Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Dynamic Diversity

Toward a Contextual Understanding of Critical Mass

Bibliographic Data

ID9733822
AuthorsLiliana M Garces (0000-0002-8224-0512, Pennsylvania State University, University Park, PA, corresponding author), Uma Mazyck Jayakumar (0000-0003-1193-7483, University of San Francisco)
Year2014
Volume43
Issue3
Pages115-124
Publication date2014-04-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueEducational Researcher (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0013-189X • E-ISSN: 1935-102X
PublisherAmerican Educational Research Association (AERA) (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.3102/0013189x14529814
OpenAlexW2118669728
LanguageEN
Citations received44
References cited60

Through an analysis of relevant social science evidence, this article provides a deeper understanding of critical mass, a concept that has become central in litigation efforts related to affirmative action admissions policies that seek to further the educational benefits of diversity. We demonstrate that the concept of critical mass requires an understanding of the conditions needed for meaningful interactions and participation among students, given the particular institutional context. To highlight this contextual definition of critical mass and to avoid further obfuscations in the legal debate, we offer the term dynamic diversity and outline four main components of dynamic diversity that institutions can attend to. By thinking of dynamic diversity as the goal, institutions and lawyers should be better poised to answer the question of how much diversity is necessary for leveraging its educational benefits

Action (physics · Affirmative action · Context (archaeology · Critical mass (sociodynamics · Diversity (politics · Engineering ethics · Epistemology · Political science · Public relations · Social science · Sociology · Term (time · Critical Race Theory in Education · Higher Education Research Studies · Law · School Choice and Performance

  • Race/Ethnicity and Social Adjustment of Adolescents

    Sandra Graham•Educational Psychologist•2018

  • The Racial Mascot Speaks

    Oiyan Poon, OiYan A Poon et al.•Review of higher education/ The…•2018

  • Diversity Ideologies and Racial Commodification

    Open Access•Román Liera, Aireale J Rodgers et al.•Innovative Higher Education•2026

  • An examination of the bidirectional relationship between federal civil rights guidance and research

    Open Access•Maria M Lewis, Sarah Kern•Education Policy Analysis Archives•2020

  • Racial conflict in a higher education policy vacuum

    Open Access•Blanca Elizabeth Vega•Education Policy Analysis Archives•2024

  • “What’s Math Got to Do with It?” Emphasizing Math as an Impediment to STEM Excellence for Black Students

    Open Access•Kirk D Rogers•Education Sciences•2024

  • Why Are All the White Kids Sitting Together in the Cafeteria

    Open Access•Uma Mazyck Jayakumar, Annie S Adamian et al.•Education Sciences•2021

  • The Diversity and Success of Medical School Applicants With Scores in the Middle Third of the MCAT Score Scale

    Carol A Terregino, Aaron Saguil et al.•Academic Medicine•2020

  • How Do Affirmative Action Bans Affect the Racial Composition of Postsecondary Students in Public Institutions

    Open Access•Huacong Liu•Educational Policy•2022

  • When Students Speak Out

    Open Access•Richard Blissett, Richard S L Blissett et al.•Teachers College Record The Voice…•2020

  • “What Is the Real Belief on Campus?” Perceptions of Racial Conflict at a Minority-Serving Institution and a Historically White Institution

    Open Access•Blanca Elizabeth Vega•Teachers College Record The Voice…•2021

  • Racial/ethnic disparities in academic achievement in U.S. middle schools

    Open Access•Hye‐young Yun, Hye-Young Yun et al.•Journal of School Psychology•2024

  • Numerical Minority Status in Middle School and Racial/Ethnic Segregation in Academic Classes

    Open Access•Kara Kogachi, Sandra Graham•Child Development•2020

  • An Education Scholar and a Tightrope Walker

    Open Access•Christina S Haynes•International Journal of…•2022

  • Engaging race and racism for socially just intergroup relations

    Jaclyn Rodríguez, Biren A Nagda et al.•Multicultural Education Review•2018

  • Reproducing whiteness through diversity

    Marlo Goldstein Hode, Rebecca J Meisenbach•Journal of Diversity in Higher…•2016

  • Beyond the numbers

    Louis Rocconi, Aaron N Taylor et al.•Journal of Diversity in Higher…•2018

  • A critical race feminist analysis of men of color matriculating into a higher education doctoral program

    Dian D Squire, Bridget Turner Kelly et al.•Journal of Diversity in Higher…•2016

  • Manipulating diversity

    Open Access•Amy L Petts, Alma Nidia Garza•Sociology Compass•2021

  • From Predominantly White to Hispanic-Serving

    Open Access•Gabriel Velez, Jacqueline Black et al.•Journal of Hispanic Higher…•2023

  • Diversity’s twilight Zone

    Hoang Vu Tran•Race Ethnicity and Education•2017

  • Is Affirmative Action interfering with the Chinese dream in America? Exploring WeChat users’ views on Affirmative Action in US. college admissions

    Marc P Johnston‐guerrero, Kai Zhao•Race Ethnicity and Education•2020

  • Imperialistic reclamation of higher education diversity initiatives through semantic co-option and concession

    Naomi W Nishi•Race Ethnicity and Education•2020

  • The vacuous rhetoric of diversity

    Dian D Squire, Dian Squire•International Journal of…•2017

  • Women executives and off‐the‐job misconduct by high‐profile employees

    Open Access•Mary E Graham, Mary Graham et al.•Journal of Organizational Behavior•2020

  • Aligning Diversity, Quality, and Equity

    Liliana M Garces•American Journal of Education•2014

  • Selective High School Admissions Policies in Court

    Benjamin Michael Superfine, Benjamin Superfine et al.•American Journal of Education•2025

  • Data snapshots of the access and participation of ‘women’ academics in UK universities

    Open Access•Dina Zoe Belluigi, Jason Arday et al.•British Educational Research…•2024

  • Promoting Cross-Racial and Ethnic Friendships in Schools

    Open Access•Mei-ki Chan, Aprile D Benner•Journal of Youth and Adolescence•2025

  • It’s Pretty Essential”

    Open Access•Dian D Squire•The Urban Review•2020

  • Voices of Aspiring Teachers of Color

    Open Access•Conra D Gist•Urban Education•2017

  • Balancing Liberty and Equality

    Open Access•Liliana M Garces•Educational Researcher•2015

  • Beyond the Incident

    Dominique J Baker, Richard Blissett et al.•The Journal of Higher Education•2017

  • Strategies of Resistance among Racially Minoritized Students at a Hispanic-Serving Institution

    Eddie Comeaux, Sara E Grummert et al.•The Journal of Higher Education•2020

  • The Imperative to Promote Diversity Post- Students for Fair Admissions Analyzing the Effects of Student-Body Diversity on Attrition, GPA, and Bar Passage in Law Students and Graduates

    Open Access•Jason Scott, Jason M Scott et al.•The Journal of Higher Education•2024

  • The Far Reach of the Texas Top Ten Percent Plan

    Toni Templeton, Chaunté L White et al.•The Journal of Higher Education•2023

  • What Discourse on the Texas Top Ten Percent Plan Says about Accountability for Diversity

    Dina C Maramba, Venice Thandi Sulé et al.•The Journal of Higher Education•2015

  • Community-As-Difference

    Debbie Sonu, Sherry L Deckman•Educational Studies•2021

  • Repressive Legalism

    Open Access•Liliana M Garces, Brianna Davis Johnson et al.•American Educational Research…•2021

  • The College Access and Choice Processes of High-Achieving African American Students

    Open Access•Eddie Comeaux, Thandeka K Chapman et al.•American Educational Research…•2020

  • Affirming Race, Diversity, and Equity Through Black and Latinx Students’ Lived Experiences

    Open Access•Rican Vue, Siduri J Haslerig et al.•American Educational Research…•2017

  • The Demise of Affirmative Action in College Admissions

    Open Access•Natasha Warikoo•Annual Review of Sociology•2025

  • Toward a Healthy Racial Climate

    Open Access•Rita Kohli, Alison G Dover et al.•Journal of Teacher Education•2022

  • Critical Mass for Affirmative Action

    Open Access•Jessica Rose Kalbfeld•Law & Society Review•2019

  • Keeping track

    Jeannie Oakes•Keeping track•2005

  • Higher Education: Handbook of Theory and Research

    Open Access•Michael B Paulsen•Higher Education : Handbook of…•2014

  • The Difference

    Sarah E Page, Scott Page•Difference•2008

  • Nine themes in campus racial climates and implications for institutional transformation

    Open Access•Shaun R Harper, Sylvia Hurtado•New Directions for Student Services•2007

  • Diversity and Higher Education

    Patricia Gurin, Eric L Dey et al.•Harvard Educational Review•2002

  • Promoting Participation in a Diverse Democracy

    Open Access•Nicholas A Bowman•Review of Educational Research•2011

  • Latent Ability

    Open Access•Gary M Walton, J Spencer et al.•Psychological Science•2009

  • Extending Notions of Campus Climate and Diversity to Students' Transition to College

    Angela M Locks, Sylvia Hurtado et al.•Review of higher education/ The…•2008

  • Predicting transition and adjustment to college

    Open Access•Sylvia Hurtado, June C Han et al.•Research in Higher Education•2007

  • Differing Perceptions

    Susan Rankin, Susan R Rankin et al.•Journal of college student…•2005

  • College Diversity Experiences and Cognitive Development

    Open Access•Nicholas A Bowman•Review of Educational Research•2010

  • Enhancing Campus Climates for Racial/Ethnic Diversity

    Sylvia Hurtado, Jeffrey F Milem et al.•Review of higher education/ The…•1998

  • Effects of Racial Diversity on Complex Thinking in College Students

    Open Access•Anthony Lising Antonio, Mitchell J Chang et al.•Psychological Science•2004

  • Can Higher Education Meet the Needs of an Increasingly Diverse and Global Society? Campus Diversity and Cross-Cultural Workforce Competencies

    Uma Mazyck Jayakumar, Uma Jayakumar•Harvard Educational Review•2008

  • A Model for Diverse Learning Environments

    Open Access•Sylvia Hurtado, Cynthia L Alvarez et al.•Higher Education : Handbook of…•2012

  • Journal of Negro Education

    Laura Renée Chandler•2009

  • Stereotypes as Explanations

    Open Access•Vincent Yzerbyt, Craig Mcgarty et al.•Stereotypes as Explanations•2002

  • “Assume the Position . . . You Fit the Description”

    Open Access•W Alan Smith, William A Smith et al.•American Behavioral Scientist•2007

  • Intergroup Cognition and Intergroup Behavior

    Constantine Sedikides, John Schopler et al.•Intergroup Cognition and…•2013

  • Signaling Threat

    Open Access•Mary C Murphy, Claude M Steele et al.•Psychological Science•2007

  • The Effects of Affirmative Action Bans on College Enrollment, Educational Attainment, and the Demographic Composition of Universities

    Peter Hinrichs•The Review of Economics and…•2012

  • Racial microaggressions and the Asian American experience

    Derald Wing Sue, Jennifer Bucceri et al.•Asian American Journal of…•2009

  • Assessing the value of climate assessments

    Sylvia Hurtado, Kimberly A Griffin et al.•Journal of Diversity in Higher…•2008

  • A longitudinal examination of the role of stereotype threat and racial climate on college outcomes for minorities at elite institutions

    Open Access•M J Fischer•Social Psychology of Education•2009

  • Beyond a Dream Deferred

    Karen Brodkin Sacks, Karen Sacks et al.•Contemporary Sociology A Journal…•1995

  • The Next Generation of Diversity and Intergroup Relations Research

    Open Access•Sylvia Hurtado•Journal of Social Issues•2005

  • Social identity contingencies

    Valerie Purdie-Vaughns, Valerie Purdie‐Vaughns et al.•Journal of Personality and Social…•2008

  • Diversity and Moral Reasoning

    Matthew J Mayhew, Mark E Engberg•The Journal of Higher Education•2010

  • Campus Racial Climate and the Adjustment of Students to College

    Alberto F Cabrera, Amaury Nora et al.•The Journal of Higher Education•1999

  • The Role of Perceptions of Prejudice and Discrimination on the Adjustment of Minority Students to College

    Amaury Nora, Alberto F Cabrera•The Journal of Higher Education•1996

  • The Campus Racial Climate

    Sylvia Hurtado•The Journal of Higher Education•1992

  • Stereotypic explanatory bias

    Open Access•Denise Sekaquaptewa, Penelope Espinoza et al.•Journal of Experimental Social…•2003

  • Seeing is believing

    Open Access•Nilanjana Dasgupta, Shaki Asgari•Journal of Experimental Social…•2004

  • Understanding the Impact of Affirmative Action Bans in Different Graduate Fields of Study

    Open Access•Liliana M Garces•American Educational Research…•2013

  • Racial Diversity Matters

    Open Access•Nida Denson, Mitchell J Chang•American Educational Research…•2009

  • Some Effects of Proportions on Group Life

    Rosabeth Moss Kanter•American Journal of Sociology•1977

  • Enhancing the impact of counterstereotypic information

    David A Wilder, Andrew F Simon et al.•Journal of Personality and Social…•1996

  • A question of belonging

    Gary M Walton, Gregory M Walton et al.•Journal of Personality and Social…•2007

  • Critical Race Theory, Racial Microaggressions, and Campus Racial Climate for Latina/o Undergraduates

    Tara J Yosso, Tara Yosso et al.•Harvard Educational Review•2009

  • A threat in the air

    Claude M Steele•American Psychologist•1997

  • Keeping Race in Place

    Daniel Solóranzo, Walter R Allen et al.•Chicana/o Latina/o Law Review•2002

  • Cognitive adaptation to the experience of social and cultural diversity

    Richard J Crisp, Richard N Turner•Psychological Bulletin•2011

  • Effects of College Transition and Perceptions of the Campus Racial Climate on Latino College Students' Sense of Belonging

    Sylvia Hurtado, Deborah Faye Carter•Sociology of Education•1997

  • The End of Affirmative Action in Washington State and Its Impact on the Transition from High School to College

    Open Access•Susan K Brown, Charles Hirschman•Sociology of Education•2006

Unique citing works44
Citations per year3,67
Citation span2014 - 2026 (13)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 44

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae