Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Toxicity 1

On Ambiguity and Sewage in Mumbai's Urban Sea

Bibliographic Data

ID4382485
AuthorsNikhil Anand (0000-0001-9249-3655, corresponding author)
Year2022
Volume46
Issue4
Pages687-697
Publication date2022-07-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueInternational Journal of Urban and Regional Research (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0309-1317 • E-ISSN: 1468-2427
PublisherWiley (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1111/1468-2427.13093
OpenAlexW4293033005
LanguageEN
Citations received15
References cited41

In this essay, I focus on the remarkable process through which Mumbai's urban administration has continued to release its sewage, largely untreated, into the Arabian Sea. I show how it does this by rendering sewage both legally and materially ambiguous. I urge an attention to the processes of legal and material ambiguation, through which 'slow violence' is unevenly administered in Mumbai. Building on the work of Jacqueline Best, I argue that ambiguity does not simply leave open improvised forms of technocratic administration; ambiguity also defers bureaucratic activity in particular domains, while permitting activity in others. Taken together, the municipal administration mobilizes ambiguity so as to evade rendering toxicity an actionable problem of urban living and distributed social vulnerability in the city

Ambiguity · Bureaucracy · Environmental planning · Geography · Political science · Politics · Sociology · Technocracy · Law · Philosophy · Water Governance and Infrastructure

  • Eviscerating the Sea

    Nikhil Anand, Lalitha Kamath•Comparative Studies of South Asia…•2024

  • Habitability, viability and disaster risk creation in urban India

    Maansi Parpiani, Suchismita Goswami et al.•Urban Geography•2025

  • Fish Drought

    Jelena Salmi, Jelena Johanna Salmi•Current Anthropology•2025

  • Everyday practices of administrative ambiguation and the labour of de-ambiguation

    Open Access•Purva Dewoolkar, Deljana Iossifova et al.•Urban Studies•2025

  • Operationalizing and navigating ambiguity – Land-making and fisherfolk negotiations in the land-water frontier of Karachi

    Open Access•Dur-E-Shahwar Khalil, Maarten Van Acker et al.•Environment and Planning E Nature…•2026

  • Teardrops at the Taj

    L Meskell•International Journal of Heritage…•2024

  • Anthroposea

    Open Access•Nikhil Anand•Environment and Planning D…•2023

  • Ambivalent Governance and Slow Violence in Mumbai's Mithi River

    Open Access•Lalitha Kamath, Anushri Tiwari•International Journal of Urban…•2022

  • Sewers and sewage treatment in Mumbai

    Open Access•Purva Dewoolkar•Environment and Planning E Nature…•2025

  • From contested commons to ornamental ecologies

    Open Access•Pullanna Vidyapogu, Indivar Jonnalagadda•Environment and Planning E Nature…•2025

  • After the Right to Water

    Open Access•Pranjal Deekshit, Simran Sumbre•International Journal of Urban…•2022

  • Coda

    Open Access•M Ranganathan•International Journal of Urban…•2022

  • Toxicity 2

    Open Access•Tathagat Bhatia•International Journal of Urban…•2022

  • Dossiê

    Open Access•Marcos Lopes Campos, Deborah Fromm et al.•Revista Brasileira de Sociologia…•2024

  • Enduring Harm

    Open Access•Nikhil Anand, Bethany Wiggin et al.•International Journal of Urban…•2022

  • Rule By Aesthetics

    D Asher Ghertner, Asher Ghertner•Rule by Aesthetics•2015

  • The Promise of Infrastructure

    Open Access•Nikhil Anand, Akhil Gupta et al.•Promise of Infrastructure•2018

  • Sick Building Syndrome and the Problem of Uncertainty

    Michelle Murphy•Sick Building Syndrome and the…•2006

  • The Fabric of Space

    Matthew Gandy•Fabric of Space•2014

  • In the Nature of Cities

    Gary Bridge, Sophie Watson et al.•Urban Political Ecology•2006

  • Waste Siege

    Sophia Stamatopoulou‐robbin, Sophia Stamatopoulou-Robbins•Waste Siege•2020

  • Slow Violence and the Environmentalism of the Poor

    Rob Nixon•Slow violence and the environmental…•2011

  • Reinventing London

    Herbert Girardet•City•1996

  • Rethinking urban metabolism

    Matthew Gandy•City•2004

  • Chemical warfare in Colombia, evidentiary ecologies and senti-actuando practices of justice

    Open Access•K Lyons•Social Studies of Science•2018

  • The Afterlives of “Waste”

    Open Access•Vinay Gidwani, Rajyashree N Reddy•Antipode•2011

  • Spectral Housing and Urban Cleansing

    A Appadurai•Public Culture•2000

  • Defacement

    Michael Taussig, Michael J Taussig•Defacement•1999

  • Hydraulic City

    Nikhil Anand•Hydraulic City•2017

  • Toxic politics

    Open Access•Max Liboiron, M Tironi et al.•Social Studies of Science•2018

  • Political Infrastructures

    Open Access•Colin Mcfarlane, Jonathan Rutherford•International Journal of Urban…•2008

  • Ambivalent Governance and Slow Violence in Mumbai's Mithi River

    Open Access•Lalitha Kamath, Anushri Tiwari•International Journal of Urban…•2022

  • Thinking with Flint

    M Ranganathan•Capitalism Nature Socialism•2016

  • Contesting the Unethical City

    Sapana Doshi, M Ranganathan•Annals of the American…•2017

  • Greening Displacements, Displacing Green

    Open Access•Sapana Doshi•International Journal of Urban…•2019

  • Disciplining De Facto Development

    Open Access•Katie Meehan, Katharine Meehan•Environment and Planning D…•2013

  • After the Right to Water

    Open Access•Pranjal Deekshit, Simran Sumbre•International Journal of Urban…•2022

  • Slum as theory

    Open Access•Vyjayanthi Rao•International Journal of Urban…•2006

  • Restoring a River, Re-storying History

    Open Access•Bethany Wiggin•International Journal of Urban…•2022

  • Toxicity 2

    Open Access•Tathagat Bhatia•International Journal of Urban…•2022

  • The Ethnography of Infrastructure

    Open Access•Susan Leigh Star•American Behavioral Scientist•1999

  • Urban Development and Death

    Open Access•Ira Klein•Modern Asian Studies•1986

  • Advocacy after Bhopal

    Kim Fortun•Advocacy after Bhopal•2001

  • A History of the Modern Fact

    Mary Poovey•A history of the modern fact•1998

  • What Gets Inside

    Open Access•E F S Roberts•Cultural Anthropology•2017

  • Infrastructural violence

    Open Access•D Rodgers, Bruce O’neill•Ethnography•2012

  • Redefining pollution and action

    Open Access•Max Liboiron•Journal of Material Culture•2016

  • The Politics and Poetics of Infrastructure

    Brian Larkin•Annual Review of Anthropology•2013

  • State Making, Knowledge, and Ignorance

    Open Access•Andrew S Mathews•American Anthropologist•2008

  • Rhizomes and other uncountables

    Open Access•Shaylih Muehlmann•American Ethnologist•2012

  • When infrastructures attack

    Open Access•Julie Y Chu•American Ethnologist•2014

  • Bureaucratic ambiguity

    Jacqueline Best•Economy and Society•2012

  • Strategic unknowns

    Linsey Mcgoey•Economy and Society•2012

Unique citing works15
Citations per year3,75
Citation span2022 - 2026 (5)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 15

Tools

Open DOI
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae