Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

The Recognition Game

Soviet Russia Against the West

Bibliographic Data

ID8911941
AuthorsErik Ringmar (0000-0002-8110-6514, London School of Economics and Political Science, corresponding author)
Year2002
Volume37
Issue2
Pages115-136
Publication date2002-06-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueCooperation and Conflict (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0010-8367 • E-ISSN: 1460-3691
PublisherSAGE Publishing (PUBLISHER • US)
DOI10.1177/0010836702037002973
OpenAlexW2042440824
LanguageEN
Citations received84
References cited79

The problem with traditional explanations of relations between states is that they focus on matters of interests and pay insufficient attention to matters of identities. This article seeks to improve on this situation by providing a formal discussion of the role of recognition. World politics is best described as a recognition game rather than as a prisoner's dilemma. To prove the applicability of this argument, an analysis is made of the relations that obtained between Soviet Russia and the West. From the perspective of the alternative, identity-based, model, a number of the most important events of the twentieth century are explained in quite a new fashion

Aesthetics · Argument (complex analysis · Dilemma · Economics · Epistemology · Focus (optics · Identity (music · International relations · Law and economics · Perspective (graphical · Political economy · Political science · Politics · Positive economics · Prisoner's dilemma · Sociology · Artificial Intelligence · Computer Science · International Relations and Foreign Policy · Law · Religion and Society Interactions

  • A Nonpermanent Seat in the United Nations Security Council

    Open Access•Ann-Marie Ekengren, Ann‐marie Ekengren et al.•Global Governance A Review of…•2020

  • Russia's European Choice

    Ted Hopf•Russia's European Choice•2008

  • Regions and Powers

    Barry Buzan, Ole Waever•Regions and Powers•2009

  • Cultural Diplomacy

    Duncan Clarke, David Clarke•Comparative Immigration Policy•2020

  • Power, knowledge, and pipelines

    Murad Ismayilov•Caucasus Survey•2014

  • Ruptures in Depiction—Recognition and Political Cartoons of Putin

    Open Access•Ákos Kopper•Global Studies Quarterly•2024

  • Russia’s great power imaginary and pursuit of digital multipolarity

    Open Access•Stanislav Budnitsky•Internet Policy Review•2020

  • China's Role in Global Development Finance

    Open Access•Salvatore Babone, John H S Åberg et al.•Global Policy•2020

  • The struggle for recognition, ontological security and the case of China as a rising power

    Open Access•Siavash Chavoshi, Mohammad Reza Saeidabadi•International Politics Reviews•2021

  • The Red Mirror

    Gulnaz Sharafutdinova•Red Mirror•2020

  • Russia's Quest for International Society and the Prospects for Regional-Level International Societies

    Open Access•Pami Aalto•International Relations•2007

  • Acknowledging pain

    Open Access•Irena Kalhousová, Emmanuelle Blanc•Cooperation and Conflict•2026

  • Confirming, suturing and transforming international recognition

    Open Access•Elif Kalaycıoğlu•International Theory•2025

  • Is Desecuritisation of Memory Possible? Ontological Dissonance and the Curious Case of the Russian–Polish Mnemonic Reconciliation

    Natalia Morozova•Europe Asia Studies•2025

  • Recognising recognition through thick and thin

    Open Access•Kristina Gustafsson, Karl Gustafsson•Cooperation and Conflict•2015

  • Power, knowledge, and pipelines

    Murad Ismayilov•Caucasus Survey•2014

  • Challenges in the Baltic Sea region

    Anke Schmidt-Felzmann, Kjell Engelbrekt•Global Affairs•2018

  • Spiraling toward a New Cold War in the North? The Effect of Mutual and Multifaceted Securitization

    Open Access•Julie Wilhelmsen•Journal of Global Security Studies•2020

  • Recognition and the origins of international society

    Erik Ringmar•Global Discourse•2014

  • Illusions of independence

    Michelle Murray•Global Discourse•2024

  • Differentiating recognition in international politics

    Michelle Murray•Global Discourse•2014

  • Gender, power and international (mis)recognition

    Tanya Narozhna•Global Discourse•2023

  • Det store nordiske rum

    Open Access•Henrik Ø Breitenbauch•Internasjonal politikk•2017

  • Respect and disrespect in international politics

    Open Access•Reinhard Wolf•International Theory•2011

  • An intercultural theory of international relations

    Open Access•Jörg Friedrichs•International Theory•2015

  • Duelling Honors

    Open Access•Andrei P Tsygankov, Matthew Tarver-Wahlquist•Foreign Policy Analysis•2009

  • The Ontological (In)security of Similarity Wahhabism Versus Islamism in Saudi Foreign Policy

    Mahmud Darwich•Foreign Policy Analysis•2016

  • Crimea Is Ours!” Russian popular geopolitics in the new media age

    Mikhail Suslov•Eurasian Geography and Economics•2014

  • When the “subaltern empire” speaks. On recognition, Eurasian integration, and the Russo-Georgian war

    Danijela Čanji, Aliaksei Kazharski•Eurasian Geography and Economics•2022

  • Contested Identity and Foreign Policy

    Open Access•Andrei P Tsygankov•International Studies Perspectives•2012

  • A Typology of Ontological Insecurity Mechanisms

    Open Access•Hugo von Essen, August Danielson•International Studies Review•2023

  • Nations, national identity and prestige

    Steve Wood•National Identities•2014

  • Ontological security, the struggle for recognition, and the maintenance of security communities

    Open Access•Patrícia Greve•Journal of International…•2017

  • Forum-shifting from above and below

    Open Access•Caroline Fehl•Journal of International…•2024

  • Indigeneity and subaltern subjectivity in decolonial discourses

    Open Access•Viacheslav Morozov, Viatcheslav Morozov et al.•Journal of International…•2016

  • Introduction by guest editor

    Open Access•Pertti Joenniemi•Journal of International…•2008

  • Special issue

    Open Access•Andrea Oelsner, Antoine Vion•International Politics•2010

  • Constructing great powers

    Open Access•Catherine Jones•International Politics•2014

  • Peace Mediation and the Minefield of International Recognition Games

    Karin Aggestam•International Negotiation•2015

  • Recognition through dialogue

    Open Access•Emmanuelle Blanc•The British Journal of Politics…•2021

  • Suturing the Neighborhood? Russia and the EU in Conflictual Intersubjectivity

    Aliaksei Kazharski, Andrey Makarychev•Problems of Post-Communism•2015

  • Misrecognition, ontological security and state foreign policy

    Tanya Narozhna•Australian Journal Of International…•2021

  • Going global

    Christian Reus-Smit•Australian Journal Of International…•2021

  • International recognition regimes and the projection of France

    Jeremy Ahearne•International Journal of Cultural…•2018

  • Assessing Cultural and Regime-Based Explanations of Russia's Foreign Policy. ‘Authoritarian at Heart and Expansionist by Habit’

    Andrei P Tsygankov•Europe Asia Studies•2012

  • Das Deutschlandbild

    Open Access•Steve Wood•Contemporary European History•2018

  • Recognition in the European Union

    Jozef Bátora•Cambridge Review of International…•2025

  • Identity and recognition

    Kristina Gustafsson•The Pacific Review•2014

  • Crisis in EU-US relations under Trump

    Open Access•Emmanuelle Blanc•Journal of European Integration•2024

  • Constructing Interfaces

    Rikard Bengtsson•Journal of European Integration•2008

  • Political opportunities and the quest for political recognition in Tibet, Taiwan, and Palestine

    DaShanne Stokes•International Review of Sociology•2019

  • Keeping face in the public sphere

    Bernardo Teles Fazendeiro, Bernardo da Silva Relva Teles Fazendeiro•Central Asian Survey•2015

  • Sovereign equality as misrecognition

    Open Access•Ayşe Zarakol•Review of International Studies•2018

  • What does it take to be a great power? The story of France joining the Big Five

    Open Access•Gadi Heimann•Review of International Studies•2015

  • Grading greatness

    Pål Røren, Paul R Beaumont•Third World Quarterly•2019

  • Forum on Recognition in Foreign Policy (Analysis) and (The Study of) Diplomacy

    Open Access•Stefano Guzzini, Sam Okoth Opondo et al.•Contexto Internacional•2024

  • On the Social Status of the European Union

    Open Access•Pål Røren•JCMS Journal of Common Market…•2019

  • The return of the Nordic voice at the United Nations

    Open Access•Katie Verlin Laatikainen, Kristin E Smith•Cooperation and Conflict•2025

  • The EU’s ontological (in)security

    Open Access•Elisabeth Johansson-Nogués•Cooperation and Conflict•2018

  • From Nordic neutrals to post-neutral Europeans

    Open Access•Ulrika Möller, Ulf Bjereld•Cooperation and Conflict•2010

  • Nation Branding, National Self-Esteem, and the Constitution of Subjectivity in Late Modernity

    Open Access•Christopher S Browning•Foreign Policy Analysis•2013

  • Foreign aid and identity after the Chernobyl nuclear disaster

    Open Access•E Zhukova•Cooperation and Conflict•2017

  • Branding Nordicity

    Open Access•Christopher S Browning•Cooperation and Conflict•2007

  • Competitive Stigmatization in International Conflicts

    Open Access•Brent E Sasley•Global Studies Quarterly•2026

  • Performative power and strategic illusion in Russian foreign policy

    Ana Jović-Lazić•Journal of Political Power•2026

  • The constitutive power of outsiders

    Open Access•Christopher S Browning, George Christou•Political Geography•2010

  • Struggles for Recognition

    Open Access•Rebecca Adler-Nissen, Ayşe Zarakol•International Organization•2021

  • The End of ‘Central Europe’? The Rise of the Radical Right and the Contestation of Identities in Slovakia and the Visegrad Four

    Aliaksei Kazharski•Geopolitics•2018

  • National ideology and IR theory

    Open Access•Andrei P Tsygankov, Pavel A Tsygankov et al.•European Journal of International…•2010

  • Spirituality and anti-Western rhetoric in Uzbekistan in the early 2000s

    Bernardo Teles Fazendeiro•Post-Soviet Affairs•2018

  • Recognizing International Status

    Open Access•Marina G Duque•International Studies Quarterly•2018

  • Forum Isolation

    Open Access•Giovanni Mantilla•International Organization•2018

  • Security Communities and the Unthinkabilities of War

    Jennifer Mitzen•Annual Review of Political Science•2016

  • Compliance and non-compliance as sources of recognition

    Jozef Bátora•Communist and Post-Communist…•2013

  • International misrecognition

    Open Access•Rebecca Adler-Nissen, Alexei Tsinovoi•European Journal of International…•2019

  • Regional powers and security

    Open Access•Derrick Frazier, Derrick V Frazier et al.•European Journal of International…•2010

  • Theorizing the globally engaged city in world politics

    Open Access•D J Gordon, Kristin Ljungkvist•European Journal of International…•2022

  • A post-Hegelian theory of human rights

    Open Access•David Jason Karp•European Journal of International…•2025

  • Why a World State is Inevitable

    Open Access•Alexander Wendt•European Journal of International…•2003

  • Representation, recognition and foreign policy in the Iran–US relationship

    Open Access•Constance Duncombe•European Journal of International…•2016

  • Norms as a status marker

    Mohamad Rosyidin, Muhammad Rum et al.•Contemporary Politics•2025

  • Identity Politics and the East China Sea

    Open Access•Wrenn Yennie Lindgren, Petter Y Lindgren•Asian Politics & Policy•2017

  • Dynamics of exclusion and everyday bordering through Schengen visas

    Open Access•Zelal Özdemir, Ayşe Güneş Ayata et al.•Political Geography•2018

  • Governação global e ajuda ao desenvolvimento

    Open Access•Eunice Castro Seixas, Eunice Cristina De Castro Seixas•e-cadernos CES•2008

  • Détente and confrontation

    Raymond L Garthoff•Détente and confrontation•1985

  • The struggle for recognition

    Axel Honneth•The struggle for recognition•1995

  • Perestroika

    Mikhail Sergeevich Gorbachev•Perestroika•1987

  • Superpower Games

    Steven J Bram, Steven J Brams•Superpower Games•1985

  • The Theory of Moral Sentiments

    Adam Smith•The Two Narratives of Political…•2010

  • Essence of Decision

    Graham T Allison•Essence of Decision•1972

  • The tragedy of American diplomacy

    William Appleman Williams•The tragedy of American diplomacy•1984

  • After Hegemony

    Robert O Keohane•After Hegemony•2005

  • The Origins of Detente

    Open Access•Stephen E White, Stephen White•Origins of Detente•1985

  • The Rivals

    B F Cooling, Jack B Hilliard et al.•Military Affairs•1972

  • The Soviet Union and the Origins of the Second World War

    Open Access•Geoffrey K Roberts, Geoffrey Roberts•The Soviet Union and the Origins…•1995

  • The Soviets in World Affairs

    Robert J Kerner, Louis Fischer•The American Historical Review•1931

  • Identity, Interest and Action

    Open Access•Erik Ringmar•Identity, Interest and Action•1996

  • War and Change in World Politics

    Open Access•Robert Gilpin, Robert Gılpın•War and change in world politics•1981

  • Russia and the Idea of Europe

    Iver B Neumann•Russia and the Idea of Europe•2013

  • Phenomenology of Spirit

    Open Access•Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel•On Violence•2007

  • The End of the Empire

    Martin Kitchen•The British empire and commonwealth•1996

  • Retreat from Power

    Open Access•David Dilks•Retreat from Power•1981

  • An Economic Theory of Alliances

    Mancur Olson, Richard Zeckhauser•The Review of Economics and…•1966

  • After the Tumult

    Gary R Hess•Diplomatic History•1988

  • The Emerging Post-Revisionist Synthesis on the Origins of the Cold War

    John Lewis Gaddis•Diplomatic History•1983

  • The End of U.S. Cold War History? A Review Essay

    Lynn Eden, Melvyn P Leffler•International Security•1993

  • Civil religion and the arms race

    Open Access•Sheldon Ungar•Canadian Review of Sociology/Revue…•1991

  • The end of the outer Empire—Soviet-East European Relations in Transition, 1985-90

    Open Access•S Nihal Singh•India Quarterly A Journal of…•1992

  • End of the ‘low, dishonest decade’

    Michael Jabara Carley•Europe Asia Studies•1993

  • Metaphor in Political Discourse

    Open Access•Paul Chilton, Mikhail M Ilyin et al.•Discourse & Society•1993

  • Explaining the emergence of great power concerts

    Open Access•Benjamin Miller•Review of International Studies•1994

  • The Sources and Prospects of Gorbachev's New Political Thinking on Security

    Stephen M Meyer•International Security•1988

  • The Origins of Overkill

    David Rosenberg, David Alan Rosenberg•International Security•1983

  • The Origins of the Second World War

    Wilson Carey Mcwilliams, A J P Taylor•The Western Political Quarterly•1963

  • Gorbachev's Struggle for Economic Reform

    David M Kemme, Anders Aslund•The Russian Review•1991

  • The Origins of Detente

    Anthony R De Luca, Stephen E White et al.•The Russian Review•1987

  • Prelude to Appeasement

    Piotr S Wandycz, Lisanne Radice•The Russian Review•1982

  • The Rivals

    E Berkeley Tompkins, Adam B Ulam•The Russian Review•1972

  • The Soviets in World Affairs. A History of the Relations between the Soviet Union and the Rest of the World, 1917-1929

    Louis Fischer•The Russian Review•1951

  • Burying Lenin

    S Neil MacFarlane, Steven Kull•The Russian Review•1993

  • Detente and Confrontation

    Robert Dallek, Raymond L Garthoff•The Russian Review•1986

  • Soviet Foreign Policy since World War II

    Walter C Clemens, Joseph L Nogee et al.•The Russian Review•1982

  • Détente in Europe

    Open Access•Raymond L Garthoff•Political Science Quarterly•1992

  • The Politics of War

    Thomas G Paterson, Gabriel Kolko•Journal of American History•1969

  • The Heavens and the Earth

    Clayton R Koppes, Walter A Mcdougall•Journal of American History•1986

  • The Politics of War

    Wilfrid Knapp, Gabriel Kolko•International Journal Canada s…•1970

  • Russia's Road to the Cold War

    William Hayter, Vojtech Mastny•International Journal Canada s…•1979

  • Soviet foreign policy, the League of Nations and Europe, 1917–1939

    Lorna Lloyd•International Affairs•1987

  • The cold war

    Nigel Clive•International Affairs•1988

  • The Cold War and its Origins 1917–1960

    W N Medlicott•International Affairs•1962

  • From Trust to Terror

    Geoffrey Warner•International Affairs•1972

  • Neorealism and its critics

    Barry Buzan•International Affairs•1986

  • The Soviet High Command

    Norman H Gibbs, Norman Gibbs•International Affairs•1963

  • Sputnik, Scientists and Eisenhower

    Richard G Head, James R Killian•Foreign Affairs•1978

  • From Brezhnev to Gorbachev

    John C Campbell, Hans‐joachim Veen et al.•Foreign Affairs•1987

  • The origins of the cold war

    Open Access•H James, Marzenna James•The Historical Journal•1994

  • The end of history and the last man

    Francis Fukuyama•The end of history and the last man•1992

  • Ideas, Institutions, and the Gorbachev Foreign Policy Revolution

    Open Access•Jeffrey T Checkel, Jeff Checkel•World Politics•1993

  • Integrity and Disrespect

    Open Access•A Honneth•Political Theory•1992

  • The Diplomats, 1919-1939

    John C Cairns, Gordon A Craig et al.•International Journal Canada s…•1954

  • Responsibility for the Cold War - A Case Study in Historical Responsibility

    Robert V Stover, Robert Stover•History and Theory•1972

  • The League of Nations in Retrospect

    Albert Resis•The Journal of Modern History•1985

  • Origins of the Cold War

    Arthur M Schlesinger, Arthur Schlesinger•Foreign Affairs•1967

  • War Origins Again

    Anthony Adamthwaite•The Journal of Modern History•1984

  • The Genesis of Gorbachev's World

    Seweryn Bialer, Joan Afferica•Foreign Affairs•1985

  • The Cold War and Its Origins, 1917-1960

    F H Soward, D F Fleming•Pacific Affairs•1962

  • Social Theory for a Changing Society

    Zdzislawa Walaszek Coleman, Pierre Bourdieu et al.•Social Theory for a Changing…•2019

  • Politics and Culture in International History

    Adda B Bozeman•Politics and Culture in…•2017

  • Mind, Self, and Society

    George Herbert Mead, Charles W Morris•Mind, self, and society•1967

  • Dramas, Fields, and Metaphors

    Victor Turner•Dramas, Fields, and Metaphors•2018

Unique citing works84
Citations per year3,65
Citation span2003 - 2026 (24)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 83

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae