Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

How Unregulated Is the U.S. Labor Market? The Penal System as a Labor Market Institution

Bibliographic Data

ID7611269
AuthorsB Western (0000-0001-8615-6767, Princeton University), Katherine Beckett (0000-0002-5523-087X, Indiana University)
Year1999
Volume104
Issue4
Pages1030-1060
Publication date1999-01-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessNo
TypeARTICLE
VenueAmerican Journal of Sociology (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0002-9602 • E-ISSN: 1537-5390
PublisherUniversity of Chicago Press (PUBLISHER • US)
DOI10.1086/210135
OpenAlexW2088253486
LanguageEN
Citations received237
References cited33

Comparative research contrasts the corporatist welfare states of Europe with the unregulated U.S. labor market to explain low rates of U.S. unemployment in the 1980s and 1990s. In contrast, this article argues that the U.S. state made a large and coercive intervention into the labor market through the expansion of the penal system. The impact of incarceration on unemployment has two conflicting dynamics. In the short run, U.S. incarceration lowers conventional unemployment measures by removing able‐bodied, working‐age men from labor force counts. In the long run, social survey data show that incarceration raises unemployment by reducing the job prospects of ex‐convicts. Strong U.S. employment performance in the 1980s and 1990s has thus depended in part on a high and increasing incarceration rate

Economic growth · Economics · Institution · Labour economics · Market economy · Political science · Unemployment · Welfare · Welfare state · Welfare system · Fiscal Policy and Economic Growth · Gender, Labor, and Family Dynamics · Labor market dynamics and wage inequality

  • Changing cartographies of health in a globalizing world

    Open Access•Ted Schrecker•Medicine Anthropology Theory•2014

  • Punishing Immigrants

    Open Access•Amairini Sanchez, Michele Cadigan et al.•RSF The Russell Sage Foundation…•2022

  • Institutional Castling

    Open Access•Bryan L Sykes, A K Bailey•RSF The Russell Sage Foundation…•2020

  • Working to Avoid Incarceration

    Open Access•Zatz Zatz, Stoll Stoll•RSF The Russell Sage Foundation…•2020

  • A Wealth of Inequalities

    Open Access•Bryan L Sykes, Michelle Maroto•RSF The Russell Sage Foundation…•2016

  • Level of Criminal Justice Contact and Early Adult Wage Inequality

    Open Access•R Apel, Kathleen Powell•RSF The Russell Sage Foundation…•2019

  • Exclusion and Extraction

    Open Access•Sandra Susan Smith, Jonathan Simon•RSF The Russell Sage Foundation…•2020

  • Lest we forget thee

    Open Access•Alexes Harris, Walter R Allen et al.•Race and Society•2003

  • Velvet Glove, Iron Fist, or Even Hand? Protest Policing in the United States, 1960-1990

    Sarah A Soule, Sarah Soule et al.•Mobilization An International…•2009

  • Megan's Law

    Open Access•Jonathan Simon•Law & Social Inquiry•2000

  • Policing Social Marginality

    Open Access•Steve Herbert, Katherine Beckett et al.•Law & Social Inquiry•2017

  • Criminal Punishment, Labor Market Outcomes, and Economic Inequality

    Open Access•Brett C Burkhardt•Law & Social Inquiry•2009

  • Cárceles Privadas

    Open Access•Isabel Arriagada Gajewski•Política criminal•2013

  • La persistente importancia de las clases

    Open Access•A Portes•Estudios Sociológicos de El…•2003

  • Exchange, Action, and Social Structure

    Richard Swedberg, Milan Zafirovski•Contemporary Sociology A Journal…•2002

  • Resisting Homelessness

    Talmadge Wright•Contemporary Sociology A Journal…•2000

  • Do Affluent Countries Face an Incomes-Jobs Trade-Off

    Open Access•Lane Kenworthy•Comparative Political Studies•2003

  • Reintegrating women leaving jail into urban communities

    Beth E Richie•Journal of Urban Health•2001

  • Narrative im Justizvollzug. Identitäten von Mitarbeitenden, medialer Diskurs und historischer Kontext

    Christopher Young•Narrative im Justizvollzug.…•2018

  • Orange-Collar Labor

    Michael Gibson-Light•Orange-Collar Labor•2023

  • The Prisoners' Dilemma

    Open Access•Nicola Lacey•Prisoners' Dilemma•2008

  • Asset Manager Capitalism as a Corporate Governance Regime

    Open Access•Bonnie Braun•American Political Economy•2021

  • The Effect of Incarceration on Marriage and Work Over the Life Course

    Beth M Huebner•Justice Quarterly•2005

  • Coercive mobility and crime

    Todd R Clear, DINA R ROSE et al.•Justice Quarterly•2003

  • Labeling and Cumulative Disadvantage

    Open Access•Giza Lopes, Marvin D Krohn et al.•Crime & Delinquency•2012

  • Das „europäische Sozialmodell” und die USA

    Jens Alber•Leviathan•2006

  • The Role of the Law in the American Political Economy

    Open Access•K Sabeel Rahman, Kathleen Thelen•American Political Economy•2021

  • Labour Market Regimes Under Threat? Sources of Continuity in Germany, Britain, and Sweden

    Stewart Wood•The New Politics of the Welfare…•2001

  • Welfare State and Production Regimes in the Era of Retrenchment

    E Huber, Joyce Stephens et al.•The New Politics of the Welfare…•2001

  • Political Institutions and Welfare State Restructuring

    Duane Swank•The New Politics of the Welfare…•2001

  • Who Pays for Health Care Reform?

    Susan Giaimo•The New Politics of the Welfare…•2001

  • Partisan Competition and Welfare State Retrenchment

    Herbert Kitschelt•The New Politics of the Welfare…•2001

  • The Comparative Political Economy of Pension Reform

    John Myles, Paul Pierson•The New Politics of the Welfare…•2001

  • The Political Economy of Social Pacts

    Martin Rhodes•The New Politics of the Welfare…•2001

  • Round Up the Usual Suspects!

    Herman Schwartz•The New Politics of the Welfare…•2001

  • Political Institutions, Veto Points, and the Process of Welfare State Adaptation

    Giuliano Bonoli•The New Politics of the Welfare…•2001

  • Post‐Industrial Pressures on the Mature Welfare States

    Paul Pierson•The New Politics of the Welfare…•2001

  • The New Politics of the Welfare State

    Paul Pierson•The new politics of the welfare…•2001

  • Comparative Institutional Advantages of Welfare State Regimes and New Coalitions in Welfare State Reforms

    Philip Manow•The New Politics of the Welfare…•2001

  • The Dynamics of Welfare State Expansion

    Trine Iversen, Torben Iversen•The New Politics of the Welfare…•2001

  • Coping With Permanent Austerity Welfare State Restructuring in Affluent Democracies

    Paul Pierson•The New Politics of the Welfare…•2001

  • The Political Economies of Red States

    Open Access•Jacob M Grumbach, Jacob S Hacker et al.•American Political Economy•2021

  • The Politics of Economic Inequality

    D Brady, Benjamin Sosnaud•Handbooks of Sociology and Social…•2010

  • The American Political Economy

    Open Access•Alex Hertel-Fernandez, Kathleen Ann Thelen et al.•American Political Economy•2021

  • Same as it Never Was

    Open Access•Mark Blyth•Comparative European Politics•2003

  • Inequitable access to sport in juvenile justice across the USA

    Open Access•Kalyn McDonough, Erin K Knight•Health Promotion International•2023

  • Converging on the Poles

    Open Access•Angelina Snodgrass Godoy•Law & Social Inquiry•2005

  • Jails, prisons, and the health of urban populations

    Nicholas Freudenberg•Journal of Urban Health•2001

  • Searching for Work with a Criminal Record

    Open Access•Sandra Susan Smith, Nora Broege et al.•Social Problems•2020

  • The More You Have, The More You Lose

    Open Access•C R Dennison, Stephen Demuth•Social Problems•2018

  • Invisible Men

    C Wildeman•Social Forces•2013

  • The Current Crisis of American Criminal Justice

    Open Access•David Garland•Annual Review of Criminology•2023

  • Love after lockup

    Open Access•Jemar R Bather, Anna-Michelle Marie McSorley et al.•Health & Justice•2024

  • The health effects of gendered and devalued work

    Open Access•Sage J Kim, Caryn E Peterson et al.•Health & Justice•2020

  • “An Enormous Amount of Human Waste”

    Open Access•Anaïs Lefèvre•Transatlantica•2020

  • Criminal History, Sex, and Employment

    Open Access•Colin P Holloway, Richard L Wiener•Analyses of Social Issues and…•2020

  • How Jailed Mothers Envision Future Motherhood in the Context of State Intrusion

    Open Access•Ella Siegrist, L Broidy•Journal of Contemporary Criminal…•2025

  • The Long-Term Incarceration Consequences of Coming-of-Age in a Crime Boom

    Open Access•David Bjerk, Shawn D Bushway et al.•Journal of Quantitative Criminology•2023

  • Spiegare le variazioni della politica sociale e penale con il principio di less eligibility

    Françoise Bonnet, François Bonnet•Sociologia del Lavoro•2022

  • Advocating for an Incarcerated Informed Lens in Therapy

    Open Access•Eman Tadros, Rayna Hutcherson et al.•International Journal of Offender…•2021

  • Pathways to second chances

    Open Access•C Allen Gorman, Sarah Tucker et al.•Journal of Vocational Behavior•2025

  • The racial implications of the effects of parental incarceration on intergenerational mobility

    Open Access•Marcus Shaw•Sociology Compass•2016

  • Converging on the Poles

    Open Access•Angelina Snodgrass Godoy•Law & Social Inquiry•2005

  • Educational Attainment, Teacher-Student Ratios, and the Risk of Adult Incarceration Among U.S. Birth Cohorts Since 1910

    Open Access•Richard Arum, G Lafree•Sociology of Education•2008

  • Reconsidering the Relationship between Incarceration, Trust in the State, Community Engagement, and Civic Participation

    Open Access•Youngmin Yi, Peter K Enns et al.•Socius Sociological Research for…•2024

  • Erasing the Mark of a Criminal Record

    Patrick R Cundiff•Corrections•2016

  • Pathways to Skin Color Stratification

    Open Access•M Abascal, Denia Garcia•Sociological Science•2022

  • Unintended Consequences

    Open Access•Anna R Haskins•Sociological Science•2014

  • Prison, Coerced Demand, and the Importance of Incarcerated Bodies in Late Capitalism

    Open Access•Natalie Delia Deckard•Social Currents•2016

  • Milwaukee's Disregarded Population

    Open Access•Lenard Wells•SAGE Open•2013

  • Authoritarianism and the precariat

    Bill Jordan•Global Discourse•2013

  • A Relational Theory of Inequality in the Criminal Legal System

    Open Access•Muriel Clair, Matthew Clair•Sociology Compass•2026

  • Institutional competitiveness in the global economy

    Open Access•Gary Shaffer, John L Campbell et al.•Regulation & Governance•2007

  • The Origins of Mass Incarceration

    Open Access•Katherine Beckett, Megan Ming Francis•Annual Review of Law and Social…•2020

  • Who Benefits from Mass Incarceration? A Stratification Economics Approach to the “Collateral Consequences” of Punishment

    Open Access•Tasseli Mckay, William Darity•Annual Review of Law and Social…•2024

  • Racial Innocence

    Naomi Murakawa•Annual Review of Law and Social…•2019

  • Commerce with Criminals

    Open Access•Michael Hallett•Review of Policy Research•2004

  • Criminal background check laws and labor market inequality in the United States

    Open Access•David Mcelhattan•Criminology & Public Policy•2024

  • On cash and conviction

    Open Access•Katherine Beckett, Alexes Harris•Criminology & Public Policy•2011

  • Effect of Electronic Monitoring on Social Welfare Dependence

    Open Access•Lars Højsgaard Andersen, Signe H Andersen•Criminology & Public Policy•2014

  • Homeless Shelter Use and Reincarceration Following Prison Release

    Open Access•Stephen Metraux, Dennis P Culhane•Criminology & Public Policy•2004

  • Neoliberalism, criminal justice and Latinos

    Open Access•Martin Guevara Urbina, Sofía Espinoza Álvarez•Latino Studies•2016

  • When work is punishment

    Open Access•Erin Hatton•Punishment & Society•2017

  • Race, crime, and forprofit imprisonment

    Open Access•Michael Hallett, Michael A Hallett•Punishment & Society•2002

  • Theoretical advances and problems in the sociology of punishment

    Open Access•David Garland•Punishment & Society•2017

  • Decarceration and its possible effects on inmates, staff, and communities

    Open Access•Brett Garland, Nancy L Hogan et al.•Punishment & Society•2014

  • Whither neoliberal penality? The past, present and future of imprisonment in the US

    Open Access•Sappho Xenaki, Leonidas K Cheliotis•Punishment & Society•2018

  • Novus Ordo Saeclorum

    Open Access•D F Greenberg•Punishment & Society•2001

  • Extraction without reserve

    Open Access•Justin D Strong•Punishment & Society•2022

  • The Causes and Consequences of Prison Growth in the United States

    Open Access•Marc Mauer•Punishment & Society•2001

  • Lesson‐drawing in family policy

    Janet C Gornick, Marcia K Meyers•Journal of Comparative Policy…•2001

  • Twin towers, iron cages and the culture of control

    J Hagan•Critical Review of International…•2004

  • Laziness or liberation? Labor market policies and workers' attitudes toward employment flexibility

    Open Access•Lena Hipp, Christopher J Anderson•International Journal of Social…•2015

  • Neoliberalism’s penal and debtor states

    Open Access•John L Campbell•Theoretical Criminology•2010

  • The Environmental Paradox of the Welfare State

    Open Access•Daniel Bailey•New Political Economy•2015

  • Constructing the rapist

    Shelby Holme, Shelby Holmes et al.•Social Identities•2019

  • Male Nonemployment in White, Black, Hispanic, and Multiethnic Urban Neighborhoods, 1970−2000

    Open Access•Robert L Wagmiller•Urban Affairs Review•2008

  • Father Absence and Youth Incarceration

    Open Access•Cynthia C Harper, Mclanahan et al.•Journal of Research on Adolescence•2004

  • Introduction

    Open Access•Daniel Béland, Martin Seeleib‐kaiser•Journal of European Social Policy•2025

  • Get to Work or Go to Jail

    Open Access•Noah D Zatz, Noah Zatz•Law & Social Inquiry•2019

  • Internal labor markets and manpower analysis

    Peter B Doeringer•Internal labor markets and…•1985

  • Time series analysis

    George E P Box, Gregory C Reinsel et al.•Time series analysis•1970

  • Crime in the making

    John H Laub, Robert J Sampson•Crime in the making•1993

  • The decline of organized labor in the United States

    Michael Goldfield•The decline of organized labor in…•1987

  • Punishment and Social Structure

    Georg Rusche, Otto Kirchheimer et al.•Punishment and Social Structure•1939

  • What Went Wrong? The Erosion of Relative Earnings and Employment Among Young Black Men in the 1980s

    J Bound, R B Freeman•The Quarterly Journal of Economics•1992

  • Bargaining Structure, Corporatism and Macroeconomic Performance

    Open Access•Lars Calmfors, John Driffill et al.•Economic Policy•1988

  • The Rise and Decline of Nations

    Mancur Olson•The Rise and Decline of Nations•2022

  • Social Protection vs. Economic Flexibility

    Rebecca M Blank•Social Protection Versus Economic…•1994

  • Politics in hard times

    Peter Gourevitch, Peter Alexis Gourevitch•Politics in hard times•1986

  • Punishment and Social Structure

    D Melossi, Georg Rusche et al.•Punishment and Social Structure•2017

  • Crime and Social Justice

    Open Access•Anthony M Platt, Herman Schwendinger et al.•Crime and Social Justice•1981

  • Analysis of Panel Data

    Open Access•Cheng Hsiao•Analysis of Panel Data•2003

  • Malign Neglect Race, Crime, And Punishment In America

    Michael Tonry, Michael H Tonry•Malign neglect--race, crime, and…•1995

  • The Effect of Arrests on the Employment and Earnings of Young Men

    Jeffrey Grogger•The Quarterly Journal of Economics•1995

  • Economic Action and Social Structure

    Mark Granovetter•American Journal of Sociology•1985

  • Research and Methodology

    WOUTER BUIKHUISEN, FOKKE P H DIJKSTERHUIS•The British Journal of Criminology•1971

  • The Political Economy of Unemployment

    Michael Shalev, T Janoski•Contemporary Sociology A Journal…•1991

  • An exploration of the determinants of labor market performance for prison releasees

    Open Access•Ann Dryden Witte, Pamela A Reid•Journal of Urban Economics•1980

  • Welfare States and Employment Regimes

    Jon Eivind Kolberg, G Esping-Andersen•International Journal of Sociology•1991

  • The Interaction of Welfare States and Labor Markets

    Kåre Hagen, Kåre Petter Hagen•International Journal of Sociology•1990

  • Openness for Prosperity

    Richard Cooper, Herbert Giersch•Foreign Affairs•1993

  • Police Productivity and Crime Rates

    Open Access•Robert M O’brien, Robert M O'Brien•Criminology•1996

  • Postrelease Depression and the Importance of Familial Support

    Open Access•Sheldon Ekland-Olson, SHELDON EKLAND‐OLSON et al.•Criminology•1983

  • Does Conviction Affect Employment Opportunities

    Roger Boshier, Derek Johnson•The British Journal of Criminology•1974

  • Political and Economic Explanations for Unemployment

    Open Access•Walter Korpi•British Journal of Political…•1991

  • Great Transformation

    Open Access•Vadim Radaev, Вадим Радаев•Journal of Economic Sociology•2002

  • Two Studies of Legal Stigma

    Richard D Schwartz, Jerome H Skolnick•Social Problems•1962

  • Spillover, standardization and stratification

    Tom Colbjørnsen, A L Kalleberg•European Sociological Review•1988

Unique citing works237
Citations per year8,78
Citation span1999 - 2026 (28)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedYes
Citation typesNeutral: 220

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae