Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Does It Matter Where You Read the News Story? Interaction of Incivility and News Frames in the Political Blogosphere

Bibliographic Data

ID23364009
AuthorsPorismita Borah (0000-0002-1140-4233, Washington State University, Pullman, WA, USA, corresponding author)
Year2014
Volume41
Issue6
Pages809-827
Publication date2014-08-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueCommunication Research (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0093-6502 • E-ISSN: 1552-3810
PublisherSAGE Publications (PUBLISHER • US)
DOI10.1177/0093650212449353
OpenAlexW2164803079
LanguageEN
Citations received102
References cited44

The political blogosphere is replete with uncivil discussions and is apt to examine the influence of incivility on news frames. The present study brings in literature from incivility and framing effects and uses two experiments to examine the influence of incivility on news frames for democratic outcomes such as willingness to participate, online participation, openmindedness, and attitude certainty. Primary findings indicate the detrimental effects of incivility causing less openmindedness and more attitude certainty. At the same time, incivility causes more willingness to participate and online participation. More importantly, the findings demonstrate how incivility interacts with news frames. Implications for news framing effects in the social media landscape are discussed.

Blogosphere · Certainty · Democracy · Epistemology · Framing (construction) · Framing effect · Incivility · Media studies · News media · Persuasion · Political science · Politics · Sociology · The Internet · Computer Science · History · Law · Media Studies and Communication · Psychology · Social and Intergroup Psychology · Social Media and Politics · Social Psychology

  • Kommentoijat julkisina osallistujina

    Open Access•Veera Kangaspunta•Media & viestintä•2022

  • The normative value of political entertainment

    Open Access•Carina Weinmann•Studies in Communication and Media•2019

  • Replying, disliking, flagging

    Open Access•Anja Kalch, Teresa K Naab•Studies in Communication and Media•2017

  • Incivility in user comments on online news articles

    Open Access•Julia Lück, Carlotta Nardi•Studies in Communication and Media•2019

  • Incivility makes me angrier than uncivil disagreement

    Andrés Rosenberg•Journal of Information Technology…•2024

  • A contemporaneidade e o fenômeno da polarização de ideias

    Open Access•Margarita A V Luis, Alisséia G Lemes•SMAD Revista Eletrônica Saúde…•2023

  • When Does Fame Not Matter? Examining Gender Differences in Politicians’ Social Media Experiences

    Open Access•Maarja Lühiste, Stiene Praet et al.•Politics & Gender•2025

  • Post-Truth, Polarization and Other Emotional Threats to Democracy

    Open Access•Alessandra Giordano•Nordicum-Mediterraneum•2020

  • El estudio de la polarización afectiva

    Esteban Freidin, Robert Moro et al.•REVISTA SAAP•2022

  • The Hyperlinked World

    Open Access•Porismita Borah•Journal of Computer-Mediated…•2014

  • Interactions of News Frames and Incivility in the Political Blogosphere

    Porismita Borah•Political Communication•2013

  • Online and Uncivil? Patterns and Determinants of Incivility in Newspaper Website Comments

    Open Access•Kevin Coe, Kate Kenski et al.•Journal of Communication•2014

  • How People Perceive Political Incivility

    Ashley Muddiman•Crisis of Civility?•2019

  • Influence of Discussion Incivility on Deliberation

    Open Access•Hyunseo Hwang, Youngju Kim et al.•Communication Research•2018

  • Online Political Discourse

    Gina M Masullo, Gina Masullo Chen et al.•Journal of Broadcasting &…•2017

  • The Importance of ‘Likes’

    Porismita Borah, Xizhu Xiao•Journal of Health Communication•2018

  • Perceptions of Uncivil Discourse Online

    Open Access•Kate Kenski, Kevin Coe et al.•Communication Research•2020

  • Seeing is Believing

    Hyunseo Hwang, Youngju Kim et al.•Journal of Broadcasting &…•2014

  • The Distorting Prism of Social Media

    Open Access•Jin Woo Kim, Allison M Gue et al.•Journal of Communication•2021

  • Partisan Bias of Perceived Incivility and its Political Consequences

    Open Access•Hai Liang, Xinzhi Zhang•Journal of Communication•2021

  • Deliberation in online political talk

    Open Access•Mark Boukes•Journal of Communication•2025

  • Differential perceptions of and reactions to incivil and intolerant user comments

    Open Access•Anna Sophie Kümpel, Julian Unkel et al.•Journal of Computer-Mediated…•2023

  • Toxic Talk

    Open Access•Andrew A Anderson, Ashley Anderson et al.•International Journal of Public…•2016

  • Keep Calm in Heated Debates

    Open Access•Juliane Tkotz, Dorothe Kienhues et al.•Frontiers in Education•2021

  • Check the Report and Comments

    Open Access•Huai-Kuan Zeng, Tai-Yee Wu et al.•Digital Journalism•2023

  • Uncivil Reactions to Sexual Assault Online

    Open Access•Hannah Stevens, Irena Acic et al.•Cyberpsychology Behavior and…•2021

  • How to report on elections? The effects of game, issue and negative coverage on reader engagement and incivility

    Open Access•Joao Fernando Ferreira Goncalves, Sara Pereira et al.•Journalism•2022

  • Online incivility

    Open Access•Seo Yoon Lee, Weizi Liu et al.•The Communication Review•2026

  • Contextures of hate

    Open Access•Niklas Barth, Elke Wagner et al.•The Communication Review•2023

  • Does Tone of Comments Matter

    Open Access•Seo Yoon Lee, Youngji Seo•Communication Studies•2023

  • The role of emotions in climate change communication

    Open Access•Shujun Liu, Kai Kuang•Current Psychology•2024

  • News-Driven Discourse and Support for Democratic Norms

    Bumsoo Kim, Xiyue Li et al.•Journal of Broadcasting &…•2025

  • Does a Speaker’s (In)formal Role in News Media Shape Perceptions of Political Incivility

    Bethany Anne Conway, R Stryker•Journal of Broadcasting &…•2021

  • Social media filtering and democracy

    Open Access•Manuel Goyanes, Porismita Borah et al.•Computers in Human Behavior•2021

  • When we tolerate online incivility

    Open Access•Yeweon Kim, Amy Gonzales et al.•Computers in Human Behavior•2022

  • Seeing red

    Open Access•Arthur D Santana, Toby Hopp•Newspaper Research Journal•2022

  • Enhancing decision support for bystander interventions

    Open Access•Xiya Guo, Jiahua Jin et al.•Decision Support Systems•2025

  • Resolving the Ethical Tension Between Creating a Civil Environment and Facilitating Free Expression Online

    Open Access•Dena Yadin, Inbal Yahav et al.•Journal of Business Ethics•2024

  • Effects of online incivility and emotions toward in-groups on cross-cutting attention and political participation

    Jiyoung Lee, Jihyang Choi et al.•Behaviour and Information…•2022

  • Classification, measurement, and antecedents of users’ cyber-incivility on social media

    Xiya Guo, Jiahua Jin et al.•Behaviour and Information…•2026

  • Whose Pants Are on Fire? Journalists Correcting False Claims are Distrusted More Than Journalists Confirming Claims

    Open Access•Randy Stein, Caroline E Meyersohn•Communication Research•2025

  • Appraising Uncivil Comments in Online Political Discussions

    Open Access•Jan P Kluck, Nicole C Krämer•Communication Research•2023

  • Beyond Incivility

    Open Access•Patrícia Rossini•Communication Research•2022

  • Media Hybridization and the Strategic Value of Political Incivility

    Open Access•Rossella Rega•Media and Communication•2025

  • Global Crisis Frame Matters for Unity

    Open Access•Miao Xiao-yan, Li Liu et al.•Social Psychological and…•2024

  • Affective polarization in crosscutting communication networks

    Open Access•Maria Nordbrandt•Frontiers in Political Science•2022

  • Exploring the metadiscursive realisation of incivility in TV news discourse

    Open Access•Jamie Mckeown, Hans J Ladegaard•Discourse Context & Media•2019

  • It’s All Relative

    Open Access•Chiara Vargiu•Politics and Governance•2022

  • Civility, gender, and gendered nationalism in the age of Trump

    Melissa Deckman•Politics Groups and Identities•2020

  • A network analysis of political incivility dimensions

    Open Access•Toby Hopp•Communication and the Public•2019

  • How do Healthy Political Discussions Invigorate Online Participation? Evidence from 17 European Countries

    Open Access•Laia Castro, Yannis Theocharis et al.•Social Media + Society•2025

  • Exposure to Online Abuse of Politicians Does Not Scare Citizens Away From Politics

    Open Access•Rasmus T Pedersen, R J Lawrence et al.•Journal of Experimental Political…•2025

  • The Polarizing Effects of Online Partisan Criticism

    Open Access•Elizabeth Suhay, Emily Bello-Pardo et al.•The International Journal of…•2017

  • Unpacking the Determinants of Outrage and Recognition in Public Discourse

    Open Access•Charlotte Löb, Eike M Rinke et al.•The International Journal of…•2022

  • In Moderation

    Hans K Meyer, Michael Clay Carey•Journalism Practice•2013

  • White Apathy and Allyship in Uncivil Racial Social Media Comments

    Jessica Roden, Muniba Saleem•Mass Communication & Society•2021

  • Who Leaves Malicious Comments on Online News? An Empirical Study in Korea

    Hyunmi Baek, Moonkyoung Jang et al.•Journalism Studies•2022

  • From “thank god for helping this person” to “libtards really jumped the shark”

    Open Access•Deana A Rohlinger, Cynthia Williams et al.•New Media & Society•2019

  • The double-edged sword of online deliberation

    Open Access•Svenja Schäfer, Philipp Müller et al.•New Media & Society•2022

  • Privacy and the Panopticon

    Open Access•Elizabeth Stoycheff, Juan Liu et al.•New Media & Society•2018

  • Twitter versus Facebook

    Open Access•Mustafa Oz, Pei Zheng et al.•New Media & Society•2017

  • National security versus freedom of speech

    Open Access•Huu Dat Tran, Pham Phuong Uyen Diep et al.•New Media & Society•2025

  • The influence of the deliberative quality of user comments on the number and quality of their reply comments

    Open Access•Teresa K Naab, Hanna-Sophie Ruess et al.•New Media & Society•2023

  • Who will intervene to save news comments? Deviance and social control in communities of news commenters

    Open Access•Brendan R Watson, Zhao Peng et al.•New Media & Society•2019

  • Political and personality predispositions and topical contexts matter

    Open Access•Leona Yi-Fan Su, Dietram A Scheufele et al.•New Media & Society•2020

  • Change is an emotional state of mind

    Open Access•Abby Koenig, B Mclaughlin•New Media & Society•2017

  • Flagging uncivil user comments

    Open Access•Teresa K Naab, Anja Kalch et al.•New Media & Society•2016

  • Incivility and Political Identity on the Internet

    Open Access•A Rain, Kate Kenski et al.•Journal of Computer-Mediated…•2017

  • Can’t You All Just Get Along? Effects of Scientific Disagreement and Incivility on Attention to and Trust in Science

    Open Access•Sedona Chinn, P Sol Hart•Science Communication•2021

  • Social Media, Science, and Attack Discourse

    Open Access•Andrew A Anderson, Heidi Huntington et al.•Science Communication•2017

  • You are a disgrace and traitor to our country”

    Open Access•Porismita Borah, Kate Keib et al.•Internet Research•2022

  • Socioeconomic Status, Social Capital, and Partisan Polarity as Predictors of Political Incivility on Twitter

    Open Access•Chris J Vargo, Toby Hopp•Social Science Computer Review•2016

  • Social Norms and the Dynamics of Online Incivility

    Open Access•Yotam Shmargad, Kevin Coe et al.•Social Science Computer Review•2021

  • Uncivil Name‐Calling in the U.S. Presidency, 1933–2018

    Open Access•Kevin Coe, Dakota Park-Ozee et al.•Presidential Studies Quarterly•2019

  • Don’t read the comments

    Kathleen Searles, Sophie Spencer et al.•Information Communication & Society•2020

  • Perceived political incivility and trust in government

    Ozan Kuru, Taberez Ahmed Neyazi•Information Communication & Society•2025

  • The dynamics of online news discussions

    Marc Ziegele, Mathias Weber et al.•Information Communication & Society•2018

  • The effect of comment moderation on perceived bias in science news

    Sara K Yeo, Leona Yi-Fan Su et al.•Information Communication & Society•2019

  • Civility, credibility, and health information

    Open Access•Freddie J Jennings, Frank Michael Russell•Public Understanding of Science•2019

  • What’s in a username? Civility, group identification, and norms

    Myiah J Hutchens, David E Silva et al.•Journal of Information Technology…•2019

  • Can a self-regulation strategy help make social media more civil? Exploring the potential of mental contrasting with implementation intentions to reduce incivility in online political discussion

    Open Access•Matthew J Kushin, Masahiro Yamamoto•New Media & Society•2023

  • Incivility and disrespectfulness in online political discussion

    Open Access•Angga Prawadika Aji, Ari Sapto•Masyarakat Kebudayaan dan Politik•2020

  • Incivilidad en Facebook durante el 8M

    Open Access•Rafael Alexis Robles Olivos, Daniel Jácobo-Morales et al.•Estudios sobre el Mensaje…•2026

  • The Effects of Political Incivility on Political Trust and Political Participation

    Open Access•Jonathan Van’t Riet, Jonathan Van ‘t Riet et al.•Human Communication Research•2022

  • Replication Note

    Open Access•R Stryker, Bethany Anne Conway et al.•Human Communication Research•2021

  • The AI Referee

    Open Access•Georgia Kernell, Seonhye Noh•Social Media + Society•2026

  • More Than Just Facts

    Ellen Middaugh•Peabody Journal of Education•2019

  • Collective Civic Moderation for Deliberation? Exploring the Links between Citizens’ Organized Engagement in Comment Sections and the Deliberative Quality of Online Discussions

    Dennis Frie, Marc Ziegele et al.•Political Communication•2020

  • Is Context the Key? The (Non-)Differential Effects of Mediated Incivility in Three European Countries

    Open Access•Lukas Otto, Sophie Lecheler et al.•Political Communication•2020

  • Uncivil yet persuasive? Testing the persuasiveness of political incivility and the moderating role of populist attitudes and personality traits

    Open Access•Chiara Vargiu, Alessandro Nai et al.•Political Psychology•2024

  • Dissonance from the Perspective of Agonistic Pluralism

    Stephan Schlögl, M Burger et al.•Political Communication•2023

  • Elite Polarization and Public Opinion

    J Robison, Kevin J Mullinix•Political Communication•2016

  • Dynamics of Polarizing Rhetoric in Congressional Tweets

    Open Access•Andrew O Ballard, Ryan Detamble et al.•Legislative Studies Quarterly•2023

  • Dimensions of Elite Partisan Polarization

    Open Access•Rasmus Skytte•British Journal of Political…•2021

  • Politics and Politeness

    Open Access•Briana M Trifiro, Sejin Paik et al.•Social Media + Society•2021

  • More Than Just Shouting? Distinguishing Interpersonal-Directed and Elite-Directed Incivility in Online Political Talk

    Open Access•Patrícia Rossini•Social Media + Society•2021

  • Politicians Under Fire

    Open Access•Sara Bentivegna, Rossella Rega•Social Media + Society•2024

  • Identifying Themes of Right-Wing Extremism in Hindutva Discourse on Twitter

    Open Access•Piyush Ghasiya, Georg Ahnert et al.•Social Media + Society•2023

  • Is Negative Campaigning a Matter of Taste? Political Attacks, Incivility, and the Moderating Role of Individual Differences

    Open Access•Alessandro Nai, J Maier•American Politics Research•2021

  • Lying, Liars, and Lies

    Open Access•Kate Kenski, Christine R Filer et al.•American Behavioral Scientist•2018

  • Participation in America

    Norman H Nie, Sidney Verba•Participation in America•1987

  • Spiral of Cynicism

    Joseph N Cappella, Joseph Cappella et al.•Spiral of cynicism•1997

  • Influence of Hostile Media Perception on Willingness to Engage in Discursive Activities

    Hyunseo Hwang, Zhongdang Pan et al.•Media Psychology•2008

  • Students as Experimental Participants

    Open Access•James N Druckman, Cindy D Kam•Cambridge Handbook of Experimental…•2011

  • “To Thine Own Self Be True”

    Open Access•Dhavan V Shah, David Domke et al.•Communication Research•1996

  • Is Anyone Responsible?

    Shanto Iyengar•Is Anyone Responsible?•1991

  • News Framing as a Multiparadigmatic Research Program

    Open Access•Paul D’angelo, Paul D'Angelo•Journal of Communication•2002

  • A Theory of Framing and Opinion Formation in Competitive Elite Environments

    Open Access•Dennis Chong, James N Druckman•Journal of Communication•2007

  • Conceptualizing sources in online news

    Open Access•Sundar, S S Sundar et al.•Journal of Communication•2001

  • Framing as a Theory of Media Effects

    Open Access•Dietram A Scheufele•Journal of Communication•1999

  • Credibility in Context

    Kjerstin Thorson, Emily K Vraga et al.•Mass Communication & Society•2010

  • The virtual sphere

    Open Access•Zizi Papacharissi•New Media & Society•2002

  • Computer-Mediated Communication and The Public Sphere

    Open Access•Lincoln Dahlberg•Journal of Computer-Mediated…•2006

  • The Impact of Synchronicity and Civility in Online Political Discussions on Perceptions and Intentions to Participate

    Open Access•Elaine W J Ng, Benjamin H Detenber•Journal of Computer-Mediated…•2006

  • Voice and Equality

    Henry Brady, Sidney Verba et al.•Voice and Equality•1995

  • The Spiral of Cynicism Reconsidered

    Open Access•Claes H De Vreese•European Journal of Communication•2005

  • Framing Policy Debates

    Open Access•Nam-Jin Lee, Nam‐jin Lee et al.•Communication Research•2008

  • Conceptual Issues in Framing Theory

    Open Access•Porismita Borah•Journal of Communication•2011

  • Emotional and behavioural responses to everyday incivility

    Open Access•Tim Phillips, Philip Smith•Journal of Sociology•2004

  • Democracy online

    Open Access•Zizi Papacharissi•New Media & Society•2004

  • Values, Political Knowledge, and Public Opinion about Gay Rights

    Paul R Brewer•Public Opinion Quarterly•2003

  • High-Conflict Television News and Public Opinion

    Open Access•Richard Forgette, Jonathan S Morris•Political Research Quarterly•2006

  • From Incivility to Outrage

    Sarah Sobieraj, Jeffrey M Berry•Political Communication•2011

  • A Spiral of Cynicism for Some

    Nicholas A Valentino, Matthew N Beckmann et al.•Political Communication•2001

  • News, Talk, Opinion, Participation

    Joohan Kim, Robert O Wyatt et al.•Political Communication•1999

  • The Implications of Framing Effects for Citizen Competence

    Open Access•James N Druckman•Political Behavior•2001

  • The Internet and the Public

    Corinna Di Gennaro•Parliamentary Affairs•2006

  • A Spot Check

    Steven E Finkel, John G Geer•American Journal of Political…•1998

  • Beyond Negativity

    Open Access•Deborah Jordan Brooks, John G Geer•American Journal of Political…•2007

  • A disconfirmation bias in the evaluation of arguments

    Kari Edwards, Edward E Smith•Journal of Personality and Social…•1996

  • The possessive self as a barrier to conflict resolution

    Carsten K W De Dreu, Daan Van Knippenberg•Journal of Personality and Social…•2005

  • Motivated inference

    Ziva Kunda•Journal of Personality and Social…•1987

  • The Dimensions of Negative Messages

    Open Access•Kim Fridkin, Kim L Fridkin et al.•American Politics Research•2008

  • Political Preference Formation

    Open Access•James N Druckman•American Political Science Review•2004

  • The case for motivated reasoning

    Ziva Kunda•Psychological Bulletin•1990

  • Media Framing of a Civil Liberties Conflict and Its Effect on Tolerance

    Open Access•Thomas E Nelson, Rosalee A Clawson et al.•American Political Science Review•1997

  • The New Videomalaise

    Open Access•Diana C Mutz, Byron Reeves•American Political Science Review•2005

  • Perspectives on politeness

    Open Access•Bruce Fraser•Journal of Pragmatics•1990

  • Effects of "In-Your-Face" Television Discourse on Perceptions of a Legitimate Opposition

    Open Access•Diana C Mutz•American Political Science Review•2007

Unique citing works102
Citations per year7,85
Citation span2013 - 2026 (14)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedYes
Citation typesNeutral: 90

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae