Can One or a Few Cases Yield Theoretical Gains?
Bibliographic Data
| ID | 23367173 |
|---|---|
| Authors | Dietrich Rueschemeyer (Brown University, corresponding author) |
| Year | 2003 |
| Pages | 305-336 |
| Publication date | 2003-02-03 |
| Peer Reviewed | Yes |
| Open Access | Yes |
| Type | CHAPTER |
| Venue | Comparative Historical Analysis in the Social Sciences (SOURCE_BOOK) |
| Publisher | Cambridge University Press (PUBLISHER • US) |
| DOI | 10.1017/cbo9780511803963.010 |
| OpenAlex | W43171261 |
| ISBN | 9780511803963 |
| Language | EN |
| Citations received | 91 |
| References cited | 35 |
The Issue The crux of skepticism about comparative historical analysis is the “small- N problem” – the combination of many factors assumed to be causally relevant with evidence from only a small number of comparable cases. Exploring the impact of a large number of relevant factors and conditions in only a few cases seems to run into insuperable obstacles for learning anything that is theoretically relevant. In this essay, I will turn a skeptical eye on these skeptical objections. I go deliberately to the extreme and ask what can be learned theoretically from the study of a single historical case and from comparative analyses of two or very few more cases, a kind of research that permits close attention to the complexities of historical developments. I begin with two opposite positions that I consider problematic and in their starkest form mistaken. One of these is the most conventional view, taught in countless classes on the methodology of social research. It holds that studying a single case yields only one reasonable theoretical outcome, the generation of hypotheses that may be tested in other, more numerous cases. And conventional methodological wisdom holds the same for single comparisons unless they offer by near-miraculous chance a naturally occurring experiment. The other position is implied in innumerable assertive historical explanations of singular processes. E. P. Thompson's essay “The Poverty of Theory” offers sophisticated, explicit formulations of such views, though I will argue that its overall argument must be understood in a less historicist way than it at first appears.
Ask price · Economics · Economy · Epistemology · Physics · Positive economics · Skepticism · Yield (engineering) · Culture, Economy, and Development Studies · Philosophy · Political Conflict and Governance · Psychology · Qualitative Comparative Analysis Research
Governing through Repression
The comparative sequential method
Shifting patterns of expectations management in innovation policy
Parâmetros para uma análise empírica da relação entre idéias, elites e instituições
Between the Party and the European Union
Can We Generalize from Case Studies
State-labour relations in East Central Europe
O que é um Estudo de Caso e quais as suas potencialidades
Allies, Targets, and the Effectiveness of Coalition Protest
Activist Human Capital
The effect of parents’ education appreciation on intergenerational inequality
Fifteen Years of Empirical Research on Collective Action in Natural Resource Management
Party cues no Brasil? Um teste crucial da capacidade do sistema de partidos brasileiro em influenciar a opinião pública
A formação do campo político profissional no Brasil
Razões emergentes para a validade dos estudos de caso na ciência política comparada
Pathways of Dominance and Displacement
Protective repression, international pressure, and institutional design
Movements, Countermovements and Policy Adoption
The Politics of Pain
Regime Type and Diffusion in Comparative Politics Methodology
Heartland Blues
Social Organizations and the Authoritarian State in China
Comparative Public Policy
Under the Banner of Islam
Populism and Securitization
A New Case for the Study of Individual Events in Political Science
Levels of Analysis and Variation in Civil War Violence and Restraint
Re-organizing the service-delivery machine in a “post-NPM” era
Implementing the transformative innovation policy in the European Union
Assessing the Multi-level Government Response to the Covid-19 Crisis
Europeanization from the periphery
How different multilevel and multi-actor arrangements impact policy implementation
The difference mafias make
Cumulative extremism
Introduction
Process Tracing in the Development and Validation of Theoretical Explanations
Growing into Trouble
Enlightened Eclecticism or Hazardous Hotchpotch? Mixed Methods and Triangulation Strategies in Comparative Public Policy Research
The Runaway Production Complex? The Film Industry as a Driver of Urban Economic Revitalization in the United States
Party family or nation state? The post-decisional politics of supranational socio-economic regulation
Coercive confinement in the Republic of Ireland
The politics of punishing
The Challenges of Implementing Merit-Based Personnel Policies in Latin America
The logico-formalist turn in comparative and case study methods
Towards a typology of ceasefires
National identity and the political economy of small states
Location, Vocation, Location? Spatial Entrapment among Women in Dual Career Households
Reparations, But for What? Presenting a New Approach to Coding Reparations
Institutional persistence despite cultural change
Zwischen Pflichten und Fiktionen
State Capacity and Health Outcomes
Can Analytic Narrative Inform Policy Change? The Political Economy of the Indian Electricity–Irrigation Nexus
Qualitative Methodology and Comparative Politics
The Logic of Process Tracing Tests in the Social Sciences
Historical Institutionalism and West European Politics
Who Are We, and Do We Need to Change? Cluster Identity and Life Cycle
Biodiversity policy and subnational implementation in the remote regions of France
Institutions and organizational change
Why Should the Business Agents Be Bigger Than the Organization?”
Enhancing the Robustness of Causal Claims Based on Case Study Research on Conflict Zones
Against the Odds
The financialisation of floor space, Mumbai 1880–2015
The bad, the good and the ugly
Internationally Comparative Research Designs in the Social Sciences
Nobody in charge
Dynamic capabilities in a sixth-generation family firm
Small States, Nationalism and Institutional Capacities
Uploading as political strategy
Defending the Gellnerian premise
Increasing Representative Accountability through Electoral Laws
From “New Institutionalism” to “Institutional Processualism
Explaining the Dominance of Legacy Unions in New Democracies
The Varieties of Capitalism and Hybrid Success
What Drives the Immigration-Welfare Policy Link? Comparing Germany, France and the United Kingdom
The Political Origins of Colonial Land Policy
Political Articulation
The Social Construction of Welfare Control
Redefining Case Study
Organizing the Precariat
Why do states in conflict with each other also sustain resilient cooperation in international regulation? Britain and telegraphy, 1860s–1914
Institutional change in a conflict setting
Promises betrayed? Ideological commitments and revolutionary outcomes
The young Lipset on the iron law of oligarchy
Toward projectified environmental governance
Planning for Path Dependence? The Case of a Network in the Berlin-Brandenburg Optics Cluster
Denunciation and Social Control
Drugs, Violence, and Capitalism
Productive Modernization and Challenges for Chilean Peasant Agriculture during the Phase of Post-Agrarian Reform
Acting out institutional change
The Silicon Valley imaginary
The Supreme Court as an Agent of Policy Drift
Professions and power.
Introduction to Mathematical Sociology
Comparative Methods in the Social Sciences
Theoretical Generalization and Historical Particularity in the Comparative Sociology of Reinhard Bendix
Theoretical Methods in Social History
The Cooperator's Dilemma
Making of the English Working Class
Profession of medicine
The Rise of Professionalism
Max Weber on Law and the Rise of Capitalism
Capitalist Development and Democracy
The Comparative Method
The Rebel's Dilemma
Does Television Erode Social Capital? A Reply to Putnam
The Conditions of Fruitfulness of Theorizing About Mechanisms in Social Science
Canons of research design in qualitative analysis
Insights and Pitfalls
Evidence and Inference in the Comparative Case Study
Tuning In, Tuning Out
Bowling Alone
II. The Comparable-Cases Strategy in Comparative Research
III. "Degrees of Freedom" and the Case Study
Comparative Methods in the Social Sciences
Comparative Politics and the Comparative Method
Lawyers and Their Society
Strategies of Causal Inference in Small-N Analysis
Nominal, Ordinal, and Narrative Appraisal in Macrocausal Analysis
The power of negative thinking
States and Social Revolutions
| Unique citing works | 91 |
|---|---|
| Citations per year | 4,14 |
| Citation span | 2004 - 2026 (23) |
| Citation velocity | current |
| Highly cited | No |
| Citation types | Neutral: 71 |