Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

The deportation continuum

Convergences between state agents and NGO workers in the Dutch deportation field

Bibliographic Data

ID4525522
AuthorsB Kalir (0000-0001-6071-1080, University of Amsterdam, corresponding author), Lieke Wissink, Lieke M Wissink (0000-0002-9383-173X, University of Amsterdam)
Year2016
Volume20
Issue1
Pages34-49
Publication date2016-01-02
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessNo
TypeARTICLE
VenueCitizenship Studies (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 1362-1025 • E-ISSN: 1469-3593
PublisherInforma UK Limited (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1080/13621025.2015.1107025
OpenAlexW2128168601
LanguageEN
Citations received75
References cited36

The social field in which deportations of illegalized migrants are operationalized is often perceived to be comprised of two opposing sides that together form a deportation regime: on the one side, street-level state agents, on the other side, civil-society actors. Focusing ethnographically on deportation case managers and NGO workers in the Netherlands, a country known for its consensus politics, our study reveals significant convergences in the manners that illegalized migrants are treated by both sides in usage of terminology, handling of face-to-face interactions and worldviews on issues like belonging and justice. Given these convergences, we argue that the field in which deportation is being negotiated and practiced amounts to a continuum formed by state agents and NGO actors. We argue that a deportation continuum is underlined by shared political subjectivities and creates a sealed-off political realm that restricts the initiatives of activist citizens, imaginaries of citizenship and alternatives for deportation policies

Citizenship · Civil society · Criminology · Deportation · Immigration · Political economy · Political science · Politics · Realm · Sociology · Asian Geopolitics and Ethnography · Law · Migration, Health and Trauma · Migration, Refugees, and Integration

  • Return and readmission policy in Europe

    Open Access•Zoran Slavnic, Branka Likić‐brborić et al.•Critical Sociology•2026

  • El internamiento de extranjeros

    Open Access•Markus González Beilfu, Joan-Josep Vallbé et al.•Migraciones Publicación del…•2018

  • Coloniality and Racism in the Spanish Deportation System

    Open Access•Daniela Lo Coco•Migraciones Publicación del…•2023

  • The navigation of good care for forensic psychiatric inpatients who face mandatory repatriation from the Netherlands

    Open Access•Anniek Van Weeghel, Charlotte Clous et al.•Social Science & Medicine•2025

  • Encounters of Despair

    Open Access•L M Borrelli•Anthropologica•2021

  • Antagonistic Collaboration

    Open Access•Maja Hertoghs•Journal of Contemporary Ethnography•2026

  • Navigating the European Migration Regime

    Open Access•Anna Wy, Anna Wyss•Masculinity, Precarity and the…•2022

  • Deportation limbo

    Open Access•A Lindberg•Deportation Limbo•2023

  • Behind Crimmigration

    Felicia Arriaga•Behind Crimmigration•2023

  • Contested Solidarity

    Open Access•Larissa Fleischmann•Contested Solidarity•2020

  • Deportation Diplomacy

    Open Access•L M Borrelli, Nadine Kheshen et al.•International Political Sociology•2026

  • At the Crossroads between Care and Control

    Open Access•Rossella Marino, Arla Mannersuo et al.•Journal of Refugee Studies•2022

  • Street-Level Justifications’

    Open Access•Aysen Ustubici•Journal of Refugee Studies•2020

  • Contesting the Securitization of Migration

    Open Access•Jean-Pierre Murray•International Studies Quarterly•2024

  • Managerializing expulsion

    Open Access•Valon Junuzi•Migration Studies•2026

  • ‘If you don’t have documents or a legal procedure, you are out!’ Making humanitarian organizations partner in migration control

    Open Access•Mieke Kox, Richard Staring•European Journal of Criminology•2022

  • Human Dignity Along a Spectrum

    Open Access•Antonella Patteri, Witold Klaus•International Migration Review•2026

  • Advocates, Implementers or Allies? NGOs between Humanitarian Borderwork and Migration Management in Libya

    Open Access•Melissa Phillips•Journal of Intercultural Studies•2023

  • Law enforcement agents at European borders

    Open Access•Rut Bermejo-Casado, Isabel Bazaga-Fernández et al.•Political Research Exchange•2025

  • Rethinking the biopolitical

    Open Access•C Minca, Alexandra Rijke et al.•Environment and Planning C…•2021

  • Bridgeheads of EU border externalisation? NGOs/CSOs and migration in Libya

    Open Access•Paolo Cuttitta•Environment and Planning C…•2023

  • Sheltering difference

    Open Access•Cesar Eduardo Merlín-Escorza, J Schapendonk et al.•Frontiers in Sociology•2023

  • At the limits of choice

    Open Access•Imen El Amouri•Territory Politics Governance•2026

  • London's deportation apparatus

    Open Access•Agnieszka Radziwinowiczówna, Benjamin Morgan•Population Space and Place•2022

  • Situated belonging as everyday practice in a semi-public Youth Living Room for undocumented young city dwellers

    Open Access•Lieke Wissink, Lieke M Wissink•Journal of Youth Studies•2024

  • The Humanitarianization of Child Deportation Politics

    Martin Lemberg-Pedersen•Journal of Borderlands Studies•2020

  • Embracing a Radically Transformative Intellectual Approach

    Open Access•Felicia Arriaga•Sociological Forum•2023

  • Behind the desk

    Open Access•Laure Deschuyteneer, Lars Breuls•Archiwum Kryminologii•2024

  • Enhancing the criminology of mobility

    Open Access•Cristina Fernández-Bessa, Valeria Ferraris et al.•Archiwum Kryminologii•2024

  • Le retour incertain d’Aya et de Prince ». Penser l'incertitude et l'intermédiation des retours volotaires à partir d'une trajectoire féminine en instance de départ depuis le Maroc

    Open Access•Anissa Maâ•Emulations - Revue de sciences…•2020

  • Re-routing migration geographies

    Open Access•J Schapendonk, Ilse Van Liempt et al.•Geoforum•2018

  • Insurgent bureaucrats in local government

    Open Access•Walter J Nicholls, B Coutin et al.•Ethnic and Racial Studies•2026

  • Good immigrants, permitted outsiders

    A Hackl•Ethnic and Racial Studies•2022

  • Departheid

    Open Access•B Kalir•Conflict and Society•2019

  • Between social integration, incorporation and exclusion

    Open Access•Lilach Lev Ari, Arie Herscovici•International Migration•2025

  • Deserving or undeserving

    Open Access•Silvia Aru, M Belloni•Cities•2024

  • I Will Return Strong”

    Open Access•Lea Müller-Funk, Sonja Fransen•International Migration Review•2023

  • Yes, But Somebody Has to Help Them, Somehow

    Open Access•Francesca Esposito, José Ornelas et al.•International Migration Review•2021

  • A Genealogy of ‘Future Orientation’

    Open Access•Soline Ballet, Robin Vandevoordt et al.•Social Policy and Administration•2025

  • The politics of aid

    Open Access•Ashley Witcher•Third World Quarterly•2022

  • Abandonment, Agency, Control

    Open Access•Silvia Aru•Antipode•2021

  • Working for Protection? Precarious Legal Inclusion of Afghan Nationals in Germany and Switzerland

    Open Access•Anna Wy, Carolin Fischer•Antipode•2022

  • Mobility control as state-making in civil war

    Open Access•Christian Fröhlich, Christiane Fröhlich et al.•Migration Politics•2023

  • Normalisation of Exception and Categorisation in Migration Governance

    Open Access•Annett Bochmann•Journal of International…•2026

  • National Goal Trends

    Zayda Sorrell-Medina•Journal of Immigrant & Refugee…•2025

  • Civil Society and Migration Governance across European Borderlands

    Paolo Cuttitta, A Pecoud et al.•Journal of Intercultural Studies•2023

  • Navigating the migration industry

    Open Access•J Schapendonk•New Community•2017

  • Multidirectional mistrust

    Open Access•Karlien Strijbosch•New Community•2025

  • Affective control

    Ioana Vrăbiescu, B Anderson•Identities•2024

  • The Exceptional Becomes Everyday

    Open Access•Regina C Serpa•Social Sciences•2021

  • Governing through partnership

    Open Access•J Darling•Political Geography•2024

  • Who Feels Safe? Uncertain Futures and Enduring Aspirations in Italy

    Daniela Giudici•Geopolitics•2024

  • The Geopolitics of Return Migration in the International System

    Tamirace Fakhoury, Zeynep Sahin Mencutek•Geopolitics•2023

  • Informing for the sake of it

    Open Access•L M Borrelli, Anna Wy•Citizenship Studies•2022

  • Manufacturing collaboration in the deportation field

    Anissa Maâ•The Journal of North African…•2021

  • Fear of small numbers

    Open Access•Jukka Könönen•Citizenship Studies•2025

  • Differential solidarity

    Maren Kirchhoff•Citizenship Studies•2020

  • Autonomy of migration in the light of deportation. Ethnographic and theoretical accounts of entangled appropriations of voluntary returns from Morocco

    Open Access•Anissa Maâ•Environment and Planning D…•2023

  • Externalising migration control in Niger

    Open Access•Fabio De Blasis, Silvia Pitzali et al.•The Journal of Modern African…•2023

  • Across the Sloping Meadow Floor

    Open Access•Joan-Josep Vallbé, Markus González-Beilfu et al.•Law & Society Review•2019

  • No place like home? The International Organization for Migration and the new political imaginary of deportation

    Shoshana Fine, William Walters•New Community•2022

  • As if the soul returns to the body

    Open Access•E Hjalmarson•New Community•2025

  • Between humanitarian assistance and migration management

    Robin Vandevoordt•New Community•2017

  • Performing freedom in the Dutch deportation regime

    Laura Cleton, Sébastien Chauvin•New Community•2020

  • Piloting sanctuary? Negotiating inclusive policies towards illegalised migrants in Ghent, Belgium

    Soline Ballet, Robin Vandevoordt•New Community•2025

  • Widening the net of immigration control

    Laure Deschuyteneer•New Community•2025

  • Our aim is to assist migrants in making a well-informed decision

    Open Access•L Cleton, Reinhard Schweitzer•New Community•2021

  • Coerced return

    Open Access•Zeynep Sahin Mencutek, Anna Triandafyllidou•New Community•2025

  • Care-full failure

    Open Access•Ioana Vrăbiescu, B Kalir•Social Identities•2018

  • State desertion and "out-of-procedure" asylum seekers in the Netherlands

    Open Access•B Kalir•Focaal•2017

  • Nonrecording the "European refugee crisis" in Greece

    Open Access•K Rozakou•Focaal•2017

  • Non- and dedocumenting citizens in Romania

    Open Access•Ioana Vrăbiescu•Focaal•2017

  • The Affective Ambiguity of Solidarity

    Open Access•Sonja Moghaddari•Critical Sociology•2021

  • Repressive Compassion

    Open Access•B Kalir•PoLAR Political and Legal…•2019

  • A Humanitarian and Imperial Return

    Ampson Hagan•Transforming Anthropology•2024

  • Refugees and Exile

    Liisa H Malkki•Annual Review of Anthropology•1995

  • Citizenship, Migrant Activism and the Politics of Movement

    Peter Nyers, Kim Rygiel•Citizenship, migrant activism and…•2012

  • Anti-Politics Machine

    James Ferguson•The anti-politics machine•2010

  • Doing Good? The Politics and Antipolitics of NGO Practices

    William F Fisher•Annual Review of Anthropology•1997

  • The contested politics of mobility

    Vicki Squire•Contested Politics of Mobility•2011

  • The Migration Apparatus

    Gregory Feldman•Migration Apparatus•2011

  • The Deportation Regime

    Nicholas De Genova, Nathalie Peutz•The deportation regime•2010

  • The Politics of International Migration Management

    Open Access•Martin Geiger, Antoine Pécoud•Politics of International…•2010

  • The Human Condition

    Hannah Arendt, Margaret Canovan et al.•Human Condition•2018

  • The Human Condition

    Hannah Arendt, Margaret Canovan•Human Condition•1998

  • Homo Sacer

    Giorgio Agamben•Homo Sacer•2020

  • Citizenship in flux

    Open Access•Engin Isin•Subjectivity•2009

  • No One is Illegal Between City and Nation

    Open Access•Peter Nyers•Studies in Social Justice•2011

  • Civil Society and the Legitimation of Global Governance

    Jan Aart Scholte•Journal of Civil Society•2007

  • What Does it Mean to be Un

    Jacques Rancière•Continuum•2007

  • From Refugees to Immigrants

    Open Access•B Coutin, Susan Bibler Coutin•International Migration Review•1998

  • From Refugees to Immigrants

    B Coutin, Susan Bibler Coutin•International Migration Review•1998

  • Transnational Flows and Permissive Polities

    Open Access•Barak Kalir, Malini Sur•Transnational Flows and…•2012

  • Street-level democracy

    Antje Ellermann•West European Politics•2006

  • From Dutch disease to Dutch model? Consensus government in practice

    Rudy B Andeweg, Ra Andeweg•Parliamentary Affairs•2000

  • Civil Society as Social Control

    Quintan Wiktorowicz•Comparative Politics•2000

  • Abject Cosmopolitanism

    Peter Nyers•Third World Quarterly•2003

  • Civil Society and Democracy in Global Governance

    Jan Aart Scholte•Global Governance A Review of…•2002

  • Citizenship, deportation and the boundaries of belonging

    B Anderson, Matthew J Gibney et al.•Citizenship Studies•2011

  • Dutch civil society at crossroads

    Rik Habraken, Lucas C P M Meijs et al.•Development in Practice•2013

  • Deportation, detention and foreign-national prisoners in England and Wales

    Mary Bosworth•Citizenship Studies•2011

  • Political Belonging in a Neoliberal Era

    Anne Mcnevin•Citizenship Studies•2006

  • Deportation, Expulsion, and the International Police of Aliens

    William Walters•Citizenship Studies•2002

  • Europe as Borderland

    Open Access•Étienne Balibar•Environment and Planning D…•2009

  • Reflections

    Maire Kurrik, Maire J Kurrik et al.•World Literature Today•1980

  • Making Undocumented Immigrants into a Legitimate Political Subject

    Open Access•Walter J Nicholls•Theory Culture & Society•2013

  • Migrant "Illegality" and Deportability in Everyday Life

    N De Genova, Nicholas P De Genova•Annual Review of Anthropology•2002

  • Mobilizing migrants, making citizens

    B Anderson•Ethnic and Racial Studies•2010

Unique citing works75
Citations per year8,33
Citation span2017 - 2026 (10)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 69

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae