Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Promiscuous Things

Perspectives on Cultural Property Through Photographs in the Purari Delta of Papua New Guinea

Bibliographic Data

ID4283301
AuthorsJoshua A Bell (0000-0001-6892-8786)
Year2008
Volume15
Issue2
Pages123-139
Publication date2008-05-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueInternational Journal of Cultural Property (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0940-7391 • E-ISSN: 1465-7317
PublisherCambridge University Press (CUP) (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1017/s0940739108080107
OpenAlexW2124836007
LanguageEN
Citations received31
References cited38

Within this article I discuss the productive potentials of looking at historic photographs of the Purari Delta with indigenous communities today. A particular type of artifact, the meanings of photographs are promiscuous. Thinking about the shape of cultural property relations that are manifest photographs, I show how engagements with indigenous communities unsettles European preconceptions about what photographs are as well as how doing so raises issues about what cultural property is, and perhaps can be. Instead of being a discreet entity, cultural property for the I'ai emerges as a network of relationships that envelopes people, environment, and ancestors. This expansive notion of cultural property can help us rethink how we treat and handle objects within museums and archives

Aesthetics · Archaeology · Art · Artifact (error · Cultural artifact · Cultural heritage · Cultural property · Epistemology · Ethnology · Expansive · Indigenous · New guinea · Property (philosophy · Sociology · Anthropological Studies and Insights · Anthropology · Computer Science · Cultural Heritage Management and Preservation · Geographies of human-animal interactions · History · Philosophy · Artificial Intelligence · Ecology

  • Objects of Affect

    Elizabeth Edwards•Annual Review of Anthropology•2012

  • Negotiating Who "Owns" Penobscot Culture

    Jane Anderson•Anthropological Quarterly•2018

  • Museum Anthropology

    Open Access•Candace S Greene•Emerging Trends in the Social and…•2015

  • Contemporary Kerewo and Urama Responses to Frank Hurley’s Collection

    Open Access•Lara Lamb, Christopher Lee•Repatriation, Exchange, and…•2022

  • Material Lives of Cold War Radio Pasts in India

    Open Access•Anandita Bajpai•Historical Journal Of Film Radio…•2024

  • Documenting discontent

    Open Access•Joshua A Bell•The Australian Journal of…•2009

  • “But they were never only the master’s tools”

    Open Access•Celeste Pedri-Spade•AlterNative An International…•2017

  • The Photograph and the Malanggan

    Open Access•H Geismar•The Australian Journal of…•2009

  • On stone tools and the ‘prehistoric’

    C D Berk•History and Anthropology•2024

  • Photographing Spirits

    Jamon Alex Halvaksz, Jamon Halvaksz•Visual Anthropology•2008

  • Floating Worlds

    Claire Langsford, Claire Margaret Langsford•Sites a journal of social…•2016

  • The Ancestral Image in the Present Tense

    Christopher Morton•Photographies•2015

  • De-colonized Collecting

    Open Access•D Lipset•Journal de la Société des…•2018

  • Retro Nuosu

    Open Access•Kaitlin Banfill•Visual Anthropology Review•2020

  • From Loss of Objects to Recovery of Meanings

    Open Access•Jeremy Pilcher, Saskia Vermeylen•M/C Journal•2008

  • After the Return

    Open Access•J A Bell, Kimberly Christen et al.•Museum Worlds•2013

  • Voicing silences in the colonial photographic archive

    Open Access•P Basu•Visual Anthropology Review•2025

  • Kryzys reżimu muzealnej własności i jego potencjały

    Open Access•Katarzyna Maniak•Konteksty Polska Sztuka Ludowa•2024

  • Building culturally meaningful chronologies

    Open Access•Cathy Urwin, Chris Urwin et al.•Archaeology in Oceania/Archæology…•2024

  • The meaning and importance of the Lapita face motif

    Open Access•John Edward Terrell, Esther M Schechter•Archaeology in Oceania/Archæology…•2009

  • Portrait of a Martyr as a Young Man

    Open Access•Lucie Ryzova•Comparative Studies in Society…•2025

  • Presence Without Identification

    Serguei Alex Oushakine•October•2018

  • The photograph as archive

    Open Access•Sabra G Thorner•Journal of Material Culture•2019

  • Thick photography

    Open Access•Jennifer Deger•Journal of Material Culture•2016

  • A Bundle of Relations

    Joshua A Bell•Annual Review of Anthropology•2017

  • Making Kin

    Open Access•J A Bell•Museum Anthropology•2022

  • Being Called to Action

    Open Access•Sabra G Thorner•Museum Anthropology•2022

  • Repatriation as Pedagogy

    Jane Anderson, Sonya Atalay•Current Anthropology•2023

  • The Photographic Assemblage

    Jamon Alex Halvaksz, Jamon Halvaksz•History and Anthropology•2010

  • Out of the Mouths of Crocodiles

    Joshua A Bell•History and Anthropology•2010

  • Rethinking agency in hiri exchange relationships on Papua New Guinea's south coast

    Open Access•Cathy Urwin, Chris Urwin et al.•Journal of Anthropological…•2023

  • Who Owns Native Culture?

    Michael F Brown•Who Owns Native Culture?•2004

  • Art And Agency

    Alfred Gell•Art and agency•1998

  • Entangled Objects

    Nicholas Thomas•Entangled Objects•1991

  • Photographs Objects Histories

    Elizabeth Edwards, Janice Hart•Photographs Objects Histories•2004

  • The Material Culture Reader

    Victor Buchli•Material Culture Reader•2020

  • Who Owns Culture?

    Susan Scafidi•Who Owns Culture?•2019

  • The Social Life of Things

    Open Access•Arjun Appadurai•Social Life of Things•1986

  • Kinship, Law and the Unexpected

    Open Access•M Strathern•Kinship, Law and the Unexpected•2005

  • Museums And Source Communities

    Alison Brown, Alison K Brown et al.•Museums And Source Communities•2005

  • Introduction

    Open Access•A Appadurai•Social Life of Things•1986

  • Protection of intellectual, biological & cultural property in Papua New Guinea

    Open Access•Kathy Whimp, M Busse•Protection of intellectual,…•2013

  • Images, Selves, and the Visual Record

    Open Access•Benjamin R Smith•Social Analysis•2003

  • Moving Images

    Open Access•J P Taylor, John Taylor•The Australian Journal of…•2012

  • Marijuana, Guns, Crocodiles and Submarines

    Open Access•Joshua A Bell•Oceania•2006

  • Beyond Aesthetics

    Open Access•Eric Gable•Visual Anthropology Review•2002

  • Raw Histories

    Open Access•Liam Buckley•Visual Anthropology Review•2002

  • Taking the photographs home

    Judith Binney, Gillian Chaplin•Visual Anthropology•1991

  • Photographs and the Sound of History

    Open Access•Elizabeth Edwards•Visual Anthropology Review•2005

  • Entangled objects

    Thomas Nicholas, Nicholas Thomas•Entangled objects•1991

  • Losing the Forest but not the Stories in the Trees

    J A Bell, Joshua Bell•Journal of Pacific History•2006

  • New Men of Papua

    J Watson, James B Watson et al.•American Sociological Review•1961

  • Cultural Property Internationalism

    Open Access•John Henry Merryman•International Journal of Cultural…•2005

  • The Kopiravi Cult of the Namau, Papua

    Alfred C Haddon•Man•1919

  • The Purari River Delta Societies, Papua New Guinea, after the Tom Kabu Movement

    Open Access•Robert F Maher•Ethnology•1984

  • Asiwinarong

    Roy Wagner•Asiwinarong•1986

  • The Gender of the Gift

    Marilyn Strathern•Gender of the Gift•2019

  • Cutting the Network

    M Strathern•Journal of the Royal Anthropologica…•1996

  • Cosmological Deixis and Amerindian Perspectivism

    Eduardo Batalha Viveiros De Castro•Journal of the Royal Anthropologica…•1998

  • Le savoir des anthropologues

    Paul Rabinow, Dan Sperber•Man•1984

  • Copyright in context

    Open Access•H Geismar•American Ethnologist•2005

  • Material and Memory

    Open Access•C Wright•Journal of Material Culture•2004

  • Owning Creativity

    Open Access•James Leach•Journal of Material Culture•2003

  • Malakula

    Open Access•H Geismar•Comparative Studies in Society…•2006

  • Telephones, Cameras and Technology in West New Britain Cargo Cults

    Open Access•Andrew Lattas•Oceania•2000

Unique citing works31
Citations per year1,72
Citation span2008 - 2025 (18)
Citation velocityrecent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 29

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae