Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Comparing the Impact of Online and Face-to-Face Professional Development in the Context of Curriculum Implementation

Bibliographic Data

ID4309833
AuthorsBarry Fishman (0000-0003-2464-1999, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, USA), Spyros Konstantopoulo, Spyros Konstantopoulos (0000-0003-1393-2440, Michigan State University, East Lansing, MI, USA), Beth W Kubitskey (Eastern Michigan University, Ypsilanti, MI, USA), Beth Kubitskey (Eastern Michigan University), Richard Vath (University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, USA), Richard J Vath (University of Michigan), Gina Park (University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, USA), Heather Johnson (0000-0003-4311-6065, Vanderbilt University, Nashville, TN, USA), Daniel C Edelson (0000-0003-2261-4065, The National Geographic Society, Washington, DC, USA)
Year2013
Volume64
Issue5
Pages426-438
Publication date2013-11-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueJournal of Teacher Education (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0022-4871 • E-ISSN: 1552-7816
PublisherSAGE Publications Inc (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1177/0022487113494413
OpenAlexW1981626132
LanguageEN
Citations received70
References cited31

This study employed a randomized experiment to examine differences in teacher and student learning from professional development (PD) in two modalities: online and face-to-face. The study explores whether there are differences in teacher knowledge and beliefs, teacher classroom practice, and student learning outcomes related to PD modality. Comparison of classroom practice and student learning outcomes, normally difficult to establish in PD research, is facilitated by the use of a common set of curriculum materials as the content for PD and subsequent teaching. Findings indicate that teachers and students exhibited significant gains in both conditions, and that there was no significant difference between conditions. We discuss implications for the delivery of teacher professional learning

Context (archaeology) · Curriculum · Face (sociological concept) · Face-to-face · Faculty Development · Mathematics education · Medical education · Modalities · Modality (human–computer interaction) · Multimedia · Online learning · Pedagogy · Professional development · Set (abstract data type) · Sociology · Computer Science · Education and Technology Integration · Medicine · Online and Blended Learning · Psychology · Teacher Education and Leadership Studies

  • Space that was safe to explore and learn

    Open Access•Ross Anderson, Jen Katz‐Buonincontro et al.•Australasian Journal of…•2022

  • Scaling-up an efficacious school-based physical activity intervention

    Open Access•Chris Lonsdale, Taren Sanders et al.•BMC Public Health•2016

  • Participatory Design Research and Educational Justice

    Megan Bang, Shirin Vossoughi•Cognition and Instruction•2016

  • Engagement through microblogging

    John P Carpenter, Jeffrey P Carpenter et al.•Professional Development in…•2015

  • Collaborative design as a form of professional development

    Open Access•Joke Voogt, Thérèse Laferrière et al.•Instructional Science•2015

  • Facilitators and Barriers of Implementing evidence-based Programs Delivered by Teachers in Early Childhood Education

    Open Access•Laura Bentley, Sonia White et al.•Early Childhood Education Journal•2026

  • Artificial Intelligence and teachers' sustainability

    Open Access•Rana Saleh Alghamdi Rana Saleh Alghamdi, Rana Saleh Alghamdi et al.•ALUSTATH JOURNAL FOR HUMAN AND…•2024

  • TriHy

    Open Access•Ildiko Porter-Szucs, Barry DeCicco•SN Social Sciences•2022

  • Teachers’ professional learning and its impact on students’ learning outcomes

    Open Access•Ourania Maria Ventista, Chris Brown•Social Sciences & Humanities Open•2023

  • Examining a Decade of Research in Online Teacher Professional Development

    Open Access•Celina Dulude Lay, Bohdana Allman et al.•Frontiers in Education•2020

  • Reinvigorating the Desire to Teach

    Open Access•Ross C Anderson, Jen Katz‐Buonincontro et al.•Frontiers in Education•2022

  • Triple Hybrid (TriHy)

    Open Access•Ildiko Porter-Szucs, Barry DeCicco•Distances et médiations des savoirs•2024

  • Hong Kong Kindergarten Teachers’ Satisfaction and Engagement in a Music-and-Movement Online Professional Development Course

    Open Access•Siu-Ping NG, Alfredo Bautista•Education Sciences•2024

  • Remote and Blended Teacher Education

    Open Access•Thomas Perry, Madeleine Findon et al.•Education Sciences•2021

  • Mathematik-Fortbildungen in Präsenz und digital

    Open Access•Birte Pöhler-Friedrich, Bettina Rösken-Winter et al.•Zeitschrift für Erziehungswissensch…•2024

  • Stichwort

    Open Access•Dirk Richter, Rebecca Lazarides et al.•Zeitschrift für Erziehungswissensch…•2024

  • Effectiveness of Online Music Professional Development

    Open Access•Alfredo Bautista, Million Wan et al.•Journal of Music Teacher Education•2025

  • How could roles shape teachers’ cognitive and interactional processes in collaborative learning? The design of GenAI-assisted collaborative role-based strategy

    Hui Zhang, Qi Wang et al.•Interactive Learning Environments•2026

  • Professional development in a pandemic

    Open Access•Alida K Hudson, Kacee Lambright et al.•Educational Technology Research…•2023

  • Effects of online teacher professional development on teacher-, classroom-, and student-level outcomes

    Open Access•Fitore Morina, Tim Fütterer et al.•Computers & Education•2025

  • What makes online professional development effective? The effect of quality characteristics on teachers’ satisfaction and changes in their professional practices

    Open Access•André Meyer, Marc Kleinknecht et al.•Computers & Education•2023

  • Competency development of pre-service teachers during video-based learning

    Open Access•Xiaojing Weng, Oi-Lam Ng et al.•Computers & Education•2023

  • The impact of an interactive, personalized computer-based teacher professional development program on student performance

    Open Access•Yasemin Copur-Gencturk, Jingxian Li et al.•Computers & Education•2024

  • Effects of web‐based training on Spanish pre‐service and in‐service teacher knowledge and implicit beliefs on learning to write

    Open Access•Juan E Jiménez, Rocío C Seoane et al.•Journal of Computer Assisted…•2021

  • Effects of collaborative filtering‐based peer recommendation mechanism on in‐service teachers’ learning performance, knowledge construction, and social network during online training

    Open Access•Ning Ma, Kaixin Gong et al.•Journal of Computer Assisted…•2023

  • Effectiveness of online and blended delivery methods on preservice teachers’ knowledge and beliefs for writing instruction

    Rocío C Seoane, Juan E Jiménez•Journal of Education for Teaching…•2022

  • Identifying Levers Related to Student Performance on High-Stakes Science Exams

    Open Access•Christian Fischer, Brandon Foster et al.•Teachers College Record The Voice…•2020

  • Instilling social accountability into the health professions education curriculum with international case studies

    Mohamed Elhassan Abdalla, Mohamed H Taha et al.•Medical Teacher•2025

  • “It Gave Us an Outlet”

    Open Access•Hillary M Kapa, Laura Vega et al.•Psychology in the Schools•2025

  • STEM professional development of early childhood teachers

    Open Access•Ahmet Erol, Asiye Ivrendi•Psychology in the Schools•2025

  • Prompts or Protocol

    Open Access•Ashlyn Pierson, Heather Johnson et al.•Journal of Research in Science…•2026

  • A qualitative evaluation of remote training to develop a fitness surveillance system

    Open Access•Cate A Egan, Christopher B Merica et al.•Health Education Journal•2023

  • The impact of teacher engagement in an interactive webinar series on the effectiveness of financial literacy education

    Open Access•Boukje Compen, Kristof De Witte et al.•British Journal of Educational…•2021

  • Comparing quality and engagement in face‐to‐face and online teacher professional development

    Open Access•Nina Mulaimović, Elise Richter et al.•British Journal of Educational…•2025

  • Transitioning to remote learning

    Open Access•Liz Owens Boltz, Aman Yadav et al.•British Journal of Educational…•2021

  • Design Recommendations for Self-Paced Online Faculty Development Courses

    Open Access•Melissa Rizzuto•TechTrends•2016

  • Generative AI for Teachers’ Self-Directed Professional Development

    Open Access•Zixi Li, Chaoran Wang et al.•TechTrends•2025

  • You know you can do this, right?”

    Thomas Hammond, Alec M Bodzin et al.•Cartography and Geographic…•2018

  • Effects of repeated implicit bias training in a North American university

    Brett Lehman, Karen Colbert et al.•Journal of Higher Education…•2022

  • Replication of combined school readiness interventions for teachers and parents of head start pre-kindergarteners using remote delivery

    Open Access•Susan H Landry, Tricia A Zucker et al.•Early Childhood Research Quarterly•2021

  • Does the area and learning modality of teacher qualification matter to middle school students’ performance in mathematics

    Open Access•Dayane S R Souza, Luciano Menezes Bezerra Sampaio et al.•International Journal of…•2024

  • Satisfaction with online learning in the new normal

    Open Access•Wiam Elshami, Mohamed H Taha et al.•Medical Education Online•2021

  • Supporting teachers to enact science talk in early elementary classrooms

    Open Access•Tanya S Wright, Amelia Wenk Gotwals et al.•Early Childhood Research Quarterly•2025

  • Decomposing practice in teacher professional development

    Open Access•Paola Sztajn, Daniel J Heck et al.•Teaching and Teacher Education•2020

  • U.S. teachers’ perceptions of online professional development

    Open Access•Seth A Parsons, Amy Hutchison et al.•Teaching and Teacher Education•2019

  • Investigating relationships between school context, teacher professional development, teaching practices, and student achievement in response to a nationwide science reform

    Open Access•Christian Fischer, Barry Fishman et al.•Teaching and Teacher Education•2018

  • Which teacher induction practices work? Linking forms of induction to teacher practices, self-efficacy, and job satisfaction

    Open Access•Todd D Reeves, Valerie Hamilton et al.•Teaching and Teacher Education•2021

  • Video-based reflection as a tool for instructional coach development

    Open Access•Lindsay Stoetzel, Stephanie Shedrow et al.•Teaching and Teacher Education•2025

  • How am I a creative teacher? Beliefs, values, and affect for integrating creativity in the classroom

    Open Access•Ross C Anderson, Jennifer Katz‐Buonincontro et al.•Teaching and Teacher Education•2021

  • Coaching our coaches

    Open Access•Lindsay Stoetzel, Stephanie Shedrow•Teaching and Teacher Education•2019

  • A virtual coaching model of professional development to increase teachers' digital learning competencies

    Open Access•Wendi K Zimmer, Sharon D Matthews•Teaching and Teacher Education•2021

  • If you build it, will they reflect? Examining teachers' use of an online video-based learning website

    Open Access•Meg Bates, Meg Schleppenbach Bates et al.•Teaching and Teacher Education•2016

  • Teachers’ preferences for online professional development

    Open Access•Muhammad Fauzan Ansyari, Wim Groot et al.•Teaching and Teacher Education•2022

  • A new framework for teachers’ professional development

    Open Access•Raziye Sancar, Deniz Atal et al.•Teaching and Teacher Education•2021

  • Lower-secondary school teachers’ perceptions of professional development in university-school collaboration

    Open Access•Tara Sapkota, Siv M Gamlem et al.•Teaching and Teacher Education•2023

  • EFL Teachers’ Perspectives of Online and In-Person Professional Development Practices

    Open Access•Mohd Nazim, Ali Abbas Falah Alzubi•SAGE Open•2025

  • When Do Students in Low-SES Schools Perform Better-Than-Expected on a High-Stakes Test? Analyzing School, Teacher, Teaching, and Professional Development Characteristics

    Open Access•Christian Fischer, Barry Fishman et al.•Urban Education•2020

  • Student Enrollment Patterns and Achievement in Ohio’s Online Charter Schools

    Open Access•June Ahn, Andrew Mceachin•Educational Researcher•2017

  • Professional Development Research

    Open Access•Heather C Hill, Heather Hill et al.•Educational Researcher•2013

  • Designing for Framing in Online Teacher Education

    Open Access•Jessica Watkins, Merredith Portsmore•Journal of Teacher Education•2022

  • The Future of Professional Development Will Be Designed, Not Discovered

    Open Access•Barry Fishman, Spyros Konstantopoulo et al.•Journal of Teacher Education•2014

  • Equipping Educators for Equity Through Ethnic‐Racial Identity Curriculum

    Open Access•Adriana J Umaña‐taylor, Stefanie Martinez‐fuente et al.•Journal of Community Psychology•2025

  • Efficacité d’une formation en ligne pour les enseignants afin d’améliorer la gestion des comportements extériorisés

    Alexis Boudreault, Julie Lessard et al.•Spirale - Revue de recherches en…•2021

  • The Affordances of Blogging As a Practice to Support Ninth-Grade Science Teachers' Identity Development as Leaders

    Open Access•Deborah L Hanuscin, Deborah Hanuscin et al.•Journal of Teacher Education•2014

  • Effects of a Multimedia Professional Development Package on Inclusive Science Teachers' Vocabulary Instruction

    Open Access•Michael J Kennedy, Wendy J Rodgers et al.•Journal of Teacher Education•2017

  • Taking Stock in 2014

    Open Access•Stephanie L Knight, Gwendolyn M Lloyd et al.•Journal of Teacher Education•2014

  • Reframing for Social Justice

    Open Access•Nadia Behizadeh, Clarice Thomas et al.•Journal of Teacher Education•2019

  • Profiling Teachers' Motivation for Professional Development

    Open Access•Elise Richter, Tim Fütterer et al.•Journal of Teacher Education•2025

  • Beyond Comparisons of Online Versus Face-to-Face PD

    Open Access•Jean Moon, Cynthia Passmore et al.•Journal of Teacher Education•2014

  • Sentence Stems to Foster Dialogue

    Open Access•Eleanor R Anderson, Tracy E Dobie•Journal of Teacher Education•2022

  • Resources, Instruction, and Research

    Open Access•David K Cohen, Stephen W Raudenbush et al.•Educational Evaluation and Policy…•2003

  • Will media influence learning? Reframing the debate

    Open Access•Róbert Kozma, Robert B Kozma•Educational Technology Research…•1994

  • Reconsidering Research on Learning from Media

    Open Access•Richard E Clark•Review of Educational Research•1983

  • Effects of Professional Development on Teachers’ Instruction

    Open Access•Laura M Desimone, Andrew C Porter et al.•Educational Evaluation and Policy…•2002

  • How Large Are Teacher Effects?

    Open Access•Barbara Nye, Spyros Konstantopoulos et al.•Educational Evaluation and Policy…•2004

  • Toward the development of an elementary teacher's science teaching efficacy belief instrument

    Open Access•Iris M Riggs, Larry G Enochs•Science Education•1990

  • Effects of an early literacy professional development intervention on head start teachers and children.

    Douglas R Powell, Karen E Diamond et al.•Journal of Educational Psychology•2010

  • Reform by the Book

    Open Access•Deborah Loewenberg Ball, David K Cohen•Educational Researcher•1996

  • Designing Educative Curriculum Materials to Promote Teacher Learning

    Open Access•Elizabeth A Davis, Joseph Krajcik et al.•Educational Researcher•2005

  • Professional Development and Teacher Learning

    Open Access•Harold Borko, Hilda Borko•Educational Researcher•2004

  • What Makes Professional Development Effective? Results From a National Sample of Teachers

    Open Access•Michael S Garet, Andrew C Porter et al.•American Educational Research…•2001

  • Improving Impact Studies of Teachers' Professional Development

    Open Access•Laura M Desimone•Educational Researcher•2009

  • Linking teacher and student learning to improve professional development in systemic reform

    Open Access•Barry J Fishman, Barry Fishman et al.•Teaching and Teacher Education•2003

  • Building sustainable science curriculum

    Open Access•Sasha Alexander Barab, April Lynn Luehmann et al.•Science Education•2003

  • A Research Agenda for Online Teacher Professional Development

    Open Access•Christopher Dede, Chris Dede et al.•Journal of Teacher Education•2009

  • Effects of a Computerized Professional Development Program on Teacher and Student Outcomes

    Open Access•Joseph B Fisher, Jean B Schumaker et al.•Journal of Teacher Education•2010

Unique citing works70
Citations per year5,38
Citation span2013 - 2026 (14)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 69

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae