatt et al.•Nature Sustainability•2020

  • Humanosphere Potentiality Index

    Open Access•Takahiro Sato, Mario Lopez et al.•International Journal of Social…•2016

  • Land-use intensity mediates ecosystem service tradeoffs across regional social-ecological systems

    Open Access•Jiangxiao Qiu, Cibele Queiroz et al.•Ecosystems and People•2021

  • Harnessing genomic technologies for one health solutions in the tropics

    Open Access•Andrew Calcino, Ira Cooke et al.•Globalization and Health•2024

  • Socio-ecological resilience and environmental sustainability

    Open Access•Nadeem Khan, Nada Kakabadse et al.•International Journal of…•2021

  • Trading Land

    Open Access•A Schaffartzik, H Haberl et al.•Journal of Industrial Ecology•2015

  • Carbon Costs and Bushmeat Benefits of Hunting in Tropical Forests

    Open Access•Jedediah F Brodie•Ecological Economics•2018

  • Heterogeneity analysis of food supply-demand patterns and land carbon loss under different dietary structures in China

    Open Access•Ai Xiang, Xin Ye et al.•Land Use Policy•2024

  • Using spatially explicit data to improve our understanding of land supply responses

    Open Access•Nelson B Villoria, Jing Liu•Land Use Policy•2018

  • Urban, periurban and horticultural landscapes – Conflict and sustainable planning in La Plata district, Argentina

    Open Access•Carolina Baldini, Mariana Edith Marasas et al.•Land Use Policy•2022

  • Recultivating abandoned cropland intensifies the trade-off between climate change mitigation and food security within the Yangtze River Basin, China

    Open Access•Yuqiao Long, Jing Sun et al.•Land Use Policy•2025

  • Land use change and the carbon debt for sugarcane ethanol production in Brazil

    Open Access•Akenya Alkimim, Keith C Clarke•Land Use Policy•2018

  • Organizing anarchy

    Open Access•T K Rudel, Patrick Meyfroidt•Land Use Policy•2014

  • Attributing land-use change carbon emissions to exported biomass

    Open Access•Laura Saikku, Sampo Soimakallio et al.•Environmental Impact Assessment…•2012

  • Tropical grasslands

    Open Access•Maryline Boval, Valérie Angeon et al.•AMBIO•2017

  • Climate Change 2007

    Intergovernmental Panel On Climate Change, Intergovernmental Panel on Climate…•Climate Change 2007 - Mitigation…•2007

  • Understanding relationships among multiple ecosystem services

    Open Access•Edward M Bennett, Glen D Peterson et al.•Ecology Letters•2009

  • Environmental, economic, and energetic costs and benefits of biodiesel and ethanol biofuels

    Open Access•Jason Hill, Erik Nelson et al.•Proceedings of the National…•2006

  • Greenhouse gas mitigation by agricultural intensification

    Open Access•Jennifer A Burney, Steven J Davis et al.•Proceedings of the National…•2010

  • Biofuel Plantations on Forested Lands

    Open Access•Finn Danielsen, HENDRIEN BEUKEMA et al.•Conservation Biology•2009

  • Soil carbon stocks and land use change

    Open Access•L B Guo, Roger M Gifford•Global Change Biology•2002

  • Farming the planet

    Open Access•Chad Monfreda, Navin Ramankutty et al.•Global Biogeochemical Cycles•2008

  • The global distribution of cultivable lands

    Open Access•Navin Ramankutty, Jonathan A Foley et al.•Global Ecology and Biogeography•2002

  • Forecasting Agriculturally Driven Global Environmental Change

    Open Access•D Tilman, Joseph Fargione et al.•Science•2001

  • Land Clearing and the Biofuel Carbon Debt

    Open Access•Joseph Fargione, Jason Hill et al.•Science•2008

  • CO2 emissions from forest loss

    Open Access•Guido R van der Werf, Douglas C Morton et al.•Nature Geoscience•2009

  • Agricultural Intensification and Ecosystem Properties

    Open Access•Pamela A Matson, W J Parton et al.•Science•1997

  • Farming the planet

    Open Access•Navin Ramankutty, Amato T Evan et al.•Global Biogeochemical Cycles•2008

  • Contributions to accelerating atmospheric CO 2 growth from economic activity, carbon intensity, and efficiency of natural sinks

    Open Access•Josep G Canadell, Corinne Le Quéré et al.•Proceedings of the National…•2007

  • Science for managing ecosystem services

    Open Access•R Carpenter, Stephen R Carpenter et al.•Proceedings of the National…•2009

  • Farming and the Fate of Wild Nature

    Open Access•Rhys E Green, Stephen J Cornell et al.•Science•2005

  • Tropical forests were the primary sources of new agricultural land in the 1980s and 1990s

    Open Access•Holly K Gibbs, A S Ruesch et al.•Proceedings of the National…•2010

  • Global Consequences of Land Use

    Open Access•Jonathan A Foley, Ruth Defries et al.•Science•2005

  • Protecting climate with forests

    Open Access•Robert B Jackson, James T Randerson et al.•Environmental Research Letters•2008

  • Carbon payback times for crop-based biofuel expansion in the tropics

    Open Access•Holly K Gibbs, Holly Gibbs et al.•Environmental Research Letters•2008

  • Monitoring and estimating tropical forest carbon stocks

    Open Access•Holly K Gibbs, Holly Gibbs et al.•Environmental Research Letters•2007

Unique citing works66
Citations per year4,4
Citation span2011 - 2025 (15)
Citation velocityrecent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 63

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae