Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Feeding 9 billion people

Global Food Security Debates and the Productionist Trap

Bibliographic Data

ID6289866
AuthorsÈve Fouilleux (0000-0001-6991-0932, Université de Montpellier, corresponding author), Nicolas Bricas (Center for International Cooperation and Research in Agriculture for Development (Cirad), Unité Marché Organisations Institutions et Stratégies d'Acteurs (Moisa), Montpellier, France), Arlène Alpha (Center for International Cooperation and Research in Agriculture for Development (Cirad), Unité Marché Organisations Institutions et Stratégies d'Acteurs (Moisa), Montpellier, France)
Year2017
Volume24
Issue11
Pages1658-1677
Publication date2017-11-29
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessNo
TypeARTICLE
VenueJournal of European Public Policy (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 1350-1763 • E-ISSN: 1466-4429
PublisherInforma UK Limited (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1080/13501763.2017.1334084
OpenAlexW2625159568
LanguageEN
Citations received38
References cited47

Food security, a long-established item on the international agenda, raises many issues including production, consumption, poverty, inequalities, healthcare and conflicts. However, in 2007/2008 the global food security debate was relaunched with a single dominant focus which continues to the present day: increasing agricultural production. This paper explains this productionist bias – which may translate into inadequate policies – by combining insights from institutionalist and cognitive analyses. We show that, despite recent reforms, the global food security field remains dominated by macro- and micro-institutions that put food availability and agricultural production at the heart of the problem and solutions. The political and discursive strategies developed by transnational corporations and private foundations to promote their productivist interests are also key, along with the demands of dominant farmers' unions in exporting countries. Although advocating opposite development patterns, civil society actors implicitly reinforce the productionist perspective through their focus on family agriculture

Agriculture · Biology · Development economics · Economics · Food security · Geography · Political economy · Political science · Trap (plumbing · Agriculture, Land Use, Rural Development · Food Security and Health in Diverse Populations · Organic Food and Agriculture · Ecology

  • Why do large-scale agricultural investments induce different socio-economic, food security, and environmental impacts? Evidence from Kenya, Madagascar, and Mozambique

    Open Access•Christoph Oberlack, Markus Giger et al.•Conservation Ecology•2021

  • From Transition to Domains of Transformation

    Open Access•Colin Ray Anderson, Colin Anderson et al.•Sustainability•2019

  • Trajectories and turning points

    Open Access•Allison Loconto, Matthias Weber et al.•Technological Forecasting and…•2026

  • Science, Technology and Food Security

    Open Access•Antoine Bernard De Raymond, Frédéric Goulet•Science Technology and Society•2020

  • Debating Global Food Security Through Models The Agrimonde Foresight Study (2008–2010) and Criticism of Economic Models and of Their ‘Productionist’ Translations

    Open Access•Gilles Tétart•Science Technology and Society•2020

  • Family Farming and The Emergence of an Alternative Sociotechnical Imaginary in Argentina

    Open Access•Frédéric Goulet•Science Technology and Society•2020

  • Technovisions for Food Security as Sweden Restores Its Civil Defence

    Open Access•Camilla Eriksson, Klara Fischer et al.•Science Technology and Society•2020

  • Bounded Futures

    Open Access•Vincent Cardon•Science Technology and Society•2020

  • Convergências Entre a Soberania Alimentar E a Agroecologia

    Open Access•Diamantino Pereira, Tamires Fakih et al.•Terra Livre•2024

  • Le cheminement des controverses dans la globalisation néo-libérale

    Open Access•Ève Fouilleux, Bruno Jobert•Gouvernement et action publique•2017

  • The land sparing – land sharing controversy

    Open Access•Allison Loconto, Marion Desquilbet et al.•Land Use Policy•2020

  • Forests support people’s food and nutrition security through multiple pathways in low- and middle-income countries

    Open Access•Rasmus Skov Olesen, Charlotte Hall et al.•One Earth•2022

  • Policies to combat nitrogen pollution in South Asia

    Open Access•Anastasia Yang, Nandula Raghuram et al.•Environmental Research Letters•2022

  • Local rice cultivar diversity and household food security in northern Iran

    Open Access•Somayeh Shirazi, S M Hassan A Shirazi et al.•Environment Development and…•2023

  • Strengthening the governance of food systems for nutrition in Africa

    Open Access•Anne Marie Thow, David Neves et al.•Public Health Nutrition•2024

  • Understanding the grain deal and its pitfalls

    Open Access•Caroline Dufy•New Perspectives•2024

  • Aligned Sustainability Understandings? Global Inter-Institutional Arrangements and the Implementation of SDG 2

    Open Access•Helmut Breitmeier, Sandra Schwindenhammer et al.•Politics and Governance•2021

  • Food system narratives to end hunger

    Open Access•Molly D Anderson, Marta G Rivera-Ferre•Current Opinion in Environmental…•2021

  • Moving beyond pesticides

    Open Access•Frédéric Goulet, Alexis Aulagnier et al.•Environmental Science & Policy•2023

  • Politicized Sustainability and Agricultural Policy

    Helmut Breitmeier, Sandra Schwindenhammer et al.•Journal of Comparative Policy…•2020

  • Explaining Policy Convergence and Divergence through Policy Paradigm Shifts

    Open Access•Thies R Popp•Journal of Comparative Policy…•2019

  • Late bloomer? Agricultural policy integration and coordination patterns in climate policies

    Niels Martin Schmidt, Nicole M Schmidt•Journal of European Public Policy•2019

  • Digital Agroecology and the Inhuman

    Open Access•Georgios Tsagdis•Journal of Agricultural and…•2025

  • Reframing the sustainable seafood narrative

    Open Access•Michael F Tlusty, Peter Tyedmers et al.•Global Environmental Change•2019

  • The troubled path to food sovereignty in Nepal

    Open Access•Puspa Raj Sharma, Carsten Daugbjerg•Agriculture and Human Values•2019

  • The agroecological transition in Senegal

    Open Access•Boillat, Raphaël Belmin et al.•Agriculture and Human Values•2021

  • AD, Volume 48, n° 4, 2023 - Full Issue

    Open Access•Journal System, Journal System Journal System•Africa Development•2024

  • Meat or mitigation? That's the question

    Open Access•Jessica Larsson, Jostein Vik•Journal of Rural Studies•2023

  • Exploring national trajectories of organic agriculture in Africa. Comparing Benin and Uganda

    Open Access•Pauline Bendjebbar, Ève Fouilleux•Journal of Rural Studies•2021

  • Food, power and agency

    Open Access•Antonio Allegretti, Johnstone O Omukoto et al.•Maritime Studies•2025

  • Food security in times of war

    Open Access•Caroline Dufy•International Sociology•2023

  • New ‘old’ risks on the small farm

    Open Access•Dominic Duckett, Hilde Bjorkhaug et al.•Land Use Policy•2022

  • The rise and fall of the New Alliance for Food Security and Nutrition

    Dagmar Milerová Prášková, Josef Novotný•Third World Quarterly•2021

  • Make bloom and let wither

    Open Access•Ryan Stock, Maaz Gardezi•Geoforum•2021

  • Food crises in the third food regime

    Open Access•Phoebe Stephens, Lucy Hinton•Agriculture and Human Values•2024

  • Sécurité alimentaire, souveraineté alimentaire et politiques publiques

    Ève Fouilleux, Théo Régniez et al.•Regards croisés sur l'économie/Rega…•2023

  • Brazilian Foreign Policy and Family Farming

    Open Access•Juliana R Luiz, Carlos R S Milani•Contexto Internacional•2022

  • Toxic Sensorium

    Open Access•Serena Stein, Jessie K Luna et al.•Environment and Society•2021

  • The Spirit of the Soil

    Paul B Thompson•Spirit of the Soil•2005

  • Process-Tracing Methods

    Open Access•Derek Beach, Rasmus Brun Pedersen et al.•Process-Tracing Methods:…•2013

  • Transnational Communities

    Open Access•Marie-Laure Salles-Djelic, Marie-Laure Djelic et al.•Transnational Communities•2010

  • Knowledge Actors and Transnational Governance

    Open Access•Diane Stone•Knowledge Actors and Transnational…•2013

  • Anatomy of a crisis

    Open Access•Derek D Headey, Derek Headey et al.•Agricultural Economics•2008

  • Institutional Evolution and Change

    Andrew J Hoffman•Academy of Management Journal•1999

  • Food security governance

    Open Access•Jeroen J L Candel•Food Security•2014

  • Measuring Food Insecurity

    Open Access•Christopher B Barrett•Science•2010

  • Food Security

    Open Access•H Charles J Godfray, John R Beddington et al.•Science•2010

  • From Moby Dick to Free Willy

    Open Access•T B Lawrence, Nelson Phillips•Organization•2004

  • From productivism to post‐productivism … and back again? Exploring the (un)changed natural and mental landscapes of European agriculture

    Open Access•Geoff A Wilson•Transactions of the Institute of…•2001

  • Making Food Count

    Open Access•Suzan Ilcan, Lynne Phillips•Canadian Review of Sociology/Revue…•2003

  • Defining World Hunger

    Lucy Jarosz•Food Culture & Society•2011

  • Food security and global environmental change

    Open Access•Polly J Ericksen, Polly Ericksen et al.•Environmental Science & Policy•2009

  • Food security and the justification of productivism in New Zealand

    Open Access•Chris J Rosin, Christopher Rosin•Journal of Rural Studies•2012

  • Doubling food production to feed the 9 billion

    Open Access•Isobel Tomlinson•Journal of Rural Studies•2011

  • Food security

    Open Access•Damian Maye, John Kirwan et al.•Journal of Rural Studies•2013

  • Food security

    Open Access•Simon Maxwell•Food Policy•1996

  • Measuring food insecurity

    Open Access•Daniel G Maxwell•Food Policy•1996

  • Commanding Heights? The Strength and Fragility of Business Power in Global Politics

    Open Access•Doris Fuchs•Millennium Journal of International…•2005

  • The State of Family Farms in the World

    Open Access•Benjamin E Graeub, M Jahi Johnson‐chappell et al.•World Development•2015

  • La Vía Campesina and the UN Committee on World Food Security

    Open Access•Josh Brem-Wilson•Review of International Studies•2017

  • The World Food Council

    D John Shaw•Canadian Journal of Development…•2010

  • World Development Report 2008

    World Bank, Derek Byerlee•Agriculture and development.•2007

  • CAP Reforms and Multilateral Trade Negotiations

    Ève Fouilleux•West European Politics•2004

  • Politics of private regulation

    Open Access•Allison Loconto, Ève Fouilleux•Regulation & Governance•2014

  • Power through, over and in ideas

    Open Access•Martin B Carstensen, Vivien A Schmidt•Journal of European Public Policy•2016

  • Post-exceptionalism in public policy

    Carsten Daugbjerg, Peter H Feindt•Journal of European Public Policy•2017

  • The Regime Complex for Food Security

    Matias E Margulis•Global Governance A Review of…•2013

  • World Politics and Organizational Fields

    Open Access•Klaus Dingwerth, Philipp Pattberg•European Journal of International…•2009

  • Introduction

    Open Access•Pierre Lascoumes, Patrick Le Galès•Governance•2007

  • À propos de crises mondiales

    Ève Fouilleux•Revue française de science…•2009

  • Some Elements of a Sociology of Translation

    Open Access•Michel Callon•The Sociological Review•1984

  • Food Security

    Open Access•Patrick H Mooney, Scott A Hunt•Rural Sociology•2009

Unique citing works38
Citations per year4,22
Citation span2017 - 2026 (10)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 37

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae