Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Rooted America

Immobility and Segregation of the Intercounty Migration Network

Bibliographic Data

ID4522147
AuthorsPeng Huang (0000-0001-5614-786X, University of California, Irvine), C T Butts (0000-0002-7911-9834, University of California, Irvine, corresponding author)
Year2023
Volume88
Issue6
Pages1031-1065
Publication date2023-12-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueAmerican Sociological Review (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0003-1224 • E-ISSN: 1939-8271
PublisherSAGE Publications Inc (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1177/00031224231212679
OpenAlexW4388945175
LanguageEN
Citations received14
References cited180

Despite the popular narrative that the United States is a "land of mobility," the country may have become a "rooted America" after a decades-long decline in migration rates. This article interrogates the lingering question about the social forces that limit migration, with an empirical focus on internal migration in the United States. We propose a systemic, network model of migration flows, combining demographic, economic, political, and geographic factors and network dependence structures that reflect the internal dynamics of migration systems. Using valued temporal exponential-family random graph models, we model the network of intercounty migration flows from 2011 to 2015. Our analysis reveals a pattern of segmented immobility, where fewer people migrate between counties with dissimilar political contexts, levels of urbanization, and racial compositions. Probing our model using "knockout experiments" suggests one would have observed approximately 4.6 million (27 percent) more intercounty migrants each year were the segmented immobility mechanisms inoperative. This article offers a systemic view of internal migration and reveals the social and political cleavages that underlie geographic immobility in the United States

Demographic economics · Development economics · Economic geography · Economic growth · Economics · Geography · Internal migration · Political economy · Political science · Politics · Population · Sociology · Urbanization · Demography · Law · Migration and Labor Dynamics · Migration, Refugees, and Integration · Urban, Neighborhood, and Segregation Studies

  • The Structure of Inter-Occupational Marriages in the United States 1970-2021

    Open Access•Jingying Wang, Per Block•Research in Social Stratification…•2026

  • Geographic Immobility in the United States

    Open Access•Mark Ellis, Lee Fiorio et al.•Population Space and Place•2026

  • Marginal Structural Effects for Exponential Random Graph Models

    Open Access•W Duxbury•Sociological Methods & Research•2026

  • Micro Effects on Macro Structure

    Open Access•Jenna Wertsching, W Duxbury•Sociological Methods & Research•2026

  • Migration Connectivity of the Regions of Asian Russia

    Open Access•T Yu Cherkashina, N L Mosienko•Regional Research of Russia•2026

  • Multidimensional Segregation Among Asian American Voters

    Open Access•Ting-Syuan Lin, Yongjun Zhang•Population Space and Place•2026

  • Micro–macro analysis of network change

    Open Access•Peng Huang•Social Networks•2026

  • Global Division of Responsibility Sharing

    Open Access•A H N Vo, Michelle S Dromgold-Sermen•Social Sciences•2025

  • Network threats to causal inference

    Open Access•C Mcmillan, Mark C Pachucki et al.•Social Networks•2026

  • A Simulation Approach for the Spatial Testing of Migration Theories

    Open Access•Micol Matilde Morellini•European Journal of Population /…•2026

  • Connecting the dots

    Open Access•C Mcmillan•International Migration•2024

  • Curricular Differentiation and Informal Networks

    Open Access•Wesley Jeffrey•Sociology of Education•2025

  • Micro-Macro Mediation Analysis in Social Networks

    Open Access•W Duxbury•Sociological Methodology•2024

  • Evidence for the welfare magnet hypothesis? A global examination using exponential random graph models

    Open Access•Tim S Müller, Tim Müller•Social Forces•2025

  • Chinatown

    Min Zhou•Chinatown•1992

  • American apartheid

    Douglas Massey, Douglas S Massey et al.•American apartheid•1993

  • International migration systems

    Hania Zlotnik, Lin Lean Lim et al.•International migration systems•1992

  • Internal migration in developing countries

    Michael P Todaro•Internal migration in developing…•1976

  • The age of migration

    Stephen Castles•The age of migration•1998

  • Human prosociality from an evolutionary perspective

    Open Access•D S Wilson, Daniel Tumminelli O''Brien et al.•Evolution and Human Behavior•2009

  • Moving to Opportunity

    Xavier De Souza Briggs, Susan J Popkin et al.•Moving to opportunity•2010

  • The Partisan Sort

    Matthew Levendusky•Partisan Sort•2009

  • Sacrificing Families

    Leisy J Abrego•Sacrificing Families•2014

  • Systems Approach to a Theory of Rural‐Urban Migration

    Open Access•Akin L Mabogunje•Geographical Analysis•1970

  • Can Quantum-Mechanical Description of Physical Reality Be Considered Complete?

    Open Access•Albert Einstein, Boris Podolsky et al.•Physical Review D•1935

  • Ergm

    Open Access•David R Hunter, Mark S Handcock et al.•Journal of Statistical Software•2008

  • The snowball effect

    D Krackhardt, Lyman W Porter•Journal of Applied Psychology•1986

  • Internal Migration in Decline

    Thomas J Cooke•The Professional Geographer•2013

  • Process and Structure in Leader-Member Exchange

    Raymond T Sparrowe, Robert C Liden•Academy of Management Review•1997

  • The effect of partisanship and political advertising on close family ties

    Open Access•M Keith Chen, Ryne Rohla•Science•2018

  • Gibrat's Law for (All) Cities

    Jan Eeckhout•American Economic Review•2004

  • Exponential-family random graph models for valued networks

    Open Access•Pavel N Krivitsky•Electronic Journal of Statistics•2012

  • Specification of Exponential-Family Random Graph Models

    Open Access•M Morris, Mark S Handcock et al.•Journal of Statistical Software•2008

  • Understanding the Long‐run Decline in Interstate Migration

    Open Access•Greg Kaplan, Sam Schulhofer‐wohl•International Economic Review•2017

  • Bowling alone

    Open Access•Robert D Putnam•Proceedings of the 2000 ACM…•2000

  • Social Structure, Household Strategies, and the Cumulative Causation of Migration

    D S Massey•Population Index•1990

  • Sociological theories in progress

    Joseph Berger, Bo Anderson et al.•Sociological theories in progress•1966

  • The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science (Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science (Paper))

    Richard D Lambert•The Annals of the American…•2001

  • Migration Systems, Pioneer Migrants and the Role of Agency

    Oliver Bakewell, Hein De Haas et al.•Journal of Critical Realism•2012

  • Worlds in Motion

    D S Massey, Joaquín Arango et al.•Worlds in motion•1999

  • Advances in Social Theory and Methodology (RLE Social Theory)

    Karin Knorr Cetina, A V Cicourel•Advances in Social Theory and…•2014

  • Migration and Culture

    Robin Cohen, Gunvor Jόnsson et al.•Migration and Culture•2011

  • Multinational Maids

    Open Access•A M Paul•Multinational Maids•2017

  • Beyond Networks

    Open Access•Mônica Lúcia Fonseca, Oliver Bakewell et al.•Beyond Networks•2016

  • The Latino Threat

    L R Chavez, Leo Chavez•Latino Threat•2013

  • Exploring Contemporary Migration

    Peter Boyle, Paul Boyle et al.•Exploring Contemporary Migration•2014

  • Cycle of Segregation

    Maria Krysan, Kyle Crowder•Cycle of Segregation•2017

  • The Politics of Resentment

    Katherine J Cramer•Politics of Resentment•2015

  • Immigrant Inflows, Native Outflows, and the Local Labor Market Impacts of Higher Immigration

    David Card•Journal of Labor Economics•2001

  • The Dynamics of U.S. Internal Migration

    George I Treyz, Dan S Rickman et al.•The Review of Economics and…•1993

  • Regional Labor Market Adjustment in the United States

    Mai Dao, Davide Furceri et al.•The Review of Economics and…•2017

  • Preferences in the Early Stages of Mate Choice

    K Lewis•Social Forces•2016

  • Emigration from China in Comparative Perspective

    Yao Lu, Z Liang et al.•Social Forces•2013

  • Rules of the Game

    Open Access•K Lewis, A V Papachristos•Social Forces•2020

  • Duality of departmental specializations and PhD exchange

    Open Access•N Gondal•Social Networks•2018

  • Parameter estimation procedures for exponential-family random graph models on count-valued networks

    Open Access•Peng Huang, C T Butts•Social Networks•2024

  • Pack Your Politics! Assessing the Vote Choice of Latino Interstate Migrants

    Open Access•Robert R Preuhs•The Journal of Race Ethnicity and…•2020

  • Extrapolative simulation of neighborhood networks based on population spatial distribution

    J R Hipp, C T Butts et al.•Social Networks•2013

  • Communication flows and the durability of a transnational social field

    Open Access•A M Verdery, T Mouw et al.•Social Networks•2018

  • The network of global migration 1990–2013

    Open Access•M Windzio•Social Networks•2018

  • The Modern World-System I

    Immanuel Wallerstein, Antonio Resines et al.•The Modern World-System I:…•2011

  • Social Networks and Transnational Social Fields

    Open Access•M J Lubbers, A M Verdery et al.•International Migration Review•2020

  • Theories of International Migration

    D S Massey, Joaquín Arango et al.•Population and Development Review•1993

  • Relaunching migration systems

    Oliver Bakewell•Migration Studies•2013

  • Changing spatial interconnectivity during the “Great American Migration Slowdown”

    Open Access•Jack Dewaard, E Fussell et al.•Population Space and Place•2019

  • Ever‐More Rooted Americans

    Open Access•C S Fischer•City and Community•2002

  • Why Poor Families Move (And Where They Go)

    Open Access•Stefanie Deluca, Holly Wood et al.•City and Community•2019

  • Population recovery in New Orleans after Hurricane Katrina

    Open Access•Jack Dewaard, Katherine J Curtis et al.•Population and Environment•2016

  • Immigration and internal migration “flight”

    Open Access•William H Frey•Population and Environment•1995

  • Determinants of International Migration Flows to and from Industrialized Countries

    Open Access•Keuntae Kim, J E Cohen•International Migration Review•2010

  • The Effect of Visas on Migration Processes

    Open Access•Mathias Czaika, Hein De Haas•International Migration Review•2017

  • Step-Wise Migration

    Open Access•Dennis Conway•International Migration Review•1980

  • The Impact of Tourist Visas on Intercontinental South-South Migration

    Open Access•Luisa Feline Freier, Kyle Holloway•International Migration Review•2019

  • Networks, Linkages, and Migration Systems

    Open Access•James T Fawcett•International Migration Review•1989

  • Causality Chains in the International Migration Systems Approach

    Open Access•Roel Jennissen•Population Research and Policy…•2007

  • User Beware

    Open Access•Jack Dewaard, Mathew Hauer et al.•Population Research and Policy…•2022

  • Simulating Dynamic Network Models and Adolescent Smoking

    Cynthia M Lakon, J R Hipp et al.•American Journal of Public Health•2015

  • A theory of migration

    Open Access•Everett S Lee•Demography•1966

  • Birds of a feather, or friend of a friend? using exponential random graph models to investigate adolescent social networks

    Open Access•Steven M Goodreau, James A Kitts et al.•Demography•2009

  • Job Changing and the Decline in Long-Distance Migration in the United States

    Open Access•Raven Molloy, Christopher L Smith et al.•Demography•2017

  • Geographic Migration of Black and White Families Over Four Generations

    Open Access•P Sharkey•Demography•2015

  • Reexamining the moving to opportunity study and its contribution to changing the distribution of poverty and ethnic concentration

    Open Access•W A V Clark•Demography•2008

  • Social capital and migration

    Open Access•F Garip•Demography•2008

  • Tied Together

    Open Access•C Mcmillan•Demography•2019

  • Migration Systems in Europe

    Open Access•Jack Dewaard, Keuntae Kim et al.•Demography•2012

  • Interstate Migration and Employer-to-Employer Transitions in the United States

    Open Access•Henry R Hyatt, Henry Hyatt et al.•Demography•2018

  • Immigration and Internal Migration 'Flight' from US Metropolitan Areas

    Open Access•William H Frey•Urban Studies•1995

  • A Pure Theory of Local Expenditures

    Charles M Tiebout•Journal of Political Economy•1956

  • Family Migration Decisions

    Jacob Mincer•Journal of Political Economy•1978

  • The checkerboard model of social interaction

    James M Sakoda•Journal of Mathematical Sociology•1971

  • Ethnic Preferences, Social Distance Dynamics, and Residential Segregation

    Mark Fossett•Journal of Mathematical Sociology•2006

  • The Systems Approach to International Migration

    Open Access•June Marie Nogle•International Migration•1994

  • Voter Migration and the Geographic Sorting of the American Electorate

    Wendy K Tam Cho, James G Gimpel et al.•Annals of the Association of…•2013

  • Geographical variability and network structure

    Open Access•C T Butts, Ryan M Acton et al.•Social Networks•2011

  • What's Driving Mexico-U.S. Migration? A Theoretical, Empirical, and Policy Analysis

    D S Massey, Kristin E Espinosa•American Journal of Sociology•1997

  • Network Effects in Mexico–U.S. Migration

    Open Access•F Garip, Asad L Asad•American Behavioral Scientist•2016

  • Predicting Regional Self‐Identification from Spatial Network Models

    Open Access•Z Almquist, Zack W Almquist et al.•Geographical Analysis•2014

  • Impacts of Return Migration on R ural U . S . Communities

    Open Access•Christiane Von Reichert, John Cromartie et al.•Rural Sociology•2013

  • The ‘Global South’ in the transnational student mobility network. Effects of institutional instability, reputation of the higher education systems, post-colonial ties, and culture

    Eva Maria Vögtle, M Windzio•Globalisation Societies and…•2025

  • Why Partisans Do Not Sort

    Jonathan Mummolo, Clayton Nall•The Journal of Politics•2017

  • State Policy Components of Interstate Migration in the United States

    Open Access•Robert R Preuhs•Political Research Quarterly•1999

  • Models for Generalized Location Systems

    Open Access•C T Butts•Sociological Methodology•2007

  • The Origins and Consequences of Affective Polarization in the United States

    Sharad Iyengar, Yphtach Lelkes et al.•Annual Review of Political Science•2018

  • Understanding Immobility

    Open Access•Kerilyn Schewel•International Migration Review•2019

  • Affect, Not Ideology

    Sharad Iyengar, Shanto Iyengar et al.•Public Opinion Quarterly•2012

  • New World Orders

    Open Access•Jorge Durand, D S Massey•The Annals of the American…•2010

  • A Comparison of Traditional and Discrete-Choice Approaches to the Analysis of Residential Mobility and Locational Attainment

    Open Access•L Quillian•The Annals of the American…•2015

  • Seeking politically compatible neighbors? The role of neighborhood partisan composition in residential sorting

    Open Access•James G Gimpel, Iris S Hui et al.•Political Geography•2015

  • The Social Geography of Interstate Mobility and Persistence

    Jerald R Herting, David B Grusky et al.•American Sociological Review•1997

  • The P 1 P 2 D Hypothesis

    George Kingsley Zipf•American Sociological Review•1946

  • Migration, Segregation, and the Geographic Concentration of Poverty

    D S Massey, Andrew B Gro et al.•American Sociological Review•1994

  • Deciding to Cross

    Open Access•Emily Ryo•American Sociological Review•2013

  • Network Ecology and Adolescent Social Structure

    Open Access•D A Mcfarland, James Moody et al.•American Sociological Review•2014

  • Culture, Cognition, and Collaborative Networks in Organizations

    Open Access•B Srivastava, Sameer B Srivastava et al.•American Sociological Review•2011

Unique citing works14
Citations per year7
Citation span2024 - 2026 (3)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 13

Tools

Open DOIOpen Access
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae