Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

A Meta-Analytic Review of Moral Licensing

Bibliographic Data

ID23377100
AuthorsIrene Blanken (Tilburg University, the Netherlands, corresponding author), Niels Van De Ven (0000-0002-6730-9200, Tilburg University, the Netherlands), Marcel Zeelenberg (0000-0002-7100-4223, Tilburg University, the Netherlands)
Year2015
Volume41
Issue4
Pages540-558
Publication date2015-04-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenuePersonality and Social Psychology Bulletin (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0146-1672 • E-ISSN: 1552-7433
PublisherSAGE Publications (PUBLISHER • US)
DOI10.1177/0146167215572134
PMID25716992
OpenAlexW2170109954
LanguageEN
Citations received126
References cited73

Moral licensing refers to the effect that when people initially behave in a moral way, they are later more likely to display behaviors that are immoral, unethical, or otherwise problematic. We provide a state-of-the-art overview of moral licensing by conducting a meta-analysis of 91 studies (7,397 participants) that compare a licensing condition with a control condition. Based on this analysis, the magnitude of the moral licensing effect is estimated to be a Cohen’s d of 0.31. We tested potential moderators and found that published studies tend to have larger moral licensing effects than unpublished studies. We found no empirical evidence for other moderators that were theorized to be of importance. The effect size estimate implies that studies require many more participants to draw solid conclusions about moral licensing and its possible moderators.

Control (management) · Economics · Meta-analysis · Moral disengagement · Emotions and Moral Behavior · Ethics in Business and Education · Psychology · Psychology of Moral and Emotional Judgment · Social Psychology

  • The Double-Edged Power of Mentors

    Open Access•Margaret S Stockdale, Amanda E Mosier et al.•Sex Roles•2026

  • Karma and God

    Cindel White, Ara Norenzayan•Psychology of Religion and…•2022

  • Forensic clinicians’ understanding of bias

    Nina Maclean, Tess M S Neal et al.•Psychology Public Policy and Law•2019

  • Ignorance by choice

    Open Access•Linh Vu, Ivan Soraperra et al.•Psychological Bulletin•2023

  • When is sensory consumption immoral

    Shreyans Goenka, Manoj Thomas•Journal of Personality and Social…•2023

  • The balancing act of performance

    Open Access•Megan R Lowery, Malissa A Clark et al.•Journal of Vocational Behavior•2021

  • From Good Citizens to Bad Apples? The Effect of Boredom Proneness

    Open Access•Shih Yung Chou, Tree Chang et al.•Psychological Reports•2024

  • Neuroethics

    Joshua May•Neuroethics•2023

  • Consistency Versus Licensing Effects of Past Moral Behavior

    Elizabeth Mullen, Benoît Monin•Annual Review of Psychology•2016

  • Towards an understanding of performative allyship

    Open Access•Maja Kutlaca, Helena R M Radke•Social and Personality Psychology…•2023

  • Behavioural factors affecting the adoption of sustainable farming practices

    Open Access•Francois J Dessart, Jesús Barreiro-Hurlé et al.•European Review of Agricultural…•2019

  • Understanding the human dimensions of a sustainable energy transition

    Open Access•Linda Steg, Goda Perlaviciute et al.•Frontiers in Psychology•2015

  • Increasing Vaccination

    Open Access•Noel T Brewer, Gretchen B Chapman et al.•Psychological Science in the…•2017

  • Adopting LEDs changes attitudes towards climate change

    Open Access•Yu Gao, Giovanna D’adda et al.•Environmental Research Letters•2019

  • Perceived organizational status and bootleg innovation

    Open Access•Du-Juan Huang, Xi-Ou Gao et al.•BMC Psychology•2025

  • Positive Identity Construction in Diverse Organizations

    Open Access•Laura Morgan Roberts, Brianna Barker Caza•Annual Review of Organizational…•2024

  • Unraveling the behavioral mechanisms underlying rebound effects of sustainability-oriented interventions

    Open Access•Imke G H van der Loo, Daniela C A Pigosso•Sustainability: Science, Practice…•2026

  • Forgiving the Algorithm? Consumer Responses to AI- vs. Human-Created Misrepresentative Ads

    Open Access•Kshitij Bhoumik•Journal of Advertising Research•2026

  • Indirect rebound effects on the consumer level

    Open Access•Hanna Reimers, Anke Jacksohn et al.•Cleaner and Responsible Consumption•2021

  • “Ain’t that a shame”

    Open Access•Lory Barile, John Cullis et al.•Humanities and Social Sciences…•2025

  • The appeal of the circular economy revisited

    Open Access•Hans Eickhoff•Humanities and Social Sciences…•2024

  • Social capital as a resource for prosocial donation behavior? Quantitative evidence on the dark side of strategic networking

    Open Access•Sarah Kisliuk, Kristina S Weißmüller•Social Sciences & Humanities Open•2023

  • How corporate philanthropy influences consumers’ ecotourism consumption intention? A moral licensing perspective

    Open Access•Yibo Xie, Liwen Zhang et al.•Cogent Social Sciences•2026

  • Sustainability as Cognitive “Friction”

    Open Access•Franzisca Weder, Amornpan Tungarat et al.•Frontiers in Communication•2020

  • Institutional change and the limitations of consumer activism

    Open Access•Jacy Reese Anthis, Jacy Reese•Palgrave Communications•2020

  • Harnessing Moral Psychology to Reduce Meat Consumption

    Open Access•Joshua May, Victor Kumar•Journal of the American…•2023

  • Autorregulación del deseo como competencia básica para el desarrollo emocional

    Open Access•Luis Alberto Mateos Hernández•Revista Iberoamericana de…•2020

  • How Social Media Algorithms Shape Offline Civic Participation

    Open Access•Haesung Jung, Wenhao Dai et al.•Perspectives on Psychological…•2024

  • I own I am positive

    Open Access•Hong Li, Hui Li et al.•Asian Journal Of Social Psychology•2026

  • Partner choice in human evolution

    Open Access•K M Smith, Coren L Apicella•Evolution and Human Behavior•2020

  • Children’s altruism after recalling recent and distant morally-valenced behavior and the mediating role of guilt

    Open Access•Alexandra Maftei, Andrei Corneliu Holman et al.•Current Psychology•2023

  • Moral in the future, better now

    Open Access•Alexandra Maftei, Andrei Corneliu Holman•Current Psychology•2023

  • From inspiration to justification

    Open Access•Munisa Akhmadjanovna Toirova, Yoonjung Baek et al.•Current Psychology•2026

  • The relationship between negative life events and problematic social networking use among Chinese high school students

    Open Access•Dan Li, Li Dan et al.•Current Psychology•2026

  • Moral disengagement and the harms of cocaine use

    Open Access•Harry Sumnall, Catharine Montgomery et al.•Drugs Education Prevention and…•2022

  • Flying rebound

    Stefan Hoffmann, Norris Lang et al.•Journal of Sustainable Tourism•2023

  • Home and away

    Open Access•Feifei Xu, Lei Huang et al.•Journal of Sustainable Tourism•2020

  • Mapping Moral Pluralism in Behavioural Spillovers

    Open Access•Margaret Vincent, Ann-Kathrin Koessler•Environmental Values•2020

  • The Impact of Emissions Reduction Awareness on Moral Self-Concept

    Open Access•Aitor Marcos, Patrick Hartmann et al.•Environmental Values•2023

  • Digital piracy and the perception of price fairness

    Open Access•Anna Kukla-Gryz, Joanna Tyrowicz et al.•Journal of Cultural Economics•2021

  • Doing well by doing good

    Open Access•Tong Chen, Shida Tang et al.•Computers in Human Behavior•2023

  • Moral identity as a goal of moral action

    Tobias Krettenauer•Journal of Moral Education•2020

  • When altruistic decisions shape egoistic motives

    Jappy P Fanggidae, Hyun Seung Jin et al.•International Journal of…•2023

  • The Influence of Visual Perspective on Moral Licensing Effect

    Tun Yuan Hu, Wenwen Tao et al.•Basic and Applied Social Psychology•2021

  • Unethical Pro-organizational Behavior

    Open Access•Madhurima Mishra, Koustab Ghosh et al.•Journal of Business Ethics•2022

  • Doing Good While Behaving Badly

    Open Access•Michael Giebelhausen, Benjamin Lawrence et al.•Journal of Business Ethics•2021

  • Green is the New White

    Open Access•Nathalie Spielmann•Journal of Business Ethics•2021

  • A Paradox of Ethics

    Open Access•Muel Kaptein•Journal of Business Ethics•2023

  • The Paradox of Paranoia

    Open Access•Annika Hillebrandt, Daniel L Brady et al.•Journal of Business Ethics•2023

  • The Dark Side of Firms’ Green Technology Innovation on Corporate Social Responsibility

    Open Access•Xu Chu, Yuntao Bai et al.•Journal of Business Ethics•2024

  • Can Green Needs Always Promote Green Innovation? Moral Licensing in Corporate Environmental Responsibility

    Open Access•Heng Zhang, Binglin Gong•Journal of Business Ethics•2025

  • Selfish Sharing? The Impact of the Sharing Economy on Tax Reporting Honesty

    Open Access•L L Berger, Lan Guo et al.•Journal of Business Ethics•2020

  • Preventing Disclosure-Induced Moral Licensing

    Open Access•Thomas G Canace, Leigh Salzsieder et al.•Journal of Business Ethics•2023

  • Unethical Behavior in the Name of the Family

    Open Access•Meilan NONG, Wenjuan Mei•Journal of Business Ethics•2025

  • Are Fairness Perceptions Related to Moral Licensing Behavior? Evidence From Tax Compliance

    Open Access•Donna Bobek, Amy Hageman et al.•Journal of Business Ethics•2025

  • Investigating the Interactive Effects of Prosocial Actions, Construal, and Moral Identity on the Extent of Employee Reporting Dishonesty

    Open Access•Joseph A Johnson, Patrick R Martin et al.•Journal of Business Ethics•2022

  • Observation Moderates the Moral Licensing Effect

    Open Access•Amanda Rotella, Jisoo Jung et al.•Personality and Social Psychology…•2025

  • Does Conceptual Abstraction Moderate Whether Past Moral Deeds Motivate Consistency or Compensatory Behavior? A Registered Replication and Extension of Conway and Peetz (2012)

    Open Access•Jareef Bin Martuza, Olivia Kim•Personality and Social Psychology…•2025

  • Balancing Prosocial Effort Across Social Categories

    Open Access•Julia Peetz, Andrea L Howard et al.•Personality and Social Psychology…•2021

  • Moral Balancing in Video Games

    Open Access•Yu-Hao Lee, Mo Chen et al.•Communication Research•2026

  • Suspicious minds and views of fairness

    Open Access•Øivind Schøyen•Theory and Decision•2024

  • Understanding the dark side of gamified interactions on short-form video platforms

    Open Access•Fei Zhou, Youhai Lin et al.•Technological Forecasting and…•2023

  • A counterfactual thinking perspective of moral licensing effect in machine-driven communication

    Open Access•Yibo Xie, Wenbin Ma et al.•Technological Forecasting and…•2023

  • No Evidence of Within-Domain Moral Licensing in the Environmental Domain

    Open Access•J Urban, Markéta Braun Kohlová et al.•Environment and Behavior•2021

  • Mechanisms of Pro-Environmental Behavioural Spillover

    Open Access•Ragnheiður “Heather” Torfadóttir, Gloria Amaris et al.•Environment and Behavior•2026

  • Once Good, Always Good? Testing Nudge’s Spillovers on Pro Environmental Behavior

    Open Access•Sophie Clot, Marina Della Giusta et al.•Environment and Behavior•2022

  • Remembering before acting

    Open Access•Mélissa Vandenbol, Marie Geurten•Cognition•2026

  • Circular intentions, minimal actions

    Open Access•Zuzana Vaculcikova, Haywantee Ramkissoon et al.•Acta Psychologica•2025

  • Moral licensing effect of work engagement

    Open Access•Lianghua Zhang, Yongli Wang•Business Ethics, the Environment…•2025

  • Two sides of the same personality coin

    Open Access•Edward N Gamble, Anne L Christensen•Business Ethics, the Environment…•2022

  • Ethical leadership in a complex environment

    Open Access•Geneviève Morin, David Talbot•Business Ethics, the Environment…•2023

  • The Illusion of Moral Superiority

    Open Access•Ben M Tappin, Ryan T Mckay et al.•Social Psychological and…•2017

  • Direct and Conceptual Replications of Eskine (2013)

    Open Access•Eileen Moery, Robert J Calin-Jageman•Social Psychological and…•2016

  • Morality as a Basic Psychological Need

    Open Access•Mike Prentice, Eranda Jayawickreme et al.•Social Psychological and…•2019

  • The licensing effect of green luxury

    Open Access•Zhijun Li, Jiuling Xiao et al.•Sustainable Futures•2026

  • Exposure to individual climate solutions does not reduce support for systemic solutions

    Open Access•Omid Ghasemi, Mina Almasi et al.•Behavioural Public Policy•2025

  • Sticky brown sludge everywhere

    Open Access•Ganga Shreedhar, Cahal Moran et al.•Behavioural Public Policy•2024

  • Young energy savers

    Open Access•Hayley Pearce, Liselot Hudders et al.•Energy Research & Social Science•2019

  • How (many) descriptive claims about political polarization exacerbate polarization

    Open Access•Uwe Peters•Journal of Social and Political…•2021

  • Ethical Learning

    Open Access•Isaac H Smith, Maryam Kouchaki•Social Issues and Policy Review•2020

  • The Implosion of the Moral Third

    Open Access•Malin Fors•Studies in Gender and Sexuality•2019

  • Compensation and consistency effects in proenvironmental behaviour

    Open Access•Fanny Lalot, Juan Manuel Falomir-Pichastor et al.•Group Processes & Intergroup…•2017

  • Conditional secondary transfer effect

    Open Access•Inga Jasinskaja‐lahti, Loris Vezzali et al.•Group Processes & Intergroup…•2020

  • Gamification in C2C secondary marketplace apps

    Calvin Wan, Peggy Ng•Internet Research•2025

  • Carbon tax salience counteracts price effects through moral licensing

    Open Access•Patrick Hartmann, Aitor Marcos et al.•Global Environmental Change•2023

  • Synergies of interventions to promote pro-environmental behaviors – A meta-analysis of experimental studies

    Open Access•Marius Alt, Hendrik Bruns et al.•Global Environmental Change•2024

  • Guilty pleasures

    Open Access•Axel M Burger, Johannes Schuler et al.•Global Environmental Change•2021

  • What you don't know, can't hurt you

    Open Access•Valeria Fanghella, Lisette Hafkamp Ibanez et al.•Ecological Economics•2025

  • Animal welfare as a public good

    Open Access•Ricardo Espinosa, Nicolas Treich•Ecological Economics•2023

  • Pro-environmental behavior and environmentalist movements

    Open Access•Daniela Flörchinger, Manuel Frondel et al.•Ecological Economics•2025

  • Are people more selfish after giving gifts

    Open Access•Evan Polman, Zoe Y Lu•Journal of Behavioral Decision…•2021

  • When “Good People” Sexually Harass

    Open Access•Tuyen K Dinh, Tuyen Dinh et al.•Psychology of Women Quarterly•2022

  • Willing or complying? The delicate interplay between voluntary and mandatory interventions to promote farmers' environmental behavior

    Open Access•Jesús Barreiro-Hurlé, Francois J Dessart et al.•Food Policy•2023

  • Religious Dietary Practices

    Open Access•Sedat Arslan, Ayça Aydın•Journal of Religion and Health•2024

  • Should You Stay Away from Strangers

    Open Access•Ethan C Busby, Ethan Busby•Should You Stay Away from…•2021

  • Meta-analysis of pro-environmental behaviour spillover

    Open Access•Alexander Maki, Amanda R Carrico et al.•Nature Sustainability•2019

  • Bringing contact interventions to the lab

    Open Access•Gwen-Jirō Clochard, Guillaume Hollard et al.•World Development•2025

  • Residential solar PV and electricity consumption

    Open Access•Tomoaki Nakaishi, Sunbin Yoo et al.•Cities•2025

  • The impact factor

    Open Access•Liat Levontin, Zohar Gilad et al.•Journal of Experimental Social…•2025

  • Licence to kill? Investigating the moral licensing effect of meat reducing petitions on personal meat avoidance pledges

    Open Access•Christopher J Bryant, Anna Hancox•Psychology of Human-Animal…•2022

  • A Theory of Cognitive Dissonance

    Leon Festinger•A Theory of Cognitive Dissonance•1957

  • Morality in everyday life

    Open Access•Wilhelm Hofmann, Daniel C Wisneski et al.•Science•2014

  • Gpower

    Open Access•Edgar Erdfelder, Franz Faul et al.•Behavior Research Methods,…•1996

  • Fixed- and random-effects models in meta-analysis.

    Larry V Hedges, Jack L Vevea•Psychological Methods•1998

  • Washing Away Your Sins

    Open Access•Chen-Bo Zhong, Chen‐Bo Zhong et al.•Science•2006

  • The psychology of sunk cost

    Open Access•Hal R Arkes, Catherine Blumer•Organizational Behavior and Human…•1985

  • Moral Self‐Licensing

    Open Access•Anna C Merritt, Daniel A Effron et al.•Social and Personality Psychology…•2010

  • Meta-analysis in clinical trials

    Open Access•Rebecca DerSimonian, Nan M Laird et al.•Controlled Clinical Trials•1986

  • Licensing Effect in Consumer Choice

    Open Access•Uzma Khan, Ravi Dhar•Journal of Marketing Research•2006

  • Publication bias in meta-analysis its causes and consequences

    Open Access•A Thornton, Alison J Thornton•Journal of Clinical Epidemiology•2000

  • Striving for the Moral Self

    Open Access•Jennifer Jordan, Elizabeth Mullen et al.•Personality and Social Psychology…•2011

  • Money, Kisses, and Electric Shocks

    Open Access•Yuval Rottenstreich, Christopher K Hsee•Psychological Science•2001

  • When Does Feeling Moral Actually Make You a Better Person? Conceptual Abstraction Moderates Whether Past Moral Deeds Motivate Consistency or Compensatory Behavior

    Open Access•Paul Conway, Julia Peetz et al.•Personality and Social Psychology…•2012

  • Moral sentiments and cooperation

    Ilona E De Hooge, Marcel Zeelenberg et al.•Cognition & Emotion•2007

  • Do Green Products Make Us Better People?

    Open Access•Nina Mazar, Chen-Bo Zhong et al.•Psychological Science•2010

  • Exploiting moral wiggle room

    Open Access•Jason Dana, Roberto A Weber et al.•Economic Theory•2007

  • Psychological License

    Dale T Miller, Daniel A Effron•Advances In Experimental Social…•2010

  • Sinning Saints and Saintly Sinners

    Open Access•Sonya Sachdeva, Rumen Iliev et al.•Psychological Science•2009

  • Estimation of a Single Effect Size

    Open Access•Larry V Hedges, Ingram Olkin•Statistical Methods for…•1985

  • Bias in meta-analysis detected by a simple, graphical test

    Open Access•Matthias Egger, Gregory D Smith et al.•BMJ•1997

  • Quantifying heterogeneity in a meta‐analysis

    Open Access•Julian P T Higgins, Simon G Thompson•Statistics in Medicine•2002

  • G*Power 3

    Open Access•Franz Faul, Edgar Erdfelder et al.•Behavior Research Methods•2007

  • Attitudes and Cognitive Organization

    Fritz Heider•The Journal of Psychology•1946

  • Self-Perception Theory

    Daryl J Bem•Advances in Experimental Social…•1972

  • Conducting Meta-Analyses in R with the metafor Package

    Open Access•Wolfgang Viechtbauer•Journal of Statistical Software•2010

  • Wholesome Foods and Wholesome Morals

    Open Access•Kendall J Eskine•Social Psychological and…•2013

  • A Theory of Cognitive Dissonance

    Leon Festinger, Camille Morvan et al.•A Theory of Cognitive Dissonance•2017

  • One Hundred Years of Social Psychology Quantitatively Described

    Open Access•F Richard, F D Richard et al.•Review of General Psychology•2003

  • License to sin

    Open Access•Jessie C de Witt Huberts, Catharine Evers et al.•European Journal of Social…•2012

  • Endorsing Obama licenses favoring Whites

    Open Access•Daniel A Effron, Jessica Schwartz Cameron et al.•Journal of Experimental Social…•2009

  • The strategic pursuit of moral credentials

    Open Access•Anna C Merritt, Daniel A Effron et al.•Journal of Experimental Social…•2012

  • The unhealthy road not taken

    Open Access•Daniel A Effron, Benoît Monin et al.•Journal of Experimental Social…•2012

  • Prospective moral licensing

    Open Access•Jessica Cascio, E Ashby Plant•Journal of Experimental Social…•2014

  • On the consequences of priming

    Open Access•Paul M Herr, Steven J Sherman et al.•Journal of Experimental Social…•1983

  • Antifragile

    Open Access•John P A Ioannidis, Nassim Nicholas Taleb et al.•Antifragile•2012

  • Moral credentials and the expression of prejudice

    Benoît Monin, Dale T Miller•Journal of Personality and Social…•2001

  • Ease of retrieval as information

    Norbert Schwarz, Herbert Ble et al.•Journal of Personality and Social…•1991

  • Inventing racist roads not taken

    Daniel A Effron, Dale T Miller et al.•Journal of Personality and Social…•2012

  • Compliance without pressure

    Jonathan L Freedman, Scott C Fraser•Journal of Personality and Social…•1966

  • Three Attempts to Replicate the Moral Licensing Effect

    Open Access•Irene Blanken, Niels Van De Ven et al.•Social Psychology•2014

  • Meta-analytic procedures for combining studies with multiple effect sizes

    Robert Rosenthal, Donald B Rubin•Psychological Bulletin•1986

  • A power primer

    Jacob Cohen•Psychological Bulletin•1992

  • When Sunlight Fails to Disinfect

    Daylian M Cain, G Loewenstein et al.•Journal of Consumer Research•2011

  • Recalling Past Temptations

    Anirban Mukhopadhyay, Jaideep Sengupta et al.•Journal of Consumer Research•2008

  • Goals as Excuses or Guides

    Ayelet Fishbach, Ravi Dhar•Journal of Consumer Research•2005

Unique citing works126
Citations per year11,45
Citation span2015 - 2026 (12)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedYes
Citation typesNeutral: 120

Tools

Open DOISci-HubOpen Access
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae