Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Mass Persuasion as a Means of Legitimation and China's Popular Authoritarianism

Bibliographic Data

ID3759434
AuthorsAnne-Marie Brady (University of Canterbury, Christchurch, New Zealand), Anne‐marie Brady (0000-0002-7112-6810, University of Canterbury, corresponding author)
Year2009
Volume53
Issue3
Pages434-457
Publication date2009-11-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueAmerican Behavioral Scientist (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0002-7642 • E-ISSN: 1552-3381
PublisherSAGE Publications Inc (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1177/0002764209338802
OpenAlexW2040118471
LanguageEN
Citations received54
References cited30

States traditionally maintain power by means of either performance-based legitimacy or promulgating ideology. Mass persuasion can be used to both promote a regime's ideology and persuade the public that it is performing the tasks of government effectively and equitably. Most states use a combination of these two approaches to maintain political stability. In China, since the violent crackdown on the 1989 protest movement, the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) government has stressed an old slogan to set a new line on its format for maintaining political power: "Seize with both hands; both hands must be strong." This means that the CCP now bases its legitimacy on both economic growth and a renewed emphasis on persuasion, or what in Chinese terms is known as propaganda and thought work. The two "hands" in this slogan are strong and intertwined, as the key themes of propaganda and thought work in the current period are promoting economic growth, building market confidence, and engaging in economic thought reform. In an extraordinary process of cultural exchange, in recent years China's propaganda system has deliberately absorbed the methodology of political public relations, mass communications, social psychology, and other modern methods of mass persuasion commonly used in Western democratic societies, adapting them to Chinese conditions and needs. China's modern-day propaganda and thought work is now market friendly, scientific, high tech, and politics-lite. Focusing on the years from 1989 to 2007, this article uses the case of contemporary China to examine the role of mass persuasion as a force for maintaining and, in China's case, reclaiming political legitimacy to rule and introduces a new term to understand the China model, popular authoritarianism

Authoritarianism · China · Communism · Democracy · Government (linguistics) · Ideology · Legitimacy · Legitimation · Mass line · Mass media · Persuasion · Political economy · Political science · Politics · Public opinion · Slogan · Sociology · China's Socioeconomic Reforms and Governance · Chinese history and philosophy · Law · Psychology · Social Media and Politics · Social Psychology

  • Politics by numbers

    Hone Mandefro•International Review of Sociology•2016

  • When propaganda resonates

    Open Access•Xiaoxiao Shen•Political Psychology•2026

  • Party-state, nation, empire

    Vivienne Shue•Journal of Chinese Governance•2018

  • Language, gender, and patriarchy in Mulan

    Open Access•Pimpatchanok Manaworapong, Neil Evan Jon Anthony Bowen•Humanities and Social Sciences…•2022

  • How Propaganda Works in the Digital Era

    Open Access•Yuner Zhu, King-Wa Fu•Digital Journalism•2024

  • Powers of persuasion? China's struggle for human rights discourse power at the UN

    Open Access•Malin Oud•Global Policy•2024

  • Pseudo-participation, authentic nationalism

    Lutgard Lams, Wendy Weile Zhou•Asian Journal of Communication•2023

  • How Do Chinese Media Frame Arab Uprisings

    Open Access•Shiming Hu, Weipeng Hou et al.•Media and Communication•2021

  • Propaganda and thought work in the Mao era

    Open Access•Haoguang Li•Sociology Lens•2024

  • Security and Religion

    Open Access•Marat Iliyasov•Journal of Muslims in Europe•2021

  • Seizing the Window of Strategic Opportunity’

    Open Access•Wenlong Song•Social Sciences•2022

  • Slogans, Pragmatism, and Crisis Response at the Grassroots Level

    Open Access•Liu Yang, Kinglun Ngok•Journal of Current Chinese Affairs•2023

  • Alien Rule in the Longue Durée

    Michael Hechter•Ethnopolitics•2010

  • Migrant Street Vendors in Urban China and the Social Production of Public Space

    Open Access•Ryanne Flock, W Breitung•Population Space and Place•2015

  • Looking inward

    Open Access•Yifan Yang•The British Journal of Politics…•2020

  • How Propaganda Affects Public Opinion in China

    Dan Chen•Asian Studies Review•2023

  • Killing Politics Softly

    Paul Shields•Communist and Post-Communist…•2021

  • Policy-Mediated Epistemic Control

    Open Access•Arash Beidollahkhani•Higher Education Policy•2025

  • Discourse, Politics and Media in Contemporary China

    Paul A Chilton, Jiang Zemin et al.•Discourse, politics and media in…•2014

  • In Pursuit of an Alternative Model? The Modernisation Trap in China’s Official Development Discourse

    Open Access•Elena Barabantseva•East Asia•2011

  • The Rise of Xenophobia and Nationalism in China Since the Covid Pandemic

    Open Access•Lai-Ha Chan, Pak K Lee•East Asia•2023

  • Ideology and Mass Killing

    Jonathan Leader Maynard•Ideology and Mass Killing•2022

  • Legitimizing Ruptures of Development Trajectories

    Open Access•Y Song, Tsan‐kuo Chang•The International Journal of…•2012

  • Rethinking Two-Way Socialisation

    Open Access•Karl Yan, Yin Yang•Journal of Current Chinese Affairs•2024

  • Creating Political Legitimacy

    Open Access•Bo Rothstein•American Behavioral Scientist•2009

  • The Communist hero and the April Fool's joke

    Open Access•Z Gao, K Bischoping•Social Anthropology•2019

  • Embedding “Society” into the Chinese Communist Party’s Rule of Law

    Open Access•Susan Trevaske, Delia Lin•Hague Journal on the Rule of Law•2025

  • Legitimationsstrategien von Autokratien

    Open Access•Steffen Kailitz, Stanley Wurster•Zeitschrift für Vergleichende…•2017

  • Legitimationsstrategien von Autokratien im Vergleich

    Open Access•Julia Grauvogel, Christian Von Soest•Zeitschrift für Vergleichende…•2017

  • Legitimation towards whom

    Open Access•Maria Josua•Zeitschrift für Vergleichende…•2017

  • Tradition, modernity, and Chinese masculinity

    Open Access•Feng William Dezheng, Mandy Hoi Man Yu•Pragmatics Quarterly Publication…•2022

  • Authoritarian legitimation

    Mariya Y Omelicheva•Central Asian Survey•2016

  • Theorizing Legitimacy in Migration Research

    Open Access•Nathan T B Ly•International Migration Review•2025

  • Regimes of temporality

    Open Access•Séagh Kehoe•Media Culture & Society•2020

  • Creating the spectacular city in everyday life

    Open Access•Ryanne Flock•Urban Studies•2024

  • Propaganda to a cynical audience

    Open Access•Alexei Zakharov•Political Science Research and…•2026

  • The effects of forced versus selective exposure to propaganda in China

    Open Access•Xiaoxiao Shen•Political Science Research and…•2025

  • Information Credibility under Authoritarian Rule

    Charles Chang•Political Communication•2021

  • The Art of Self-Criticism

    Charles Chang•Political Communication•2024

  • Good Minzu and bad Muslims

    Open Access•D R Stroup•Nations and Nationalism•2021

  • Managing Nationalism

    Open Access•Kai Quek, Samuel S H Chan•Journal of Conflict Resolution•2025

  • Authoritarian Propaganda Campaigns on Foreign Affairs

    Open Access•Andrew Chubb, Frances Yaping Wang•International Studies Quarterly•2023

  • Claims to legitimacy count

    Open Access•Julia Grauvogel, Christian Von Soest•European Journal of Political…•2014

  • Media capture, captured

    Open Access•Hennes-Michel Barnehl, G Schumacher•Democratization•2024

  • Authoritarian legislature, legitimacy strategy, and shadow economy

    Da Sul Kim, Chungshik Moon•Democratization•2022

  • The Chinese Ideology

    Open Access•André Lieber•Journal of Chinese Political…•2013

  • Constructing a New Socialist Countryside’ and Beyond

    Open Access•Günter Schubert, Anna L Ahlers•Journal of Chinese Political…•2011

  • Conceptualizing the Relationship Between Persuasion and Legitimacy

    Open Access•Maria Bondes, Sandra Heep•Journal of Chinese Political…•2013

  • Slogans as an Organizational Feature of Chinese Politics

    Open Access•Aleš Karmazin•Journal of Chinese Political…•2020

  • Debating China beyond the Great Firewall

    Open Access•Rongbin Han•Journal of Chinese Political…•2023

  • Decoding Xieshang Minzhu in Chinese Politics

    Open Access•Li-Chia Lo•Journal of Chinese Political…•2021

  • Identity, procedures and performance

    Christian Von Soest, Julia Grauvogel•Contemporary Politics•2017

  • The relevance of legitimation – a new framework for analysis

    Christian Von Haldenwang•Contemporary Politics•2017

  • The Politics of Covid-19

    Y Zhai•Journal of Contemporary Asia•2023

  • Taxation without Representation in Contemporary Rural China

    Open Access•Thomas P Bernstein, Xiaobo Lü•Taxation Without Representation…•2003

  • Legitimacy and Power Politics

    Mlada Bukovansky•Legitimacy and Power Politics•2009

  • The Decline of Communism in China

    Open Access•X L Ding•Decline of Communism in China•1994

  • After the Propaganda State

    Daniel C Lynch•After the Propaganda State•1999

  • North Korea

    Han S Park•North Korea•2002

  • Party vs. State in Post-1949 China

    Open Access•Shiping Zheng•Party vs. State in Post-1949 China•1997

  • The Birth of the Propaganda State

    Open Access•Peter Kenez•Birth of the Propaganda State•1985

  • The Legitimation of Power

    Open Access•David Beetham•The legitimation of power.•1991

  • The Legitimation of Power

    Open Access•David Beetham•Legitimation of Power•2013

  • Factions and the Politics of Guanxi

    Lucian W Pye•The China Journal•1995

  • Weapons of Mass Distraction

    Open Access•William R Freudenburg, Margarita V Alario et al.•Sociological Forum•2007

  • Contemporary International Relations, 1949-1950

    Linden A Mander, Norman J Padelford•The Western Political Quarterly•1950

  • Public Opinion in Soviet Russia

    Donald G Macrae•International Affairs•1951

  • The Engineering of Consent

    Open Access•Edward L Bernays•The Annals of the American…•1947

  • Legitimation from the Top to Civil Society

    Open Access•Giuseppe Di Palma•World Politics•1991

  • Public Opinion in Soviet Russia; A Study in Mass Persuasion

    Alex Inkele, Alex Inkeles•The American Journal of Psychology•1951

  • Working with a Dying Ideology

    Zhou He, He Zhou•Journalism Studies•2000

  • Manufacturing consent

    Edward S Herman, John Pruden et al.•La fabrication du consentement :…•1988

  • Toward a Psychology of Framing Effects

    Open Access•Thomas E Nelson, Zoe M Oxley et al.•Political Behavior•1997

  • Some Social Requisites of Democracy

    Open Access•Seymour Martin Lipset•American Political Science Review•1959

  • The Theory of Political Propaganda

    Open Access•Harold D Lasswell•American Political Science Review•1927

  • Governing China

    D Campbell, David N Campbell et al.•Pacific Affairs•1995

  • From Paris to the Paris of the East and Back

    Open Access•Elizabeth J Perry•Comparative Studies in Society…•1999

Unique citing works54
Citations per year3,18
Citation span2009 - 2026 (18)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 52

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae