Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

The paradox of police violence in democratic Brazil

Bibliographic Data

ID2402168
AuthorsTeresa Pires Do Rio Caldeira (0000-0002-7737-7522, University of California, Irvine, corresponding author), Teresa Caldeira (corresponding author), Teresa Pr Caldeira
Year2002
Volume3
Issue3
Pages235-263
Publication date2002-09-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueEthnography (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 1466-1381 • E-ISSN: 1741-2714
PublisherSAGE Publications Inc (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1177/146613802401092742
OpenAlexW2004709111
LanguageEN
Citations received81
References cited6

This article addresses some of the main challenges to the democratic reform of police institutions in Brazil, particularly in São Paulo. It identifies and explores patterns of police abuse through an analysis of a famous kidnapping together with the field observations, interviews and available statistical evidence. It analyses the sources and logic of popular support for a `violent police', which coexists with a negative evaluation of the police and a high victimization of working-class people. It argues that the roots of this paradox are found in a long history of state disrespect for civil rights, in particular poor people's rights, and in a deep disbelief in the fairness of the justice system and its ability to function without bias

Criminology · Democracy · Economic Justice · Field (mathematics · Function (biology · Inequality · Political science · Politics · Sociology · State (computer science · Crime Patterns and Interventions · Crime, Illicit Activities, and Governance · Law · Policing Practices and Perceptions

  • Notes on law and police occupational culture in Brazil’s Military Polices

    Open Access•Julia Maia Goldani•Oñati Socio-legal Series•2021

  • Urban Risks and Violence

    Open Access•Nicolás Dallorso, Nicolás Santiago Dallorso•The Wiley Blackwell Encyclopedia…•2019

  • Police Unlimited

    Paul Mutsaers•Public Anthropology of Policing•2019

  • Governing Delinquency Through Freedom

    Open Access•Géraldine Bugnon, Lucy Garnier•Governing Delinquency Through…•2020

  • Contesting repression in divided democracies

    Open Access•Yanilda González, Natán Skigin•American Journal of Political…•2026

  • Technologies of Invisibility

    João B Biehl, João Biehl•Anthropologies of Modernity•2005

  • Personalizing the State

    Open Access•I Koch, Insa Lee Koch•Personalizing the State•2018

  • ‘It’s a Matter of Land’

    Open Access•Ragini Saira Malhotra•Urbanisation•2023

  • The Spatial Concentration and Dispersion of Homicide during a Period of Homicide Increase in Brazil

    Open Access•Spencer P Chainey, Franklin Almeida•ISPRS International Journal of…•2021

  • Corruption and Trust in Police

    Open Access•Mahesh K Nalla, Yongjae Nam•International Journal of Offender…•2021

  • Exploring the multilevel nature of police confidence in Brazil

    Open Access•Carlos Solar•The Police Journal Theory…•2023

  • Explaining citizen support for women police in India

    Mahesh K Nalla, Yongjae Nam•Police Practice and Research•2020

  • Authoritarian Police in Democracy

    Open Access•Yanilda María González, Yanilda González•Authoritarian Police in Democracy•2020

  • La Sociología del crimen y la violencia en América Latina

    Open Access•Arturo Alvarado Mendoza•Tempo Social•2020

  • Antagonistic Authorities and the Civil Police in São Paulo, Brazil

    Open Access•G D Willis•Latin American Research Review•2014

  • The Permeable Olympic Fortress

    Open Access•Dennis Pauschinger•Conflict and Society•2020

  • Two processes of dehumanization

    Open Access•A Nassauer•Ethnic and Racial Studies•2024

  • Citizenship and the Social Geography of Deep Neo-Liberalization

    Open Access•John Gledhill•Anthropologica•2005

  • Por que é tão difícil reformar democraticamente as polícias militares brasileiras

    Open Access•Julia Maia Goldani•Dilemas - Revista de Estudos de…•2024

  • Evade, Corrupt, or Confront? Organized Crime and the State in Brazil and Mexico

    Open Access•J Bailey, Matthew M Taylor•Journal of Politics in Latin…•2009

  • Shattered trust

    Open Access•Giordano Morangueira Magri, Flávio Eiró•Journal of Legal Anthropology•2024

  • Criminal Politics

    Open Access•Nancy Barnes, Nicholas Barnes•Perspectives on Politics•2017

  • Repensando a Violência Policial no Brasil

    Open Access•Jan Hoffman French•Revista TOMO•2017

  • Toward a Dictatorship Over the Poor

    Open Access•L Wacquant•Punishment & Society•2003

  • Perceptions of moralizing agents and cooperative behavior in Northeastern Brazil

    M Soler, B G Purzycki et al.•Religion Brain & Behavior•2022

  • La mala administración de la seguridad pública

    Open Access•John Gledhill•Revista de Antropología Social•2013

  • Homicide investigation in the Global South

    Rafael Alcadipani, Edward Maguire et al.•Policing & Society•2025

  • Performances of Police Legitimacy in Rio's Hyper Favela

    Open Access•Erika Robb Larkins•Law & Social Inquiry•2013

  • O que é que se passa no tabernáculo? Oração e espacialização na igreja tokoista angolana

    Open Access•R L Blanes•Religião & Sociedade•2009

  • The Divergence of Democratic Policing

    Open Access•Soniya Wazed, Jinea Akhtar•Sociology and Anthropology•2015

  • Securitization, mafias and violence in Brazil and Mexico

    J Gledhill•Global Discourse•2018

  • Preventing Human Rights Violations 'From the Inside

    Danielle Celermajer, Kiran Grewal•Journal of Human Rights Practice•2013

  • Minor narratives

    Open Access•P A Zoettl•International journal of law,…•2016

  • Police legitimacy, ideology and qualitative methods

    Open Access•Diarmaid Harkin•Criminology & Criminal Justice•2015

  • Human Rights and Policing

    Open Access•Julia Hornberger•Annual Review of Law and Social…•2010

  • Chicago Police Torture and the Limits of Human Rights Enforcement in Liberal Democracies

    Open Access•Mark S Berlin•Perspectives on Politics•2024

  • Uma Outra Pena De Morte

    Open Access•Luiz Dal Santo•Revista Direito Estado e Sociedade•2020

  • Dangerous Spaces of Citizenship

    Open Access•James Holston•Planning Theory•2009

  • Moving beyond punitivism

    Open Access•I Koch•Punishment & Society•2016

  • The epistemic power of the police

    Open Access•Magda Boutros•Theoretical Criminology•2024

  • The police and punishment

    Open Access•Diarmaid Harkin, Diarmaid M Harkin•Theoretical Criminology•2014

  • Policing following political and social transitions

    Open Access•Matthew Light, Mariana Mota Prado et al.•Theoretical Criminology•2015

  • Police reform and the problem of trust

    Open Access•Andrew Goldsmith•Theoretical Criminology•2005

  • Forging a Modern Democratic Imaginary

    Jong Bum Kwon•positions asia critique•2014

  • Policing as social control

    Open Access•Kamau Wairuri•Policing & Society•2025

  • Serving States and Serving Citizens

    Elizabeth Leeds•Policing & Society•2007

  • Community policing’s extended military history

    Markus M Müller, Markus-Michael Müller et al.•Policing & Society•2020

  • Police worker politics in India, Brasil, and beyond

    Beatrice Jauregui•Policing & Society•2022

  • He said he was going to kill me

    Open Access•Daryl Paul Evans, Nancy DeSousa et al.•Journal of Comparative Social Work•2018

  • Dilemmas of substitution

    Lucía Tiscornia, Verónica Pérez Bentancur•Journal of Urban Affairs•2022

  • Policing Development

    Open Access•Tony Roshan Samara•Urban Studies•2010

  • Police legitimacy and procedural justice among young Brazilian adolescents

    Open Access•Herbert Rodrigues, Justin C Medina•The British Journal of Criminology•2021

  • Police and racial identity formation

    Open Access•Morgan Olive-Carmellini•Identities•2026

  • Natural Hegemonies

    Matthew Wolf‐meyer, Matthew Wolf-Meyer•Current Anthropology•2011

  • The Social Origins of Institutional Weakness and Change

    Open Access•Yanilda González•World Politics•2019

  • Executive Constraints and Repression in Democratic Contexts

    Open Access•Anna Elizabeth Mackin•Political Research Quarterly•2016

  • Reforming to Avoid Reform

    Open Access•Yanilda González•Perspectives on Politics•2023

  • Love is over, this is going to be Turkey

    Batuhan Eren•Social movement studies•2025

  • Urban violence and the militarisation of security

    Kristian Hoelscher, Per M Norheim-Martinsen•Small Wars and Insurgencies•2014

  • A resposta judicial para homicídios envolvendo policiais no Brasil

    Ludmila Mendonça Lopes Ribeiro, Ludmila Ribeiro et al.•Canadian Journal of Latin…•2016

  • Oportunidades perdidas

    Open Access•Marcelo Ryngelblum, Maria F T Peres•Cadernos de Saude Publica•2025

  • Crime Prevention and the Coproduction of Security

    Open Access•María Paz Trebilcock, Alejandra Luneke•Latin American Perspectives•2019

  • Fear and legitimacy in São Paulo, Brazil

    Open Access•Jonathan Jackson, Krisztián Pósch et al.•Law & Society Review•2022

  • Capability Failures and Corrosive Disadvantage in a Violent Rainforest Metropolis

    Open Access•Mariana Piva Da Silva, James Angus Fraser et al.•Geographical Review•2023

  • Police killings and the vicissitudes of borders and bounding orders in Mathare, Nairobi

    Open Access•Naomi Van Stapele•Environment and Planning D…•2020

  • I stick to this side of the park

    Open Access•Luciana Lang, Ian Mell•Environment and Planning E Nature…•2020

  • Legal cynicism, intrusive policing, and the dynamics of police legitimacy

    Open Access•Thiago R Oliveira•Law & Society Review•2025

  • God Even Blessed Me with Less Money

    Open Access•George St Clair•Journal of Latin American Studies•2017

  • Policing, Democratic Participation, and the Reproduction of Asymmetric Citizenship

    Open Access•Yanilda González, Lindsay Mayka•American Political Science Review•2023

  • Observing the Everyday

    Ilana Feldman•Interventions•2007

  • Participation as a Safety Valve

    Open Access•Yanilda María González, Yanilda González•Latin American Politics and Society•2019

  • Rethinking Police Violence in Brazil

    Open Access•Jan Hoffman French•Latin American Politics and Society•2013

  • The Exceptional Prison

    Samira Bueno, G D Willis et al.•Public Culture•2019

  • Life of the mind

    Open Access•João B Biehl, João Biehl•American Ethnologist•2004

  • Police violence in West Africa

    Open Access•J Beek, Maira Hayat et al.•Ethnography•2013

  • Obstetrics in a Time of Violence

    Open Access•Lydia Zacher Dixon•Medical Anthropology Quarterly•2015

  • The Cross Politics of Ecuador's Penal State

    Open Access•Chris Garces•Cultural Anthropology•2010

  • Global Customs Regimes and the Traffic in Sovereignty

    B Chalfin•Current Anthropology•2006

  • Fear and Intimacy

    Martijn Koster•Ethnos•2014

  • Permissive Space and Policing Practices in Mathare and Kaptembwo, Kenya

    Patrick Mutahi•African Studies•2024

  • Thugs, Spies and Vigilantes

    Open Access•Marco Di Nunzio•Africa•2014

  • Edge of the knife

    Paul Chevigny•Edge of the knife•1995

  • City of Walls

    Teresa Caldeira, Teresa P R Caldeira•City of Walls•2000

  • The Future of Policing

    Open Access•David H Bayley, Clifford D Shearing et al.•Law & Society Review•1996

  • Violência fatal

    Open Access•Paulo S Pinheiro, Eduardo A Izumino et al.•Revista USP•1991

  • Democracia e violência

    Open Access•Angelina Peralva•Lua Nova Revista de Cultura e…•1997

  • Democracy and Violence in Brazil

    Open Access•Teresa P R Caldeira, James Holston•Comparative Studies in Society…•1999

Unique citing works81
Citations per year3,52
Citation span2003 - 2026 (24)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 81

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae