Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

The dimensions of topiccomment

Bibliographic Data

ID3988692
AuthorsJoachim Jacobs (0000-0003-1669-1232, corresponding author)
Year2001
Volume39
Issue4
Publication date2001-01-03
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueLinguistics (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0024-3949 • E-ISSN: 1613-396X
PublisherWalter de Gruyter GmbH (PUBLISHER • DE)
DOI10.1515/ling.2001.027
OpenAlexW2576720793
LanguageEN
Citations received74
References cited23

This paper argues that the common denominator of topic–comment (TC) constructions in natural languages is not a single functional feature (e.g. aboutness) but rather the fact that they share some salient semantic attri-butes with prototypical examples of TC. The paper tries to disentangle these prototypical semantic attributes of TC and then shows, mainly refer-ring to examples from German, that diVerent TC constructions are charac-terized by diVerent combinations of these attributes and therefore cannot be analyzed properly by unitary theories of TC function. 1

Linguistics · Sociology · Discourse Analysis in Language Studies · Language, Discourse, Communication Strategies · Language, Metaphor, and Cognition · Philosophy · Psychology

  • Contrastive topics decomposed

    Open Access•Michael Wagner•Semantics and Pragmatics•2012

  • Issues on topics

    Open Access•Klaus Schwabe, Kerstin Schwabe et al.•ZAS Papers in Linguistics•2000

  • Competing constraints on Vorfeldbesetzung in German

    Open Access•Augustin Speyer•ZAS Papers in Linguistics•2004

  • Expression of information structure in the Bantu language Northern Sotho

    Open Access•Sabine Zerbian•ZAS Papers in Linguistics•2006

  • Syntactic requirements on adjuncts

    Open Access•Werner Frey•ZAS Papers in Linguistics•2000

  • Satztopik und Diskurstopik in Elaboration-Kontexten

    Open Access•Michael Grabski•ZAS Papers in Linguistics•2000

  • Topicality and differential object marking

    Giorgio Iemmolo•Studies in Language•2010

  • Variation Im Europäischen Kontrast

    Cathrine Fabricius‐Hansen, Martine Dalmas et al.•Variation Im Europäischen Kontrast•2016

  • Quantifier‐Float

    Open Access•Gema Chocano, Esther Torrego•The Wiley Blackwell Companion to…•2017

  • Cross-Linguistic Variation and Efficiency

    Open Access•John A Hawkins•Cross-Linguistic Variation and…•2014

  • The Oxford Handbook of Information Structure

    Caroline Fery, Shinichiro Ishihara•Oxford Handbook of Information…•2016

  • The Oxford Handbook of Ergativity

    Jessica Coon, Diane Massam et al.•The Oxford Handbook of Ergativity•2017

  • Verum Focus

    Horst Lohnstein•Oxford Handbook of Information…•2015

  • Information Structure in Slavic

    Katja Jasinskaja•Oxford Handbook of Information…•2014

  • Information Structure and Discourse Particles

    Patrick Georg Grosz•Oxford Handbook of Information…•2015

  • Indo-European syntax and pragmatics

    Open Access•Eirik Welo•Oslo Studies in Language•1970

  • Latin Word Order

    A M Devine, Laurence D Stephens•Latin word order•2006

  • Über die syntaktische Position der Satztopiks im Deutschen

    Open Access•Werner Frey•ZAS Papers in Linguistics•2000

  • On the Position and Interpretation of Locative Modifiers

    Open Access•Claudia Maienborn•Natural Language Semantics•2001

  • Mehrfache Vorfeldbesetzung und Informationsstruktur

    Felix Bildhauer•Deutsche Sprache•2011

  • The Linearity of Verb Copying Cleft Construction in Chinese

    Open Access•Moying Li, Lian Zhang•Journal of Language Teaching and…•2021

  • Des-, Mata- Ja Maks-Konverbitarindi Inforoll

    Open Access•Carl Eric Simmul•Eesti ja soome-ugri keeleteaduse…•2021

  • Recomplementation in Old Spanish – que as a Versatile Pragmatic Marker

    KRISTIN HAGEMANN, Kristin Føsker Hagemann•Bulletin of Hispanic Studies•2020

  • Forma e função das construções de tópico-comentário no Jornal Nacional

    Open Access•Lou-Ann Kleppa•Revista Investigações•2022

  • The intangible demonstrative yu- in Hup

    Open Access•Luiza de Moura Alves, Laura Becker et al.•Language Typology and Universals•2025

  • Can you retrieve it

    Open Access•Chiara Calderone•Sign Language & Linguistics•2021

  • Information structure of converb constructions

    Open Access•Carl Eric Simmul•Folia Linguistica•2024

  • Focused Topics in Hungarian

    Open Access•Zsuzsanna Gécseg•Studia Linguistica•2020

  • Extraction from subjects

    Open Access•Alexis Abeille, Barbara Hemforth et al.•Cognition•2020

  • Discourse-related expletives

    Open Access•Hannah Booth, Kim A Groothuis•Open Linguistics•2024

  • How large is the left periphery of Present-Day German? A unifying approach to multiply-filled-prefield configurations

    Open Access•Nicholas Catasso•Open Linguistics•2021

  • Conditional conjunctions informed by Japanese and Korean

    Magdalena Kaufmann, John Whitman•Linguistics Vanguard•2022

  • Cognitive foundations of topic-comment and foreground-background structures

    Open Access•Elisabeth Engberg-Pedersen•Cognitive Linguistics•2011

  • Topic chains in dialogues

    Open Access•Aria Adli•Journal of Pragmatics•2019

  • Information structure in Korean

    Open Access•Chongwon Park, Jaehoon Yeon•Journal of Pragmatics•2023

  • Information structure without topic and focus

    Pavel Ozerov•Studies in Language•2015

  • The psycholinguistic realization of topic in Chinese

    Open Access•Liulin Zhang•Studies in Language•2024

  • Symmetries and asymmetries

    John A Hawkins•Theoretical Linguistics•2002

  • Focus and contrastive topic in questions and answers, with particular reference to Turkish

    Beste Kamali, Manfred Krifka•Theoretical Linguistics•2020

  • Decomposing the aboutness condition for Chinese topic constructions

    Jianhua Hu, Haihua Pan•The Linguistic Review•2009

  • The prosodic marking of topical referents in the German “Vorfeld” by children and adults

    Laura E De Ruiter, Laura de Ruiter•The Linguistic Review•2009

  • Focus as prosodic alignment

    Open Access•Caroline Fery•Natural Language and Linguistic…•2013

  • The information structure of French il y a clefts and c'est clefts

    Open Access•Lena Karssenberg, Karen Lahousse•Linguistics•2018

  • Pragmatic Properties of Certain German and English Left Peripheral Constructions

    Open Access•Werner Frey•Linguistics•2005

  • Basic notions of information structure

    Open Access•Manfred Krifka•Acta Linguistica Hungarica•2008

  • When Swedes begin to learn German

    Open Access•Ute Bohnacker•Second language Research•2006

  • Information structural notions and the fallacy of invariant correlates

    Open Access•Caroline Fery•Acta Linguistica Hungarica•2008

  • Die Bedeutung der Centering Theory für Fragen der Vorfeldbesetzung im Deutschen

    Open Access•Augustin Speyer•Zeitschrift für Sprachwissenschaft•2007

  • Topic drop in German

    Open Access•Lisa Schäfer•Zeitschrift für Sprachwissenschaft•2021

  • Komma & Co

    Open Access•Ursula Bredel, Beatrice Primus•Zeitschrift für Sprachwissenschaft•2007

  • Structural topic marking

    Open Access•Sophie Repp•Lingua•2016

  • Investigating the role of information structure triggers

    Open Access•Jutta Hartmann, Jutta M Hartmann et al.•Lingua•2013

  • The syntactic flexibility of German and English idioms

    Open Access•Marta Wierzba, J M M Brown et al.•Journal of Linguistics•2023

  • A dynamic account of verb doubling cleft construction in Chinese

    Open Access•Xiaolong Yang, Yicheng Wu•Language Sciences•2017

  • Texte argumentatif et structures syntaxiques en Moyen Français

    Bernard Combettes•Linx•2002

  • Topic marking in Kusaal and selected Mabia (Gur) languages of West Africa

    Open Access•Hasiyatu Abubakari•Linguistics•2021

  • Selectives (“topic markers”) on subordinate clauses

    Open Access•Bernhard Wälchli•Linguistics•2022

  • When subjects frame the clause

    Open Access•Eva Schultze-Berndt•Linguistics•2022

  • Is Hong Kong Sign Language a topic-prominent language

    Open Access•Felix Sze•Linguistics•2015

  • About what about

    Open Access•Wenshan Li, Jiang Liu•Linguistics•2023

  • Grammatical innovation in multiethnic urban Europe

    Open Access•Heike Wiese•Lingua•2009

  • Can Korean -(n)un mark (contrastive) focus

    Open Access•Ilkyu Kim•Language Sciences•2016

  • Information Structure, Discourse Structure, and Noun Phrase Position in Kiowa

    Daniel Harbour, Laurel J Watkins et al.•International Journal of American…•2012

  • Is Korean -(n)un a topic marker? On the nature of -(n)un and its relation to information structure

    Open Access•Ilkyu Kim•Lingua•2015

  • Ancient Greek Infinitives and Phases

    Open Access•Christina Sevdali•Syntax•2013

  • Time for a change? The semantics and pragmatics of marking temporal progression in an Australian language

    Open Access•Marie-Eve Ritz, Eva Schultze-Berndt•Lingua•2015

  • Symmetric Merge and Local Instability

    Open Access•Dana Ott, Dennis Ott•Syntax•2015

  • Focus in Georgian and the expression of contrast

    Open Access•Stavros Skopetea, Gisbert Fanselow•Lingua•2010

  • Dynamic formulation in Functional Discourse Grammar

    Open Access•Kees Hengeveld, Niels Smit•Lingua•2009

  • Coherence in new urban dialects

    Open Access•Heike Wiese, Ines Rehbein•Lingua•2016

  • On the discourse function of particles in post-initial position

    Open Access•Elena Karagjosova•Lingua•2012

  • Accentual preferences and predictability

    Open Access•Elisabeth Verhoeven, Frank Kügler•Lingua•2015

  • Construções de tópico-comentário no Jornal Nacional

    Open Access•Lou-Ann Kleppa•Cadernos de Linguística e Teoria…•2020

  • Double subjects and verbal demonstrations

    Open Access•William Salmon•Journal of Pragmatics•2010

  • Givenness, Contrastiveness, Definiteness, Subjects, Topics, and Point of View

    Wallace L Chafe, Wallace Chafe•Subject and Topic•2026

  • Universals of topic-comment structure

    Jeanette K Gundel, Jeanette Κ Gundel•Studies in syntactic typology•1988

  • The Logical Form of Action Sentences

    Donald Davidson•The Logic of Decision and Action•1967

  • Assertion

    Robert C Stalnaker•Pragmatics•1978

  • Information Structure and Sentence Form

    Open Access•Knud Lambrecht•Information Structure and…•1994

  • An Introduction to Functional Grammar

    M A K Halliday, Μ Α Κ Halliday et al.•Introduction to Functional Grammar•2014

  • Verben, Ereignisse und das Lexikon

    Stefan Engelberg•Verben, Ereignisse und das Lexikon•2000

  • Satzinitiale Voranstellungen im gesprochenen Deutsch als Mittel der Themensteuerung und Referenzkonstitution

    Hannes Scheutz•Syntax des Gesprochenen Deutsch•1997

  • Formen der "Herausstellung" im Deutschen

    Hans Altmann•Formen der Herausstellung Im…•1981

  • A modular approach to the grammar of additive particles

    M Reis•Journal of Semantics•1997

  • Über die syntaktische Position der Satztopiks im Deutschen

    Open Access•Werner Frey•ZAS Papers in Linguistics•2000

  • Syntax und Semantik der Negation im Deutschen

    Open Access•Jack Hoeksema, Joachim Jacobs•Language•1987

  • Pragmatics and Linguistics

    Open Access•Tanya Reinhart•Philosophica•1981

  • A Course in Modern Linguistics

    Open Access•Charles F Hockett•Language Learning•1958

  • Thematic Proto-Roles and Argument Selection

    David R Dowty, David Dowty•Language•1991

  • The Structure of the Japanese Language

    Noriko A Mccawley, Susumu Kuno•Language•1976

Unique citing works74
Citations per year1,32
Citation span1970 - 2025 (56)
Citation velocityrecent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 67

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae