Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Immigration Attitudes and Support for the Welfare State in the American Mass Public

Bibliographic Data

ID6231028
AuthorsJames Garand (0000-0001-5754-8673, Louisiana State University), James C Garand, Ping Xu (0000-0001-6099-1748), Belinda Creel Davis (0000-0002-9603-2677, Louisiana State University)
Year2017
Volume61
Issue1
Pages146-162
Publication date2017-01-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueAmerican Journal of Political Science (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0092-5853 • E-ISSN: 1540-5907
PublisherWiley (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1111/ajps.12233
OpenAlexW2220835863
LanguageEN
Citations received83
References cited44

In this article, we explore the relationship between Americans’ attitudes toward immigrants and immigration and their attitudes toward welfare. Using data from the Cumulative American National Election Study from 1992 to 2012, we find ample evidence of the influence of immigration attitudes on both individuals’ attitudes toward welfare recipients and their attitudes toward increased welfare spending. These immigration effects persist even in the face of statistical controls for attitudes toward African Americans and attitudes toward the poor; indeed, in our models, the magnitude of the effects of immigration attitudes surpasses the magnitude of effects of attitudes toward blacks. Further, our findings of immigration effects withstand a range of robustness tests. Our results point to the possible “immigrationalization” of Americans’ welfare attitudes and provide strong evidence that how Americans think about immigration and immigrants is a major factor in how they think about welfare

Demographic economics · Economics · Immigration · Political science · Politics · Public opinion · Welfare · Welfare state · Electoral Systems and Political Participation · Law · Migration and Labor Dynamics · Migration, Refugees, and Integration

  • Complicated Loyalties

    Open Access•Samantha Chapa, Stella M Rouse et al.•Political Research Quarterly•2026

  • Me Against Myself

    Open Access•Yifei Wang, Miriam J Metzger et al.•Journalism & Mass Communication…•2025

  • Immigration and Public Support for Social Policy

    Open Access•Kellogg, Achim Edelmann et al.•Socius Sociological Research for…•2025

  • Perceptions of Immigrant Threat, American Identity, and Vote Choice in the 2016 U.S. Presidential Election

    Open Access•James Garand, Dan Qi et al.•Political Behavior•2022

  • Bridges and Walls

    Open Access•Matthew Polacko, Giacomo Di Pasquale et al.•Political Research Quarterly•2026

  • Do Americans Exhibit “Welfare Chauvinism?” Experimental Evidence on Social Welfare, Immigration, and Voting

    Open Access•Jake Haselswerdt•Politics & Policy•2026

  • Perceived China Threat, Conspiracy Belief, and Public Support for Restrictive Immigration Control During the Covid-19 Pandemic

    Open Access•J H Kim, Jihye Park•Race and Justice•2023

  • Impact of Race/Ethnicity, Veteran Status, and Place of Birth on Attitudes Towards Welfare Recipients

    Open Access•Amanda ElBassiouny, Sabith Khan•Psychological Reports•2020

  • Inferring what hardliners would do

    Adriano Udani•Politics Groups and Identities•2017

  • Americans’ Perceptions About Immigrants from Different World Regions

    Open Access•K Zhirkov•Journal of Experimental Political…•2025

  • The influence of family‐based social assistance programs and parenting on child development

    Open Access•Kimberly R M Osborne•Journal of Family Theory & Review•2024

  • Immigration, Beneficiary Assumptions, and Welfare Support

    Open Access•Hang Qi•Review of Policy Research•2026

  • Identity- versus effort-based bureaucratic discrimination among mobile European Union citizens

    Open Access•Jana Gómez Díaz, Eva Thomann et al.•European Union Politics•2026

  • Support networks among immigrant parents of young children

    Open Access•Nicole Megan Edwards, Zeynep Isik‐Ercan et al.•Child & Family Social Work•2023

  • Racialization and Subsidized Low-Income Housing in American Cities

    Twyla Blackmond Larnell, Cameron Williams•Journal of Poverty•2018

  • Exploring Variation in Welfare Attitudes Among Low-Income Parents

    D Bolger, Michelle Sarah Livings•Journal of Poverty•2025

  • Political Underrepresentation Among Public Benefits Recipients

    Open Access•Seth Chizeck, K Fong et al.•Urban Affairs Review•2023

  • The Authoritarian Predisposition and American Public Support for Social Security

    Open Access•David Macdonald•Political Research Quarterly•2021

  • Who Is Perceived as Deserving? How Social Identities Shape Attitudes about Disaster Assistance in the United States

    Open Access•Ashley D Ro, Stella M Rouse et al.•PS Political Science & Politics•2024

  • Multidimensional Constructions of Target Groups and Their Political Implications

    Open Access•K Zhirkov, Lauren Van De Hey•PS Political Science & Politics•2025

  • The political economy of individual-level support for the basic income in Europe

    Open Access•Tim Vlandas•Journal of European Social Policy•2020

  • The Line Must Be Drawn Somewhere”

    Open Access•C Fox•Studies in American Political…•2019

  • Antiblackness as a Logic for Anti‐Immigrant Resentment

    Open Access•G C Mora, Tianna S Paschel•Sociological Forum•2020

  • Anti-immigration party success abroad and voter polarization at home

    Open Access•Tobias Böhmelt, Lawrence Ezrow et al.•Electoral Studies•2024

  • Health systems in the Covid ‐19 crises

    Open Access•Christopher Deeming•Social Policy and Administration•2024

  • How does immigration affect welfare support in Korea

    Open Access•Kyunghwan Kim•Social Policy and Administration•2022

  • Does the immigration issue divide the left’s attitudes towards social welfare? A study on public support of social benefits and services in the Nordic countries

    Open Access•Laura Häkkilä, Timo Toikko•International Journal of…•2021

  • Explaining social insurance participation

    Yeqing Huang, Shurong Han•Policy Studies•2022

  • Ideology and Immigration Patterns in European Union (1988–2015)

    Open Access•Marcelo De A Medeiros, Dalson Figueiredo Filho et al.•Revista de Sociologia e Política•2019

  • Another Civil War in America? Comparing the Social Psychology of the United States of the 1850s to Today

    Open Access•Montgomery Van Wart, Jeremy L Hall et al.•Administration & Society•2024

  • Påvirker innvandringsscenarier nordmenns holdningertil innvandrere? Et surveyeksperiment

    Open Access•Dag Arne Christensen, Sveinung Arnesen et al.•Tidsskrift for samfunnsforskning•2019

  • The system is broken

    Open Access•Kyung Suk Lee, Kirby Goidel et al.•Social Science Quarterly•2023

  • Far from a Burden

    Open Access•Marie Godin•International Migration•2019

  • Immigration and support for redistributive social policy

    Open Access•R Kwon, Michaela Curran•International Journal of…•2016

  • Concerns about immigration and demand for social protection

    Open Access•Jakob Henninger•International Journal of…•2026

  • Immigration and the welfare state

    Open Access•Maureen A Eger, Nate Breznau•International Journal of…•2017

  • In‐group bias in preferences for redistribution

    Open Access•Riccardo Bruni, Alessandro Gioffré et al.•Economica•2025

  • Unpacking Welfare Deservingness Theory

    Open Access•Juhyun Bae•Policy Studies Journal•2026

  • Deservingness perceptions, welfare state support and vote choice in Western Europe

    David Attewell•West European Politics•2020

  • Elections, Party Rhetoric, and Public Attitudes Toward Immigration in Europe

    Open Access•Elizabeth Dekeyser, Michael Freedman•Political Behavior•2023

  • Discrimination against mobile European Union citizens before and during the first Covid-19 lockdown

    Open Access•Xavier Fernández-I-Marín, Carolin Rapp et al.•European Union Politics•2021

  • Welfare policy and immigration attitudes in Western Europe

    Open Access•Alina Vrânceanu, Bilyana Petrova•European Journal of Political…•2025

  • Immigrant Resentment and Voter Fraud Beliefs in the U.S. Electorate

    Open Access•Adriano Udani, David C Kimball•American Politics Research•2018

  • Authoritarianism, Prejudice, and Support for Welfare Chauvinism in the United States

    Jason Kehrberg•Statistics Politics and Policy•2020

  • Comparative political economy and international migration

    Alexandre Afonso, Camilla Devitt•Socio-Economic Review•2016

  • Education and market liberal preferences

    Open Access•John V C Nye, John VC Nye et al.•Journal of Economic Behavior &…•2025

  • The Politics of (Mis)perception

    Open Access•Ping Xu, Belinda Davis et al.•Social Science Quarterly•2025

  • Beliefs and opinions about “illegal” and “undocumented” immigrants

    Open Access•K Zhirkov, Robert H Brehm•Research & Politics•2025

  • Immigration and the conditionality of unemployment benefits in OECD countries

    Open Access•Samir Negash, Olaf Van Vliet•West European Politics•2024

  • Immigrationization’ of welfare politics? Anti-immigration and welfare attitudes in context

    Open Access•Brian Burgoon, Matthijs Rooduijn•West European Politics•2021

  • Once Racialized, Now “Immigrationized”? Explaining the Immigration-Welfare Link in American Public Opinion

    Morris Levy, Morris E Levy•The Journal of Politics•2021

  • Compensation or Retrenchment? The Paradox of Immigration and Public Welfare Spending in the American States

    Open Access•Ping Xu•State Politics & Policy Quarterly•2017

  • Poverty

    Christopher Howard, Amirio Freeman et al.•Public Opinion Quarterly•2017

  • Understanding Public Attitudes Toward Redistribution

    Open Access•Hang Qi•Public Opinion Quarterly•2025

  • Attitudes Toward Asylum Seekers

    Open Access•Anselm Hager, Susanne Veit•Public Opinion Quarterly•2019

  • Does Administrative Burden Influence Public Support for Government Programs? Evidence from a Survey Experiment

    Open Access•Lael R Keiser, Susan M Miller•Public Administration Review•2019

  • Give Us Your Tired, Your Poor and We Might Buy Them Dinner

    Open Access•Daniel P Hawes, Austin Michael Mccrea et al.•Political Research Quarterly•2018

  • Closing the Solidarity Gap? How Ethnic Diversity Alters Who We Are Willing to Support

    Open Access•Mathias Kruse•Political Psychology•2023

  • Who Is “On Welfare”? Validating the Use of Conjoint Experiments to Measure Stereotype Content

    Open Access•C Daniel Myers, K Zhirkov et al.•Political Behavior•2024

  • Who Benefits? Race, Immigration, and Assumptions About Policy

    Open Access•Jake Haselswerdt•Political Behavior•2022

  • Who Deserves Solidarity? Unequal Treatment of Immigrants in Swiss Welfare Policy Delivery

    Open Access•Eva Thomann, Carolin Rapp•Policy Studies Journal•2018

  • Anti‐Immigrant Sentiment and the Adoption of State Immigration Policy

    Open Access•Adam M Butz, Jason Kehrberg•Policy Studies Journal•2019

  • Immigration, government type, and social welfare spending

    Open Access•Hang Qi•Policy Studies Journal•2025

  • Did low-income essential workers during Covid-19 increase public support for redistribution

    Jeong Hyun Kim, J Kuk et al.•Policy & Politics•2024

  • Social Welfare Attitudes and Immigrants as a Target Population

    Open Access•Jake Haselswerdt•Perspectives on Politics•2021

  • Submerged for Some? Government Visibility, Race, and American Political Trust

    Open Access•Aaron Rosenthal•Perspectives on Politics•2021

  • Differential discrimination against mobile EU citizens

    Christian Adam, Xavier Fernández-I-Marín et al.•Journal of European Public Policy•2021

  • From immigration over redistributive attitudes to welfare spending. The moderating role of social program design

    Open Access•Leonce Röth, Dennis Christopher Spies et al.•European Political Science Review•2022

  • Labour market risks and preferences for EU unemployment insurance

    Open Access•Francesco Nicoli, Stefano Sacchi et al.•European Political Science Review•2025

  • Emigration, Social Remittances and Fiscal Policy Preferences

    Open Access•Ana Isabel López García, Sarah Beren et al.•Comparative Political Studies•2024

  • Boundaries of Solidarity

    Open Access•Gabriele Magni•American Journal of Political…•2024

  • Political Trust and Support for Immigration in the American Mass Public

    Open Access•David Macdonald•British Journal of Political…•2021

  • Work Requirements and Perceived Deservingness of Medicaid

    Open Access•Jennifer D Wu•American Politics Research•2021

  • Immigration Attitudes and White Americans’ Responsiveness to Rising Income Inequality

    Open Access•David Macdonald•American Politics Research•2021

  • Ideology, Information, and Social Welfare Preferences

    Open Access•Hang Qi, Jake Haselswerdt•American Politics Research•2024

  • Listening to snitches

    Open Access•Spencer Headworth, Victor Rios et al.•Law & Policy•2021

  • Intervening in Anti-Immigrant Sentiments

    Open Access•M Abascal, Tiffany J Huang et al.•The Annals of the American…•2021

  • Getting to Know You

    Open Access•Spencer Headworth•American Sociological Review•2019

  • Social trust and support for immigrants' social rights in Spain

    J Fierro, Parella et al.•New Community•2023

  • "Immigrationalization" of the Welfare State

    Open Access•P Xu, Belinda Davis et al.•The Journal of Race Ethnicity and…•2025

  • What Lies between the Poles? Selective Uncertainty and Occluded Bias in Immigration Attitudes in California

    Open Access•G C Mora, Chelsea Daniels et al.•Social Forces•2025

  • Threatening for whom? National boundary-making, immigration, and support for the welfare state

    Open Access•M Triguero Roura•European Sociological Review•2025

  • Identifying the Undeserving Poor

    Daniel Lanford, Jill Quadagno•Sociological Quarterly•2022

  • Race, Money, and the American Welfare State

    Michael E Brown, Michael K Brown•Race, Money, and the American…•1999

  • Enhanced Routines for Instrumental Variables/Generalized Method of Moments Estimation and Testing

    Open Access•Christopher F Baum, Mark E Schaffer et al.•The Stata Journal: Promoting…•2007

  • Instrumental Variables and GMM

    Open Access•Christopher F Baum, Mark E Schaffer et al.•The Stata Journal: Promoting…•2003

  • Ethnic diversity, social sanctions, and public goods in Kenya

    Open Access•Edward Miguel, Mary Kay Gugerty•Journal of Public Economics•2005

  • Testing for Weak Instruments in Linear IV Regression

    Open Access•James H Stock, Motohiro Yogo•Identification and Inference for…•2005

  • Shifting the Color Line

    Robert C Lieberman•Shifting the Color Line•2001

  • Fighting Poverty in the US and Europe

    Alberto Alesina, Edward L Glaeser et al.•Fighting poverty in the US and…•2004

  • Multiculturalism and the Welfare State

    Keith Banting, Will Kymlicka•Multiculturalism and the welfare…•2006

  • Welfare As We Knew It

    Charles Noble, Charles H Noble•Welfare as we knew it•1997

  • Do multiculturalism policies erode the welfare state? An empirical analysis

    Keith Banting, Richard Johnston et al.•Multiculturalism and the welfare…•2006

  • Identity Politics and the Welfare State

    Open Access•Alan Wolfe, Jytte Klausen•Social Philosophy and Policy•1997

  • Disciplining the Poor

    Joe So, Joe Soss et al.•Disciplining the Poor•2011

  • Stereotype content model across cultures

    Open Access•Amy J C Cuddy, Susan T Fiske et al.•British Journal of Social…•2009

  • Support for redistribution and the paradox of immigration

    Open Access•Brian Burgoon, Ferry Koster et al.•Journal of European Social Policy•2012

  • Migration and welfare state solidarity in Western Europe

    Open Access•Steffen Mau, Christoph Burkhardt•Journal of European Social Policy•2009

  • Making the difference in social Europe

    Open Access•Wim Van Oorschot•Journal of European Social Policy•2006

  • Immigration, Multiculturalism, and the Welfare State

    Open Access•Will Kymlicka, Keith Banting•Ethics & International Affairs•2006

  • Not an outgroup, not yet an ingroup

    Open Access•Tiane L Lee, Susan T Fiske•International Journal of…•2006

  • Group Loyalty and the Taste for Redistribution

    Erzo F P Luttmer•Journal of Political Economy•2001

  • Immigration and Natives’ Attitudes towards the Welfare State

    Open Access•Claudia Senik, Holger Stichnoth et al.•Social Indicators Research•2008

  • Immigration and the Evolving American Welfare State

    Open Access•Rodney E Hero, Robert R Preuhs•American Journal of Political…•2007

  • Why Americans hate welfare

    Martin Gilens•Why Americans hate welfare•1999

  • Group Affect and Attribution in Social Policy Opinion

    Thomas E Nelson•The Journal of Politics•1999

  • Ethnic Heterogeneity and Public Support for Welfare

    Open Access•Christian Albrekt Larsen•Scandinavian Political Studies•2011

  • Community Structure and Voting in the South

    Gerald Wright, Jr Gerald C Wright•Public Opinion Quarterly•1976

  • The American Welfare State, or States

    Clifford Howard, Christopher J Howard et al.•Political Research Quarterly•1999

  • How much heterogeneity can the welfare state endure? The influence of heterogeneity on attitudes to the welfare state

    Open Access•Mikael Hjerm, Annette Schnabel•Nations and Nationalism•2012

  • Tolerating Threat? The Independent Effects of Civil Conflict on Domestic Political Tolerance

    Open Access•Marc L Hutchison•Journal of Conflict Resolution•2014

  • Immigration and Social Policy in the United States

    Rodney E Hero•Annual Review of Political Science•2010

  • Racial Stereotypes and Whites' Political Views of Blacks in the Context of Welfare and Crime

    Mark Peffley, Mark Hurwitz Peffley et al.•American Journal of Political…•1997

  • Public Attitudes toward Government Spending

    William G Jacoby•American Journal of Political…•1994

  • Setting the Terms of Relief

    Joe So, Joe Soss et al.•American Journal of Political…•2001

  • A model of (often mixed) stereotype content

    Susan T Fiske, Amy J C Cuddy et al.•Journal of Personality and Social…•2002

  • Government Monitoring and Political Participation in the United States

    Open Access•Samuel J Best, Brian S Krueger•American Politics Research•2011

  • The Color of Welfare

    Jill Quadagno, Jill S Quadagno•The color of welfare•1994

  • Dis)respecting versus (Dis)liking

    Open Access•Susan T Fiske, Xu Juan et al.•Journal of Social Issues•1999

  • Public Goods and Ethnic Divisions

    Alberto Alesina, Reza Baqir et al.•World Bank policy research…•1999

  • A Politico-Economic Theory of Income Redistribution

    Open Access•Robert D Plotnick, Richard F Winters•American Political Science Review•1985

  • Does Immigration Erode the Multicultural Welfare State? A Cross-National Multilevel Analysis in 19 OECD Member States

    T Sumino•New Community•2014

  • Why Does Ethnic Diversity Undermine Public Goods Provision

    Open Access•James Habyarimana, Michael Humphreys et al.•American Political Science Review•2007

  • The Limits of Social Solidarity

    Open Access•Ann-Helen Bay, Ann‐helen Bay et al.•Acta Sociologica•2006

  • Even in Sweden

    Maureen A Eger•European Sociological Review•2010

Unique citing works83
Citations per year8,3
Citation span2016 - 2026 (11)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 83

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae