Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Implications from the Disequilibrium of Majority Rule for the Study of Institutions

Bibliographic Data

ID3342842
AuthorsWilliam H Riker (University of Rochester, corresponding author)
Year1980
Volume74
Issue2
Pages432-446
Publication date1980-06-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueAmerican Political Science Review (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0003-0554 • E-ISSN: 1537-5943
PublisherCambridge University Press (CUP) (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.2307/1960638
OpenAlexW4245824675
LanguageEN
Citations received324
References cited15

While contemporary political science (as, for example, in such subjects as political socialization, studies of public opinion, etc.) tends to emphasize the study of values and tastes (because of an assumption that political outcomes-like market outcomes-are determined by the amalgamation of individual preferences), the older tradition of political science emphasized the study of institutions. The line of research in political theory followed during the last generation has involved seeking an equilibrium of tastes; but it has revealed that such an equilibrium exists only rarely, if at all. The inference then is that prudence in research directs the science of politics toward the investigation of empirical regularities in institutions, which, though congealed tastes, are "unstable constants" amenable to scientific investigation

Disequilibrium · Economics · Epistemology · Political science · Politics · Positive economics · Prudence · Electoral Systems and Political Participation · Game Theory and Voting Systems · Law · Philosophy · Political Influence and Corporate Strategies

  • New Perspectives and Evidence on Political Communication and Campaign Effects

    Sharad Iyengar, Adam F Simon•Annual Review of Psychology•2000

  • Formal Models

    Open Access•James Johnson, James Turner Johnson•Research Methods in Deliberative…•2022

  • Rational Choice Institutionalism

    Kenneth A Shepsle•The Oxford Handbook of Political…•2009

  • Political Parties In and Out of Legislatures

    John H Aldrich•The Oxford Handbook of Political…•2009

  • Public Choice Economics

    Open Access•Michael C Munger•International Encyclopedia of the…•2015

  • Old Questions and New Answers about Institutions

    Kenneth A Shepsle•The Oxford handbook of political…•2009

  • Setting the Agenda

    Open Access•Gary W Cox, Mathew D Mccubbins•Setting the Agenda•2005

  • The Engines of European Integration

    Mark A Pollack•ENGINES OF EUROPEAN INTEGRATION:…•2003

  • Designing Federalism

    Open Access•Mikhail Filippov, Михаил Филиппов et al.•Designing Federalism•2004

  • Elections, Parties, Democracy

    Michael D Mcdonald, Ian Budge•Elections, parties, democracy•2005

  • Dominance and subordination in world politics

    Open Access•David A Lake•Power, Order, and Change in World…•2014

  • Lost in Translation

    Open Access•Arthur Lupia, Mathew D Mccubbins•SSRN Electronic Journal•2004

  • L'Année de la régulation n° 7 (2003-2004)

    Kathleen Thelen•L'Année de la régulation n° 7…•2003

  • Power, institutions, and the production of inequality

    Open Access•Andrew Hurrell•Power in Global Governance•2004

  • Capitalism and Democracy

    Trine Iversen, Torben Iversen•The Oxford handbook of political…•2009

  • How Institutions Evolve

    Open Access•Kathleen Thelen•Comparative Historical Analysis…•2003

  • Formale und informale Institutionen in defekten Demokratien

    Open Access•Wolfgang Merkel, Aurel Croissant•Politische Vierteljahresschrift.…•2000

  • The power of liberal international organizations

    Open Access•Michael Barnett, Martha Finnemore•Power in Global Governance•2004

  • Power in Global Governance

    Open Access•Andrew Hurrell, Mark Laffey et al.•Power in Global Governance•2004

  • Democracy Defended

    Open Access•Gerry Mackie•Democracy Defended•2003

  • The Shared Challenges of Institutional Theories

    Open Access•Henry Farrell•Knowledge and Institutions•2018

  • The Political Economy of Skills in Comparative-Historical Perspective

    Open Access•Kathleen Thelen•How Institutions Evolve•2004

  • Historical Institutionalism in Rationalist and Sociological Perspective

    Open Access•Peter A Hall•Explaining Institutional Change•2009

  • The State and International Relations

    David A Lake•The Oxford handbook of…•2009

  • Policing and global governance

    Open Access•Mark Laffey, Jutta Weldes•Power in Global Governance•2004

  • How Institutions Evolve

    Open Access•Kathleen Thelen•How Institutions Evolve•2004

  • Some Rules of Constitutional Design

    Open Access•Peter C Ordeshook•Social Philosophy and Policy•1993

  • Political Institutions

    Bo Rothstein•A New Handbook Of Political Science•1998

  • Explanations and Designs in Political Science

    Open Access•Flávio Da Cunha Rezende, Flávio Rezende et al.•Revista Latinoamericana de…•2021

  • It Takes a Model to Beat a Model

    Open Access•Michael C Munger•Journal of Contextual Economics –…•2022

  • Zimbabwe opposition’s quest for electoral reforms in the post-GNU era

    Open Access•Gift Mwonzora•Cogent Social Sciences•2024

  • Science, institutions, and values

    Open Access•C Mantzavinos•European Journal of Philosophy•2021

  • On the instability of majority decision-making

    Open Access•Jan Sauermann•Theory and Decision•2020

  • Ideology and the Direction of Causation in the Acquisition and Maintenance of Shared Belief Systems

    Open Access•Michael C Munger•Kyklos•2020

  • Groups Agendas as the Root of Party Position Change

    Open Access•Christopher Baylor•The Forum•2017

  • The Manchin Paradox

    Keith Krehbiel, Sara Krehbiel•Quarterly Journal of Political…•2023

  • The Evolution of National Constitutions

    Scott F Abramson, Michael Barber•Quarterly Journal of Political…•2019

  • The Decline of the Death Penalty and the Discovery of Innocence

    Open Access•F R Baumgartner, Suzanna L De Boef et al.•The Decline of the Death Penalty…•2001

  • Legislative Development in Africa

    Open Access•Ken Ochieng’ Opalo, Ken Ochieng Opalo et al.•Legislative Development in Africa•2019

  • Public Debt and the Birth of the Democratic State

    Open Access•David Stasavage•Public Debt and the Birth of the…•2003

  • Meritocracy and Autocratic Power-Sharing

    Clair Yang, Yasheng Huang et al.•The Journal of Politics•2026

  • Term Limits as a Boon to Legislative Scholarship

    Open Access•Christopher Z Mooney•State Politics & Policy Quarterly•2009

  • Role of institutions in public management

    Open Access•Vaishali Singh•Frontiers in Political Science•2024

  • The Rikerian Arrow at the Heart of Democratic Backsliding

    Open Access•Dwayne Woods•Chinese Political Science Review•2025

  • Agenda Control by Committee Chairs in Fragmented Multi-party Parliaments

    Maoz Rosenthal•Israeli Studies Review•2018

  • Prosociality in Majority Decisions

    Open Access•Jan Sauermann•Journal of Experimental Political…•2021

  • Choosing anarchy

    Open Access•Moonhawk Kim, Scott Wolford•International Theory•2014

  • Strategic agenda setting and Prime Ministers’ approval ratings

    Open Access•Maoz Rosenthal•British Politics•2020

  • Covid-19 and the second exams fiasco across the UK

    Open Access•Sean Kippin, Paul Cairney•British Politics•2022

  • The role of bureaucrats in designing policy outcomes

    Open Access•Assaf Meydani•International Journal of Law in…•2015

  • Enlargement and Institutional Reform in the European Union

    Open Access•Bernard Steunenberg•Constitutional Political Economy•2001

  • Institutional Design, Uncertainty, and Path Dependency during Transitions

    Open Access•Michael Mcfaul•Constitutional Political Economy•1999

  • Endogenous Selection of Institutions and Their Exogenous Effects

    Open Access•Olga Shvetsova•Constitutional Political Economy•2003

  • The politics within institutions for regulating public spending

    Open Access•Bernard Steunenberg•Constitutional Political Economy•2020

  • From Schumpeterian Democracy to Constitutional Democracy

    Open Access•Paulo Trigo Pereira•Constitutional Political Economy•2000

  • Constitutional coordination in unstable party systems

    Open Access•Gary M Reich•Constitutional Political Economy•2007

  • Decentralized Governance, Constitution Formation, and Redistribution

    Open Access•Erik Wibbels•Constitutional Political Economy•2005

  • New Institutional Economics

    Open Access•Peter G Klein•SSRN Electronic Journal•1998

  • Taking the Lead

    Open Access•Ralph G Carter, Jennifer M Scott•Politics & Policy•2004

  • A Dynamic Model of Democratic Elections in Multidimensional Policy Spaces

    Jeffrey S Banks, Jim Duggan•Quarterly Journal of Political…•2008

  • Why Are Some Institutions Replaced while Others Persist? Evidence from State Constitutions

    Open Access•Adam Cayton•State Politics & Policy Quarterly•2015

  • On the importance of personal sources of power in politics

    Open Access•Annette Baturo, Johan A Elkink•French Politics•2017

  • Europeanization Beyond the Goodness of Fit

    Open Access•Ellen Mastenbroek, Michael Kaeding•Comparative European Politics•2006

  • Legislative Process in International Organizations

    Open Access•Courtenay R Conrad, Nathan W Monroe•International Studies Review•2020

  • Presidents’ Strategic Action and Policy Change in Mexico

    Jose-Luis Mendez•Journal of Comparative Policy…•2017

  • The Union for the Mediterranean, or the Changing Context of Euro-Mediterranean Relations

    Federica Bicchi•Mediterranean Politics•2011

  • Fiscal transparency puzzle and electoral institutions

    Lobna Abdellatif, Mazen Hassan et al.•Journal of Legislative Studies•2016

  • Policy Spaces

    Jay D Gatrell, Jeff Worsham•Space and Polity•2002

  • Reconsidering the new institutional approach to China

    Chih-Yu Shih, Chih‐yu Shih•Journal of Communist Studies•1999

  • Right as Opposed to Wrong as Opposed to Left

    Gideon Doron•Israel Studies•2005

  • Al Qaeda as a Dune Organization

    Shaul Mishal, Maoz Rosenthal•Studies in Conflict and Terrorism•2005

  • Delayed cooperation

    Huei-Jyun Ye•Review of International Political…•2023

  • The role of committee systems in post-communist legislatures

    Terry D Clark, Eglė Verseckaitė et al.•Europe Asia Studies•2006

  • The Transformation of Political Institutions

    Open Access•Daniel J Galvin•Studies in American Political…•2012

  • Interests, Institutions, and Positive Theory

    Open Access•Terry M Moe•Studies in American Political…•1987

  • If Politics Matters

    Open Access•R M Smith•Studies in American Political…•1992

  • Gradual Institutional Change in Congressional Ethics

    Open Access•Denis Saint-Martin, Denis Saint‐martin•Studies in American Political…•2014

  • Number of Parties, Endogenous Partisan Preferences, and Electoral Turnout Rates

    Open Access•Christian W Martin, Thomas Plümper•Social Science Computer Review•2005

  • Buying treaties with cigarettes

    Chad Rector•International Interactions•2001

  • Empirical Strategies in International Development Research

    Open Access•Victor Menaldo, Aseem Prakash•Journal of Policy Analysis and…•2014

  • Modeling Public Decision Preferences Using Context-Specific Value Hierarchies

    Open Access•Eva M Witesman, Eva Witesman et al.•The American Review of Public…•2014

  • Membership Balance, Open Meetings, and Effectiveness in Federal Advisory Committees

    Open Access•Kevin D Karty•The American Review of Public…•2005

  • Abstract Judicial Review, Legislative Bargaining, and Policy Compromise

    Open Access•Georg Vanberg•Journal of Theoretical Politics•1998

  • An Altimeter for Mr. Escher's Stairway

    Open Access•Douglas Rae, Douglas W Rae•American Political Science Review•1980

  • The Heresthetics of Constitution-Making

    Open Access•William H Riker•American Political Science Review•1984

  • Modeling the effect of campaign advertising on US presidential elections when differences across states matter

    Open Access•Maria Gallego, Norman Schofield•Mathematical Social Sciences•2017

  • Some economic applications of Scott domains

    Open Access•Spyros Vassilakis•Mathematical Social Sciences•1992

  • The Return to History and the New Institutionalism in American Political Science

    Open Access•David Brian Robertson, David Robertson•Social Science History•1993

  • Presidential Reorganization and the Politics of Public Agencies

    Open Access•Andrew B Whitford•Administration & Society•2021

  • The Origins of Budgetary Preferences

    Open Access•James D Savage•Administration & Society•2002

  • U.S. Treaty Making with American Indians

    Open Access•Arthur Spirling•American Journal of Political…•2012

  • Collective Action for Sustainable Forestry

    Open Access•Satyapriya Rout•Social Change•2010

  • Why so much stability? An optimistic view of the possibility of rational legislative decisionmaking

    Open Access•Kenneth Koford•Public Choice•1982

  • Equilibrium institutions

    Open Access•Josep M Colomer•Public Choice•2014

  • The median voter model in public choice theory

    Open Access•Randall G Holcombe•Public Choice•1989

  • Citizens’ preferences about voting rules

    Open Access•André Blais, Jean-François Laslier et al.•Public Choice•2015

  • A general probabilistic spatial theory of elections

    Open Access•James M Enelow, Melvin J Hinich•Public Choice•1989

  • On the empirical relevance of Condorcet’s paradox

    Open Access•Adrian Van Deemen•Public Choice•2014

  • Existence of a ?structurally stable? equilibrium for a non-collegial voting rule

    Open Access•Norman Schofield•Public Choice•1986

  • The stability of international coalitions in United Nations voting from 1946 to 1973

    Open Access•Randall G Holcombe, Russell S Sobel•Public Choice•1996

  • A Possibility Theorem on Majority Decisions

    A Sen, Amartya K Sen•Econometrica•1966

  • Instability of Simple Dynamic Games

    Norman Schofield•The Review of Economic Studies•1978

  • Intransitivities in multidimensional voting models and some implications for agenda control

    Open Access•Richard D Mckelvey•Journal of Economic Theory•1976

  • General Conditions for Global Intransitivities in Formal Voting Models

    Richard D Mckelvey•Econometrica•1979

  • An economic theory of democracy

    Anthony Downs•An economic theory of democracy•1985

  • Social Choice and Individual Values

    Kenneth J Arrow, Eric S Maskin•Social Choice and Individual Values•2017

  • The Theory of Committees and Elections

    Open Access•Duncan Black, Georg Kunze•Theory of Committees and Elections•1986

  • Voting and the Summation of Preferences

    Open Access•William H Riker•American Political Science Review•1961

  • Stable outcomes in majority rule voting games

    Open Access•Judith Sloss•Public Choice•1973

  • On the Rationale of Group Decision-making

    Duncan Black•Journal of Political Economy•1948

  • Institutional Arrangements and Equilibrium in Multidimensional Voting Models

    Kenneth A Shepsle•American Journal of Political…•1979

  • Some Ambiguities in the Notion of Power

    Open Access•William H Riker•American Political Science Review•1964

  • An Expository Development of a Mathematical Model of the Electoral Process

    Open Access•Otto A Davis, Melvin J Hinich et al.•American Political Science Review•1970

Unique citing works324
Citations per year7,04
Citation span1980 - 2026 (47)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedYes
Citation typesNeutral: 324

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae