Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Theological Correctness

Cognitive Constraint and the Study of Religion

Bibliographic Data

ID12201804
AuthorsJustin L Barrett (0000-0001-7178-5237, 1Calvin College, corresponding author)
Year1999
Volume11
Issue4
Pages325-339
Publication date1999-01-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessNo
TypeARTICLE
VenueMethod & Theory in the Study of Religion (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0943-3058 • E-ISSN: 1570-0682
PublisherBrill (PUBLISHER • NL)
DOI10.1163/157006899x00078
OpenAlexW2004014836
LanguageEN
Citations received111

In both natural and religious thinking, people have ntultiple versions of the same concepts that may be contradictory. In the domain of religious concepts, these ntultiple levels of representation in single individuals may be termed "Theological Correctness." Versions of religioiis concepts range front fairly simple or concrete to very complex and abstract. Selection of the, concept to be used in any given context is largely dependent on the cognitive processing demands of the task. In tasks in which there is great derrtand to draw quick and rich inferences, a basic concept comprised largely of intuitive knowledge, is used. In tasks in which there is less demand, as when one is slowly and carefully riflecting on one's knowledge, more complicated, intuition violating theoretical concepts may be drawn upon. In the domain of religious concepts these concepts closely match traditional theology and so may be termed theological concepts. Implications for data gathering and theorizing in the study of religion are discussed. Finally, these observations suggest the. importance of insights from cognitive sciertce, for the study of religion

Algorithm · Cognition · Cognitive psychology · Cognitive science · Correctness · Epistemology · Intuition · Representation (politics · Sociology · Computer Science · Evolution and Science Education · Evolutionary Game Theory and Cooperation · Philosophy · Psychology · Social Psychology · Study and Philosophy of Religion

  • Weaving Together Culture and Cognition

    Rita Astuti•Intellectica Revue de l…•2007

  • Religion in Mind

    Jesper Sørensen•Numen•2005

  • The Cognitive Study of Religious Activity

    P Boyer•Oxford Handbook of the Cognitive…•2022

  • Culturing Belief

    Open Access•N Levy•Bad Beliefs•2021

  • Concluding Thoughts

    Open Access•N Levy•Bad Beliefs•2021

  • Key Ingredients for a World Religion

    James van Slyke, D Jason Slone•Oxford Handbook of the Cognitive…•2022

  • What Should We Believe About Belief?

    Open Access•N Levy•Bad Beliefs•2021

  • Lived Faith and Cognitive Intuitions

    Laird R O Edman, Myron A Penner•Oxford Handbook of the Cognitive…•2022

  • How Our Minds Are Made Up

    Open Access•N Levy•Bad Beliefs•2021

  • The Failure of Religious Systems

    Hugh Turpin, Jonathan A Lanman•Oxford Handbook of the Cognitive…•2022

  • Nudging Well

    Open Access•N Levy•Bad Beliefs•2021

  • Dare to Think?

    Open Access•N Levy•Bad Beliefs•2021

  • Epistemic Pollution

    Open Access•N Levy•Bad Beliefs•2021

  • Historical and Ethnographic Setting

    E Cohen•The Mind Possessed•2007

  • Spirits as Concepts

    E Cohen•The Mind Possessed•2007

  • The Social Relevance of Spirits

    E Cohen•The Mind Possessed•2007

  • The Research Community

    E Cohen•The Mind Possessed•2007

  • Observing Possession

    E Cohen•The Mind Possessed•2007

  • Introducing Possession

    E Cohen•The Mind Possessed•2007

  • Explaining Distributions of Spirit Concepts and Spirit Possession

    E Cohen•The Mind Possessed•2007

  • Medicalist, Physiological, and Sociological Explanations

    E Cohen•The Mind Possessed•2007

  • Describing, Interpreting, and Explaining Spirit Possession

    E Cohen•The Mind Possessed•2007

  • Naturalismus a protekcionismus ve studiu náboženství

    Juraj Franek•Naturalismus a protekcionismus ve…•2017

  • Religion's evolutionary landscape

    Open Access•Atran, Scott Atran et al.•Behavioral and Brain Sciences•2004

  • Religious credence is not factual belief

    Open Access•Neil Van Leeuwen•Cognition•2014

  • The essential moral self

    Open Access•Nina Strohminger, Shaun Nichol et al.•Cognition•2014

  • Social Identity Processes in the Development of Maximally Counterintuitive Theological Concepts

    H Nicholson•Journal of the American Academy…•2014

  • Presidential Address

    A Taves•Journal of the American Academy…•2011

  • Learning psychology changes deep-rooted beliefs about the nature of psychological phenomena

    Open Access•Francisco Cruz, André Mata•Learning and Instruction•2026

  • «Anthropomorphism» as a Source of Religious Representations

    Open Access•Dmitry Horyevoy•St. Tikhons' University Review•2015

  • Believing in Shmeliefs

    Open Access•N Levy•Ergo an Open Access Journal of…•2024

  • Seeing Afar

    Jadyn Forman, Jed Forman•Journal of Cognitive Historiography•2022

  • Fast and Slow

    Benjamin Beit-Hallahmi, Benjamin Beit‐hallahmi•Journal for the Cognitive Science…•2021

  • Claire White’s An Introduction to the Cognitive Science of Religion

    LUTHER H MARTIN•Journal for the Cognitive Science…•2022

  • Is Religion Special

    Open Access•Jordan W Moon, Adam B Cohen et al.•Perspectives on Psychological…•2023

  • Against Intellectual Autonomy

    Open Access•N Levy•Social Epistemology•2024

  • Why Do God and Humans Punish? Perceived Retributivist Punishment Motives Hinge on Views of the True Self

    Open Access•Young-Eun Lee, James P Dunlea et al.•Personality and Social Psychology…•2024

  • One God but three concepts

    Carissa A Sharp, Peter J Rentfrow et al.•Psychology of Religion and…•2017

  • Whose Theology? The Promise of Cognitive Theories and the Future of a Disputed Field

    Nickolas P Roubekas•Religion and Theology•2014

  • Idolatry, indifference, and the scientific study of religion

    Open Access•Daniel Linford, JASON MEGILL•Religious Studies•2020

  • Holding doctrinal belief as an artefact

    Open Access•Elena Kalmykova•Religious Studies•2021

  • Dilemmas with Disciplinary Hierarchies and Ideals of Scientific Research in the Study of Religion

    Indrek Peedu•Implicit Religion•2023

  • Kinship in Mind

    Doug Jones•Focality and Extension in Kinship•2018

  • Theological Incorrectness

    D Jason Slone•Theological Incorrectness•2004

  • Minds and Gods

    Todd Tremlin, E Thomas Lawson•Minds and gods•2006

  • Bad Beliefs

    Open Access•N Levy•Bad Beliefs•2021

  • The Cognition of Hardship Experience in Himalayan Pilgrimage

    Andreas Nordin•Numen•2011

  • God as a White man

    Steven O Robert, Kara Weisman et al.•Journal of Personality and Social…•2020

  • The “Archaeology” of Popular Culture

    Open Access•Marek Kaźmierczak•Poznanskie Studia Slawistyczne•2023

  • Do we need to restart the psychology of religion? Commentary on Belzen (2010)

    Benjamin Beit-Hallahmi, Benjamin Beit‐hallahmi•Mental Health Religion & Culture•2010

  • Great houses for whom

    R S Weiner, Ema L Smith•Time and Mind•2021

  • Cross-cultural similarities in reasoning about personal continuity in reincarnation

    Claire White•Religion Brain & Behavior•2016

  • Minding the pandemic

    Open Access•Jonas Svensson•Approaching Religion•2021

  • Kognitywne badania nad religią a antropologia kulturowa

    Open Access•Maciej Czeremski•Etnografia Praktyki Teorie…•2022

  • MCI theory

    B G Purzycki, Aiyana K Willard•Religion Brain & Behavior•2016

  • How much do models of human cognition matter in the study of religious systems

    Open Access•B G Purzycki•Religion Brain & Behavior•2024

  • Predictive coding in agency detection

    Marc Malmdorf Andersen, Marc Andersen•Religion Brain & Behavior•2019

  • Farewell, old syllabus

    R Sosis, Wesley J Wildman et al.•Religion Brain & Behavior•2020

  • From drowning to debunking

    Open Access•Ryan Mckay, N Levy et al.•Religion Brain & Behavior•2025

  • Do religious experiences shape religious beliefs or religious concepts

    Andrew Shtulman•Religion Brain & Behavior•2019

  • Finding consonance

    John Balch, Jordan Grafman et al.•Religion Brain & Behavior•2024

  • Belie the belief? Prompts and default states

    N Levy•Religion Brain & Behavior•2020

  • God

    Open Access•Ilkka Pyysiainen•Temenos - Nordic Journal for the…•2005

  • Understanding Mortality and the Life of the Ancestors in Rural Madagascar

    Open Access•Rita Astuti, Paul L Harris•Cognitive Science•2008

  • In the name of

    Open Access•K A Cerulo, Andrea Kirstie C Barra et al.•Poetics•2008

  • Dalmatian Silvanus

    Open Access•Josipa Lulić•Theoretical Roman Archaeology…•2014

  • Las distancias del creer

    Open Access•Diego Cagüeñas, Diego Cagüeñas Rozo•Revista de Estudios Sociales•2009

  • Good-death Beliefs and Cognition in Himalayan Pilgrimage

    Andy Nordin, Andreas Nordin•Method & Theory in the Study of…•2009

  • Focality and Extension in Kinship

    Warren Shapiro, Warrren Shapiro•Focality and Extension in Kinship•2018

  • Just Out of Reach

    Richard D G Irvine, T Kyriakides•Implicit Religion•2019

  • Revelation and Resolution

    Edward Swenson•Reviews in Anthropology•2010

  • Speculating on the Eschaton

    Gregory D Alles, Gregory Alles•Method & Theory in the Study of…•2004

  • The Mind Possessed

    E Cohen, Emma E A Cohen•The Mind Possessed•2007

  • The spirit is noble, but the flesh is corrupt

    Francisco Cruz, André Mata•Self and Identity•2025

  • Deity Representation

    Open Access•Ross W May, F D Fincham•Archive for the Psychology of…•2018

  • Rethinking with Demons

    Andrew Keitt•Preternature Critical and…•2017

  • Beneath the Surface

    Open Access•Elisa Järnefelt•Secularism and Nonreligion•2020

  • Robert McCauley and Ernest Thomas Lawson, Philosophical Foundations of the Cognitive Science of Religion

    Hans Van Eyghen•Journal for the Study of Religion…•2020

  • From individual to social counterintuitiveness

    Open Access•M Afzal Upal•Mind & Society•2011

  • Reverse Engineering Complex Cultural Concepts

    A Taves•Journal of Cognition and Culture•2015

  • Establishing Personal Identity in Reincarnation

    Claire White•Journal of Cognition and Culture•2015

  • When Seeing Is Not Believing

    Justin L Barrett, Roxanne Moore Newman et al.•Journal of Cognition and Culture•2003

  • Who Wants to Live Forever

    Claire White•Journal of Cognition and Culture•2017

  • Imagery Effects on Recall of Minimally Counterintuitive Concepts

    D Jason Slone, Lauren O Gonce et al.•Journal of Cognition and Culture•2007

  • What Counts as Religious/Spiritual Experience in the US and India

    Open Access•A Taves, Elliott Ihm•International Journal for the…•2025

  • Cognitive Artifacts in the Evolution of Cultural Systems of Beliefs and Practices

    Open Access•Piotr Szymanek, J P Grodniewicz et al.•Method & Theory in the Study of…•2025

  • Religion, Cognition, and the Myth of Conscious Will

    Hugh Nicholson•Method & Theory in the Study of…•2018

  • The Cognitive Foundations of Reincarnation

    Claire White•Method & Theory in the Study of…•2016

  • The Rubber Meets the Road

    Ted Vial•Method & Theory in the Study of…•2004

  • How to Know You’ve Survived Death

    Claire White, Michael Kinsella et al.•Method & Theory in the Study of…•2018

  • Buddha as a God

    B G Purzycki, Edward C Holland•Method & Theory in the Study of…•2019

  • God in the Fractals

    István Czachesz•Method & Theory in the Study of…•2012

  • Counting hiddenness

    Open Access•Adam Green•Religious Studies•2025

  • Naturalistic Explanation for Religious Belief

    Open Access•David Leech, Aku Visala•Philosophy Compass•2011

  • Magic, Religion, and Science

    Open Access•Luke J Matthews, Werner B Hertzog et al.•Journal for the Scientific Study…•2023

  • The religious experience of homeless people who use drugs in the city of Porto - Portugal

    Open Access•Camila Chagas, Luís Fernandes et al.•Ethnography•2025

  • Supernaturalizing Social Life

    Open Access•Matt J Rossano•Human Nature•2007

  • Blessings, strength, and guidance

    Open Access•W Cadge, M Daglian•Poetics•2008

  • Testing the Spirits

    Steven G Smith•The Journal of Religion•2014

  • God is great - but not necessary? On Ara Norenzayan,Big Gods(2013)

    Ilkka Pyysiainen•Religion•2014

Unique citing works111
Citations per year4,83
Citation span2003 - 2026 (24)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedYes
Citation typesNeutral: 109

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae