Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Autonomy of migration in the light of deportation. Ethnographic and theoretical accounts of entangled appropriations of voluntary returns from Morocco

Bibliographic Data

ID4476789
AuthorsAnissa Maâ (0000-0002-2286-9212, Université libre de Bruxelles, Belgium; University of Oxford, UK, corresponding author)
Year2023
Volume41
Issue1
Pages92-109
Publication date2023-02-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueEnvironment and Planning D Society and Space (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0263-7758 • E-ISSN: 1472-3433
PublisherSAGE Publications Inc (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1177/02637758221140885
OpenAlexW4315640561
LanguageEN
Citations received12
References cited68

The intricate relationship between border control and migrations is the core puzzle of this paper, which takes voluntary returns from Morocco as a case study and autonomy of migration (AoM) as a theoretical framework. More precisely, the paper examines voluntary returns from the perspective of migrants themselves to grasp border control through the lens of its disputed, distorted and sometimes subverted implementation. The paper draws on data collected during fieldwork conducted between 2016 and 2018 in Morocco, including ethnographic observations and interviews with staff from the International Organisation for Migration (IOM), migrants and local intermediaries. It focuses on the case of sub-Saharan migrants leaving Morocco through "Assisted Voluntary Return and Reintegration" programmes led by IOM and confronts empirical data with the AoM theoretical framework. The paper demonstrates that migrants' entangled appropriations of return are defined in close relationship with a wide range of actors intervening during the process of return. Ultimately, migrants reformulate the meaning of their involvement in voluntary return into strategic, moral, relative, and symbolic terms. However, these entangled appropriations of a deportation device simultaneously reinforce social norms and institutional regulations underlying migration dynamics and border control. Eventually, the paper draws conclusions on the political effects of migrants' entangled appropriation of a deportation device on the production of intertwined im/mobility regimes between the Mediterranean and sub-Saharan Africa

Appropriation · Autonomy · Deportation · Economics · Ethnography · Immigration · Intermediary · Political economy · Political science · Politics · Sociology · African Studies and Geopolitics · Law · Migration and Labor Dynamics · Migration, Refugees, and Integration

  • Négocier l’éloignement au quotidien. Le rôle ambivalent des migrants et des intermédiaires dans les « retours volontaires » depuis le Maroc

    Anissa Maâ•Métropolitiques•2023

  • Internal Deportation

    Open Access•Ali Bhagat, Ayushman Bhagat•Area•2026

  • Migración "extrarregional" como categoría racial. Gobernanza migratoria y "tránsitos sur-norte" en Sudamérica y Mesoamérica

    Open Access•C Trabalón•Si Somos Americanos•2024

  • Border and im/mobility entanglements in the Mediterranean

    Open Access•Beste Işleyen, Nora El Qadim•Environment and Planning D…•2023

  • The autonomy of migration as travelling theory

    Open Access•Ali Bhagat•Environment and Planning D…•2025

  • Migration aspirations in relation to border closures, employment opportunities and risk-taking attitudes

    Open Access•Eda Kiriscioglu, Aysen Ustubici et al.•New Community•2024

  • It takes courage to return

    Open Access•Sylvain Barone•New Community•2025

  • A "Migrantisation" of Borderwork? Emergence, Work Status, and Careers of Peer Intermediaries in Morocco's Migration Industry

    Open Access•Anissa Maâ•Cahiers d études africaines•2024

  • Widening the net of immigration control

    Laure Deschuyteneer•New Community•2025

  • An "Indigenous" Migration Control? Coloniality and Contrasting Effects of Peer-to-Peer Intermediation in the Implementation of Voluntary Returns from Morocco

    Open Access•Anissa Maâ, Alexandra Poméon O’Neill et al.•Revue européenne des migrations…•2023

  • Un contrôle migratoire « indigène » ? Colonialité et effets contrastés de l'intermédiation par les pairs dans la mise en œuvre des retours volontaires depuis le Maroc

    Open Access•Anissa Maâ•Revue européenne des migrations…•2023

  • A Humanitarian and Imperial Return

    Ampson Hagan•Transforming Anthropology•2024

  • Entry Denied

    Eithne Luibhéid•Entry Denied•2010

  • « La morgue, la forêt et le presbytère ». Articulations entre expérience migratoire et violence des frontières dans le Nord du Maroc

    Open Access•Anissa Maâ•Les Cahiers d’EMAM•2022

  • Hope and Uncertainty in Contemporary African Migration

    Open Access•Nauja Kleist, Dorte Thorsen•Hope and Uncertainty in…•2016

  • Les damnées de la mer

    Camille Schmoll•Les damnées de la mer•2020

  • Autonomy of Migration

    Stephan Scheel•Autonomy of Migration?•2019

  • The Borders of "Europe"

    Open Access•Nicholas De Genova•Borders of Europe•2017

  • Moving beyond refugees and migrants

    Open Access•Annick Pijnenburg, Conny Rijken•Interventions•2021

  • Intégration symbolique à Fès et ancrages sur l’ailleurs

    Open Access•Johara Berriane•L Année du Maghreb•2014

  • Appropriating mobility and bordering Europe through romantic love

    Stephan Scheel•Migration Studies•2017

  • We must do it gently.’ The contested implementation of the IOM’s migration management in Morocco

    Irena Bartels, Inken Bartels•Migration Studies•2017

  • Not Just a Personal Decision

    Open Access•Elin Berstad Mortensen•African Diaspora•2014

  • Mobile transmigrants’ or ‘unsettled returnees’? myth of return and permanent resettlement among Senegalese migrants

    Open Access•Giulia Sinatti•Population Space and Place•2010

  • La migration empêchée et la survie économique

    Anaïk Pian•Cahiers du Genre•2010

  • Aimer et contrôler son prochain » ? Imbrications négociées des logiques compassionnelle et sécuritaire chez les acteurs confessionnels chrétiens dans l’industrie migratoire marocaine

    Sophie Bava, Anissa Maâ•Critique internationale•2022

  • Can Migrants do the (Border)Work? Conflicting Dynamics and Effects of “Peer-to-peer” Intermediation in North and West Africa

    Anissa Maâ, Julia Van Dessel et al.•Journal of Borderlands Studies•2022

  • L'aventurier, une figure de la migration africaine

    Sylvie Bredeloup•Cahiers internationaux de…•2008

  • What Determines the Embeddedness of Forced-Return Migrants? Rethinking the Role of Pre- and Post-Return Assistance

    Open Access•Ruerd Ruben, Marieke Van Houte et al.•International Migration Review•2009

  • Riding Routes and Itinerant Borders

    Open Access•M Casas-Cortes, Sebastian Cobarrubia et al.•Antipode•2015

  • Return Schemes from European Countries

    Open Access•Giulia Scalettaris, Flore Gubert•International Migration•2018

  • Héros du retour

    Eliane De Latour•Critique internationale•2003

  • Expansion et sous-traitance des logiques d’enfermement de l’Union européenne

    Abdelkrim Belguendouz•Cultures & conflits/Cultures et…•2005

  • Navigating the migration industry

    Open Access•J Schapendonk•New Community•2017

  • Non-Voluntary Return? The Politics of Return to Afghanistan

    Open Access•Brad K Blitz, Rosemary Sales et al.•Political Studies•2005

  • Joining the UN Family

    Open Access•Megan Bradley•Global Governance A Review of…•2021

  • Le retour incertain d’Aya et de Prince ». Penser l'incertitude et l'intermédiation des retours volotaires à partir d'une trajectoire féminine en instance de départ depuis le Maroc

    Open Access•Anissa Maâ•Emulations - Revue de sciences…•2020

  • The Right to Maim

    J K Puar•Right to Maim•2017

  • Migrants congolais en route vers l'Europe

    Élie Goldschmidt•Les Temps Modernes•2002

  • Aventuriers ou orphelins de la migration internationale

    Mahamet Timera•Politique africaine•2009

  • Morocco's new migration policy

    Sara Benjelloun•The Journal of North African…•2021

  • Manufacturing collaboration in the deportation field

    Anissa Maâ•The Journal of North African…•2021

  • Crafting a 'liberal monarchy

    Open Access•Katharina Natter•The Journal of North African…•2021

  • Studying embodied encounters

    Stephan Scheel•Postcolonial Studies•2013

  • The deportation continuum

    B Kalir, Lieke Wissink et al.•Citizenship Studies•2016

  • Contained and abandoned in the "humane" border

    Open Access•Leslie Gross-Wyrtzen•Environment and Planning D…•2020

  • Trans-frontieres

    Open Access•Nancy L Green•Socio-anthropologie•1999

  • Signer la déportation

    Open Access•Anissa Maâ•Terrain•2019

  • Humanitarianism and black female bodies

    Elsa Tyszler•The Journal of North African…•2021

  • Immigration and Pensée d'Etat

    Myriam Cherti, Michael Collyer•The Journal of North African…•2015

  • Sub-Saharan students in Morocco

    Johara Berriane•The Journal of North African…•2015

  • Introduction

    Mohamed Berriane, Hein De Haas et al.•The Journal of North African…•2015

  • Sub-Saharan leaders in Morocco's migration industry

    Cynthia Magallanes-Gonzalez•The Journal of North African…•2021

  • Autonomy of Migration and the Radical Imagination

    Open Access•Philippa Metcalfe•Geopolitics•2022

  • Political Activism Between Journey and Settlement

    Aysen Ustubici•Geopolitics•2016

  • Deaths, Borders, and the Exception

    Open Access•Lorena Gazzotti•American Behavioral Scientist•2020

  • No place like home? The International Organization for Migration and the new political imaginary of deportation

    Shoshana Fine, William Walters•New Community•2022

  • Raconte-moi ta migration

    Open Access•Annalisa Maitilasso•Cahiers d études africaines•2014

  • Containment through mobility

    Martina Tazzioli•New Community•2018

  • Performing freedom in the Dutch deportation regime

    Laura Cleton, Sébastien Chauvin•New Community•2020

  • The Politics and Discourse of Migrant Return

    Anne Koch•New Community•2014

  • Some Reflections on Structure and Agency in Migration Theory

    Oliver Bakewell•New Community•2010

  • The conceptual limits of the 'migration journey'. De-exceptionalising mobility in the context of West African trajectories

    Open Access•J Schapendonk, Matthieu Bolay et al.•New Community•2021

  • Our aim is to assist migrants in making a well-informed decision

    Open Access•L Cleton, Reinhard Schweitzer•New Community•2021

  • Aviation as deportation infrastructure

    William Walters•New Community•2018

  • Les « expulsions volontaires

    Open Access•Clément De Senarclens, Ibrahim Soysüren•Revue européenne des migrations…•2017

  • Humanitarian Reason

    D Fassin•Humanitarian Reason•2011

  • Where ethics and politics meet

    Open Access•M Ticktin•American Ethnologist•2006

  • How voluntary are voluntary returns

    Open Access•Frances Webber•Race & Class•2011

  • Fighting against Clandestine Migration

    Open Access•Sébastien Bachelet•PoLAR Political and Legal…•2018

  • We Live in a Country of UNHCR'-Refugee Protests and Global Political Society

    Open Access•Carolina Moulin Aguiar, Carolina Moulin et al.•International Political Sociology•2007

  • Resistance and the Problem of Ethnographic Refusal

    Open Access•B Ortner, Sherry B Ortner•Comparative Studies in Society…•1995

Unique citing works12
Citations per year4
Citation span2023 - 2026 (4)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 12

Tools

Open DOIOpen Access
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae