Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Studying Obduracy in the City

Toward a Productive Fusion between Technology Studies and Urban Studies

Bibliographic Data

ID5337445
AuthorsAnique Hommels (0000-0003-4657-5048, Maastricht University, corresponding author)
Year2005
Volume30
Issue3
Pages323-351
Publication date2005-07-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueScience Technology & Human Values (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0162-2439 • E-ISSN: 1552-8251
PublisherSAGE Publications Inc (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1177/0162243904271759
OpenAlexW2139411229
LanguageEN
Citations received146
References cited59

This article draws the city into the limelight of social studies of technology. Considering that cities consist of a wide range of technologies, it is remarkable that cities as an object of research have so far have been relatively neglected in the field of technology studies. This article focuses on the role of obduracy in urban sociotechnical change, an issue that, it is argued, has considerable importance for both students of the cities and the daily practice of town planners and architects, and, at the same time, forms an important theoretical debate in science, technology, and society (STS) studies. The article provides an overview of theoretical conceptions of obduracy in both technology studies and urban studies and proposes a heuristic model for the analysis of this phenomenon. In this way, this article aims to contribute to the establishment of a common interdisciplinary playground for these disciplines

Engineering ethics · Epistemology · Knowledge management · Limelight · Phenomenon · Political science · Regional science · Social science · Sociology · Sociotechnical system · Technology and Society · Computer Science · Engineering · Information Systems Theories and Implementation · Innovative Approaches in Technology and Social Development · Innovative Human-Technology Interaction · Law · Urban Studies

  • Building a circular construction economy in New York State

    Open Access•Jennifer S Minner, Courtney Bower et al.•Urban Studies•2026

  • The Pervasiveness of Corporate Authority

    Sara Angeli Aguiton, Marc-Olivier Déplaude et al.•Pervasive Powers•2021

  • What Fragility? Multiple Professional Visions in the Maintenance of French Public Roads

    Open Access•Roman SOLE-POMIES•Engaging Science Technology and…•2024

  • Wind energy meets buildings? Generating socio-technical change in the urban built environment through vanguard visions

    Open Access•Iryna Lunevich, Sanneke Kloppenburg•Energy Research & Social Science•2023

  • Speculative redevelopment and conservation

    Maroš Krivý•City•2011

  • La identidad en un objeto técnico

    Open Access•Jorge Eduardo Vergara Vidal•Política y Sociedad•2020

  • Did Americans Choose Sprawl

    Kirkman Kirkman•Ethics & the Environment•2010

  • Una red de incertidumbre en la planificación de megaproyectos urbanos

    Open Access•Rafael Crisosto, Francisco Salinas•EURE (Santiago•2017

  • The "Script" of a New Urban Layout

    Álvaro Ferreira Da Silva, M Luísa Sousa•Technology and Culture•2019

  • The Geography of Radionavigation and the Politics of Intangible Artifacts

    William Rankin, William W Rankin•Technology and Culture•2014

  • Digital Domesticity

    Jenny Kennedy, Matthew Arnold et al.•Digital Domesticity•2020

  • Les métamorphoses des infrastructures, entre béton et numérique

    Open Access•Konstantinos Chatzis, Gilles Jeannot et al.•Métamorphoses des Infrastructures,…•2018

  • Energy Transition in the Baltic Sea Region

    Open Access•Farid Karimi, Michael Rodi•Energy Transition in the Baltic…•2022

  • Urban experimentation and institutional arrangements

    Open Access•Rob Raven, Frans Sengers et al.•European Planning Studies•2019

  • Interdependent Infrastructure as Linked Social, Ecological, and Technological Systems (Setss) to Address Lock‐in and Enhance Resilience

    Open Access•Samuel A Markolf, Mikhail Chester et al.•Earth's Future•2018

  • Urban experimentation & sustainability transitions

    Lea Fuenfschilling, Niki Frantzeskaki et al.•European Planning Studies•2019

  • Flows of Standards and Materials

    Open Access•Roman SOLE-POMIES•Journal of Urban Technology•2026

  • Creative Networks and the City

    Open Access•Bas Van Heur•Creative Networks and the City•2010

  • Territorial and institutional obduracy in regional transition

    Open Access•Griet Juwet, Laura Deruytter•Cambridge Journal of Regions…•2021

  • Smart city projects in the continuity of the urban socio-technical regime

    Open Access•Gilles Jeannot•Information Polity•2019

  • Toward post-growth infrastructure

    Open Access•E Schramm, Federico Savini•Environment and Planning F•2026

  • The Socio-politics of the urbanization - transportation nexus

    Maritza Toro López, Joris Scheers et al.•International Planning Studies•2021

  • Public perceptions of networked infrastructure

    Open Access•Katy Roelich, Nina Litman-Roventa•Local Environment•2020

  • Négociations, mobilisations et reproduction quotidienne des infrastructures électriques à Ibadan (Nigéria)

    Mélanie Rateau•Flux•2022

  • Planning to grow, planning to rock on – infrastructure management and development in shrinking municipalities

    Open Access•Ida Grundel, Dick Magnusson•European Planning Studies•2023

  • How do local factors shape transformation pathways towards climate-neutral and resilient cities

    Open Access•Wolfgang Haupt, Peter Eckersley et al.•European Planning Studies•2023

  • Architektur und Gesellschaft

    Werner Reichmann, Andre L Müller et al.•Soziologische Revue•2021

  • Unlikely climate pioneers? Net-zero governance and innovation in ‘left behind’ places

    Open Access•Oleg Golubchikov, Sina Shahab et al.•Applied Geography•2026

  • Challenges and dilemmas in strategic urban experimentation An analysis of four cycling innovation living labs

    Open Access•Arnoud Van Waes, Anna Nikolaeva et al.•Technological Forecasting and…•2021

  • Making and mobilising place

    Open Access•Ami Crowther, Saska Petrova et al.•Norsk Geografisk Tidsskrift -…•2023

  • Citizenship in Collision

    Open Access•Beate Elvebakk•Science & Technology Studies•2018

  • Bodies and everyday practices in designed urban environments

    Open Access•Monica Degen, G Rose et al.•Science & Technology Studies•2010

  • Hacking the pipes

    Open Access•Sophie Schramm, Basil Ibrahim•Environment and Planning C…•2019

  • Comparative infrastructural modalities

    Open Access•Jennifer Mcarthur•Environment and Planning C…•2018

  • Not in transition

    Open Access•Stefania Sardo, Elena Parmiggiani et al.•Energy Research & Social Science•2021

  • Space and energy transitions in sub-Saharan Africa

    Open Access•Idalina Baptista•Energy Research & Social Science•2017

  • Transforming power

    Open Access•Andy Stirling•Energy Research & Social Science•2014

  • How deep is incumbency? A ‘configuring fields’ approach to redistributing and reorienting power in socio-material change

    Open Access•Andy Stirling•Energy Research & Social Science•2019

  • Challenging obduracy

    Open Access•Tineke van der Schoor, Harro Van Lente et al.•Energy Research & Social Science•2016

  • Multiscalar governance of urban energy transitions in Australia

    Open Access•Robyn Dowling, Pauline Mcguirk et al.•Energy Research & Social Science•2018

  • A matter of time

    Open Access•Sareen, Devyn Remme et al.•Energy Research & Social Science•2021

  • Toward energy democracy

    Open Access•J Palm, Anna-Riikka Kojonsaari et al.•Energy Research & Social Science•2025

  • How does air conditioning become ‘needed’? A case study of routes, rationales and dynamics

    Open Access•Gordon Walker, Elizabeth Shove et al.•Energy Research & Social Science•2014

  • Citizen Participation in Healthy City Making

    Open Access•Mare Knibbe, Sanne Raap et al.•Social Inclusion•2025

  • Le pouvoir des gestionnaires de réseau électrique de gouverner les systèmes électriques insulaires

    Open Access•Anne Goerens•L’Espace Politique•2026

  • How water and its use shaped the spatial development of Vienna

    Open Access•Friedrich Hauer, Severin Hohensinner et al.•Water History•2016

  • Rethinking the governance of urban infrastructural transformations

    Open Access•Jochen Monstadt, Jonas Torrens et al.•Current Opinion in Environmental…•2022

  • Climate geoengineering

    Open Access•Rose Cairns•Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews…•2014

  • Where Inequality Takes Place

    Open Access•Mike Owen Benediktsson•City and Community•2018

  • Orchestrating energy transitions

    Robyn Dowling, Chantel Carr et al.•Social & Cultural Geography•2022

  • Anyway, the dashboard is dead’

    Open Access•J Sadowski•New Media & Society•2021

  • Housing and Social and Material Vulnerabilities

    Rob Bartram•Housing Theory and Society•2016

  • Technology transition within secure message delivery (SMD) systems

    Open Access•Rowan Wilken, Jenny Kennedy•International Journal of Cultural…•2025

  • Concrete and corruption

    Eli Elinoff•City•2017

  • Imagining and enacting the future of the German energy transition

    Alexander Wentland•Innovation The European Journal…•2016

  • Crossing the Implementation Line

    Open Access•Paul M Leonardi•Communication Theory•2009

  • Autonomous vehicles, car-dominated environments, and cycling

    Open Access•Alan Latham, Michael Nattrass•Journal of Transport Geography•2019

  • Resilience in Scientific Research

    M Fukushima•Science as Culture•2015

  • Promises and Techno-Politics

    Open Access•Douglas Parks•Science as Culture•2019

  • From Public Engagement to Research Intervention

    Rider W Foley, Richard Rushforth et al.•Science as Culture•2020

  • Imaginaries of Sustainability

    Thomas R Miller•Science as Culture•2019

  • Urban Techno-Politics

    Rider W Foley, Thomas R Miller•Science as Culture•2020

  • The Nature of Decision Making in the Practice of Dwelling

    Håkon Fyhn, Nina Baron•Society & Natural Resources•2016

  • Conditions and Consequences of Elulu Improvement

    Open Access•Miriam Solis•Journal of Planning Education and…•2020

  • Carbonscapes and beyond

    Open Access•Håvard Haarstad, Tarje I Wanvik•Progress in Human Geography•2016

  • Small technologies, big change

    Open Access•Kathryn Furlong•Progress in Human Geography•2010

  • Smart City Control Rooms

    Open Access•Devika Prakash, Andy Karvonen et al.•International Journal of Urban…•2025

  • Historicizing Urban Sustainability

    Open Access•Håvard Haarstad, Stina Ellevseth Oseland•International Journal of Urban…•2017

  • Expanding the boundaries of food policy

    Open Access•Nevin Cohen, Rositsa T Ilieva•Food Policy•2020

  • Incompleteness of urban infrastructures in transition

    Open Access•Prince K Guma•Social Studies of Science•2020

  • Ordering theories

    Open Access•B K Sovacool, David J He•Social Studies of Science•2017

  • Discarded surrogates, modified traditions, welcome complements

    Open Access•Timothy Mo, Timothy Moss•Social Studies of Science•2016

  • Social technologies

    Open Access•Maarten Derksen, Signe Vikkelsø et al.•Theory & Psychology•2012

  • Towards hydrosocial autonomy within modernity. A long-term analysis (1850–1980) of socio-material fracturing of flood protection infrastructures in an Alpine valley

    Open Access•Antoine Brochet, Jean‐Dominique Creutin et al.•Political Geography•2025

  • Nanotechnology in the City

    Arnim Wiek, David H Guston et al.•Journal of Urban Technology•2013

  • A Cable Laid Is a Cable Played

    Björn Wallsten, Nils Johansson et al.•Journal of Urban Technology•2013

  • All That Is Urban Melts into Data

    Michelle Mouton, R Burns•Journal of Urban Technology•2025

  • Disassembling Bike-Sharing Systems

    Fábio Duarte•Journal of Urban Technology•2016

  • Agricultural innovations for sustainability? Diverse pathways and plural perspectives on rice seeds in Odisha, India

    Open Access•Sanjeev Arora, Bhuvana Narayanarao et al.•Agriculture and Human Values•2024

  • (Re-)locating ‘place’ in energy demand

    Open Access•George Marsden, Stefan Bouzarovski et al.•Geoforum•2025

  • Materiality matters

    Open Access•Sachin Tiwale•Geoforum•2019

  • Beyond passive consumption

    Open Access•Sophie Schramm, Lucía Wright-Contreras•Geoforum•2017

  • Infrastructure governance for the Anthropocene

    Open Access•Mikhail Chester, Mikhail V Chester et al.•Elementa Science of the…•2020

  • Towards a Sociotechnical Horizon of Expectations

    Open Access•Darryl Cressman•Philosophy & Technology•2026

  • A socio-natural standpoint to understand coproduction of water, energy and waste services

    Luisa Moretto, Marco Ranzato•Urban Research & Practice•2017

  • The smart city and its publics

    Open Access•Roger Cowley, Sandra Jo et al.•Urban Research & Practice•2018

  • Infrastructure and the environment in the Anthropocene

    Open Access•Mikhail Chester, Samuel A Markolf et al.•Journal of Industrial Ecology•2019

  • Shockwaves

    Open Access•Sara Fregonese•Conflict and Society•2021

  • Rewritten in stone

    Gruia Bădescu•Cultural Studies•2020

  • Interpreting mega-development projects as territorial traps

    Open Access•Marina Bertoncin, Andrea Pase•Geographica Helvetica•2017

  • The social construction of technological stasis

    Open Access•Matthias Plennert•Big Data & Society•2018

  • Dossier « Politiques locales de l’énergie

    Open Access•Yoan Miot•Natures Sciences Sociétés•2021

  • The enactment of policy inside an academic profession

    Francisco Salinas•Journal of Education Policy•2023

  • Conceptualizing urban transformative capacity

    Open Access•Marc Wolfram•Cities•2016

  • Citizen engagement and urban change

    Open Access•Sarah R Davies, Cynthia Selin et al.•Cities•2012

  • Do cities have tools to meet their climate targets? The limits of soft governance in climate action plans

    Open Access•Håvard Haarstad, Jakob Grandin et al.•Cities•2024

  • Governing cities for sustainable energy

    Open Access•Janette Webb, David Hawkey et al.•Cities•2016

  • Climate change and non-migration — exploring the role of place relations in rural and coastal Bangladesh

    Open Access•M M Golam Rabbani, Matthew Cotton et al.•Population and Environment•2022

  • Embracing change in infrastructure landscapes

    Vanesa Castán Broto, Enora Robin•Landscape Research•2023

  • Divided City, Divided Infrastructures

    Open Access•Timothy Mo, Timothy Moss•Journal of Urban History•2009

  • Scientific knowledge

    Barry Barnes•Scientific knowledge•1996

  • Science in action

    Bruno Latour•Science in action•1987

  • The Sociology of Culture

    Diana Crane•The Sociology of Culture•1994

  • Managing technology in society

    Arie Rip, Johan Schot et al.•Managing technology in society•1995

  • Changing Large Technical Systems

    Jane Summerton•Changing Large Technical Systems•2021

  • Down the asphalt path

    Clay Mcshane•Down the asphalt path•1994

  • Technology's storytellers

    John M Staudenmaier•Technology's storytellers•1985

  • Technology and the rise of the networked city in Europe and America

    Gabriel Dupuy, Joel A Tarr•Technology and the rise of the…•1988

  • Social Responses to Large Technical Systems

    Open Access•Todd R La Porte, Todd R Porte•Social Responses to Large…•1991

  • Networks of Power

    Thomas Hughes, Thomas Park Hughes et al.•Networks of power•1993

  • Splintering Urbanism

    Steve Graham, Simon Marvin et al.•Splintering Urbanism•2002

  • Telecommunications and the City

    Steve Graham, Simon Marvin et al.•Telecommunications and the City•2002

  • Urban Fortunes

    Logan Molotch, John R Logan et al.•Urban Fortunes•2007

  • Of bicycles, bakelites, and bulbs

    Wiebe E Bijker•Of bicycles, bakelites, and bulbs•1995

  • The Social construction of technological systems

    T J Pinch, Thomas Parke Hughes et al.•The Social construction of…•1989

  • The Social shaping of technology

    Donald A Mackenzie, Judy Wajcman•The Social shaping of technology•1985

  • Handbook of Science and Technology Studies

    Sheila Jasanoff, Gerald E Markle et al.•Handbook of Science and…•1995

  • The Development of Large Technical Systems

    Thomas Hughes, Renate Mayntz et al.•The Development of Large…•2019

  • Technology and culture

    H A Warren•The Vocational Aspect of Education•1950

  • Sociohistorical Technology Studies

    Wiebe E Bijker•Handbook of Science and…•2012

  • The Social Shaping of Technology

    Robin Williams, David Edge•Information and Communication…•1996

  • Exploring the City. Inquiries Toward an Urban Anthropology

    Ulf Hannerz•Exploring the City. Inquiries…•1980

  • How can we Assess the Content of Urban Research

    Open Access•Raymond J Burby, Edward J Kaiser•Urban Affairs Quarterly•1988

  • City-building regimes in post-war Stockholm

    Anders Gullberg, Arne Kaijser•Journal of Urban Technology•2004

  • Technology and the City

    Josef W Konvitz, Myra Rose et al.•OAH Magazine of History•1990

  • The postmodern invasion

    Open Access•Sharon Zukin•International Journal of Urban…•1992

  • The Social Construction of Facts and Artefacts

    Open Access•Trevor Pinch, Trevor J Pinch et al.•Social Studies of Science•1984

  • Light, Heat, and Power

    Open Access•Mark H Rose, Mark Rose et al.•Journal of Urban History•1979

  • The Networked City

    Open Access•Eugene P Moehring•Journal of Urban History•1990

  • Sites, Cities, and Technologies

    Open Access•Bill Luckin•Journal of Urban History•1991

  • Infrastructural Improvement in Nineteenth-Century Cities

    Open Access•Christine Meisner Rosen•Journal of Urban History•1986

  • Splintering Networks

    Open Access•Simon Guy•Urban Studies•1997

  • District Heating Comes to Town

    Mikael Hard, Jane Summerton•Technology and Culture•1994

  • Notes on the Underground

    Joseph W Slade, Rosalind Williams•Technology and Culture•1991

  • Obduracy and Urban Sociotechnical Change

    Open Access•Anique Hommels•Urban Affairs Review•2000

  • L'urbanisation du capital

    D C Harvey, David Harvey•Actuel Marx•2004

  • The City Unbound

    Open Access•J M Jacobs•Urban Studies•1993

  • Do Politics Have Artefacts

    Open Access•Bernward Joerges•Social Studies of Science•1999

  • Constructing a City

    Open Access•Eduardo Aibar, Wiebe E Bijker•Science Technology & Human Values•1997

  • The Social Construction of Technology

    Open Access•Hans K Klein, Hans Klein et al.•Science Technology & Human Values•2002

  • Technology Theory and Deliberative Democracy

    Open Access•Patrick W Hamlett•Science Technology & Human Values•2003

  • Interpreting Invention as a Cognitive Process

    Open Access•Michael E Gorman, W Bernard Carlson•Science Technology & Human Values•1990

  • How Machines Make History, and how Historians (And Others) Help Them to Do So

    Open Access•Thomas J Misa•Science Technology & Human Values•1988

  • Technology and the City

    Josef W Konvitz, Mark H Rose et al.•Technology and Culture•1990

  • Lewis Mumford

    Kenneth R Stunkel, Thomas P Hughes et al.•The Journal of Interdisciplinary…•1992

  • Down the Asphalt Path

    Peter J Hugill, Clay Mcshane•Technology and Culture•1995

  • William Morris's Socialist Diary

    Florence Boos, Florence S Boos•History Workshop Journal•1982

  • Urban Ideals and the Design of Railroad Stations

    Sally A Kitt Chappell•Technology and Culture•1989

  • Who Built the Built Environment? Artifacts, Politics, and Urban Technology

    Julie Johnson-Mcgrath•Technology and Culture•1997

  • Power, Discretion and Strategy

    Open Access•John Law•The Sociological Review•1990

  • Introduction

    Sven Dierig, Jens Lachmund et al.•Osiris•2003

  • Techno-economic Networks and Irreversibility

    Open Access•Michel Callon•The Sociological Review•1990

  • Some Elements of a Sociology of Translation

    Open Access•Michel Callon•The Sociological Review•1984

  • What buildings do

    Open Access•Thomas F Gieryn•Theory and Society•2002

Unique citing works146
Citations per year7,3
Citation span2006 - 2026 (21)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedYes
Citation typesNeutral: 136

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae