Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Cultural Complexity

The Concept and Its Measurement

Bibliographic Data

ID24315510
AuthorsG Chick (0000-0001-9935-0032, University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign)
Year1997
Volume31
Issue4
Pages275-307
Publication date1997-11-01
Open AccessNo
TypeARTICLE
VenueCross-Cultural Research (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 1069-3971 • E-ISSN: 1552-3578
PublisherSAGE Publications (PUBLISHER • US)
DOI10.1177/106939719703100401
OpenAlexW2061440497
LanguageEN
Citations received47
References cited55

Cultural complexity is one of the most commonly used variables in cross-cultural research. It has often been used as a measure of cultural evolution and has been shown to correlate with numerous other variables. At least eight measures of cultural complexity have been constructed since the late 1940s. The purpose of this article is to examine three of them, those proposed by Carneiro, Murdock and Provost, and Naroll. Particular attention will be devoted to the validity of these measures. Factor analysis and reliability analysis indicate that Murdock and Provost's index, designed for use with the Standard Cross-Cultural Sample, although reliable, has two dimensions rather than one and may lack content and construct validity. A case is made for the use of the logarithm of the size of the largest settlement in a society as a measure of cultural complexity, as suggested by Naroll.

Construct validity · Content validity · cross-cultural measurement · cultural complexity · Cultural Evolution · Factor analysis · reliability statistics · settlement size · Standard Cross-Cultural Sample · Cross-Cultural and Social Analysis · Cultural Differences and Values · Language and cultural evolution

  • Case Studies in Cultural Control

    G Chick, Liliana González•Cross-Cultural Research•2005

  • Size, Complexity, and Organizational Variation

    Gary M Feinman•Cross-Cultural Research•2011

  • A Cognitivist’s View of the Units Debate in Cultural Anthropology

    Roy D’Andrade•Cross-Cultural Research•2001

  • Modernization as Changes in Cultural Complexity

    William Divale, Albert Seda•Cross-Cultural Research•2001

  • Predicting Leisure Satisfaction in Mainland China, Taiwan, and Brazil

    Open Access•G Chick, Dong Erwei et al.•Cross-Cultural Research•2026

  • Cultural Complexity Revisited

    Trevor Denton•Cross-Cultural Research•2004

  • Economy and Religion in the Neolithic Revolution

    Jill E Fuller, Burke D Grandjean•Cross-Cultural Research•2001

  • Games in Culture Revisited

    Garry Chick•Cross-Cultural Research•1998

  • House Floor Area as a Correlate of Marital Residence Pattern

    Marko Porčić•Cross-Cultural Research•2010

  • Culture-Bearing Units and the Units of Culture

    Garry Chick•Cross-Cultural Research•2001

  • Multiple Predictors of Contribution by Women to Agriculture

    Herbert Barry, Brian L Yoder•Cross-Cultural Research•2002

  • Leisure and Cultural Complexity

    Garry Chick, Xiangyou Sharon Shen Xiangyou Sharon Shen•Cross-Cultural Research•2011

  • The Ibadan Conference and Beyond

    Open Access•Harry C Triandis•Online Readings in Psychology and…•2009

  • Settlement scaling and increasing returns in an ancient society

    Open Access•G Ortman, Andrew H F Cabaniss et al.•Science Advances•2015

  • Cultural Influences on Personality

    Harry C Triandis, Eunkook M Suh•Annual Review of Psychology•2002

  • Did alcohol facilitate the evolution of complex societies

    Open Access•Václav Hrnčíř, Angela M Chira et al.•Humanities and Social Sciences…•2025

  • Urban Scalograms

    J W Hanson•Journal of Urban Archaeology•2022

  • Behavioral Relations for Components of Recent Preindustrial Modernization

    Open Access•Trevor Denton•Ethnology•2006

  • Social complexity and inequality in the Late Neolithic of the Central Balkans

    Open Access•Marko Porčić•Documenta Praehistorica•2012

  • Material Scaffolds in Numbers and Time

    Open Access•Karenleigh A Overmann•Cambridge Archaeological Journal•2013

  • Exploring the Effects of “Smart City” in the Inner-City Fabric of the Mediterranean Metropolis

    Open Access•Stella Kyvelou, Nicos Bobolos et al.•Heritage•2021

  • Is leisure studies “ethnocentric”? A view from Taichung, Taiwan

    Chieh-Lu Li•World Leisure & Recreation•2010

  • The Influence of Individualism and Drinking Identity on Alcohol Problems

    Open Access•Dawn W Foster, Nelson C Y Yeung et al.•International Journal of Mental…•2014

  • What connects positivism and interpretivism in cross-cultural management studies

    Open Access•Jasmin Mahadevan•International Journal of Cross…•2023

  • Evaluating Social Complexity and Inequality in the Balkans Between 6500 and 4200 BC

    Open Access•Marko Porčić•Journal of Archaeological Research•2018

  • Cultural Complexity Thinking by Social Workers in Their Address of Sustainable Development Goals in a Culturally Diverse South Africa

    Zibonele France Zimba•Journal of Progressive Human…•2020

  • Settlement scaling and economic change in the Central Andes

    Open Access•G Ortman, Kaitlyn E Davis et al.•Journal of Archaeological Science•2016

  • Measuring the Complexity of Past Social Systems

    Open Access•Gustavo Barrientos, Leonardo García Sanjuán•Journal of Archaeological Method…•2020

  • The role of materiality in numerical cognition

    Open Access•Karenleigh A Overmann•Quaternary International•2015

  • Flashpackers

    Open Access•Cody Morris Paris•Annals of Tourism Research•2012

  • A Cross-Regional Comparison of Recreation Patterns of Older Hunters

    Chieh-Lu Li, Harry C Zinn et al.•Leisure Sciences•2003

  • Por que a sociedade sambaquiana deve ser considerada como de meio termo

    Open Access•Rita Scheel-Ybert, Taís Cristina Jacinto Pinheiro Capucho et al.•Revista de Arqueologia•2022

  • Ethnicity as a Variable in Leisure Research

    Chieh-Lu Li, G Chick et al.•Journal of Leisure Research•2007

  • Gambling Across Cultures

    Per Binde•International Gambling Studies•2005

  • Psychological Dimensions of Unemployment

    Yannick Griep, Sebastiaan Rothmann et al.•Journal of Psychology in Africa•2012

  • Science, materialism, and the quest for an anthropology of leisure

    G Chick•Leisure Sciences•1998

  • An Exploration of Leisure Motivation as Cultural Practices

    Joane Adeclas, Taekyun Hur et al.•Leisure Sciences•2024

  • The Weight of the Past

    Open Access•Patrick Ziltener, Hans-Peter Mueller et al.•International Journal of…•2007

  • Power and Wisdom

    Open Access•Akop P Nazaretyan•Journal for the Theory of Social…•2003

  • Individualism-Collectivism’ as an Explanatory Device for Mental Illness Stigma

    Open Access•Chris Papadopoulos, John Foster et al.•Community Mental Health Journal•2012

  • Coevolution of religious and political authority in Austronesian societies

    Open Access•Oliver Sheehan, Joseph Watts et al.•Nature Human Behaviour•2022

  • Male Androphilia in the Ancestral Environment

    Open Access•Doug P Vanderlaan, Zhiyuan Ren et al.•Human Nature•2013

  • Scaling of Hunter-Gatherer Camp Size and Human Sociality

    J Lobo, Todd Whitelaw et al.•Current Anthropology•2022

  • Sustainability and an archaeology of the future

    Open Access•Innocent Pikirayi•Antiquity•2019

  • Cross-Cultural Comparative Approaches in Archaeology

    Peter N Peregrine•Annual Review of Anthropology•2001

  • Settlement Scaling in Middle-Range Societies

    Open Access•G Ortman, Scott G Ortman et al.•American Antiquity•2017

  • Universal Patterns in Cultural Evolution

    Open Access•Peter N Peregrine, C R Ember et al.•American Anthropologist•2004

  • Ethnographic Atlas

    Open Access•George Peter Murdock•Ethnology•1967

  • At Home in the Universe

    Stuart Kauffman•At Home in the Universe•1996

  • Measurement theory for the behavioral sciences

    Edwin Ernest Ghiselli•Measurement theory for the…•1981

  • Culture

    A L Kroeber•Culture•1952

  • Principles of anthropology

    Eliot Dismore Chapple•Principles of anthropology•1978

  • Slavery as an Industrial System

    Open Access•H J Nieboer•Slavery As an Industrial System•1900

  • Reliability and Validity Assessment

    Edward Carmines, Edward G Carmines et al.•Reliability and Validity Assessment•1979

  • The Origins of Order

    Stuart Kauffman, Stuart A Kauffman•The origins of order•1993

  • A Mathematical Theory of Communication

    Claude E Shannon•Bell System Technical Journal•1948

  • The Cultural Part of Cognition

    Open Access•Roy G D’andrade, Roy Goodwin D'Andrade•Cognitive Science•1981

  • Basic color terms

    Brent Berlin•Basic color terms•1969

  • Cultural Anthropology

    Andrew J Strathern, Richard B Lee et al.•Cultural Anthropology•1997

  • Rethinking Polygyny

    Douglas R White, L Betzig et al.•Current Anthropology•1988

  • The Politics of Reproductive Ritual

    Open Access•Karen Ericksen Paige, Jeffery M Paige et al.•Politics of Reproductive Ritual•2023

  • Rise of Anthropological Theory

    Marvin Harris, Maxine L Margolis•Rise of Anthropological Theory•2001

  • The Social Organization of Australian Tribes

    Open Access•A R Radcliffe‐brown•Oceania•1930

  • The Social Organization of Australian Tribes

    Open Access•A R Radcliffe‐brown•Oceania•1931

  • Magico-Religious Practitioner Types and Socioeconomic Conditions

    Open Access•Michael James Winkelman•Behavior Science Research•1986

  • Female Status and Cultural Evolution

    Open Access•William Divale, William Tulio Divale•Behavior Science Research•1976

  • The Idea of Culture in the Social Sciences

    Zoltan Tar, Louis Schneider et al.•Contemporary Sociology A Journal…•1974

  • The Idea of Culture in the Social Sciences

    Morton H Fried, Morton Fried et al.•The Western Political Quarterly•1974

  • Coefficient alpha and the internal structure of tests

    Open Access•Lee J Cronbach•Psychometrika•1951

  • An Index of Sociocultural Development Applicable to Precivilized Societies

    Open Access•Edgar Bowden•American Anthropologist•1969

  • Standardization of an Index of Sociocultural Development for Precivilized Societies 1

    Open Access•Edgar Bowden•American Anthropologist•1972

  • A Preliminary Index of Social Development

    Open Access•Raoul Naroll•American Anthropologist•1956

  • Natural Selection in Cultural Evolution

    Open Access•Raoul Naroll, William Divale et al.•American Ethnologist•1976

  • Proxemics [and Comments and Replies]

    Edward T Hall, Everette Hall et al.•Current Anthropology•1968

  • Warfare, Aggression, and Resource Problems

    Open Access•C R Ember, Melvin Ember•Behavior Science Research•1992

  • Leisure, Labor, and the Complexity of Culture

    G Chick, Garry E Chick•Journal of Leisure Research•1986

  • Societal Complexity and Lexical Growth

    Open Access•Stanley R Witkowski, Harold W Burris•Behavior Science Research•1981

  • A Basis for Scaling Qualitative Data

    Louis Guttman•American Sociological Review•1944

  • Convergent and discriminant validation by the multitrait-multimethod matrix

    Donald T Campbell, Donald W Fiske•Psychological Bulletin•1959

  • The Material Culture and Social Institutions of the Simpler Peoples

    Open Access•L T Hobhouse, G C Wheeler et al.•The Sociological Review•1914

  • The Evolution of Complexity in Human Societies and Its Mathematical Expression

    Robert L Carneiro•International Journal of…•1987

  • Art Styles as Reflections of Sociopolitical Complexity

    Open Access•Elizabeth Bryant Merrill•Ethnology•1987

  • Settlement Patterns and Community Organization

    Open Access•George Peter Murdock, Suzanne F Wilson•Ethnology•1972

  • Measurement of Cultural Complexity

    Open Access•George Peter Murdock, Caterina Provost•Ethnology•1973

  • Traits Inculcated in Childhood

    Open Access•Herbert Barry, Herbert Barry Iii et al.•Ethnology•1976

  • Standard Cross-Cultural Sample

    Open Access•George Peter Murdock, Douglas R White•Ethnology•1969

  • The Hidden Dimension

    Edward T Hall•Leonardo•1973

  • Art Styles, Social Stratification, and Cognition

    Open Access•W W Dressler, M C Robbins•American Ethnologist•1975

  • Culture as Consensus

    Open Access•A Kimball Romney, C Weller et al.•American Anthropologist•1986

  • Art Styles as Cultural Cognitive Maps1

    Open Access•J L Fischer•American Anthropologist•1961

  • Games in Culture

    Open Access•John M Roberts, Malcolm J Arth et al.•American Anthropologist•1959

  • Comparative Sociology, 1950-1963

    Open Access•Robert M Marsh•Current Sociology•1966

  • Cross-Cultural Comparisons

    Joseph G Jorgensen•Annual Review of Anthropology•1979

  • On the Relationship between Size of Population and Complexity of Social Organization

    Robert L Carneiro•Journal of Anthropological Research•1986

  • Scale Analysis as an Instrument for the Study of Cultural Evolution

    Robert L Carneiro•Southwestern Journal of…•1962

  • Societal Complexity

    Linton C Freeman, Robert F Winch•American Journal of Sociology•1957

  • Regions Based on Social Structure

    Michael L Burton, Carmella C Moore et al.•Current Anthropology•1996

  • Social Structural Bases of Art

    Alvin W Wolfe•Current Anthropology•1969

Citations per year1.68
Citation span1998 - 2026 (29)
Highly citedNo
Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae