Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Thinking with Flint

Racial Liberalism and the Roots of an American Water Tragedy

Bibliographic Data

ID4887112
AuthorsM Ranganathan (0000-0003-4787-1519, American University, corresponding author)
Year2016
Volume27
Issue3
Pages17-33
Publication date2016-07-02
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessNo
TypeARTICLE
VenueCapitalism Nature Socialism (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 1045-5752 • E-ISSN: 1548-3290
PublisherInforma UK Limited (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1080/10455752.2016.1206583
OpenAlexW2463872193
LanguageEN
Citations received146
References cited42

The lead poisoning of Flint, Michigan's water is popularly framed as a case of "environmental racism" given that Flint's population is mostly black and lower income. In this essay I argue that we see the environmental racism that underlies Flint's water poisoning not as incidental to our political-economic order, nor even as stemming from racist intent, but as inseparable from liberalism, an organizing logic we take for granted in our modern age. I expand on the idea of "racial liberalism" here. While upholding the promise of individual freedoms and equality for all, racial liberalism—particularly as it was translated into urban renewal and property making in mid-20th-century urban America—drove dispossession. In Flint racialized property dispossession has been one major factor underlying the city's financial duress, abandonment, and poisoned infrastructure. Yet, through austerity discourse, Flint is disciplined as if it were a financially reckless individual while the structural and historical causes of its duress are masked. Tracing the history of property making and taking in Flint and the effects of austerity urbanism on its water infrastructure, my central argument is that our understanding of Flint's predicament—the disproportionate poisoning of young African-Americans—can be deepened if we read it as a case of racial liberalism's illiberal legacies

Environmental ethics · Liberalism · Political economy · Political science · Politics · Social science · Sociology · Tragedy (event · American Environmental and Regional History · Environmental Justice and Health Disparities · Law · Philosophy · Water Governance and Infrastructure

  • Suturing a failing district heating system

    Open Access•Caterina Sartori•City•2026

  • Rethinking water insecurity, inequality and infrastructure through an embodied urban political ecology

    Open Access•Yaffa Truelove•WIREs Water•2019

  • From Transportation Equity to Transportation Justice

    Open Access•Alex Karner, Jonathan K London et al.•Journal of Planning Literature•2020

  • From Kern Island to the Streets of Bakersfield

    Open Access•Vivian Underhill•Catalyst Feminism Theory…•2022

  • Toward a Dracula urbanism

    Open Access•David Wilson, Elvin Wyly•Dialogues in Urban Research•2023

  • Variations in household water affordability and water insecurity

    Open Access•Sameer H Shah, L Harris et al.•Environment and Planning F•2023

  • Moving beyond a climate politics of justice with no peace

    Kimberley Anh Thomas, Kevon Rhiney•Climate and Development•2024

  • US Higher education and fossil fuels

    Open Access•Danya Al-Saleh, Neha Vora•Climate and Development•2024

  • Infrastructure That Connects/Infrastructure That Divides

    Lisa K Bates, Matti Siemiatycki et al.•Planning Theory & Practice•2023

  • The Flint water crisis

    Bruno Takahashi, Ellis A Adams et al.•Local Environment•2020

  • Covid-19’s Cracks, Climate Crisis, and Academia’s Role in Bringing about an Ontological Shift

    Beverley Mullings•The Professional Geographer•2022

  • Le capitalisme racial et la production de villes coloniales de peuplement

    Heather Dorries, David Hugill et al.•Espaces et sociétés•2024

  • W.E.B. Du Bois and the urban political economy tradition in geography

    Open Access•J Hackworth•Progress in Human Geography•2021

  • State-Sanctioned Violence

    Melvin Delgado•State-Sanctioned Violence•2020

  • The Bronx River and Environmental Justice Through the Lens of a Watershed

    Michael H Finewood, Diamond Ebanks Holloman et al.•Case Studies in the Environment•2023

  • Environmental justice organizing as commoning practice in groundwater reform

    Open Access•Kristin Babson Dobbin•Elementa Science of the…•2021

  • On loss, limits and the possibilities of critical geographic thought in a climate-changed world

    Open Access•Kevon Rhiney•Dialogues in Urban Research•2026

  • Making repair reparative

    Open Access•Nate Millington, Suraya Scheba et al.•Progress in Human Geography•2026

  • Experiences of the Flint Water Crisis Among Reproductive-Age Michigan Women in Communities Outside of Flint

    Open Access•Sidonie K Kilpatrick, Sidonie Kilpatrick et al.•Journal of Racial and Ethnic…•2023

  • Can community-based participatory action research fulfill environmental justice principles in Newark, NJ

    Open Access•Bavisha Kalyan, Anthony Dwayne Diaz et al.•Environmental Research Letters•2025

  • Splintering Urbanism @ 20

    Kathryn Furlong•Journal of Urban Technology•2022

  • In the Excess of Splintering Urbanism

    Omar Jabary Salamanca, Jonathan Silver•Journal of Urban Technology•2022

  • Racial and Ethnic Differences in Emotional Reactions to the Flint Water Crisis among Michigan Women in Communities Outside of Flint

    Darya Dokshina, Sidonie K Roque et al.•Ethnicity & Disease•2024

  • Justice in nature-based solutions

    Open Access•Joshua J Cousins•Ecological Economics•2021

  • Households’ access and expenditure on water services

    Open Access•Louis Kusi Frimpong, Stephen Leonard Mensah et al.•Urban Governance•2024

  • Improvising against the racial state in Atlanta

    Open Access•Richard Milligan, Tyler Mccreary et al.•Environment and Planning C…•2021

  • Philanthropy to the rescue? Detroit’s schools and urban policymaking under austerity

    Open Access•Dan Cohen•Environment and Planning C…•2021

  • The domestic geopolitics of racial capitalism

    Open Access•Pavithra Vasudevan, Sara Smith•Environment and Planning C…•2020

  • Black Geographies and Trans-Corporeality

    SV Madhu, Soumya Jose•GeoHumanities•2025

  • Developing deeply intersectional environmental justice scholarship

    A Malin, Stacia S Ryder•Environmental Sociology•2018

  • Intersections of disability justice, racial justice and environmental justice

    Catherine Jampel•Environmental Sociology•2018

  • Intersectional feminism for the environmental studies and sciences

    Open Access•Teresa Lloro-Bidart, Michael H Finewood•Journal of Environmental Studies…•2018

  • Dismantling white supremacy in environmental studies and sciences

    Open Access•Eve Z Bratman, Eve Bratman et al.•Journal of Environmental Studies…•2022

  • The hydro-racial fix in infrastructural regions

    Richard Milligan, Ellis A Adams et al.•Territory Politics Governance•2022

  • Can political ecology be decolonised? A dialogue with Paul Robbins

    Open Access•Ishfaq Hussain Malik•Geo Geography and Environment•2024

  • Conserving what? Conservation easements and environmental justice in the coastal US South

    Open Access•Levi Van Sant, Dean Hardy et al.•Human Geography•2020

  • Climate finance governance

    Open Access•Sarah Bracking, Benjamin Leffel•Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews…•2021

  • Infrastructure in the Jungle

    Open Access•Jasmine Erdener•Communication Culture and Critique•2020

  • Routine Dilapidation

    Open Access•Rob Bartram•City and Community•2023

  • Introducing infrastructural harm

    Yannis Kallianos, Alexander Dunlap et al.•Globalizations•2022

  • Grappling with real property supremacy in US urban climate finance

    Open Access•Julia Wagner, Mark Kear et al.•City•2024

  • Property-time

    Open Access•Hun Kim•City•2024

  • Confronting the urban climate emergency

    Daniel Aldana Cohen•City•2020

  • Thinking racial capitalism from the Inland Empire

    Nina Ebner•City•2020

  • Latent alliances

    Garrett Graddy-Lovelace•Gender Place & Culture•2017

  • Institutional diversity and safe drinking water provision in the United States

    Open Access•Kristin Babson Dobbin, Amanda Fencl•Utilities Policy•2021

  • Co-opting the rural

    Open Access•Veronica Limeberry, Jaclyn Fox•Journal of Rural Studies•2020

  • Reimagining geographies of public finance

    Open Access•Marilyn August, Martine August et al.•Progress in Human Geography•2021

  • Urban political ecology

    Open Access•Matthew Gandy•Progress in Human Geography•2021

  • Race and ethnicity I

    Open Access•Anne Bonds•Progress in Human Geography•2018

  • Infrastructure as Territorial Stigma

    Open Access•Nabeela Ahmed•International Journal of Urban…•2025

  • The policing of Black debt

    Open Access•Sawyer Phinney•Urban Geography•2022

  • Negotiating infrastructural citizenship beyond the state

    Open Access•Melissa Heil•Urban Geography•2023

  • Empire’s infrastructures

    M Ranganathan•Urban Geography•2019

  • Take the houses back/take the land back

    Margaret Marietta Ramírez•Urban Geography•2020

  • Racing the creative class

    Yui Hashimoto•Urban Geography•2020

  • Decline machines and economic development

    David Wilson, Melissa Heil•Urban Geography•2020

  • Spatial allocation of nature-based solutions in the form of public green infrastructure in relation to the socio-economic district profile–a GIS-based comparative study of Gdańsk and Rome

    Open Access•Anahita Azadgar, Giulia Luciani et al.•Land Use Policy•2025

  • Financing Reparative Climate Infrastructures

    Open Access•Sabra Webber, Sara Nelson et al.•Antipode•2022

  • Schooling in the University Town

    Open Access•Carlos Serrano•Antipode•2023

  • Revealing Properties of Citizenship through Landscape

    Open Access•Stephen Przybylinski•Antipode•2024

  • Flowing Capital‐Disrupted Homes

    Open Access•Defne Kadıoğlu, Ilhan Kellecioglu•Antipode•2024

  • Fanon's Mobilities

    Open Access•William Conroy•Antipode•2023

  • Particulate Matters

    Open Access•Becky Mansfield•Antipode•2022

  • The island is now a big vegetable garden”

    Open Access•Zoe Alexander•Antipode•2024

  • Political Ecologies of Race

    Open Access•Levi Van Sant, Richard Milligan et al.•Antipode•2021

  • The long‐time requirements of the nation”

    Open Access•Levi Van Sant•Antipode•2021

  • The Limits of Liberal Recognition

    Open Access•Tyler Mccreary, Richard Milligan•Antipode•2021

  • Site Fight! Toward the Abolition of Immigrant Detention on Tacoma’s Tar Pits (and Everywhere Else)

    Open Access•Megan Ybarra•Antipode•2021

  • Flood Risk as Legacy Vulnerability

    Open Access•Dean Hardy•Geoforum•2023

  • Temporal analysis of displacement

    Open Access•Joseph T Miller, Jessica Ty Miller•Geoforum•2020

  • Seeking environmental justice through the state

    Open Access•Jill Lindsey Harrison, Jonathan K London•Geoforum•2024

  • The violence of municipal debt

    Open Access•C S Ponder, Cs Ponder et al.•Geoforum•2019

  • Racial capitalism and the production of settler colonial cities

    Open Access•Heather Dorries, David Hugill et al.•Geoforum•2019

  • Designing justice? Race and the limits of recognition in greater Miami resilience planning

    Open Access•Kevin Grove, Allain J Barnett et al.•Geoforum•2020

  • Critical geographies of discretion in the environmental bureaucracy

    Open Access•Marc Tadaki, Jill Lindsey Harrison•Progress in Environmental Geography•2025

  • Doing Justice in Environmental Justice

    Open Access•Jesus Alejandro Garcia Aguilera, Jesús Alejandro García et al.•Capitalism Nature Socialism•2026

  • Managed normlessness

    Open Access•James W Love•Critical Sociology•2026

  • Political ecology III

    Open Access•Alex Loftus•Progress in Human Geography•2019

  • Notes toward an anticolonial environmental sociology of race

    Michael Warren Murphy•Environmental Sociology•2020

  • Florida in the Global South

    Open Access•Seth Schindler, Jonathan Silver•International Journal of Urban…•2019

  • Racial Capital, Abolition, and a Geographic Argument for Reparations

    Open Access•Joshua F J Inwood, A L Brand et al.•Antipode•2020

  • From Urban Resilience to Abolitionist Climate Justice in Washington, DC

    Open Access•M Ranganathan, Eve Bratman•Antipode•2019

  • Perceived risk, health protective behavior, and trust

    Dilshani Sarathchandra, Cedric A L Taylor•Environmental Sociology•2024

  • Plumbing Poverty

    Shiloh Deitz, Katie Meehan•Annals of the American…•2019

  • Theorizing on neo public assistance

    Open Access•J M Ezell, Brooke Olson et al.•Social Science & Medicine•2022

  • Climate Change and Disability-Inclusive Adaptation

    Adam Michael Auerbach, Abdulla Abdukhalilov et al.•The Journal of Development Studies•2026

  • Examining the Generational Intersection of Interpersonal, Cultural, and Institutional Betrayal in Flint, Michigan

    Open Access•Amanda Isabel Osuna, Tiffany Williams et al.•Journal of Community Psychology•2025

  • Embracing ‘Abolition Ecology

    Open Access•Nathan Stephens Griffin•Critical Criminology•2023

  • On the therapist's couch and in the streets

    Open Access•Rebecca Patterson-Markowitz•Political Geography•2025

  • Political geography in and for 2020

    Open Access•Kevin Grove, Tor A Benjaminsen et al.•Political Geography•2020

  • Producing water scarcity in São Paulo, Brazil

    Open Access•Nate Millington•Political Geography•2018

  • Unsettling nature as liberal public good

    Open Access•Clare M Beer•Political Geography•2025

  • Realizing citizenship in property

    Open Access•Stephen Przybylinski•Political Geography•2021

  • It is the innocence which constitutes the crime

    Open Access•Joshua F J Inwood•Geography Compass•2018

  • Rethinking geographies of race and austerity urbanism

    Open Access•Sawyer Phinney•Geography Compass•2020

  • Emerging Currents in the Political Ecology of Water

    Open Access•Samuel B Feldblum•Geography Compass•2025

  • An active role for political geography in our current conjuncture

    Open Access•Nicholas Jon Crane, Kevin Grove•Geography Compass•2018

  • The uneven distribution of futurity

    Open Access•Kevin Grove, Lauren Rickards et al.•Geographical Research•2022

  • Mechanisms, smoke and fun-house mirrors

    Louise Seamster•Ethnic and Racial Studies•2025

  • Capitalism and Slavery

    Eric Eustace Williams, Eric Williams•Capitalism and Slavery•1944

  • A history of pan-African revolt

    C L R James, Gema Facal Lozano et al.•A history of pan-African revolt•1969

  • Confronting Environmental Racism

    Robert D Bullard•Confronting Environmental Racism•1993

  • Whiteness as Property

    Cheryl I Harris•Harvard Law Review•1993

  • Stamped from the Beginning

    Ibram X Kendi•Stamped from the Beginning•2098

  • Black Marxism, Revised and Updated Third Edition

    Cedric J Robinson, Damien Sojoyner et al.•Black Marxism, Revised and…•2021

  • Toward a Political Philosophy of Race

    Falguni A Sheth•Toward a Political Philosophy of…•2009

  • Racial Liberalism

    Open Access•C W Mills•PMLA/Publications of the Modern…•2008

  • The Cold War and the Color Line

    Open Access•Thomas Borstelmann•Cold War and the Color Line•2009

  • Liberalism in Empire

    Andrew Sartori, Andrew Stephen Sartori•Liberalism in Empire•2019

  • Black Is a Country

    Open Access•Nikhil Pal Singh•Black Is a Country•2009

  • River of Dark Dreams

    Walter Johnson•River of Dark Dreams•2013

  • Golden Gulag

    Ruth Wilson Gilmore•Golden Gulag•2019

  • Racial Formation in the United States

    Michael Omi, Howard Winant•Racial Formation in the United…•2014

  • Liberal Strategies of Exclusion

    Open Access•Uday S Mehta•Politics & Society•1990

  • A Critical Review of the Methodology of Environmental Racism Research

    Open Access•Lucila Pulido, Laura Pulido•Antipode•1996

  • Post-Liberalism

    Open Access•A Roy•Planning Theory•2008

  • Geographies of race and ethnicity 1

    Open Access•Lucila Pulido, Laura Pulido•Progress in Human Geography•2015

  • Urban political ecology II

    Open Access•Nik Heynen•Progress in Human Geography•2015

  • River of Dark Dreams

    David Brion Davis•The SHAFR Guide Online•2017

  • Defining Environmental Justice and Environmental Racism

    Ryan Holifield•Urban Geography•2001

  • Water marginalization at the urban fringe

    M Ranganathan, Carolina Balazs•Urban Geography•2015

  • Race and the Making of Southeast San Francisco

    Open Access•Rachel Brahinsky•Antipode•2014

  • Crossing the Neoliberal Line

    Open Access•J Glassman•Canadian Geographies /…•2005

  • The Rule of Freedom

    Patrick Joyce•Rule of Freedom•2003

  • Demolition Means Progress

    Andrew R Highsmith•Journal of American History•2016

  • Geographies of race and ethnicity II

    Open Access•Lucila Pulido, Laura Pulido•Progress in Human Geography•2016

  • Urban geography II

    Open Access•Kate D Derickson•Progress in Human Geography•2016

  • Rethinking Land Struggle in the Postindustrial City

    Open Access•Sara Safransky•Antipode•2016

  • Bind Us Apart

    Robert L Tsai•Journal of American History•2017

  • The Spirit of Neoliberalism

    Jodi Melamed•Social Text•2006

  • On plantations, prisons, and a black sense of place

    Katherine Mckittrick•Social & Cultural Geography•2011

  • The Political Theory of Possessive Individualism

    Caroline Robbins, C B Macpherson•The American Historical Review•1963

  • From 'Dangerous Classes' to 'Quiet Rebels

    Open Access•Asef Bayat•International Sociology•2000

Unique citing works146
Citations per year14,6
Citation span2016 - 2026 (11)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedYes
Citation typesNeutral: 145

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae