Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

What Are We Busy Doing

Engaging the Idiot

Bibliographic Data

ID5337133
AuthorsMike Michael (0000-0001-9272-2294, Goldsmiths, University of London, London, United Kingdom, corresponding author)
Year2012
Volume37
Issue5
Pages528-554
Publication date2012-09-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueScience Technology & Human Values (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0162-2439 • E-ISSN: 1552-8251
PublisherSAGE Publications Inc (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1177/0162243911428624
OpenAlexW2111652967
LanguageEN
Citations received72
References cited44

Engagement events-whether interviews, installations, or participatory encounters-can entail a range of happenings which, in one way or another, "overspill" the empirical, analytic, or political framing of those engagement events. This article looks at how we might attend to these overspills-for instance, forms of "misbehavior" on the part of lay participants-not only to provide accounts of them but also to explore ways of deploying them creatively. In particular, Stengers' figure of the "idiot" is proposed as a device for deploying those overspills to interrogate "what we are busy doing" as social science researchers in engagement events. This interrogation is furthered by considering the proactive idiocy of "Speculative Design's" version of the public engagement with science which seems directly to engender "overspilling." Providing examples of speculative design prototypes and practices, the article develops an ideal typical contrast between social scientific and designerly perspectives on public engagement. It is suggested that speculative design can serve as a resource for supplementing "science and technology studies" (STS) conceptualizations of, and practices toward, public, engagement, and science

Citizen journalism · Civic engagement · Engineering ethics · Epistemology · Idiot · Media studies · Political science · Politics · Public engagement · Public relations · Sociology · Engineering · Information Systems Theories and Implementation · Innovative Human-Technology Interaction · Law · Posthumanist Ethics and Activism · Psychology

  • Drawing Out by Drawing Into

    Open Access•Pablo Schyfter•Engaging Science Technology and…•2016

  • Transforming power

    Open Access•Andy Stirling•Energy Research & Social Science•2014

  • Contradictory cares in community-led planning

    Open Access•Andy Yuille•Nordic Journal of Science and…•2021

  • Linhas de fuga do Antropoceno

    Open Access•António Carvalho, Mariana Riquito•e-cadernos CES•2022

  • Toward the abstractors

    Mike Michael•Distinktion Journal of Social…•2019

  • Into the wild online

    Open Access•Andreas Birkbak•First Monday•2018

  • Reluctant Objects

    K Race•GLQ A Journal of Lesbian and Gay…•2016

  • Speculative method in digital education research

    Open Access•Jen Ro, Jen Ross•Learning Media and Technology•2017

  • Wilding AI as collective research-creation

    Open Access•Maurice Jones, M Cameron Jones et al.•Artnodes•2025

  • Researching with young children

    Open Access•Satu Karjalainen•Journal of Early Childhood Research•2026

  • Love and Fear

    Open Access•Lisa Lindén•Science & Technology Studies•2020

  • ArtIA

    Open Access•Maurice Jones, Fenwick Mckelvey et al.•AI & Society•2026

  • A very public mess

    Open Access•Sebastián Ureta•Energy Research & Social Science•2017

  • Knowledge politics, vulnerability and recognition-based justice

    Open Access•Poonam Pandey, Aviram Sharma•Energy Research & Social Science•2020

  • Speculating with glitches

    Bodden, Jen Ro•Global Discourse•2020

  • Between Wit and Reason

    Matt Malpass•Design and Culture•2013

  • So much for snapshots’

    Open Access•Felicity Picken•Tourist Studies•2014

  • Questionable devices

    Open Access•L Waller, David Moats et al.•Environmental Science & Policy•2024

  • The interrupting capacities of knowledge co-production experiments

    Open Access•Helena Valve, David Lazarevic et al.•Environmental Science & Policy•2023

  • Analytics for local knowledge

    Raul P Lejano, Daniel Stokols•Journal of Risk Research•2018

  • Public perceptions of geoengineering research governance

    Open Access•Rob Bellamy, Javier Lezaun et al.•Global Environmental Change•2017

  • Making Energy Infrastructure

    Lea Schick, Brit Ross Winthereik•Science as Culture•2016

  • Empty Minds

    Open Access•Veerle Spronck, Peter Peters et al.•Science as Culture•2021

  • Aesthetics and Affect

    Mike Michael, Alex Wilkie et al.•Science as Culture•2018

  • Who's the Pest? Imagining Human–Insect Futures Beyond Antagonism

    Angela Last•Science as Culture•2013

  • Cosmopolitics of a Regulatory Fit

    Petrus Kautto, Helena Valve•Science as Culture•2018

  • Berwick-Barcelona

    Alexia Mellor•Journal of Geography in Higher…•2021

  • What can science and technology studies learn from art and design? Reflections on ‘Synthetic Aesthetics’

    Open Access•Jane Calvert, Pablo Schyfter•Social Studies of Science•2016

  • The labour of infrastructuring

    Alicia Smedberg•2022

  • Toward a manifesto for the ‘public understanding of big data’

    Open Access•Mike Michael, D Lupton•Public Understanding of Science•2016

  • Can hype be a force for good

    Open Access•Tara Roberson•Public Understanding of Science•2020

  • Crafting a public for geoengineering

    Open Access•Rob Bellamy, Javier Lezaun•Public Understanding of Science•2017

  • STS and science communication

    Open Access•Sarah R Davies•Public Understanding of Science•2022

  • Destroying iPhones

    Open Access•Mike Michael•Public Understanding of Science•2018

  • Engaging With Strangers and Brief Encounters

    Open Access•Clare Wilkinson•Bulletin of Science Technology &…•2014

  • Responsible innovation as empowering ways of knowing

    Open Access•G Valkenburg, Annapurna Mamidipudi et al.•Journal of Responsible Innovation•2019

  • Speculative approaches in social science and design research

    Open Access•Mianna Meskus, Emilia Tikka•Qualitative Research•2024

  • Reimagining publics and (non) participation

    Open Access•Ed Dawson•Public Understanding of Science•2018

  • The aesthetics of more-than-human design

    Open Access•Alex Wilkie, Mike Michael•Human-Computer Interaction•2023

  • Putting public health infrastructures to the test

    Open Access•K Tawny Paul, Iris Wallenburg et al.•Sociology of Health & Illness•2018

  • Re-presenting, performing critical/post-critical research realities

    Open Access•Stephen Heiman, Parlo Singh•Research in Education•2016

  • Overspills’ of research with children

    Z Millei, P Rautio•Children s Geographies•2017

  • Attending to ‘Computational Universalism’

    Open Access•Sarah R Davies, Miller Díaz-Valderrama•Social Studies of Science•2026

  • Speculative Method and Twitter

    Open Access•Alex Wilkie, Mike Michael et al.•The Sociological Review•2014

  • Public Deliberation on South Korean Nuclear Power Plants

    Sung Hwan Kim, Hyomin Kim et al.•East Asian Science Technology and…•2020

  • Infrastructuring and Participatory Design

    Open Access•Jane Simonsen, Helena Karasti et al.•Computer Supported Cooperative…•2020

  • Otherwising or Attaching? Play, Care, and Critique in Interdisciplinary Public Engagement

    Open Access•Catherine M Montgomery, Santini Basra et al.•Science Technology & Human Values•2026

  • What Was That Word? It’s Part of Ensuring Its Future Existence” Exploring Engagement Collectives at the European Commission’s Joint Research Centre

    Open Access•Thomas Völker, Ângela Guimarães Pereira•Science Technology & Human Values•2023

  • Constructing the “Cocreative Citizen”

    Open Access•Shelly Tsui, Sebastian Pfotenhauer et al.•Science Technology & Human Values•2025

  • Skinny as a Bird

    Open Access•Marie Hebrok, Henry Mainsah•Futures•2022

  • The thickening of futures

    Open Access•Linda Jönsson, Kristina Lindström et al.•Futures•2021

  • Thinking complex interconnections

    Open Access•Tim Schwanen•Transactions of the Institute of…•2017

  • Making the microbiome public

    Open Access•Jamie Lorimer, Timothy Hodgetts et al.•Transactions of the Institute of…•2019

  • Anticipation for Grand Challenges

    Open Access•Irem Tekogul, Carlos Teixeira et al.•Ethnographic Praxis in Industry…•2023

  • Enacting Public Value on the Abc's Q&A

    Open Access•Gay Hawkins•Media International Australia•2013

  • Engaging Publics

    Open Access•Mark Toogood•Geography Compass•2013

  • Bogeymen," "Murderers," and "Loonies

    Open Access•Floortje Moes, Christian Bröer et al.•Science Technology & Human Values•2025

  • Between Open Deliberation and the Capturing of Public Opinion

    Open Access•Svenja Breuer, Michael Penkler•Science Technology & Human Values•2024

  • Opening Up the Participation Laboratory

    Open Access•A Krzywoszynska, Matt Watson et al.•Science Technology & Human Values•2018

  • Characterizing Hacking

    Open Access•Sarah R Davies•Science Technology & Human Values•2018

  • Unpacking a citizen self-tracking device

    Open Access•Martin Tironi, Matías Valderrama Barragán et al.•Environment and Planning D…•2018

  • Methodologically materialising hate

    Open Access•Cally Gatehouse, James Pickles•Methodological Innovations•2021

  • Prehending Addiction

    Open Access•Adrian Farrugia, Fraser et al.•Qualitative Health Research•2017

  • Social innovation driven by citizen-led digital innovation

    Davide Dusi•Citizenship Studies•2019

  • The problem and the productivity of ignorance

    Open Access•Catherine M Will, Catherine Will•The Sociological Review•2020

  • Teaching Anthropology Speculatively

    Andrea Gaspar•Cadernos de arte e antropologia•2017

  • Keeping Open by Re-Imagining Laughter and Fear

    Open Access•Sonja Jerak-Zuiderent•The Sociological Review•2015

  • Life Story Talk

    Open Access•J Brannen•Sociological Research Online•2013

  • Notes toward a speculative methodology of everyday life

    Open Access•Mike Michael•Qualitative Research•2016

  • Features and form

    Open Access•Diana Graizbord, Jamie Mcpike•Ethnography•2025

  • Consumer databases as practical accomplishments

    T Ariztia•Journal of Cultural Economy•2018

  • Prototyping as Event

    Alex Wilkie•Journal of Cultural Economy•2014

  • Plans and Situated Actions

    Lucille Alice Suchman•Plans and Situated Actions•1987

  • Design Noir

    Anthony Dunne, Fiona Raby•Design Noir•2021

  • What Things Do

    Open Access•Peter-Paul Verbeek, Robert P Crease•What Things Do•2005

  • The Design of Everyday Life

    Elizabeth Shove, Matthew Watson et al.•The Design of Everyday Life•2007

  • Gender and technology in the making

    Cynthia Cockburn•Gender and technology in the making•1993

  • Studies in ethnomethodology

    Harold Garfinkel•Studies in ethnomethodology•1984

  • How Users Matter

    Nelly Oudshoorn, Trevor Pinch•How Users Matter•2003

  • Unruly ethics

    Open Access•U Felt, Maximilian Fochler et al.•Public Understanding of Science•2009

  • “… A Certain Amount of Engineering Involved”

    Open Access•Kathrin Braun, Susanne Schultz•Public Understanding of Science•2010

  • Use of the deficit model in a shared culture of argumentation

    Open Access•Nick Wright, Brigitte Nerlich•Public Understanding of Science•2006

  • To tell the truth

    Open Access•David J He, David J Hess•Public Understanding of Science•2011

  • Publics performing publics

    Open Access•Mike Michael•Public Understanding of Science•2009

  • A Cautious Prometheus? A Few Steps Toward a Philosophy of Design with Special Attention to Peter Sloterdijk

    Open Access•Bruno Latour•In medias res•2012

  • Introduction to Critical Theory

    David Held•Introduction to Critical Theory•1980

  • Consulting citizens

    Open Access•Javier Lezaun, Linda Soneryd•Public Understanding of Science•2007

  • Homo Sacer

    Giorgio Agamben•Homo Sacer•2020

  • Public Participation in Science and Technology

    Brian Wynne•East Asian Science Technology and…•2007

  • Scientific citizenships

    Mike Michael, Nik Brown•Science as Culture•2005

  • The Facts About Fictions And Vice Versa

    Mike Michael, Simon Carter•Science as Culture•2001

  • Producing the Post-Fordist Public

    C Thorpe, Jane Gregory•Science as Culture•2010

  • Creating Public Alienation

    Brian Wynne•Science as Culture•2001

  • The Issues Deserve More Credit

    Open Access•N Marres•Social Studies of Science•2007

  • Shifting Subject Positions

    Open Access•Anne Kerr, Sarah Cunningham-Burley et al.•Social Studies of Science•2007

  • Nations at Ease with Radical Knowledge

    Open Access•M Horst, Alec Irwin•Social Studies of Science•2009

  • Machineries for Making Publics

    Open Access•U Felt, Maximilian Fochler•Minerva•2010

  • Logics of interdisciplinarity

    A Barry, G Born et al.•Economy and Society•2008

  • After Method

    John Law•After Method•2004

  • Acting in an uncertain world

    Michel Callon, Pierre Lascoumes et al.•Acting in an uncertain world•2009

  • On the Shoulders of Idiots

    M Horst, Mike Michael•Science as Culture•2011

  • Parables for the Virtual

    Open Access•B Massumi, Stanley Fish et al.•Parables for the Virtual•2002

  • A Game of Cat's Cradle

    Donna Haraway, Donna Jeanne Haraway•Configurations•1994

  • An Essay on Framing and Overflowing

    Open Access•Michel Callon•The Sociological Review•1998

  • The Body Multiple

    A Mol, Barbara Herrnstein Smith et al.•The Body Multiple•2002

  • On Making Data Social

    Open Access•Mike Michael•Qualitative Research•2004

  • Consuming, Engaging and Confronting Science

    Open Access•Mark Elam, Margareta Bertilsson•European Journal of Social Theory•2003

  • Art-Science

    G Born, A Barry•Journal of Cultural Economy•2010

  • Mapping deliberation

    Gail Davies•Economy and Society•2006

  • Gino's lesson on humanity

    Michel Callon, Vololona Rabeharisoa•Economy and Society•2004

Unique citing works72
Citations per year5,54
Citation span2013 - 2026 (14)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 65

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae