From Contextual Diversity to Theoretical Patterns

A Concept Analysis of Care in Music Education

Bibliographic Data

ID17575541
AuthorsXiangming Zhang (0000-0002-0023-7396, corresponding author), Zhang Xiang-ming (0000-0002-4607-6233, Norwegian University of Science and Technology, corresponding author), Elin Angelo (0000-0002-1471-4587, Norwegian University of Science and Technology), Ronald Kibirige (0009-0003-2169-4937, Norwegian University of Science and Technology)
Year2026
Publication date2026-04-24
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueInternational Journal of Music Education (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0255-7614 • E-ISSN: 1744-795X
PublisherSAGE Publishing (PUBLISHER • US)
DOI10.1177/02557614261441347
OpenAlexW7155553818
LanguageEN
References cited52

Care has become increasingly recognised as fundamental to ethical music education practice, yet the concept encompasses diverse theoretical approaches reflecting varied contextual needs and scholarly traditions. While this diversity highlights the complexity of care, it can present challenges for operationalising concepts in empirical research. This study addresses the need for heuristic clarity by identifying theoretical patterns across care scholarship in music education. Using Walker and Avant’s concept analysis methodology, this study analysed 33 peer-reviewed sources published between 2000 and 2024, identified through systematic searches of four electronic databases. Data were analysed through collaborative coding and consensus analysis, thereby establishing defining attributes, antecedents, and consequences. Specifically, five interdependent attributes were identified: Relational Attentiveness, Responsive Reciprocity, Vulnerable Competence, Empathetic Compassion, and Transformative Responsibility. Key antecedents enabling care include educator ethical preparedness, recognition of student vulnerability, and supportive institutional contexts, while consequences encompass transformative outcomes for student well-being, agency, and musical engagement alongside enhanced teacher fulfilment. This study establishes care as a sophisticated and multidimensional practice requiring developed skill, critical awareness, and contextual navigation. The proposed framework offers a systematic perspective designed to complement, rather than replace, existing contextual approaches to understanding care in music education

Ambiguity · CLARITY · Concept map · Interdependence · Music education · Scholarship · Transformative learning · Diverse Music Education Insights · Diverse Musicological Studies · Music Therapy and Health

Tools

Open DOIOpen Access